Beis Horaah — Chayei Sara (2026-11-02)

בית הוראה שערי עזרא
Bet Horaah Z M A N I M · N E W YO R K
Shaare Ezra
Candle Lighting 4:28pm
Shabbat Ends 5:29pm
R”T 5:57pm
The Weekly Halacha Newsletter of Rabbi Shay Tahan
VOLUME 3 · ISSUE 76 Parshat Chayei Sarah 2 7 C H E S H VA N 5 7 8 7 · N O V E M B E R 7 , 2 0 2 6
Halacha Question? WhatsApp 347-666-3467 · askhalacha1@gmail.com · Over 2,500 classes: Rabbishaytahan.com
Illustration
HALACHA & OUR TIMES
Keeping Your Word: Campaign Promises in Halacha
written by Rabbi Shay Tahan
Election season brings with it a flood of promises. Candid‐ promise in the first place, thereby violating the principle of not saying one thing
ates make commitments, voters place their trust in them, and once the election with his mouth while intending another in his heart. (See Ramban and Rosh,
is over, an important question arises: What does halacha say about the Bava Metzia 49a; Sma 204:12; Tosafot Yom Tov, end of Shevi’it.) The
obligation to keep one’s word? Is a promise merely an expression of intent, or Mordechai (Bava Metzia 311) cites an additional source: “The remnant of Israel
does it carry a genuine moral and halachic responsibility? The discussion begins shall not do wrong nor speak lies” (Tzefaniah 3:13).
with the Gemara. Rabbeinu Yonah (Sha’arei Teshuvah 3:183) expresses the severity of this
The Gemara (Bava Metzia 49a) quotes Rabbi Yochanan as teaching that a conduct in particularly strong terms. A person who promises to benefit another
person may retract a promise. The Gemara questions whether this is not and then fails to do so “walks in the way of falsehood.” Moreover, one who
obvious, since nothing physically prevents someone from going back on his publicly boasts that he will give something has gone beyond an ordinary
word. It therefore concludes that Rabbi Yochanan is teaching something more promise. His public declaration itself carries the weight of a commitment, and
fundamental: under certain circumstances, retracting a promise is actually per‐ he may not retract after having gained honor from it. Rabbeinu Yonah invokes
mitted. the verse: “Clouds and wind but no rain—so is a man who boasts of a false
Rav Pappa qualifies this ruling, explaining that the permission to retract applies gift” (Mishlei 25:14).
only to a large gift (matana merubah), but not to a small gift (matana mu’etet). This principle has particular relevance to campaign promises. A candidate who
The distinction rests on the degree to which the recipient relies on the promise. publicly announces that he will provide a benefit, and thereby gains honor and
When the gift is small, the recipient naturally expects the giver to follow support, cannot simply dismiss his words as meaningless once the election is
through and relies on his word. When the gift is substantial, however, the over. The permission to retract a promise of a large gift applies to a sincere
recipient does not place the same degree of reliance on a verbal promise alone. promise upon which the recipient does not fully rely. It certainly does not
The Shulchan Aruch (Choshen Mishpat 204:8) rules accordingly. One who permit someone to make promises with no intention of fulfilling them.
promises another a gift and then fails to deliver it is considered mechusar A TWO-SIDED AGREEMENT
amanah—lacking in trustworthiness—when the gift is small, because the
recipient relied on his promise. With a large gift, however, he is not subject to
the same designation, since the recipient did not fully rely on a promise that had
not been formalized through an act of acquisition. What constitutes a small gift
depends on the circumstances and the means of the giver. For a wealthy person,
even a substantial gift may be considered small.
THE SOURCE OF THE OBLIGATION
What is the source of this obligation? Some Rishonim derive it from the verse, Illustration
“( ”הִ ין צֶדֶ קVayikra 19:36), which the Gemara expounds to mean, “Let your yes
There is, however, another dimension to this discussion, one that may be even
be righteous and your no be righteous.” According to this approach, the more directly relevant to elections.
