gilyoines.com Back to the site · חזרה לאתר

Chikei Chaim - English — Chayei Sara (2026-11-02)

Publisher: Chikei Chaim - English

Week: Chayei Sara (2026-11-02)

Chikei Chaim - English — Chayei Sara (2026-11-02)

Open the PDF Download

Dinim of Forbidden Forms Request: To Donate To Subscribe: Please send to as many paskenshtibel@gmail.com people as possible, with that, having a hand in ''‫''חוקי חיים‬ spreading Torah and Click To Download relevant Halochos to previous Gilyonos people everywhwere Archives Please do not read during davening or Krias HaTorah Depiction of Forbidden Forms | Parshas Chayei Sarah 5787 392 Issur of ‫לא תעשון אתי‬ 6. Digital camera. Certainly a modern-day digital camera, which just ‫לא תעשון אתי‬ has data stored digitally on a memory card, but no physical image, 1. In the previous two issues (391, 392), we discussed several does not involve a true act of image creation, and is not like drawing. important rules from the Torah related to the issur of creating 7. Printing the photo. Printing the photo onto paper is considered forbidden forms arising from the lav or “‫לא תעשון אתי‬.” We creating an image according to the ones who are machmir for explained (390) the halachos pertaining to a picture or engraving of pictures on flat surfaces. the sun, moon, and stars. We continued (391) with halachos 8. Machmir not to photograph. However, some tzaddikim and related to creating a human form. Because these halachos are less scrupulous people refrained—based on halacha—from familiar to the general public, many readers contacted us with photographing people to satisfy the opinions that hold one may scores of shailos on the topic. Thus, we decided to devote another not draw a picture of a person even if it does not protrude (above, issue to answering the shailos we received in an organized fashion, 3), and because photographing is also a form of image creation in addition to some interesting points on the topic. ( ‫ שו''ת אבני ישפה ח''א סי' קנ''א‬,‫הובא בתשובות והנהגות ח''ג סי' רס''ג ד''ה והנה‬ '‫)ענף ד‬. They did not grant others permission to photograph them Human Form out of concern that allowing someone to photograph them would Depicting a Human Form violate the issur of “‫לפני עוור‬.” 2. The halacha. With respect to creating a human form, we cited 9. Being photographed. Nevertheless, even those who are machmir (Issue 391, par. 12) a machlokes Rishonim whether the issur is only based on halacha did not actively prevent others from for a protruding images (‫ טור‬,‫ ר''מ‬,‫ רא''ש‬,‫ )ר''ת‬or also a sunken one photographing them since it is the photographer, not the one (‫ ר''ן‬,‫ רמב''ן‬,‫)מהר''ם מרוטנברג‬, as well as a picture on a flat surface. We being photographed, who is creating the image. The one being said most Rishonim hold that for a human image, the issur is only photographed is only an indirect factor in the photographer’s a protruding image, not a sunken one, and certainly not just a actions. They were meikel in this especially because there is basis picture (‫ תוס' יומא דף נ''ד ע''ב ד''ה כרובים‬,‫)מרדכי ב''ב סי' תקמ''ט‬. This is the to rely on according to halacha. psak of the Shulchan Aruch (‫)יו''ד קמ''א ס''ד‬, and the common 10. Common practice. In reality, though, the common practice is to be practice is to rely on this l’chatchila to allow drawing a human form completely meikel even to photograph others, as a photographed as long as it does not protrude at all (‫)חכמת אדם כלל פ''ה ס''ג‬. image is created indirectly, by opening the shutter, which was 3. L’chumra. However, some Acharonim write one should be covering the film, which results in the image being created on its machmir on sunken images too (‫)ט''ז סקי''ב לחוש לדעת הרמב''ן‬, and own. It is not considered a direct action (‫)שם‬. that it is proper to satisfy this opinion (‫)חכ''א כלל פ''ה ס''ג‬. Based on According to Kabbala this, according to those who treat a picture the same as a sunken 11. Even if there is no issue in photographing, being photographed, or image, one should be machmir not to draw a picture of a person drawing pictures of people according to halacha, some big on a paper or flat