gilyoines.com Back to the site · חזרה לאתר

Vayomer Eliyahu - English — Chayei Sara (2026-11-02)

Publisher: Vayomer Eliyahu - English

Week: Chayei Sara (2026-11-02)

Vayomer Eliyahu - English — Chayei Sara (2026-11-02)

Open the PDF Download

‫ערב שב"ק פרשת‬ By Rabbi Eli Meyer Smith Shlit”a Rosh Hakollel of Bais Ulfana Lehoroa » ‫שנת תשפ "ז‬ «Email rabbi@yeshivasrebchaim ozer.com ‫בס"ד‬ Hashem Yisborach Arranges Every Shidduch! ›› The Difference Between Shidduchim and Other are hidden, we can still clearly see His Divine guidance in Matters of Hashgachah! shidduchim. The pasuk in this week’s Parshah (Bereishis 24:50) states: Although He sometimes hides His face so as to allow “And Lavan and Besuel answered, and they said: This people to err and think they are in control of their own matter comes forth from Hashem. We cannot say destiny, shidduchim are the one area in which it is openly anything good or bad to you. Behold, here is Rivkah obvious that He is in charge. It is clear to all that He is the before you. Take her and go, and she will be a wife to the one who causes events to occur to bring two people son of your master, as Hashem has said.” together in order to finalize a match. The Gemara in Mo’ed Katan (18B) states: “From the ›› One Cannot Hasten or Delay the Appointed Time Torah, from Nevi’im and from Kesuvim, we see that We can see for ourselves that everyone agrees that Hashem matches a man with a woman. From the Torah, shidduchim come from Hashem. There are times when we see this from the verse of ‘This matter comes from shidduchim seem doomed to fail because they “don’t Hashem.’” We may ask a question on this Gemara: We make sense”, or because one of the sides seems deficient know that everything that occurs in this world comes in some way, or because outsiders try to obstruct the from Hashem, as Chazal stress in many places. Why is it match for some reason, or because of monetary issues; necessary for the Gemara to specifically say that however, despite all this, if Hashem wants a shidduch to shidduchim come from Hashem? Is this matter different work, He sets events into motion that cause all problems than every other happening and occurrence in the world? to be overcome and for the match to be finalized. It is We may ask similarly on the Medrash Socher Tov clear to all that nothing can stand in the way of His Divine (Tehilim 59) that states: “Shidduchim are extremely plan. difficult. This is seen from the Torah, Nevi’im and On the other hand, if a shidduch is not the will of Kesuvim…” The Medrash goes on to list the same verses Hashem, there is no way that it can come to fruition. It cited in the Gemara, where we see that shidduchim come doesn’t matter how much one pushes for it to work, how from Hashem, and it concludes by saying: “We see from wonderful both sides are and how suitable they seem for here that Hashem places His name on a shidduch.” What each other, or how much money they have. This match is meant by this statement? will never end up working because it is not Hashem’s will. The minhag in Klal Yisroel is that when a groom Furthermore, Hashem decides who will marry performs kiddushin under the chuppah, he places a ring whom, in which place and at what precise time. One on his bride’s index finger, which is known in Hebrew as cannot hasten or delay the conclusion of the shidduch by the “etzbah.” Rings are usually worn on the “kemitzah” one minute, no matter how hard he tries. finger, the third finger from the thumb. Why is the custom for a groom to place the ring on the “etzbah”, the first Rav Michel Yehuda Lefkowitz zt”l expounds on this finger from the thumb? Shortly after the kiddushin, the concept and explains that it is certainly true that every bride will transfer the ring to her kemitzah finger. Why occurrence in this world is guided by Hashem; however, doesn’t the groom put it there in the first place? this is not always clear for us to see. The one area that it is always easy for all to see Hashem’s guiding hand is that ›› It Is Clearly Obvious to All That Shidduchim of shidduchim. Come From Hashem! Hashem’s Divine guidance is usually We can answer our questions by quoting hidden, and one must look deeply and the words of the Chazon Ish zt”l (Sefer Maaseh contemplate events from all angles before he Ish, Chelek Aleph, page 212). It is stated in his name can see how Hashem orchestrated all that even in our times, when Hashem’s ways }‫{א‬ occurrences. Regarding shidduchim, however, it is easy to marrying off their children. Rather, Hashem is the one see how Hashem sends each person the appropriate making the chasuna, and they are merely in attendance. match in supernatural ways. He adds that the groom is referred to as an " arus " by We see very often that people extend much effort on Chazal. The Tosafos Yomtov asks why this word is used, a shidduch, and, ultimately, that does not help them, and as one who makes an engagement should be called a often even hurts them. Yet, on