obligation to keep one’s word may have a Torah basis. Others, including the
Ramban and the Rosh, understand the obligation to be rabbinic. They explain The discussion above concerns a promise to give something without receiving
that the Torah prohibition addresses a person who never intended to fulfill his anything in return. A different halachic principle applies when two parties enter
askhalacha.com · 1
B E T H O R A A H S H A A R E E Z R A · PA R S H AT C H AY E I S A R A H · V O L . 3 , I S S U E 7 6
into a verbal agreement, each undertaking something in exchange for the other’s mechusar amanah. Having obtained the votes he sought, he cannot simply
commitment. regard his promises as having served their purpose and discard them. The fact
The Rambam (Hilchot Mechirah 7:8) writes that when two people reach an that the understanding was made with the public rather than with a single
agreement through words alone, without money changing hands or a formal act individual does not diminish the seriousness of the trust placed in him.
of acquisition, it is nevertheless proper for each to stand by his word. One who Of course, not every campaign statement constitutes a definite undertaking.
retracts is considered mechusar amanah, and “the spirit of the Sages is displeased There is a meaningful difference between expressing a general aspiration,
with him.” The Shulchan Aruch (Choshen Mishpat 204:7) rules accordingly. promising to work toward a particular goal, and making an explicit
The Rosh (Bava Metzia 4:12) discusses the obligation to honor such a verbal commitment to take a specific action in exchange for electoral support.
agreement, and some Rishonim understand it to have a Torah basis, while the Furthermore, a candidate may undertake to pursue a policy without being able
Rambam’s wording—that it is proper for a person to stand by his word— to guarantee its ultimate success, particularly when its implementation depends
suggests a different level of obligation. on legislators, other officials, or circumstances beyond his control. The
The distinction is significant. In an ordinary promise of a gift, the recipient obligation is to act honestly and make a genuine effort to fulfill what he
relies on the giver’s generosity. In a two-sided agreement, however, each party undertook, not to guarantee an outcome beyond his power.
relies on the other’s commitment. One agrees to do something because the BEYOND ELECTION SEASON
other has undertaken to do something in return. Although no formal
transaction has taken place, the parties have reached an understanding, and Ultimately, the lesson of these sources extends far beyond election season. A
retracting one’s commitment undermines the trust upon which their agreement person’s word is not an empty sound. Whether speaking privately or addressing
rests. thousands of people, whether promising a gift or entering into an agreement,
one must recognize the responsibility that comes with giving his word. We may
A campaign promise may fall into this category. A candidate asks the public for
not all reach the extraordinary level of Rav Safra, whose exemplary honesty is
its votes and, in return, promises to pursue certain policies or take particular
described by the Gemara (Makkot 24a), but his conduct reminds us of the
actions if elected. The voters, in turn, give him their support in reliance on those
standard toward which every person—and certainly every public leader—
commitments. This is no longer merely a promise to bestow a gift; it is an
should strive: that his yes should remain yes, his word should be reliable, and his
undertaking made in order to obtain something in return.
promises should be made with the sincere intention of keeping them.
Accordingly, when a candidate makes a genuine commitment to voters as an
inducement for their support, there is a strong basis to apply the principle of
*To receive the weekly newsletter please email us at askhalacha1@gmail.com
HALACHA & OUR TIMES
The Winner Takes Nothing? When Election Fraud Invalidates the Vote
written by Rabbi Shay Tahan
Election fraud is hardly a new phenomenon. Throughout bribes, however, may not take part in this appointment at all—even if they
history, people have sought to manipulate the outcome of elections through return the money and accept upon themselves never to take a bribe again.
deception, bribery, and other forms of dishonesty. Although modern elections
involve systems and procedures that did not exist in earlier times, the underlying
questions are far from new. The Torah and Chazal address situations of
dishonesty and manipulation that provide important principles for understand‐
ing the halachic implications of election fraud.
What is the halachic perspective on election fraud? Does bribery invalidate an
election? Can a candidate who manipulates the voting process remain eligible
for office? And if a fraudulent act does not change the outcome, does it still
Illustration
undermine the validity of the result? To answer these questions, we must
examine the relevant sources in Chazal and the poskim. The Chatam Sofer adds an important qualification: all this applies only when
the bribery is established by valid testimony. Without it, the rabbi does not lose
THE CHATAM SOFER: BRIBERY IN A RABBINICAL his position—even if the bribe-takers and the relatives who paid them confess—
ELECTION since their word cannot take away his appointment.
