Shvilei Pinchas — Toledot (2026-11-09)

Rabbi Pinches Friedman
Parshas Toldos 5787
Translation by Dr. Baruch Fox
A Fascinating Revelation from the Shela HaKadosh
Yaakov Claims to Be Yitzchak’s Firstborn
after Rivkah Adorned Him with the Good Part of Eisav
This week’s parsha, parshas Toldos, chronicles one of the most "—בגדי עשו בנה הגדול החמודות אשר אתה בבית ותלבש את יעקב בנה הקטן
mystifying events in Jewish history—namely, Yaakov tricking his Rivkah took the precious garments of Eisav, her older son,
father Yitzchak into giving him the berachos intended for Eisav. which were with her in her house, and clothed Yaakov,
Here are the pertinent pesukim (Bereishis 27, 1): her younger son. Then, when Yitzchak asked Yaakov (ibid.
18, 19): " ויאמר יעקב אל אביו אנכי עשו בכורך,—"מי אתה בניwho are
"ויהי כי זקן יצחק ותכהין עיניו מראות ויקרא את עשו בנו הגדול ויאמר
you, my son? Yaakov answered his father, “I am Eisav, your
ועתה שא נא. ויאמר הנה נא זקנתי לא ידעתי יום מותי.אליו בני ויאמר אליו הנני
firstborn.” In this manner, Yaakov successfully swindled
ועשה לי מטעמים כאשר אהבתי.כליך תליך וקשתך וצא השדה וצודה לי צידה
Eisav and received the berachos in his stead.
."והביאה לי ואוכלה בעבור תברכך נפשי בטרם אמות
Notwithstanding, this was undoubtedly orchestrated by
And it was when Yitzchak had grown old, his vision
HKB”H; it was His will that Yaakov receive the berachos and
became poor, he summoned Eisav, his older son, and said
not Eisav. Rashi comments (Bereishis 27, 1) that the reason
to him, “My son.” And he responded to him, “Here I am.”
Yitzchak’s vision deteriorated was so that Yaakov would take
And he said, “See, now, I have aged; I know not the day of
the berachos. This is also evident from the following passuk
my death. Now sharpen, if you please your gear—your
(ibid. 5): "—"ורבקה שומעת בדבר יצחק אל עשו בנוnow Rivkah was
sword and your bow—and go out to the field and hunt
listening as Yitzchak spoke to his son, Eisav. The Targum
game for me. Then make me delicacies such as I love and
Yonatan explains that Rivkah heard the words Yitzchak spoke
bring it to me and I will eat, so that my soul may bless you
to Eisav via “ruach hakodesh.” Thus, she understood that it
before I die.”
was HKB”H’s will that she command Yaakov to enter his father’s
Here is how the Torah portrays Eisav (ibid. 25, 27): "ויהי quarters to receive the berachos prior to Eisav’s return.
"—עשו איש יודע צידand Eisav became a man who knows
trapping. Rashi interprets this as: He knew how to trap and “Grant truth to Yaakov
deceive his father verbally. He would ask him, “Father, and kindness to Avraham”
how do we tithe salt and straw?” This would give his
Clearly, it was HKB”H’s will that Yaakov receive the
father the impression that he was meticulous regarding
berachos rather than Eisav harasha. This, however, leaves
mitzvos. Rivkah was aware of Eisav’s duplicity and knew that
us with an incredibly perplexing question. After all, we have
Yitzchak believed him to be a tzaddik. Hence, she intervened
learned in the Gemara (Shabbas 55a): "—"חותמו של הקב"ה אמת
and arranged for Yaakov to receive the berachos instead of his
HKB”H’s emblem is “emes”—truth. So, why would HKB”H
undeserving, fraudulent brother, Eisav.
arrange for Yaakov Avinu to receive these special berachos
This, however, made Yaakov uneasy; he feared that his from Yitzchak Avinu in such a deceptive manner? First,
father would recognize the ruse. To prevent Yitzchak from Yaakov put on his brother’s clothes, and then he proclaimed:
recognizing Yaakov’s true identity (ibid. 15): "ותקח רבקה את “I am Eisav, your firstborn!”
