Lehisvada - English — Chayei Sara (2026-11-02)

Bechoros 49
On paying the Pidyon Haben before day thirty.
. אין בנו פדוי, מעכשיו, דכולי עלמא. ושמואל אמר אין בנו פדוי. רב אמר בנו פדוי, הפודה את בנו בתוך שלשים יום, איתמר:בבכורות דף מ"ט
, מידי דהוה אקידושי אשה, רב אמר בנו פדוי, כי פליגי לאחר שלשים יום ונתעכלו המעות,לאחר שלשים יום ואיתנהו למעות ודאי בנו פדוי
הכא אין בידו לפדותו, התם בידו לקדשה מעכשיו, ושמואל אמר לך. הכא נמי לא שנא,התם לאו אף על גב דנתעכלו המעות הוו קידושי
. הכא הלכתא כוותיה דשמואל, ואף על גב דקיימא לן דכל היכא דפליגי רב ושמואל הלכתא כרב באיסורי וכשמואל בדיני.מעכשיו
-א-
Pidyon haben paid before day thirty is not davar shelo ba la’olam.
Something that is just a matter of time is not considered shelo ba by itself, and the law that one cannot transfer davar shelo
la’olam / On day thirty, the Kohen holds the father’s five sela’im ba la’olam is only said about something which requires
for the pidyon of his son / By giving the five sela’im before day further action for it to happen, such as kiddushin to
thirty, it is considered as if he told him that it will be a deposit a married woman such that it takes effect after she is
until day thirty when he will acquire them / The mitzvah of divorced, which still requires giving a get. And he proves
pidyon haben is fulfilled through the transfer of five sela’im to from our Gemora that mechusar zman is not considered
the Kohen and there is no issue of davar shelo ba la’olam
davar shelo ba la’olam.2
פסקי הלכות יד דוד, ראשית ביכורים, אבני מילואים,משנה למלך
But the Avnei Milu’im3 disputes the Mishnah Lamel-
As stated, if the father gave five sela’im to the Kohen ech’s view that mechusar zman is not considered davar
before day thirty with the intent that the pidyon will take shelo ba la’olam, and he holds that it is also considered
effect when day thirty arrives, and the Kohen still has the shelo ba la’olam.
money on day thirty, all agree that his son is redeemed.
And regarding what the Mishnah Lamelech com-
And the Mishnah Lamelech1 comments, how can one ments how can the pidyon be done before day thirty to
give the money before day thirty such that the pidyon take effect on day thirty, on this he writes that by pidyon
will take effect on day thirty, for the rule is that anything haben there is no issue of davar shelo ba la’olam, because
that one cannot effect now, he cannot do it to take effect pidyon haben is not like kiddushin or a get which need to
later, for this is included in the teaching that one cannot be effected by the husband, or like commercial transac-
transfer something that does not yet exist (davar shelo ba tions which must be effected by the owners, where we
la’olam), and if so, how can the pidyon be done through say that what he is incapable of doing now, he cannot
giving the money now such that the transfer takes effect effect to happen later, because by pidyon haben, if on
on day thirty, since the pidyon cannot be effected today. day thirty the father’s money is sitting by the Kohen,
And he writes that something which cannot be done the Kohen can acquire it for himself, and through this
today because it is not yet its time (mechusar zman) is the son is redeemed, and therefore, when he gives five
דף היומי
not considered shelo ba la’olam, because the time comes sela’im to the Kohen before day thirty so that the pidyon
1
Bechoros 49
On paying
Shabbosbefore dayChes
Daf Lamed thirty
takes effect on day thirty, if the Kohen still has the indeed considered shelo ba la’olam, and even so, giving
L’halacha the Rishonim disagree concerning whether we pasken
money on day thirty, the pidyon takes effect through the theOnmoney
the other hand, the Biur HaGra there goes to great lengths and
for pidyon haben before day thirty is not con-
like Rebbi Meir or Rebbi Yehudah. The Rif 9 asserts that the halacha concludes like Rebbi Meir. The Mishna Berurah 18 cites this opinion
KohenRebbi
follows acquiringYehudah, theandmoney the Ranfor himselfhisforreasoning
10 explains the saketo of be the Gradavar
sidered
of and how shelo ba la’olam.