An instructive precedent appears in the responsa of the Chatam Sofer (Choshen This ruling raises fundamental questions. Does bribery invalidate the entire
Mishpat 160, cited in Pitchei Teshuvah, Choshen Mishpat 8:2), who addressed election, or only the votes affected? Can a candidate retain a position obtained
the election of a community rabbi. Four candidates were chosen, and their through a process tainted by fraud? And what responsibility rests upon voters
names were placed in a ballot box. Each name drawn was brought to a vote; if a who accept payment in exchange for their votes?
majority accepted him, he would become the rabbi, and if not, the next name
was drawn. The community rejected the first two candidates and elected the WHEN A LOTTERY IS INVALID
third by a majority. A few days later, it became known that many of the voters The Shulchan Aruch (Choshen Mishpat 175:3) discusses two brothers who
had accepted bribes from the rabbi’s relatives. divided three fields: each took one, and they shared the third. Then a third
The Chatam Sofer ruled that if two valid witnesses—not members of the brother appeared whom they had not known about. A lottery was cast, and his
community and not relatives of either side—testify to the bribery, the entire lot fell on the shared field, so each brother seemingly kept exactly what he had.
election is void from the outset. This is true even if the bribe-takers were few Nevertheless, either brother may cancel the entire division and redraw all three
and the candidate still had a majority of untainted votes. The reason is that the fields, since the original division was made in error, without the third brother.
bribery tainted not only the vote for the winner, but also the rejection of the The Chavot Yair (Responsa, no. 61) applies this halacha to a lottery among his
earlier candidates; the honest voters can claim that they accepted the third own students. Twelve of them celebrated together on Purim and cast lots for a
candidate only because the first two had already been rejected. large gilded silver goblet, each contributing toward its cost. Two boxes were
If witnesses establish that the candidate himself arranged the bribes, he is used: one held twelve slips with the participants' names, and the other held
disqualified from serving as rabbi until he repents. If, however, only his relatives twelve slips, one marked “mazal tov” and the rest blank. A child drew one slip
were involved, he retains his presumption of innocence and may stand again in a from each box, and whoever’s name came out together with the “mazal tov” slip
new vote among the three remaining candidates. The voters who accepted would win the goblet.
askhalacha.com · 2
B E T H O R A A H S H A A R E E Z R A · PA R S H AT C H AY E I S A R A H · V O L . 3 , I S S U E 7 6
The winning slip came out unusually quickly, and when they checked, they
discovered that there were only ten blank slips—and two slips marked “mazal CHEATING IN THE BEIT HAMIKDASH
tov.” The winner argued that whether the mistake was intentional, accidental, Attempts to manipulate a lottery are not a new phenomenon. Remarkably, even
or a joke, it gave no one an advantage over anyone else. The Chavot Yair in the Beit Hamikdash, where the Kohanim performed the sacred service of
nevertheless ruled that the lottery was void, based on the halacha of the brothers Hashem, the Sages established safeguards against cheating.
in the Shulchan Aruch.
The Mishnah (Yoma 22a) relates that originally, any Kohen who wished to
They cast the lots again, and this time, after a winner was drawn, someone perform the terumat hadeshen, the removal of the ashes from the Mizbe’ach,
opened the remaining slips and discovered that one participant’s name had been could do so. When many wished to perform it, they would race up the ramp,
left out entirely. The winner argued that the others had no grounds to complain and whoever reached the top first won. Once, two Kohanim were running neck
—if anything, the omission had improved their chances—and he offered the and neck, and one pushed the other, who fell and broke his leg. The Sages then
excluded participant four reichsthaler, which satisfied him. The Chavot Yair instituted that the terumat hadeshen be assigned only by lottery.
ruled that this lottery, too, was void. Compensation and consent could not cure
In this lottery, the Kohanim stood in a circle and each extended a finger. The
the defect in the procedure.
appointed Kohen chose a number and counted the fingers, and the Kohen at
The Chavot Yair explains that a lottery properly conducted, without human whose finger the count ended was chosen. The Mishnah states that a Kohen
scheming, is the vehicle of Divine Providence, as the verse states, “The lot is cast could extend one finger or two, but not his thumb. The Gemara explains that
into the lap, but its every decision is from Hashem” (Mishlei 16:33). When the this rule was a safeguard against cheaters.
lottery is defective—whether through human trickery or by mistake—we
Even in the Beit Hamikdash, the sanctity of the service did not eliminate the
cannot say that the winner received his prize from Hashem. Each participant
possibility of dishonesty; it made the need for safeguards all the more import‐
can claim that had the lottery been conducted properly, his own merit or his
ant.
prayers might have brought him success.
