Ohr Yosef - English — Chayei Sara (2026-11-02)

Ohr Yosef A Match from Hashem Chayei Sarah p1
The Story Told Twice
Parshas Chayei Sarah tells the story of Eliezer, Avraham's servant, going
to find a wife for Yitzchak, and it tells it twice. First we watch it happen.
Then we hear Eliezer tell the whole thing over again, in detail, to Rivka's
father Besuel and her brother Lavan.
The Torah is famously sparing with words. Entire halachos are learned
from a single extra letter. Yet here it spends dozens of pesukim
repeating a story we have just read. Chazal noticed this and said that
the conversation of the servants of the Avos is more precious than the
Torah of their children (Bereishis Rabbah 60:8, quoted by Rashi 24:42).
What is so precious about Eliezer's retelling? To answer that, we first
need to look at something Eliezer did wrong.
A Request Made the Wrong Way
Standing at the well, Eliezer davened: הַ ְק ֵרה נָא,ֹלהֵ י אֲ ֹדנִי ַאבְ ָרהָ ם-ה׳ א
ְל ָפנַי הַ ּיֹום: O G-d of my master Avraham, let things go well for me today.
Then he set a sign. The girl to whom he would say, "Please tip your jug
so I may drink," and who would answer, "Drink, and I will provide water
for your camels too," הכ ְַח ָת לְעַ בְ ְדָך ְליִצְ חָ ק
ֹ א ָֹתּה: she will be the one
whom You have designated for Your servant Yitzchak (Bereishis 24:12-14).
It worked. Rivka came, made the offer, and turned out to be from
Avraham's own family. Yet Chazal count Eliezer among three people
who asked Hashem for something in an improper way (Taanis 4a). What
was wrong with his request? Chazal answer: the girl could have been
lame, or blind.
At first this is hard to understand. Surely Eliezer would look at the girl
before bringing her home to Yitzchak. The commentators explain that
some things cannot be seen: a girl might have a wooden leg, or
beautiful eyes that cannot see.
© 5787 Yosi Rabinowicz. This weekly can be obtained by email from gilyonOhrYosef@gmail.com or
downloaded from www.ladaat.info
Ohr Yosef A Match from Hashem Chayei Sarah p2
But that only sharpens the question. Eliezer would have faced exactly
the same risk however he searched. Had he gone from house to house
in Charan, he could have missed a wooden leg just the same. What did
his sign have to do with it?
And there is a deeper question. Why would such a girl be wrong for
Yitzchak at all? Eliezer was looking for kindness, for a girl worthy of
entering Avraham's home. If a girl had all of that and happened to be
lame, is she less worthy? Is a person measured by her legs, or by her
middos?
He Was Sure
The answer is that Eliezer was sure he had it figured out. He had
decided what makes the right wife for Yitzchak, and so whoever showed
those middos at the well had to be the one.
But a match is not something a person can figure out. Eliezer should
have asked Hashem, simply, to send him the right girl, the one meant
for Yitzchak. And if he was going to spell out signs, he had to list physical
ones along with the middos. Not because a girl with a disability is worth
less, but because a messenger has no right to bring one home for his
master's son without his master's explicit permission. That decision was
not his to make. By making his sign about middos alone, Eliezer had
committed himself in advance to whichever girl passed it.
His certainty went further. Avraham had sent him with one clear
condition: the wife must come from Avraham's family. It never occurred
to Eliezer that a kind, generous girl might walk up to the well from the
wrong family. Had it crossed his mind, he would have davened
differently: send the right girl to the well, or at least a girl from
Avraham's family, and let me have the good fortune to ask her. But it
never crossed his mind, because he was sure his plan was right.
This is what Chazal meant by "even lame or blind." There are obvious
things, but a person can still miss them. It’s not enough to simply check.
Ohr Yosef A Match from Hashem Chayei Sarah p3
And if you cannot be sure about physical things, then the traits and the
proofs that we do check are not certain either. The heart of the matter
is asking Hashem to take care of the match.
As Hard as Splitting the Sea
Why can't a person figure out a match? Because by nature, it should not
work. Even business partners rarely stay together for decades. People
differ from one another in how they think and how they feel, and a man
and a woman differ more still. That two such people should build one
life together, for years and decades, is not something nature explains.
Chazal say that bringing a couple together is as difficult as splitting the
Yam Suf (Sotah 2a).
A Roman noblewoman once asked Rabbi Yosi bar Chalafta what Hashem
has been doing since He finished creating the world. "He sits and makes
matches," he answered, "this one's daughter for that one." She was not
impressed. "That is His work? I can do that. I have many servants, and in
an hour I can match them all." He answered, "It may be easy in your
eyes, but before Hashem it is as hard as splitting the sea," and went on
his way.
She lined up a thousand menservants and a thousand maidservants,
paired them off, and married them all in a single night. The next
morning they came to her: one with a cracked head, one with an eye
knocked out, one with a broken leg. "What happened to you?" This one
said, "I don't want him," and that one said, "I don't want her." She sent
for Rabbi Yosi and admitted, "There is no G-d like yours, and your Torah
is true" (Bereishis Rabbah 68:4).
Chazal teach that when a husband and wife are worthy, the Shechinah
rests between them; otherwise, fire consumes them (Sotah 17a). Rashi
points out that the words ( ִאיׁשman) and ( ִאשָ הwoman) each have the
letters "( "אשfire), plus one letter of Hashem's Name. A marriage is not
a natural partnership; fires will burn and tempers with flare. Hashem's
Ohr Yosef A Match from Hashem Chayei Sarah p4
presence is what holds it together, and that is something only He can
bring about.
But Hashem hides His hand. ל ִמ ְס ַת ֵתר- ָאכֵן ַא ָתה ֵא: You are indeed a G-d
who hides Himself (Yeshayahu 45:15). So most people look for natural
explanations: they have so much in common, they are such a good fit.
Only someone who stops to think realizes that it could never have
worked without Hashem.
The Second Telling
Now we can understand why the story is told twice. The first time, we
see it as Eliezer planned it: his sign, his test, his certainty. The second
time, as Eliezer tells it at Besuel's table, everyone can see that it was not
his plan that succeeded. Hashem brought Rivka to that well. Even Lavan
and Besuel, hardly tzaddikim, answer: מֵ ה׳ יָצָ א הַ דָ בָ ר: This is from
Hashem (24:50). The Gemara learns from these very words that a
person's spouse comes from Hashem (Moed Katan 18b).
The second telling is the same story, seen as it truly was. That is why the
conversation of Avraham's servant is so precious: through it, everyone
in the room saw that this match was made in Heaven.
When Our Children's Time Comes
When our children reach the stage of marriage, we have to do our part.
We look, we ask, and we try to find someone who seems right for them,
with good middos and a fine family. That is real hishtadlus, and it is our
obligation. But we must never think we have it all figured out. Whether
a match succeeds depends on the One who "sits and makes matches."
So we daven: for the right match, and that His presence rest between
the couple, so that their home will stand forever.
May we see our children build homes in which the Shechinah dwells, as
the pasuk says, ּומֵ ה׳ ִאשָ ה מַ ְש ָכלֶת: a sensible wife is from Hashem (Mishlei
19:14). May we merit the complete redemption, בִ ְמהֵ ָרה בְ יָמֵ ינּו, amen.