he follows in the footsteps of Tosafos and his
the son’s
because Ravpidyon,
publiclyand without
darshened as the
such.father having
This being the given
case the it colleagues who all pasken
And he explains, that although like Rebbi Meir it isthattrue evenforb’mayzid
things like it is
halacha follows suit. The same is raised by both the Rambam 11 and only assur to eat from food cooked on Shabbos until Motzei Shabbos.
to the Kohen before day thirty, the pidyon will take effect kiddushin
Ramban 12 as well. Additionally, the Beis Yosef 13 writes that the This applies ofeven a married
to the onewoman who cooked so that it, and it takes
b’shogeig effect after
everyone
on day thirty through
words of the Rosh seem to lean this way too.
14 the Kohen acquiring the father’s thepartake
can divorce, fromthat the foodsince the kiddushin
immediately on Shabbos cannot itself.take effect
The Mishna
money which is under his control.15[Although there are Berurah now, he cannot affect kiddushin to happen later.onAnd
asserts that in a time of need one is allowed to rely this
On the other hand, Tosafos in Chullin asserts that the halacha where the food was cooked b’shogeig.
some who
follow Rebbihold Meir,that and the his father
reasoned only fulfills the
is because this mitzvah
is how Rav of although a person can do kiddushin today such that it
pidyon haben
instructed throughAdditionally,
his students. the act of giving the Beisthe money
Yosef 16 to the
brings this The implication of his words is that it is specifically with regards
takes
to shogeig
effect after thirty days, this is only if the kiddushin
that one can rely on Tosafos to pasken like Rebbi Meir.
Kohen,both
b’shem andthenot Smag and Sefer
through theHaTerumah
Kohen taking as well.it for himself,
canthealso
On othertakehand,effect
b’mayzid today, but kiddushin
on wouldn’t be allowed to ofrelya married
on Rebbi
though there isAruch
The Shulchan no room 17 determinesto expand further
like the opinionshere].of the Rif, opinion allowing the cook
woman, since the kiddushin cannot take effect today,
Meir’s to partake from the food on Motzeihe
Rambam, and Rosh to pasken like Rebbi Yehudah (as we have already Shabbos. With regard to a mayzid we must act stringently like Rebbi
And the sefer Reishit Bikkurim explains slightly dif- Yehudah
mentioned).
cannot who kiddushin
do holds for after, because it is something
that the food is perpetually assur.
ferently why it is not considered davar shelo ba la’olam, which he cannot even do today.
and he writes that if the father gave the kohen five sela’im- ב- But by pidyon haben, when he gives the money to the
before thirty days Maiseh for the Shabbospidyonwith to take
regard effect
to aon day where
Melacha Kohennothingbefore is daydone thirty to such
the object
that the itselfpidyon takes effect
thirty, it is considered that until day thirty the money is on day thirty, there is no concept of something that he
Where one was motzi something from one reshus to the speaking, the issur of Maiseh Shabbos is not something specific to
sitting
other,by if the
suchKohen
a thing as a deposit,
is assur becauseand on dayShabbos
of Maiseh thirty it/ is Bishul cannot do today
creating an issur thatforheone is acting
to eat food to take cooked effect on tomorrow,
Shabbos. On
considered that heSpecifics is givinginitthis to inyan
him to acquire, and we the contrary, it applies to any Melacha.
because pidyon haben entails nothing more than giving If someone transgresses any
find that the pidyon is performed on ,טור
day- thirty through of the Melachos Shabbos it is then forbidden for him to benefit from
- רבנו יונה ,' תוס, חיי אדם,רמ"א five sela’im
what to a Kohen,inand
he did. Additionally, the there
Shulchan is nothing
Aruch 19 the that needs
Mechaber
[that it is considered
]בAlthough both our Mishna as if he and gave
Gemara it toonly himmakeonreference
that day.to bringsto takethiseffect
concept andofno nottransfer,
being able because
to eat what the Kohen one cooked is noton
This is unlike kiddushin of a married woman for after
cooking on Shabbos, it is already made known from the Tur that Shabbos, and the Rema adds that
transferring anything to the father in exchange for the this is applicable to the other
this concept of Maiseh Shabbos doesn’t differentiate. Practically Melachos as well.