the other hand, some “me’ares”. He answers that the word “arus”, which is in shidduchim simply happen, with no effort extended. They the passive tense, is used because the groom is not really simply happen out of nowhere. It is obvious that they making the engagement. Rather, it is orchestrated by could only have been orchestrated by Divine guidance. Hashem, and he is merely a passive participant. This answers our question of why the Gemara ›› The Father Stands on the Side! specifically says that shidduchim come from Hashem. Of course, everything comes from Hashem, but Chazal are The first shidduch in history is described in the verse emphasizing that one can clearly see that (Bereishis 2): “And Hashem said: It is not shidduchim are guided by Him. good for man to be alone. I will make him a help-mate… Hashem made a slumber fall ›› What Has Hashem Been Doing “…We can now upon the man… And He took one of his from the Time of Creation Until Now? ribs…” Some see a hint from this that answer why the Hashem makes a shidduch happen even if The Medrash (Bereishis Rabbah 68:4) relates a famous story. A noblewoman ring is placed on a person would normally vehemently object. Hashem tells a person, so to speak, once asked Rav Yosi bar Chalafta how long the “etzbah.” “I will send you the right match by ‘making it took Hashem to make the world. He told you slumber’. While you are in a state of her that Hashem created the world in six This symbolizes obliviousness, I will send your match, and days. She then asked, “What has He been doing since then?” He answered her, “He how we see the you will accept her.” Thus, one plays no role in choosing his mate. He can neither is sitting and making shidduchim and hand of Hashem help nor hinder. deciding who will marry whom.” in shidduchim Rav Shloimke of Zhvil zt”l (Yesod Tzadik, The noblewoman’s question seems page 283) explains the words in the Shtar nonsensical. Isn’t it obvious that He is just like we did Hatenayim: “The father stands at the side guiding the world at all times, providing for every living thing, sending the rain, at Kriyas Yam of his son, the groom.” This indicates that the father merely stands aside, while etc.? Why did she ask what He is doing? Suf, when we Hashem takes care of everything. Furthermore, sometimes Hashem pushes Rav Binyomin Mendelson zt”l, Rov of pointed with our Komemiyus, answers that the the father to the side to stop him from noblewoman’s question was not simply index finger and obstructing a shidduch for his child. what Hashem has been doing all this time. said, “This is our In this vein, he explains the Gemara Rather, she was asking what He does that (Sotah 2A) that states: “40 days before a G-d and we will clearly displays that He is in full control of baby is created, a Heavenly voice rings out the world. She saw that Hashem hides His face, and that He allows it to appear as if glorify Him!’…” and says: ‘The daughter of so-and-so will marry so-and-so.” There are three partners the world is functioning “naturally”. in a baby – Hashem, the father, and the Therefore, she asked what He does to mother (Kiddushin 30B). Therefore, Hashem show His Divine Providence to the world. arranges the shidduch before the father Rav Yosi bar Chalafta answered that He and mother become partners, so they does this by making shidduchim, as shouldn’t even think that they have any everyone can clearly see that only Hashem is able to say in the matter. match two people. ›› Hashem Guides the Shidduch Process! ›› The Parents are Only “Mechutanim” The pasuk states (24:2-4): “And Avrohom said to his Rav Aharon of Belz zy”a uses this idea to explain why servant… “I will adjure you by Hashem, the G-d of the a parent of a bride or groom is called a “mechutin”, rather Heaven and the G-d of earth, that you will not take a wife than a “mechasen” (one who marries off his child). for my son from the daughters of Canaan in whose midst I dwell. But you shall go to my land and to my birthplace, He explains that the word “mechutin” is in the passive and you shall take a wife for my son, for Yitzchok." tense. It literally means “one who has a chasunah made.” This word is used because, in truth, the parents are not Rashi states (ibid:7): “He said, ‘Now He is the G-d of }‫{ב‬ Heaven and the G-d of earth, because I have made Him favor from Hashem.” This means that Hashem instills a familiar in the mouths of people, but when He took me person with favor towards his intended match, so that he from my father’s house, He was the G-d of Heaven but not feels pulled towards her. Similarly, the Gemara states the G-d of earth, because mankind did not acknowledge (Makkos 10B): “In the way that a person wishes to go, he is Him, and His name was not familiar on the earth.’” led.” The Pnei Menachem explains this to mean that even the way a person wishes to go in regard to shidduchim is Rav Gedaliah Eiseman zt”l explains that Avrohom was decided by Hashem, and He leads him in that direction. telling