He then goes further: if someone deliberately slipped two slips bearing his own CONCLUSION
name into the box, and another participant won, and the cheater later revealed These sources demonstrate that halacha places great importance on the integrity
what he had done, the others may still cancel the lottery—and even the cheater of the process by which a winner is selected. Bribery, deliberate manipulation,
himself may do so. The fact that the fraud did not benefit the one who and procedural defects cannot simply be dismissed because a winner has been
committed it does not save the result. declared or because the misconduct did not change the result. At the same time,
These cases raise an important question for elections: If a candidate deliberately the Chatam Sofer teaches that such claims must be established by valid
manipulates the voting process, does it matter whether the manipulation testimony; rumor or suspicion alone does not overturn a result. The precise
actually changes the winner? The Chavot Yair’s ruling demonstrates that, in the halachic consequences depend on the circumstances and the governing rules,
context of a lottery, the integrity of the process itself is essential. Whether the but the underlying principle is clear: an election must be conducted honestly
same conclusion applies to a particular election requires further halachic and properly for its outcome to command legitimacy.
analysis, but the principle provides an important starting point.
HALACHA & OUR TIMES
Elections and Lashon Hara: What May We Say, and What May We Hear?
written by Rabbi Shay Tahan
The recent elections brought out a flood of slander. Can‐ And if one sits in a group that starts speaking forbidden things and rebuke
didates attacked each other, campaigns spread stories, and the same dirt was won’t help, it is a great mitzvah to leave or even to put a finger in one’s ears (Klal
passed from WhatsApp group to WhatsApp group, at the Shabbat table and in 6:5).
shul. Many good people joined in without a second thought: “It’s politics,”
“Everyone knows it anyway,” “It’s true.”
But the Torah’s rules don’t take a break during election season. Is it permitted
to say these things? Is it permitted to listen?
TRUE IS NOT A HETER
The Chofetz Chaim (Lashon Hara, Klal 1:1) rules that it is forbidden to speak
negatively about another Jew even if it is completely true. That is exactly what Illustration
Chazal call lashon hara, and the speaker transgresses “Lo telech rachil
be’amecha.” If any falsehood is mixed in, it becomes motzi shem ra, which is far WHEN IT IS PERMITTED: LE’TO’ELET
worse. And one who makes a habit of it, sitting and telling “so-and-so did this, I The Torah does not want a person to be harmed because others kept quiet. The
heard that about him,” is called a baal lashon hara, whose punishment is much Chofetz Chaim (Rechilut, Klal 9:1) writes that if one sees that his friend wants
greater (Klal 1:3). to go into partnership with someone, and he believes it will surely cause him
harm, he must tell him in order to save him. But this requires five conditions
LISTENING IS ALSO FORBIDDEN (Klal 9:2):
The Chofetz Chaim (Klal 6:1) rules that it is a Torah prohibition to accept
lashon hara, meaning to believe in your heart that the story is true. Even just 1 Do not jump to conclusions. First examine carefully whether the
listening is forbidden by the Torah, even if you don’t plan to believe it, since you matter is truly bad.
are lending your ear (Klal 6:2).
However, there is a difference between listening and accepting. If the 2 Do not exaggerate. Tell it no worse than it actually is.
information is relevant to you for the future, for example you were about to go
into business with this person, you may listen in order to be cautious and
protect yourself. The same applies if hearing it will help others. But to accept it,
to decide in your heart that it is true, is forbidden in every case (Klal 6:2).