she is divorced which does not take effect even if she money, only that there is a mitzvah to give money to the
still has the money, because kiddushin take effect only
NOTESKohen on day thirty, and before day thirty it is not yet
through giving money together with saying to her ‘harei time to perform the mitzvah, and we find that essentially,
If a Maiseh Shabbos is assur b’hana’ah / Two aspects to Maiseh concerning where one toivels vessels on Shabbos. We say there that if done b’shogeig
at mekudeshet li’, and at the time he gave her the money
Shabbos, and the difference between Mevashel and other Melachos / the core of the pidyon is just giving five sela’im to the
he may use them, and b’mayzid not. As such, it is clear that the issur Maiseh Shabbos
andSomething
said thecooked wordsonbefore Shabbos heris divorce,
given similar shestatus
was like davar applies
to other Kohen, even and there
to benefit throughis something’s
no placeusage, to debate
and not just whether this is
an issur achilah.
forbidden foods / Where one cooked water and it got cold again /
shelo baWhere la’olam, and after she was divorced he did not
one cooked water for washing and it got cold again davar
On theshelo
other ba
hand,la’olam,
concerningsince the isaction
Bishul there an additionalof giving
element. money
When one
say to her to be mekudeshet - מנחת שלמה with
שו"ת-the money he already
cooks on Shabbos the meat gets a din of
to the Kohen, he can give him money even before thirty basar tereifah m’drabbanan. As such, it
becomes assur for consumption just like all other forbidden foods. Because of this
gave
[1] The her,
Minchasand that’scomments
Shlomo 31
why there on thisis nothekiddushin,
that Tur writes howbut pidyon
the din Maiseh days,
the Magen and he can
Avraham also
asserts
34 thatgive
even themoney
pot it was tocooked
the Kohenin becomeseven if
assur as
Shabbos applies to all Melachos making it assur to benefit from the act performed.
haben, which only requires the father giving money to
He points out that according to this the issur Maiseh Shabbos isn’t specifically an
well. One then needs to do hagalah on the pot
he doesn’t have a son. And we find that what we said that and it is necessary even if a 24 hour
period passes making it no longer a Ben Yomo. Although there would have logically
the Kohen, is considered on day thirty that he is giving been
issur achilah (eating) but also an issur ha’na’ah (benfit). However, this is difficult oneroom cantogive
say thatfive sela’im
after 24 hoursbefore day thirty
the pot should only givesuch that tastes
off negative the
to understand. In Bava Kama we see that even Rebbi Yochanan Hasandler who
32
him the money, and then the pidyon takes effect.
holds Maiseh Shabbos is assur min hatorah, nevertheless this is only an issur achilah
through which one doesn’t benefit, nevertheless
pidyon takes effect on day thirty, is that the father gives we see clearly that the Chachamim
made the issur Maiseh Shabbos by Bishul comparable to all other forbidden foods.
Indeed, in the Piskei Halachos Yad David , he The
and not an issur ha’na’ah, and it is something learnt out from pesukim. Now, 4 if this
moneysame wayto bythe otherKohen
issurim the todaypot is such
also assurthat for the transfer
use even when nottakesa Ben
is true (that the issur is only an issur achilah and not an issur ha’na’ah) for Rebbi
Yomo, so too this follows for Maiseh Shabbos as well.