surface. According to some poskim, this is only if tzaddikim were opposed to being photographed for the Kabbalistic it includes the entire height of the person’s body (391, par. 16); reason that there is a negative ruach on every picture or according to others it is even if the picture is only of a human head photograph ( ‫ ע''פ זוה''ק פ' פקודי‬,‫יערות דבש ח''א דרוש ב' הובא בפתח''ת סק''ז‬ (ibid., par. 17) if it includes the entire face from a frontal view (ibid., ‫ יסוד שורש ועבודה שער הכולל פ''ה‬,‫)דף רס''ו ע''ב‬. par. 19). While it is true that one who is machmir is to be 12. Thus, some world-renowned tzaddikim did not allow themselves commended, strictly speaking it is mutar, as we wrote. to be photographed at all without a great need, e.g., for a passport 4. Hanging up a picture of a person. Even according to the machmir photo or for the parnassa of the photographer when he asked for opinion, the chumra would seem to only be in making the picture, permission. The Chacham Tzvi (‫)הוזכר בשו''ת שאילת יעב''ץ ח''א סי' ק''ע‬, which involves a potential issur d’Oraisa of “‫לא תעשון אתי‬.” the Chofetz Chaim, the Chazon Ish ('‫)ארחות רבינו ח''א עמ' ל‬, the However, if someone else made the picture and the only issue is Steipler (‫)ארחות רבינו שם עמ' ר''ב ר''ג‬, the rebbes of Vizhnitz Monsey, someone holding it in his possession, he can certainly rely on the the Chernobyl rebbe, and many other rebbes and big tzaddikim meikel opinion. Thus, one may hang in his home a picture of a were makpid on this. [However, it seems from the proliferation of person made by someone else (‫)רמב''ן ומאירי ע''ז דף מ''ב ע''ב‬, especially picture magazines of rabbanim today that many rabbanim and the picture of a tzaddik to fulfill in a small way the posuk “ ‫והיו עיניך‬ rebbes are not makpid on this… In fact, they encourage it…] ‫רואות את מוריך‬.” However, some write one should refrain from Partial Image of a Person hanging pictures of people on the walls of his home ( ‫ יערות דבש הובא‬13. Not the entire body. When there is a need to photograph ‫)בפתח''ת סי' קמ''א סק''ז‬. someone or there is no way to escape it, one should at least only have the upper part of his body photographed, not his whole body Photographing a Person with the feet. As we cited earlier, some hold the issur to make an According to Halacha image of a person is only the whole body, not a partial 5. Meikel. Even according to the above machmirim who forbid representation (391, par. 16-17). This way, one fulfills the halacha at drawing a picture of a person with ink, the poskim discuss whether least according to these opinions ('‫)בן איש חי שנה ב' פ' מסעי אות ט‬. using a camera to photograph a person is an issue. Some want to 14. Covering the face with the hand. Similarly, there are tzaddikim say that perhaps pressing the capture button on a camera, which who are careful to hide part of their face with their hand or the like opens the shutter and allows an image of a person to be formed even when just their head is photographed so that no picture with on photographic film, is not called making a picture; rather, it is a their entire head emerges. It was the practice of many tzaddikim grama [indirect action] ( ‫ סוף‬,‫ חוט שני‬,'‫שו''ת שבט הלוי ח''ז סי' קל''ד אות ה‬ to put their hand over their face partially when they were in a ‫)הל' פסח‬. public place where someone might photograph them. “The Cheder Horoah” | 20 Minchas Yitzchok St. Yerushalayim | paskenshtibel@gmail.com Opening times: Sun. – Thurs. 5:00pm till 8:00pm | Fri. 10:00am till 11:00am and from 1 hour before candle-lighting 15. Sunglasses. Similarly, there is a tzaddik who always wears 24. Bar mitzva invitation. We saw a figure like this made in the image sunglasses—besides for on Shabbos, when there is no concern he of a bar mitzva boy sent out to the relatives with an accompanying will be photographed—so that his entire face is not photographed. text as a bar mitzva invitation [a “bar mitzva haba b’aveira”…]. With this tactic, he can go about in public without concern of being Visiting a Wax Museum photographed, as his eyes are always concealed by the sunglasses. 