gilyoines.com Back to the site · חזרה לאתר

Rebbe Responsa - English — Chayei Sara (2026-11-02)

Publisher: Rebbe Responsa - English

Week: Chayei Sara (2026-11-02)

Rebbe Responsa - English — Chayei Sara (2026-11-02)

Open the PDF Download

REBBE RESPONSA The Rebbe's English Letters First Steps Letters to individuals beginning their journey in Jewish observance Issue 182 Inside: “Not a Religious Person” ? • Conquest by Stages “I’ll Try” • Will Torah Silence My Individuality ? New Section: Recipient Spotlight Rebbe Responsa flyer · back · trim 5.5×8.5 in · ⅛ in bleed Rebbe Responsa The Rebbe’s English Letters Now on the Web Explore Today RebbeResponsa.com Rebbe Responsa | 2 ‫ב”ה‬ A Word from the Publishers We are pleased to present Issue 182 of Rebbe Responsa, a collection of the Lubavitcher Rebbe’s English letters. This week’s booklet presents letters to individuals at the beginning of their journey in Yiddishkeit. The letters address hesitations that often arise along the way: how one who is “not a religious person” should view himself; whether understanding must come before observance; how quickly to change, and whether to promise or only to try; and whether a life of Torah and Mitzvos leaves room for individual thought. Also introduced this week is a new column, Recipient Spotlight, remembering recipients of the Rebbe’s English letters whose yahrzeits fall during the week. We remember Professor Velvl Greene, a scientist who became observant in the 1960s, and whom the Rebbe encouraged to bring others along the same path. All letter titles, summaries, and footnotes were added by the publisher. * * * We are proud to announce the launch of our new website, RebbeResponsa.com. Previously available exclusively on the app, the full collection of over 5,500 English letters can now be searched, browsed, and shared directly online. May the study of these letters hasten the coming of Moshiach speedily in our days. The Rebbe Responsa Team Kinus Hashluchim, 5787 To receive a free digital copy of Rebbe Responsa every week: Email: Editor@RebbeResponsa.com | WhatsApp: chat.rebberesponsa.com 3 | Chayei Sarah Table of Contents “Not a Religious Person”? ..................................................... 4 Connected to Chabad but “not a religious person”: a Jew’s essence cannot change, and he functions fully only within Torah and Mitzvos; the effects are not immediately evident, to allow free choice Action Before Awareness ...................................................... 6 To one seeking greater Jewish awareness before actual observance: awareness comes through doing; determination to grow brings help from Above Conquest by Stages ................................................................ 9 Personal growth in Yiddishkeit comes by stages, through steady progress; not pushing another too hard “I’ll Try” ......................................................................................11 To a newlywed hesitant to commit to observance: a promise gives strength and peace of mind that “trying” does not; G-d commands nothing beyond one’s ability Will Torah Silence My Individuality? ............................... 13 To a college student who sees Torah commitment as a loss of personal expression and choice: the Creator’s complete guide to a healthy soul and body, sparing one the time and risk of error; why the “yoke” is needed; the place of individual thought Recipient Spotlight Where Others Cannot Reach ............................................. 17 Prof. Velvl Greene: Finding the true path makes one a messenger to circles others cannot reach; beneficiaries become benefactors, in a chain reaction Rebbe Responsa | 4 1 “Not a Religious Person”? Connected to Chabad but “not a religious person”: a Jew’s essence cannot change, and he functions fully only within Torah and Mitzvos; the effects are not immediately evident, to allow free choice By the Grace of G-d 5th of Cheshvan, 5742 Brooklyn, N. Y. Dr. . . . Virginia Beach, Va. Greeting and Blessing: I am in receipt of your letter, postdated Oct. 22nd, which I read with due attention. Seeing the high regard and warm sentiments that you have for the work of our Lubavitch representatives in your area, I am confident that this is translated into concrete actions in helping and being personally involved in the work of spreading and strengthening Yiddishkeit in your surroundings. With all due respect, I must take exception to your stating that you are “not a religious person, but for the past 13 years my life path has on several occasions been intertwined with the Lubavitch movement,” etc. The basis for my objection is the fact that since Mattan Torah, each and every Jew has become a member of what G-d termed “A kingdom of Kohanim (G-d’s servants) and a holy nation.”1 And although everyone has been given the freedom of action to live up to this fully or otherwise, there are matters in which a person has no choice, as we see also in the physical aspects, such as a person being unable to change the color of his eyes, the type of his blood, etc. Similarly, although a person is free to act and conduct himself as he chooses, one cannot change one’s essence, which, in the case of a Jew, is rooted in the fact that one is a member of the “holy nation,” as mentioned above. It follows that a Jew can function properly and fully only when he, or she, lives within his or her element, namely Torah and Mitzvoth Source: Photocopy of the original. 