explains
Yochanan that giving
Hasandler who holds five sela’im
that Maiseh Shabbos assur pidyon
foris the min hatorah, haben
then it effect on day thirty, like any other delayed transfer of a
before
must dayshould
certainly thirty
be theso casethat it Rebbi
for both takesMeireffect onYehuda
and Rebbi day thirty,
who hold gift,
Withandthis therefore
in mind we can if now
theexplain
money whatis is still
said inthere,
Bava Kama everyone
that even
the issur is merely m’drabbanan. As such, it is difficult to understand how we can according to Rebbi Yochanan Hasandler the issur is only an issur achilah and not an
hasit no
say problem
is assur to benefit offromdavar
all types shelo ba la’olam,
of Maiseh Shabbos. and unlike the agrees
issur thatWhat
ha’na’ah. thethis pidyon
means takes
to say iseffect through
that although the fooditsgetacquisition
the status of a
Mishnah Lamelech who proves from this
To answer he asserts that in truth there are two forms of the issur Maiseh that mechusar on
maichalday thirty,
assur, and
nevertheless thus
this onlythe father
makes fulfills
it forbidden the
for mitzvah,
consumption and
and not
benefit. It doesn’t become like Arlah, Klayim, or Hekdesh where benefit is also
zman isTherefore,
Shabbos. although by alldavar
not considered sheloone
the Melachos badoes
la’olam, rather
on Shabbos there itis is
an there isHowever,
forbidden. no issue this of davar
is said shelowith
specifically ba regard
la’olam. to benefit that one could
issur to benefit from them, nevertheless this doesn’t pose a contradiction to what the
have enjoyed even before the Maiseh was performed. This is because it isn’t caused
Gemara in Bava Kama says concerning how a Maiseh Shabbos is only assur for
by the forbidden Melacha such as where one benefits through giving the food to his
consumption and not benefit. We will now bring a brief account of his words.
friend as a gift, or to his animal to eat. As long as these things are done in a way
The first thing to know is that by all Melachos Shabbos whenever the Melacha where one doesn’t benefit from the Bishul itself, we then say that although the
actually activates the object for benefit, then it most certainly is assur to benefit from Chachamim gave it the status of forbidden food, nevertheless this only makes it assur
the Maiseh Shabbos. Examples would include where one heats up water for bathing for his consumption and not benefit. On the other hand, there is also benefit which
purposes, or launders clothing to wear. In such cases it is assur to benefit from the one is only capable of having through the act of Bishul that was performed. Such
act of issur although in both situations the issur is purely benefit related. This is benefit is most definitely assur being that it is only had through the act of issur, and
דף היומי
because it is assur to use something if the usage only comes through benefitting from this is clear from what the Mishna teaches that one may not use vessels which he
one of the Melachos Shabbos. The source for this is from the Mishna in Terumos 33 toiveled on Shabbos.
2
Bechoros 49
On paying
Shabbosbefore dayChes
Daf Lamed thirty
-ב-
On the other hand, from the Poskim it isn’t so cut and dry that which happened on Yom Tov. His point is to show that there truly is
If the money is spentnobefore
the issur Maiseh Shabbos applies to all of the 39 Melachos. It day thirty.
issur Hotza’ah applicable. On Yom Tov such an act is completely
becomes clear from them that there is a possibility some are excluded, muttar. He even adds that of course it would be assur to eat the fruits
and According to Rabi
we will now go onMeir who holds that it is possible to do
to elaborate. ifhis
theyson
wereisn’t redeemed,
actually removed intobecause he is onincapable
a public domain of
Shabbos itself
just like the din by Mevashel. The Magen Avraham 25 cites the words
kiddushin for after her divorce, do the kiddushin take effect if
The Chayei Adam 20asserts that the issur Maiseh Shabbos is redeeming him today, is a general rule which applies to
of Tosafos.
the money
applicable is spent /where
specifically Whensomething
paying theispidyon haben
done to beforeitself.
the object day A anything that he does such that it is effected after some
thirty,change
physical is he transferring
has to happen thesuch
money nowresult
as the so theof pidyon
cookingtakes
food or Thethat
time, even26ifanswers
Ramban Tosafos’s
he can cause it toquestion using later
be effected a different
even
anything comparable. On the other hand, when one
effect on day thirty, or does the transfer of the money also need is Motzi approach. He writes that although all types of Maiseh Shabbos are
something from one domain to another where the actual object isn’t
though it cannot take effect today, still, if the money is
assur on Shabbos itself in order to prevent their benefit (such as what
to take effect on day thirty
physically affected, if done b’shogeig it can be used on Shabbos itself spent
one by then,
cooked, took itMa’aser
no longer off takes
from, effect.