25. We were asked whether one may visit a wax museum with full Photographing Someone Who Is Not Alive body wax statues. If they were made by non-Jews, e.g., in Madame 16. Story. There are stories of tzaddikim who did not allow portraits of Tussauds in London or New York, there is no issur to enjoy and see them to be painted in their lifetimes due to the above halachic or the creations. However, if they were made by Jews, e.g., those in kabbalistic reasons, yet after they passed away and before they Eretz Yisroel, one should refrain from visiting, as doing so aids an were buried, people rationalized looking at the body and painting aveira (‫ תשובות והנהגות ח''ג סי' רס''ג‬,'‫)שו''ת אבני ישפה ח''א סי' קנ''א ענף ג‬. it [they took advantage of the opportunity and the fact that the [Nevertheless, one may enter Ben Gurion Airport despite the deceased was unable to object…] so that the tzaddik’s appearance statue of the Head Kofer Ben Gurion at the entrance…] would never be forgotten. However, the poskim opposed this Figure Covered with a Hat phenomenon due to the disgrace of the deceased involved in 26. We mentioned that a human form is only assur if the whole form exposing it and using the body for personal reasons, as well as due of the person appears; if some of the ears are missing, it is mutar to the issur of deriving benefit from a deceased body ( ‫בעל מתא‬ (Issue 391, par. 21). We were asked if a figure is considered missing ‫)דירושלים הובא בס' כהנא מסייע כהנא סי' י''ב‬. a limb if it has a hat concealing the ears or if the ears are hidden by 17. Shaagas Aryeh, Mahari Assad. This was done to the holy body of curly peyos or if it has the appearance of clothing blocking the view the Shaagas Aryeh. There is a painting of him lying on his deathbed of a body part. after his petira. Also, after the petirah of the Mahari Assad [a 27. A figure missing a body part is only considered incomplete if the talmid of Rav Mordechai Banet and the Chasam Sofer], who was viewer clearly sees the deficiency. However, if the figure appears opposed to being painted and photographed in his life, some complete, only the ears or another body part are not seen due to talmidim dressed his body in Shabbos clothing and propped him clothing or a hat, that is not considered a deficiency to allow one to manufacture or hold on to the figure ( ‫ אהל‬,‫חוט שני פסח עמ' רל''ב‬ up on his chair with a sefer in his hand. They brought a professional ‫)יעקב סי' קמ''א אות פ''ג‬. photographer to take the first and last photograph of his holy appearance. The talmidim rationalized their actions by using the Hand or Foot Fell Off Doll proceeds of the pictures to support and marry off the remaining 28. We mentioned that if there is a doll in a Jewish home, with respect orphans and grandchildren. [However, his grandson testified that to the issur of holding on to a human figure, one can strictly everyone who arranged and was involved in the picture passed speaking rely on the reasoning that inferior items thrown on the away young (‫)תולדות חייו בדברי מהרי''א‬.] floor may be held on to since the issur is only d’Rabanan (Issue 391, 18. Necessity. Of course if there is a need to photograph a deceased par. 23). However, if the doll’s head, hand, or foot fell off and one person, e.g., for a criminal investigation, to identify it, or the like, it wants to restore it and repair the doll, he should be careful to first is mutar. This is not a disgrace to the deceased and there is no damage the nose, eye, or ear. Now that he wants to repair it, there is a potential issur d’Oraisa of creating, for which we do not rely on benefit derived from the picture by anyone. the heteirim of inferior items as mentioned (ibid.) ( '‫חוט שני פסח עמ‬ Photographing Someone Against His Wishes ‫ יבקש תורה שו''ע סי' מ''ג‬,'‫ שו''ת שבט הלוי ח''ז סי' קל''ד אות ד‬,‫)רל''ב‬. 