1 Shemos 19:6. 5 | Chayei Sarah Yiddishkeit, which to the Jew is what water is to a fish. To be sure, a fish may sometimes jump out of its element, the water, but it is not its normal way of life to live on land, except that in the case of a fish, the consequences are almost immediate, whereas in the case of a Jew, G-d desires that he should freely choose the path of Torah and Mitzvoth, without fear or coercion. Therefore, the consequences are not immediate, for G-d, in His infinite mercy, gives the Jew the opportunity to return to his Source out of his own volition, but when a Jew is determined so to do, the Torah assures us that he receives aid from On High, and finds his way very much easier than anticipated. With blessing, M. Schneerson Note the addition of “very” in the Rebbe’s holy handwriting Rebbe Responsa | 6 2 Action Before Awareness To one seeking greater Jewish awareness before actual observance: awareness comes through doing; determination to grow brings help from Above By the Grace of G-d* 20th of Kislev, 5736 Brooklyn, N. Y. Mr. H. M. Parker 10b Sandridge Ct. 10 Queens Dr. London, N.4 2YA, England Greeting and Blessing: This is to acknowledge receipt of your letter of Rosh Chodesh Kislev. I was pleased to note your determination to advance in matters of Yiddishkeit, in actual commitment as well as in gaining more knowledge. There is the assurance of our Sages that “He who is determined to purify himself, receives help from On High,” 2 and “A person sanctifies himself a little here on earth, and he is sanctified a great deal from Above.”3 If even a “little” sanctification brings forth a great deal from Above, how much more so more than a little. I trust that you are maintaining close contact with the Lubavitch people in London, who will surely be glad to help you in every way possible. I would like to add a few words in connection with greater “awareness” which you mention in your letter — a point which my saintly father-in-law often emphasized by the following illustration: When a person is hungry and thirsty and desires to know how food and beverage satisfies hunger and thirst, the way to go about it is to actually begin eating and drinking to still his hunger and thirst, which will also enable him to better and more quickly understand the science of the process of digestion. If he should attempt to reverse the order, and try Source: Photocopy of the original. 2 Shabbos 104a; Yoma 38b. 3 Yoma 39a. 7 | Chayei Sarah to understand the process of digestion first, he will not have the mind or heart to understand it, and may never understand it. At first glance, it may seem puzzling how such physical things as food and drink can nourish and cultivate the mind. But the fact is indisputable. If this is so in the physical aspect of life, it is certainly so in the spiritual aspect of life. In order to develop a greater awareness and sensitivity and appreciation of Torah and Mitzvoth, the first thing is to satisfy the hunger and thirst of the Neshama through the actual performance of the Mitzvoth in the daily life. If a Jew is in such a state that he does not even feel the pangs of hunger and thirst for Yiddishkeit, this makes it even more vital for him to begin with the actual observance of the daily Mitzvoth. As usual, our Sages of blessed memory express the above in a few concise words, when they emphasized that the Torah was accepted by the Jewish people on the principle of Naaseh v’Nishma, putting Naaseh (we will do) before v’Nishma (we will understand).4 At this time, before Chanukah, I send you prayerful wishes for a bright and inspiring Chanukah, and may all things go with you in a manner of “increasing the light,” in accordance with the message of the Chanukah lights which are kindled in growing numbers from day to day. With blessing, M. Schneerson 4 Shabbos 88a. Rebbe Responsa | 8 Note the Rebbe’s handwritten additions 9 | Chayei Sarah 3 Conquest by Stages Personal growth in Yiddishkeit comes by stages, through steady progress; not pushing another too hard By the Grace of G-d* 2nd of Tammuz, 5727 Brooklyn, N. Y. Mrs. Sarah Rifka Rosenbloom 501 W. 120th St. Apt. 6E New York, N.Y. 10027 Blessing and Greeting: Your