or anything comparable),
and even by the person חזון איש
who,תוספות ,אלגאזיtheמהרי"ט
committed act. If done b’mayzid it nevertheless the fruits here are different. They began in the person’s
And therefore, he writes that according to Rabi Meir
is assur even to others, but only until
As stated, Rav and Shmuel dispute Shabbos. Motzei regarding He one
does house, were removed to a public area, and then brought back to the
conclude though that one should be stringent with all Issurei Torah who holds
house. As such,that
7
thereone
is nocan transfer
reason to assurdavar
them.shelo
Theyba la’olam,
didn’t come
wholike
just gave the money
by Mevashel. Thebefore day thirty
Biur Halacha 21 citeswith the inten-
his words plainly and can do kiddushin to a married woman to take effect
to the house through issur Shabbos being that they actually originated
tion that
without the pidyon
bringing will take effect on day thirty, and the
any opposition. there. No benefit is had from a Maiseh Shabbos at all.
after her divorce, according to Shmuel this is only effec-
money wasthe
However, spent
truthbyis day
that thirty. Ravis holds
this matter alreadythat the son
broached is
by the tiveHeifthen
sheadds
stillthat
hasof the money
course if they after
were to theremain
divorce,
in the but
publicif
redeemed,
Rishonim. like
It all in kiddushin
begins for after
with the Gemara thirty 22days
in Eiruvin where
which if
teaches domain (without being returned to the house)
the money was spent, the kiddushin isn’t effective even it would be assur to eat
how
the ifmoney
fruits were removedthe
is spent, from their techum
kiddushin andtakes
still later returned, even
effect, and them. Consuming them there would be to do so through the means of
if this was done b’mayzid there is no loss to their location. What this according
issur Shabbos.toOnRabi Meir,
the other justwhen
hand, as his son to
returned is the
nothouse
redeemed
one can
Shmuel holds that unlike by kiddushin which he was also
means is that even if they were returned b’mayzid it is still permissible if the
eat themmoney is spent
there being that nobecause
benefit is he hadcouldn’t
from a Maisehredeem him
Shabbos.
capable
for them toofbedoing
consumed when place. her the money, pidyon
he gave
in their whenWhathe gaveclear
become thefrom money.
Tosafos, This is also and
the Rashba, implied
Rambaninis thethat
haben which cannot be done before day thirty, does
Tosafos there 23 questions why the fruits should be permissible for Mishnah Lamelech.
concerning where one actually [1] transgresses the issur Hotza’ah
not take effect
consumption whenon day thirty
returned b’mayzidif the
frommoney
outsideisthe
spent. [And
techum. We d’oraisa, there it would be assur for him to benefit through the issur
know that onedispute
may not ifeat
But the Chazon Ish8 cites Tosfos9 who writes that
the Poskim thefood which was
Halachah cookedRav
is with b’mayzid
or withon Maiseh Shabbos.
Shabbos. He answers that cooking is different because it involves the according to Rabi Meir who holds that one can do
Shmuel, and the Shulchan Aruch cites two opinions in5
On the other hand, the Ritvah b’shem Rabbeinu Yonah asserts that
transgression of a Melacha D’oraisa relating to Shabbos. His kiddushin on a married woman for after her divorce,
this topic].
intention is to point out how the issur relating to techumin is merely concerning both the issur Hotza’ah and techumin there is no
because he
application holds Shabbos.
to Maiseh that oneThis can transferthedavar
is because shelo
issur of Maisehba
And thereIn are
m’drabbanan. the several
case discussed nothing was
approaches removed
to this from a
halachah. la’olam,isthe
Shabbos kiddushin
something that takes effect even
was initiated where ifanthe money
actual changeis
private domain into a public one, rather from one techum to another.