19. Mutar. The poskim discuss whether there is an issur to photograph Snowman a tzaddik who is known to oppose being photographed if he is in a 29. We are currently at the public place and it is not done in a way that will degrade or upset start of the winter, and the him or the like. Some hold it is mutar to photograph him since one children waiting for snowy cannot forbid something outside his domain to someone else days are already worried (‫ חוט שני הנ''ל‬,‫ שו''ת בצל החכמה ח''ד סי' פ''ה‬,‫)שו''ת שלמת חיים ח''ב סי' י''ט‬. whether they will be able 20. Assur. However, others argue. They hold a person can oppose being to make snowmen with photographed on grounds of ona’as devarim, and the photographer protruding limbs, e.g., a is violating his friend’s wishes ( ,‫ זכיות יוצרים סי' כ''ו עמ' רפ''ה‬,‫ס' משנת יהושע‬ carrot nose, bottle cap ‫ שערי אהרן או''ח ח''א עמ' כ''ט‬,‫)חזו''א‬. Alternatively, it is because one can eyes, etc. The shaila is refrain from being photographed if doing so will cause him harm, whether this is a problem including harm in Olam Haba (‫)שו''ת משנה הלכות ח''ז סי' קי''ד‬. of creating a human figure. 21. Derech eretz. Even if one does not have the halachic power to stop 30. The answer is: since it is made with a short-lasting material which others from photographing him, from a derech eretz perspective, is here today but will be gone tomorrow, it is not considered it is inappropriate to do something directly against someone’s making a figure. Not only is there no issue when the snowman wishes (‫)ארחות רבינו ח''ג עמ' פ''ז אות ס''ג‬. It is certainly a lack of derech does not resemble a human form, but even if it has a recognizable eretz to do something like this in the other person’s domain, e.g., human form, it is mutar for the above reason ( ,‫מו''ר בעל שבט הקהתי‬ photographing a rebbe who is known to oppose being ‫)אהל יעקב סי' קמ''א סי' ס''ה‬. photographed in his own tish hall. Balloon People 22. Causing damage to one who photographs without permission. If 31. Similarly, one may put up a doll made of balloons. This does not one went ahead and took a picture without permission, he cannot resemble a human form at all; it is far from having a realistic form. be forced to erase the picture. It is certainly assur to break his The face is usually made of a single balloon with eyes and the like camera, as one who does so is literally a ganav, not just someone colored using ink, which is not considered protruding. It is also in breach of middos and derech eretz. something that does not last. Common Shailos Regarding Human Forms Shailos About the Form of the Sun, Moon Human Form with a 3D Printer 32. There are many examples of brand-name 23. There are home 3D printers today watches with pictures of the sun and moon on which can print all sorts of 3D forms them. Sometimes they protrude, sometimes they taken from a regular picture. One are just pictures. We were asked whether one must be careful not to use one to may keep such a watch. print a human form, as doing so can 33. This depends. If only part of the sun or moon is easily violate an issur d’Oraisa of making a protruding human visible because it is blocked by the base of the watch face, the engraving if it is a full body figure, or even just the head according to watch may be kept. However if a complete image of the sun or some poskim (Issue 391, par. 16-17). As we mentioned, there is an issur moon is visible—even if the moon is a half-moon—one may not even if it is only for decoration (ibid., par. 7). [See ‫)שו"ת להורות נתן ח''ג‬ hold on to it due to the issur d’Rabanan of holding on to such )'‫ סי' נ‬who considers the idea that using a machine to create a face is images. If the watch is expensive, it may be sold to a non-Jew, as only a grama, but if so, all Shabbos issurim are gone in a situation of there is no issur to derive benefit from it. necessity, as anything done via a machine and the press of a button Sun-Shaped Cake is a grama, not a true action.] 34. We were asked about baking a cake shaped like the sun garnished with candies for Parshas ‫הגליון הוקדש לרגל כלות השלושים של‬ Vayeira, as a reference to Hashem “removing the ‫מנחם בנימין חיים רעעה‬ ‫בן‬ '‫ר‬ sun from its case.” We previously wrote that one may make a cake in the shape of the sun or moon, ‫נלב''ע כ"ד תשרי תשפ"ז‬ as that is not considered making an image of the sun; it is considered ‫נדבת בני המשפחה‬ making a cake which happens to be in the shape of the sun.