askhalacha.com · 3
B E T H O R A A H S H A A R E E Z R A · PA R S H AT C H AY E I S A R A H · V O L . 3 , I S S U E 7 6
other people’s money. Warn Shimon beforehand. This is not lashon hara, but all
3 Intend only to help, to prevent the harm, and not out of hatred the conditions of Klal 9 must be met.
for the other person. Included in this, first think whether telling will
actually accomplish anything. If the listener won’t heed you and will WHAT THIS MEANS FOR ELECTIONS
partner with him anyway, and later, when they quarrel, will say “so- Choosing a leader is, in a sense, entering into a partnership with him. We place
and-so was right about you,” there is no heter at all. our community’s interests in his hands. So there can be real to’elet in warning
people about a candidate, if one truly knows something that would harm the
4 If the benefit can be achieved without revealing anything public. But all the conditions apply: know it firsthand or verified, examine it
negative, it is forbidden to tell. carefully, don’t exaggerate, speak only to protect and not out of party hatred, say
only what is necessary, and stay within the truth. Spreading a story you saw
forwarded, mocking a candidate, or repeating rumors to make “our side” look
5 The telling may not cause the person actual harm. Losing the
good does not meet these conditions. That is plain lashon hara, and often motzi
benefit the other would have given him is permitted, but causing him shem ra.
real damage requires further conditions, and certainly no harm
beyond what halacha would impose. The requirement of firsthand knowledge also includes hearing on line a speech
in which he made a promise that could potentially harm our community, or the
In Lashon Hara (Klal 10:1-2), the Chofetz Chaim adds that one who saw like. Also, if he has a record of engaging in behavior that is harmful to our way
someone wrong his fellow may publicize it to help the victim and to denounce of life, this may be relevant as well. Furthermore, the requirement to rebuke him
the act. The conditions there include: he saw it himself rather than heard it, he first may not apply in this case, assuming that he would not listen anyway (Klal
first rebuked the wrongdoer gently, he does not exaggerate, his intent is to help 10:7).
and not to enjoy the other’s shame, there is no other way, and no harm results The same goes for listening. A voter who wants to know relevant facts about a
beyond what beis din would rule. And if the speaker is guilty of the same sins candidate in order to vote responsibly may listen, in order to be careful. But he
himself, it is forbidden, because his intent is not for good but to gloat (Klal may not accept as fact everything he hears, and he must not sit and enjoy an
10:3). hour of political gossip.
Another heter is when the candidate is a wicked person who doesn’t believe in
The elections will pass. The words we spoke, and hashem or the torah. Or if he vows to fight the torah and the yeshiva system
(klal 7:5 and Tshuvot vehanagot 3:478).
the ones we listened to, remain. The elections will pass. The words we spoke, and the ones we listened to,
remain. May we merit to guard our mouths and our ears, and to see true leaders
who bring blessing to Klal Yisrael.
THE TZIYURIM
Rabbi Shay Tahan is the Rosh Kollel of Kollel Shaarei Ezra located in Bnei Yosef,
At the end of Hilchot Rechilut, the Chofetz Chaim brings Tziyurim, practical on Avenue P and Ocean Parkway, and he is the head of the Bet-Horaha Arzei
cases. In the first: you see Reuven wanting to go into business with Shimon, Halevanon. You can hear Rabbi Tahans classes at Torahanytime.com and in
who doesn’t know him, and you know well that Reuven doesn’t care about Askhalacha.com.
Originally published in The Jewish Vues, October 28 – November 3, 2026.
About Shaare Ezra
Halacha Question?
Shaare Ezra is a one of a kind, multi-faceted organization that’s there for the community. Under the leadership
W H AT S A P P
of HaRav Shay Tahan שליט״א. Shaare Ezra feels that proper Halachic guidance should be accessible to
347-666-3467
everyone, therefore we offer the community the opportunity to call, text, WhatsApp, or e-mail any halachic
EMAIL
questions they may have, through the Bet Horaah, where qualified, trained and ordained Rabbis are available
askhalacha1@gmail.com
to answer your questions in English, Hebrew and Russian. Shaare Ezra is from the community—for the com‐
munity. Over 2,500 classes can be found at
Rabbishaytahan.com
Now you can also download our newsletters from the following websites: Shiurenjoyment, Dirshu, Ladaat, Gilyonos, Kol Halashon, Parsha Sheets, Chidush,
Shareplus. Prog.
ASK HALACHA · ENGLISH
Ask the Rabbi Online
Halacha answers, classes, articles and videos by Rabbi
Shay Tahan — all in one place. Have a question? Ask it
on the site.
askhalacha.com
ASK HALACHA · РУССКИЙ
Галаха на русском языке
Ответы раввина Шая Тахана на вопросы по галахе
— теперь и на русском. Задайте свой вопрос
раввину на сайте.
askhalacha.com/category/russian
askhalacha.com · 4