SuchThe Mahari”t Algazi 6
posits that what Shmuel holds happens to the object itself. The term Maiseh refers to a physical
an act is assur only m’drabbanan. spent before she is divorced, and this implies that this
change, and this issur is dubbed Maiseh Shabbos to allude to areas
thatTheif he gave five sela’im so that the pidyon takes effect
Chiddushei HaRashba there 24 explains in greater detail. He is true
where even change
physical according happensto toShmuel
an object. who by pidyon
holdswhere
However, all one
on daythat
writes thirty,
Bishuland is the money
different beingis that
spent before day
a Melacha thirty,is
D’oraisa haben
does that if thethemoney
is transgress was already
issur Hotza’ah and nospent,
changethe son istonot
happens the
transgressed. On the other hand, the Gemara is discussing a case object itself, as such there is no reason to assur because of Maiseh
NOTES
NOTES
Through this he raises how one who cooks on Shabbos makes the food assur for Notes Now, on the surface this is difficult to understand. When the water returns to its
consumption just like other maichalos assuros. As such, the food becomes forbidden original cold state, it comes out that one isn’t benefitting from the Maiseh Shabbos
According to Shmuel, how does the lien fall on properties that he
to eat even where one doesn’t benefit from the Bishul such as in a case where it was
ba la’olam doesn’t function if the money is spent, and at the time
at all. As such, it is hard to hear why it should be assur to drink the water then. If
already roasted prior to being cooked.
bought Although
after he would have preferred to eat
the loan when
one warms theupborrower
water using bought
Arlah oil the properties
or Klayim wood and hethen
already spent
the water the
gets cold
roasted and not cooked meat and there is no real benefit from the Melacha, again, the din isn’t for it to be assur to drink. One is allowed to drink it being that
nevertheless the act of Bishul transforms the meat into forbidden food just like all
מהרי"ט אלגאזי money
there is noreceived
longer anyfrom
benefitthe
hadlender,
from theand
Arlahhow can Shmuel
or Klayim. saythethat
This being casethe
the
other maichalos assuros. On the other hand, concerning different forms of benefit same should apply to Maiseh Shabbos as well.
lien falls even on what he bought after the money is spent.
[1] Theonly
they are Mahari”t
assur if Algazi asks according
made possibly to this
purely through onofwhat
the act Shmuel
Melacha
However, if one was capable10of having a certain benefit even before the act was
itself.
As a result, we are forced to say that something cooked on Shabbos is given the
says in Baba Basra regarding the collection of encumbered He answers that Shmuel is going according to his opinion11 that
status of a maichal issur for the entire day. It doesn’t make a difference then if one
committed, then such a thing remains permissible. This applies even to food as the
properties
forbidden (nechasim
status meshu’abadim),
is only given that according
with regard to it consumption and nottobenefit.
Rabi Meir actually
shiabuda, benefits from
a lien, the aveirah
is not or rather
biblical, not. Therefore, even where
it is a rabbinic the cooking
ordinance to
happened through a Goi, since while the water was hot it was assur to drink being
whoHeholds
then continues that although we only find this difference between an issur
that a person can transfer davar shelo ba la’olam, the lien collect
that the Goifromwas encumbered
his shaliach, as properties,
such it becomesand this
assur theordinance is only in
entire Shabbos.
achilah and issur ha’na’ah within the words of Rebbi Yochanan and not Rebbi
certainlynevertheless
Yehudah, falls even on properties
it truthfully applies tothe borrower
Rebbi Yehudah asbought
well. after the documented
This then hasloans, andapplication
a practical not verbal ones,
where and we
one cooks find
water that theforlien
on Shabbos the
He then uses this concept to explain what the Beis Yosef 35 asserts b’shem the purpose of bathing. Although in doing so he transgresses an issur Torah,
loan, for it is no worse than transferring davar shelo ba la’olam [and is not effected through the money received as a loan, but through
nevertheless since bathing is merely a form of benefit, as such it would be muttar
Rashba. The Beis Yosef discusses a case where one tells a Goi to make a fire and
he asks
boil water ifforaccording to Chachamim
him on Shabbos. He writes thatthe lien
if the fallsgoton
water theit would
cold properties
still be to useshtar
the the water as soon as it the
documenting coolsloan
down.given
Whento cold
theagain there and
lender, no longer
whenis any
he
assur for him to drink it. Not only that, if the water had previously been boiled and benefit had from the Maiseh Shabbos. There isn’t reason to say that because it was
he bought
then reverted after
to thisthe loan],
state, forthose
even to according
who holdto Shmuel
even whothatholds
by liquids there that
is no bought
assur whilethehotproperties
it should beafter
assurthetheloan,
entirethe lenderThis
Shabbos. stillishas the shtar,
something said
דף היומי
Bishul after Bishul, nevertheless it would still be assur to drink the water since it was specifically with regard to eating or drinking and not benefit. [See more what he
if the money is spent before thirty days, the son is not redeemed, and the fact that the money is spent is not important, because the
cooked by a fire on Shabbos. has to say there.]
we find that according to Rabi Meir, the transfer of davar shelo shtar still exists.