letter reached me with some delay. In the meantime I was pleased to see your husband at the Farbrengen here. As for the subject matter of your letter, you surely know that the Torah tells us that the conquest of the promised Holy Land was to take place by stages.5 The same applies, in a deeper sense, to the personal conquest of the self. In other words, when it comes to personal advancement in matters of Yiddishkeit, the best method is sometimes precisely in the way of a gradual conquest, step by step, and stage by stage, rather than by means of a drastic change. Of course there are certain situations and matters where a drastic change may be necessary, but by and large steady progress is usually steadier than progress by fits and starts. Source: Photocopy of the original. Mrs. Sarah Rifka Rosenbloom (d. 5747) was the wife of Professor Paul (Pesach Betzalel) Rosenbloom, a prominent mathematician. The couple grew in Jewish observance through their friendship with Rabbi Moshe and Mindy Feller, the Rebbe’s emissaries in Minnesota. Mrs. Rosenbloom later helped found F.R.E.E. (Friends of Refugees of Eastern Europe), which assisted Soviet Jewish immigrants. See “The Rebbe’s Man in Mathematics,” A Chassidisher Derher, Shevat 5781, pp. 43–55. 5 Shemos 23:30. Rebbe Responsa | 10 In the light of the above, and in regard to the matter which you mentioned, it is possible that you may be pushing a little too hard. It is perhaps advisable that inasmuch as you have expressed your opinion, and it was not accepted, it is better to leave it alone until such time as the other party will himself come to the same conclusion.6 I trust that this will come to pass sooner than you anticipate… M. Schneerson 6 See English letter dated 21 Adar II, 5719 (available on the Rebbe Responsa app and website): “the way to ascend on the ladder of Avoidas Hashem is step by step, as was also the case in the conquest of the physical Eretz Yisroel, as it is written: "Little by little shall I expel him." So has to be the spiritual conquest, by a gradual ascent rather than by leaps and bounds. And if there is a slip, or if it seems to be a slow process, it is no cause for discouragement…”. See also English letter dated 20 Kislev 5719 (available on the Rebbe Responsa app and website): “One cannot expect a Jew who has drifted from the Jewish way of life to transform himself 100% suddenly, and it is necessary to bring him closer to G-d by stages, yet we have to present to him the true aspects of our Torah and Mitzvoth and not in any diluted form. It is only then that the Jew is responsive to the truth, as is the well-known saying of the Old Rebbe, the Founder of Chabad, that ‘No Jew wishes, nor can he, sever himself from G-d.’” 11 | Chayei Sarah 4 “I’ll Try” To a newlywed hesitant to commit to observance: a promise gives strength and peace of mind that “trying” does not; G-d commands nothing beyond one’s ability By the Grace of G-d* 27th of Elul, 5717 Brooklyn, N. Y. Blessing and Greeting: I was pleased to receive your letter of September 17th, and was particularly gratified with its contents, that you are well and happy, and gradually taking over your routine activities. There is a well-known saying to the effect that making a good start sets off a good chain of reaction for continued success. This is especially true in marriage, which begins a new life, therefore it is important to start it off well, to ensure continued happiness and contentment. May G-d help that this be so in your case. Most important of all is to start the new life in a way that corresponds with the teachings of our Torah, the Law of Life, and then the going is much easier than one anticipated. This brings me to the next point. You write that you do not want to use the expression of “promise to do,” but would rather use the expression “to try to do,” as you are afraid to commit yourself, lest you would find it difficult to live up to your promise. Experience has shown that when a person makes a promise to do something, this very promise gives him the strength to carry it out without hesitation, and with greater ease. Whereas, when one does not commit himself, promising only “to try,” or “to do one’s best,” then, when the matter comes up, and there is temptation not to do it, he is more likely to fail, saying to himself that, after all, he did not promise to do it, but only “to try,” and therefore he is not breaking his word, and his conscience doesn’t bother him. That is why I think that you should be determined to observe the laws, etc., and, knowing that you have made a promise to do so, will give you Source: Secretarial carbon copy. Rebbe Responsa | 12 not only greater strength, but also peace of mind, as it would eliminate all doubts and hesitations. Needless to say, if the things in question were impossible to carry