Eliezer that previously, Hashem had been the G-d of Heaven, but His ways were hidden from people. Since ›› Hashem Places His Name on a Shidduch! no one recognized that He was guiding every aspect of the world, He was not called the G-d of earth. Avrohom The Maharal (Beer Hagolah, Beer 4) explains that then came and taught people to recognize that He was in shidduchim do not work according to any natural rules. control of everything that occurs in this world, and their They are completely sent from Hashem. For this reason, efforts bear no fruit. He told this to Eliezer before he set the name of Hashem is found in the words “man” and out to find a shidduch for Yitzchok in order to remind him “woman”. The word for man, “ish” has the letter “yud” that Hashem would arrange the match, so he should rely in it, while the word for woman, “isha”, has the letter solely on Him and not attempt any plans of his own. “hei”. Together, this spells the name of Hashem. This lesson, which Avrohom taught to Eliezer, applies This is the meaning of the words of the Medrash that to every individual who reaches marriageable age and to says that Hashem “places His name on a shidduch.” A every parent who needs to marry off a child. They all must marriage can only succeed if Hashem places His name know that Hashem will arrange the shidduch. upon it. Even if a couple seems to be 100% compatible, their marriage cannot even last one night if Hashem does The pasuk continues to say that Hashem told Eliezer: not place His name into the shidduch. This is seen from “Hu yishlach malacho l’fanecha. (He will send his angel the Medrash that says that the noblewoman tried to before you.)” The Pmei Menachem zt”l quoted his father, match up 1,000 pairs of her slaves, but was unsuccessful. the Imrei Emes zt”l, as stating that the first letters of these four words spell the word “himmel” (Heaven). This This is also why Hashem openly shows His Divine is a hint that all shidduchim are arranged by Hashem. The Providence specifically in the area of shidduchim. The Imrei Emes says that the angel mentioned in this verse is entire concept of shidduchim is not natural or logical. It the angel that calls out from Heaven: “The daughter of can only exist if Hashem places His name on the shidduch. so-and-so will marry so-and-so.” Hashem sends this same Therefore, one will always be able to see how the angel to oversee a shidduch and take care of everything. shidduch is completely orchestrated by Hashem. ›› Neither Yichus Nor Money Brings a Shidduch! ›› The Only Hishtadlus is to Trust Hashem ! The Chidushei Harim zt”l explains the Gemara that The Vilna Gaon learns from all this that one should not proves that shidduchim are made by Hashem by saying exert undue efforts to find a shidduch and should only do that people have many ideas when it comes to marriage. a small amount of hishtadlus. He further sees this from Some specifically want distinguished yichus. Others want the verse (Tehilim 127:1): “If Hashem does not build a house, good looks. Still others want money. Many people think those who build it are working in vain.” A shidduch is that if they are blessed with these three things, they will called a “house.” If Hashem does not build it, one who have an easy time finding a shidduch. Chazal’s intention is tries to build is working in vain. Therefore, one should to correct this mindset. They teach us that shidduchim trust Hashem and not do much hishtadlus for a shidduch. come from Hashem, and from no other source. ›› As Hard as Kriyas Yam Suf! They prove this from three places, as each of these The Gemara (Sotah 2A) compares shidduchim to the types of people is hinted at in one of the sources. The splitting of the Yam Suf. At the Yam Suf, every source from the Torah is that Avrohom sent Eliezer to find maidservant experienced a level of prophecy greater a girl with good yichus – a girl from his father’s family. But than Yechezkel ben Buzi. They all pointed with their the Torah tells us that the shidduch occurred because fingers and proclaimed, “This is my G-d, and I will glorify “the thing came from Hashem.” The source in Nevi’im is Him!” They could clearly see the hand of Hashem and how the story of Shimshon Hagibor. He “went after his eyes” He guided the entire world. This is why shidduchim, where and sought a good-looking girl. The pasuk attests that this the hand of Hashem is also clearly evident, is comparable shidduch also came solely from Hashem. The pasuk in to the splitting of the Yam Suf. Kesuvim is (Mishlei 19:14): “A house and wealth are the heritage of the fathers, but an intelligent wife is from We can now answer why the ring is placed on the Hashem.” Wealth doesn’t create shidduchim. “etzbah.” This symbolizes how we see the hand of Hashem in shidduchim just like we did when we pointed He uses this idea to explain the pasuk (Mishlei 18:22): “He with our index finger and said, “This is our G-d!” . who has found a wife has found good, and has obtained }‫{ג‬