3
Bechoros 49
On paying before day thirty
redeemed, and we see that Shmuel’s view applies specif- However, Shmuel holds that he does not fulfil the
ically to pidyon haben, and not to kiddushin according to Mitzvah of pidyon haben by transferring five sela’im to
Rabi Meir. the Kohen before day thirty even on condition that the
And he explains that what Rav and Shmuel disputed pidyon will take effect on day thirty, because he holds
when the money was spent before day thirty if his son is that he needs to transfer the money to the Kohen during
redeemed, is because Rav holds that it is possible to fulfil the time when he was already obligated in the Mitzvah,
the Mitzvah of pidyon haben even if he transferred the and if he gives him the money before day thirty and tells
money to the Kohen before day thirty, with the intent him to acquire it now, his son is not redeemed even if
that the transfer of the money takes effect now and the the money is still there on day thirty, because he needs
pidyon takes effect on day thirty. Like by kiddushin for to give the money during a time when he is already obli-
after thirty days where he transfers the money today for gated in the Mitzvah, and giving the money before day
the kiddushin to take effect in thirty days, and until day thirty is only effective if he gives it to him on condition
thirty both parties can retract from the kiddushin, and that he will acquire it on day thirty, and through that
the transfer is retroactively nullified, so too by pidyon acquisition on day thirty the Mitzvah is fulfilled, and
haben, the Mitzvah can be fulfilled even if he transfers therefore, if the money is spent, his son is not redeemed,
the money today, and until day thirty the father and the because the Kohen never acquired the five sela’im for the
Kohen can retract from the pidyon, and the transfer of sake of the pidyon.
the money is retroactively canceled, and if they don’t Now we understand what Tosfos wrote that accord-
retract, the pidyon will take effect on day thirty, and the ing to Rabi Meir who holds that his kiddushin for after
Mitzvah is fulfilled even though the money was trans- her divorce is valid even if the money is spent, accord-
ferred before day thirty, since they stipulated that the ing to Rabi Meir, because he transfers her the money
pidyon will take effect on day thirty. for kiddushin immediately when giving her the money,
Therefore, Rav holds that just as in kiddushin for after and there is no contradiction from what Shmuel holds
thirty days, the kiddushin is effective even if the money is regarding pidyon haben that since he cannot redeem his
spent, because the money was given to her for the sake of son today, his son is not redeemed if the money is spent,
kiddushin, so too by pidyon haben, the pidyon takes effect because regarding pidyon haben, Shmuel holds that the
even if the money was spent before day thirty, because actual transfer of the money needs to take effect after
the money was given to the Kohen for the sake of pidyon thirty days, and if the money is spent before that, the
haben. Kohen never acquired the money.
מראי מקומות
על הלכות אישות ח"א [פרק.4 סי' מ"ג סק"א.3 ] [והוא מאריך בזה לגבי פלוגתת רש"י ותוס' ביבמות דף ל"ד לגבי קידושי קטן לכשיתגדל.2 ) בפרק ד' מהלכות אישות הלכה ז' (ד"ה ודע.1
(ד"ה קנויה) [וכן. ביבמות דף צ"ג.9 ) ולר"מ, נשים סי' ס"ב אות ז' (ד"ה ולמה.8 ) (קידושין דף ס"ב.7 שם.6 יו"ד סי' ש"ה סעיף י"ג.5 ]) מדפי הספר:ג' אות קע"ט בהגה"ה א' (דף ס"ב
: בב"ב דף קע"ה.11 . דף קנ"ז.10 ]) (ד"ה כגון.בקידושין דף ס"ג
דף היומי
4