out, there would be no room for making a promise. However, in this case, where it concerns the practical observance of the Divine Commandments, given by G-d, the Creator, Who knows also the abilities of the human beings, it is certain that He would not have commanded to do anything which is beyond one’s power to do, for G-d is the Essence of Goodness, and does not impose a greater obligation than one is capable to fulfil. Moreover, the laws that He commanded, are not for His sake, inasmuch as G-d is not deficient of anything, but they are for the good of the observer. You will recall what I said to you when you were here, that, in regard to the practical precepts, the less one debates with himself, but, rather, fulfils them with simple faith in G-d, the easier and the more natural life is, and the more harmony and happiness it brings. For one of the essential aspects of the Torah is to serve G-d with joy. Such service is carried out, not only through the act of fulfilment of a certain precept, such as putting on Tefillin, or the lighting of candles, etc., but every action, word and thought, which are dedicated to G-d with a spirit of joy of being able to serve the Creator, brings additional light in one’s world, and in the world at large. On the threshold of the New Year, may it bring blessings to us all, I send you and yours my prayerful wishes for a good and pleasant year, materially and spiritually, with the traditional, and all-embracing, blessing of Kesivo vachasimo toivo. Although you do not mention it, I trust that you duly received my two previous letters. As for your question with regard to using certain expressions, you may, of course, use the expression that best describes your thoughts and feelings, and also in any language you find most convenient. 13 | Chayei Sarah 5 Will Torah Silence My Individuality? To a college student who sees Torah commitment as a loss of personal expression and choice: the Creator’s complete guide to a healthy soul and body, sparing one the time and risk of error; why the “yoke” is needed; the place of individual thought By the Grace of G-d 6th of Shevat 5731 Brooklyn, N. Y. Miss … London, England. Blessing and Greeting: I received your letter with some delay. In it you write about the uncertainty you feel regarding commitment to Yiddishkeit, inasmuch as you think that life in accordance with the Torah and Mitzvos is restrictive, and limits the individual in personal creativeness, particularly in the area of thinking and choosing for himself, etc., so that it is hard to reconcile such commitment with the idea of personal freedom. Frankly, this attitude is somewhat surprising, coming from a thinking person. I suppose the difficulty here is due to the superficial understanding of the meaning of the “acceptance of the yoke of the Torah and Mitzvos,”7 because the word “yoke” suggests restrictiveness. In truth, however, there are many things in the daily life which a person accepts and follows without question, even if it be a highly gifted intellectual, with a searching bent of mind. Since you attend college, and have no doubt studied science, etc., you surely know that one does not go about starting everything in physics and technology from the beginning, by verifying everything through personal research and experimentation. For example, a person will board a plane without first having researched into aerodynamics, etc., to verify that it is safe to fly Source: Photocopy of the original (Return to Roots (England, 1979), pp. 224 ff). 7 See Berachos, 13a, et al. Rebbe Responsa | 14 in it, and that it will bring one to one’s destination at approximately the scheduled time. Or take an example from the area of physical health. There are well established things which are useful or harmful to one’s health. A person will not go about trying to verify the utility or harmfulness of a particular drug through personal experimentation. Even if a person has a very strong inclination to do some research and experimentation, he will surely choose such areas which have not previously been researched. This generally accepted attitude is quite understandable and logical. For inasmuch as experts have amply researched into these areas and have determined what is good and what is harmful for physical health, or have established the methods as to further technological advancement – it would be at best a waste of time to try to go over all those experiments from the beginning. On the other hand, there is no assurance that he may not make some error, and arrive at wrong conclusions, with disastrous effects, as experience has shown in some cases. What has been said above in regard to physical health is also true in regard to spiritual health, and how the Neshomoh can attain perfection and fulfillment. All the more so since spiritual health is generally related to physical health, particularly insofar as a Jew is concerned. Now the Creator of man, Who is also the Creator and Master of the whole world, surely has the best qualifications that might be expected of any authority, to know what is good for man and for the world in which he lives. In His goodness, G-d has already provided us with complete and final results, having put us on notice that if a person will conduct his daily life in a certain way, then he will have a healthy Neshomoh in a healthy body, and it will be good for him in this world as well as in the world to come. He has also left some areas where a person can carry on his own experimentations in other matters which do not interfere with the rules laid down by Him. In other words, it is quite certain that if a human being would live long enough, and would have the necessary capacities to make all sorts of experimentations, without distraction and interference and without error, he would undoubtedly arrive at the very same conclusions which we already find in the Torah which G-d has given us, namely the need to observe Shabbos, eat Kosher, etc., etc. But, as mentioned above, G-d in His infinite goodness – and it is in the nature of the Good to do 15 | Chayei Sarah good8 – wished to spare us all the trouble, as well as the possibility of error, and has already given us the results beforehand, for the benefit of both the person who has the inclination and capacity to search, as well as for those who do not. The expression of “yoke” in relation to accepting the Torah and Mitzvos in the daily life is to be understood in the sense that human nature makes it necessary to act on imperatives. For, human nature, and the Yetzer Hora, are such that an individual might easily succumb to temptation. Temptation is sweet at the beginning but bitter at the end.9 But human nature is such that an individual may disregard the bitter consequences because of the initial gratification. We see, for example, that children, and very often also adults, may be warned that overindulgence in certain foods would be harmful to them, and make them sick later on so that for a period of time they might not be able to eat anything at all, yet they may nevertheless reject all restraint to gratify their immediate appetite or passion. In a like manner, G-d has given us the “yoke” of Torah and Mitzvos, telling us that whether one understands them or not, or whatever the temptation may be, one must carry out G-d’s commandments unquestioningly. There is a further point, and this is the most essential aspect of the concept of “yoke” of the Torah and Mitzvos. It is that although, as mentioned before, the Torah and Mitzvos have been given for the benefit of man, both in this life and in Eternal Life, there is an infinitely greater quality with which G-d has endowed the Torah and Mitzvos, namely the quality of uniting man with G-d, that is, the created with the Creator, who would otherwise have nothing in common. For, by giving man a set of Mitzvos to carry out in his daily life, G-d has made it possible for man thereby to attach himself to his Creator, and transcend the limitations of a limited being, living in a limited world. The Torah and Mitzvos constitute the bridge which spans over the abyss separating the Creator from the created, enabling the human being to rise and attach himself to G-dliness.10 Of course this quality can be attained if the person observes the Torah and Mitzvos not because of the reward that goes with it for the body, or for the soul, or for both, but purely because they are the Will and Command of the Holy One blessed be He. For this reason also, the text of the Berocho which 8 Tanya, Part 2, ch. 4. 9 Prov., 5:3. 10 Tanya, Part 1, ch. 4 and 5; Hayom Yom, 8th Cheshvan. Rebbe Responsa | 16 a Jew makes before fulfiling a Mitzvah does not mention the utility of the Mitzvah, but rather the fact that “He has sanctified us with His commandments and commanded us.” Much more can be said in connection with such a profound subject, but I trust that the above lines, though limited in quantity, have sufficient content to illuminate the true aspects of the matter. Besides, should you wish to discuss these matters further, you surely have friends among Anash in London who will be glad to enlighten you. Finally, I would like to say that the fact that you have had some doubts and uncertainties, should not discourage you at all. Indeed, the Torah desires a person to utilize all his capacities including his mind and intelligence, in the service of G-d as long as the approach is right, namely accepting the Torah and Mitzvos first. It is quite natural and even desirable that one should understand everything that is within one’s mental grasp. In your case this is of additional significance, because you have an opportunity to influence and benefit other young people who have the same bent of mind as you. In the light of the above, you will also understand my answer in the matter of the Shidduch, that in my opinion it is as has been said before, namely that it is a suitable Shidduch, and may it be in a happy and auspicious hour, for a Binyan Adei Ad, on the foundation of the Torah and the Mitzvos with complete commitment to the Torah and Mitzvos in the spirit of the Berocho “Who has sanctified us with His commandments and commanded us.” This will, as a matter of course, also be the channel for good health, both for the Neshomoh and the body, and all desirable benefits - though of what value are all rewards by comparison to the achievement of “Israel and the Holy One blessed be He, through the Torah, are all one.” With blessing M. Schneerson P. S. Enclosed is a copy of my message to Neshei Chabad,11 which I trust you will find interesting and useful. 11 Letter dated 9 Shevat, 5731, available on the Rebbe Responsa app and website. 17 | Chayei Sarah Recipient Spotlight Remembering the recipients of the Rebbe’s English letters whose yahrtzeits fall this week. Professor Velvl Greene 24 Marcheshvan, 5772 Professor Velvl (Zeev) Greene (1928–2011) was a scientist and academic specializing in public health and bacteriology. He served as a professor at the University of Minnesota and later at Ben-Gurion University of the Negev. He also worked for NASA on an exobiology program aimed at determining the presence of microbes in outer space. Coming from a secular background, Prof. Greene underwent a profound spiritual transformation in the 1960s, beginning with his encounter with Rabbi Moshe Feller, the Rebbe’s shliach in Minnesota. Through Rabbi Feller he was introduced to the Rebbe, with whom he developed a close personal relationship, eventually becoming a Baal Teshuvah and devoted Chossid of the Rebbe. Over the following decades, the Rebbe took a keen interest in Prof. Greene’s scientific research and guided him in his personal life and in his efforts to spread Yiddishkeit. Their extensive correspondence covered a wide range of subjects, from Torah and science to personal and communal matters. Prof. Greene merited to receive dozens of letters from the Rebbe, most of which were later published in Professor Greene, Shalom U’vrachah (Hebrew), and are available on the Rebbe Responsa app and website. Rebbe Responsa | 18 6 Where Others Cannot Reach Finding the true path makes one a messenger to circles others cannot reach; beneficiaries become benefactors, in a chain reaction B.H. 21st of Shevat, 5729* Brooklyn, N.Y. Dr. Zeev Greene School of Public Health University of Minnesota Minneapolis, Minn. Sholom uBrocho: Thank you very much for your correspondence and enclosures... …May I also add a further point, and I believe an essential one, to the explanations mentioned in your article as to how you and Mrs. Green and your children have found the true path in life. It is that the Supreme Providence has chosen you to be special messengers to bring the word of G-d to those circles where others could not have had access to, or at any rate, could not have had the same effectiveness and success. I am referring to the academic and scientific circles which wield considerable influence on Jewish youth, particularly in this day and age. More specifically – on young men and women going into scientific careers, who are yet to establish families of their own. In other words, they represent not individuals but family units, and the beneficiaries will become benefactors, in the way of a chain reaction. This, indeed, is also what you have in mind, as I see from your letters. To use a much used phrase, our living in the “Jet Age,” I hope and pray that your influence be swift and far-reaching, and that you bring it about in joy and gladness of heart. Wishing you particular Hatzlocho on your overseas trip, especially in London, With blessing, M. Schneerson Source: Photocopy of the original. Dedicated L’Ilui Nishmas Professor Velvl Greene ‫זאב )וועלוול( בן שלמה ע״ה גרין‬ On his Yahrtzeit 24 Marcheshvan, 5772 May the study of these letters bring pleasure and elevation to his soul and inspire his descendants to deepen their hiskashrus with the Rebbe ‫יה״ר ˘נזכה ל˜יום היעוד ״ה˜יצו ורנני‬ ‫˘וכני עפר״ והוא בתוכם‬ Dedicated in honor his wife of Mrs. Gail Greene ‫גוטל בוניא בת העניא יבלחט״א‬ May she be blessed with many years of good health and happiness, and abundant yiddishe chassidishe nachas from their children, eineklach, and ur-eineklach Distribution of the Rebbe Responsa booklet has been made possible by the generous support of the Baal Shem Tov Path Foundation ‫אימ˙י ˜א˙י מר לכ˘יפוˆו מעיינו˙יך חוצה‬ Reach out to dedicate an upcoming issue: Editor@RebbeResponsa.com | +1 (347) 788 1304