Parshas Toldos 5787 | 1
This is even more confounding in light of the fact that of methods to arrive at the truth. Since “sheker” is being
the three holy Avos, Yaakov specifically is associated with employed to reveal the truth, the “sheker” is rectified.
—״אמת״HKB”H’s emblematic seal. In fact, we find an explicit Most certainly, in Olam HaZeh, which is referred to as
reference to this association in the words of the prophet “alma d’shikra” (the world of “sheker”), it was HKB”H’s
(Michah 7, 20): "—"תתן אמת ליעקב חסד לאברהםgrant “emes” intent to arrive at the truth specifically in this manner.
to Yaakov and “chesed” to Avraham. Furthermore, it is
He repeats this teaching (ibid. 5635) with a stern warning
apparent that the label ״אמת״befits Yaakov Avinu. As a mere
not to resort to the device of “sheker” if it is not absolutely
thirteen-year-old youth, he was recognized as an ״איש תם״, as it
necessary. He cites the Zohar hakadosh (Toldos 143a) that
states explicitly in our parsha (Bereishis 25, 27): ,"ויגדלו הנערים
expounds on the passuk (Tehillim 120, 2): "ה' הצילה נפשי משפת
" ויעקב איש תם יושב אהלים,—ויהי עשו איש יודע ציד איש שדהthe lads
"—שקרHashem, save my soul from lips of “sheker”—in
grew up and Eisav became a man who knows trapping, a
relation to Yaakov Avinu, a”h, when he was compelled
man of the field; but Yaakov was a wholesome man (״איש
to answer, “I am Eisav, your firstborn.” He teaches that a
)תם״, abiding in tents. Rashi comments that ״תם״implies that:
tzaddik, who is committed to “emes,” must occasionally resort
He is not proficient in all these things (that Eisav was); as
to “sheker,” as we are taught in the Gemara (Yevamos 65b): It
is his heart, so is his mouth. One who is not sharp (adept)
is permitted for a person to deviate (from the truth) for
at deceiving is called ״תם״.
the sake of “shalom.” For, someone who is committed to
Clearly, even in his youth, Yaakov was wholesome——״תם״ “emes” and is not engrossed in “sheker” can actually abolish
he was not adept at deception. In fact, he went to his father “sheker” in this manner. This, however, requires help from
to receive the berachos by means of a ruse only because his above—“siyata d’shmaya”—so as not to grow attached (and
mother Rivkah instructed him to do so, as it is written (ibid. become accustomed) to “sheker,” chas v’shalom.
27, 8): "—"ועתה בני שמע בקולי לאשר אני מצווה אותךso now, my son,
heed my voice to that which I command you. Yaakov was Yaakov Avinu Declared
already aware of the fact that his mother possessed “ruach “I am Eisav, your firstborn” Truthfully
hakodesh”; so, he obeyed her dutifully. That does not explain,
With this introduction, we will explain how HKB”H—Whose
however, why HKB”H, whose hallmark is “emes” arranged
hallmark is “emes”—protected Yaakov Avinu—the paradigm
for Yaakov Avinu to receive the berachos through deception,
of “emes—from telling an out-and-out lie. Although, what he
the antithesis of “emes.” As Yitzchak explains regrettably
said to his father appeared to be a lie, he was actually telling
to Eisav (ibid. 35): "—"בא אחיך במרמה ויקח ברכתךyour brother
the truth. We will refer to an intriguing revelation from the
came deceitfully and took your berachah.
teachings of the Shela hakadosh (Toldos, Torah Ohr 7). He
The Tikun for Deception and Falsehood begins by focusing on the passuk: “Rivkah took the precious
Is to Use It to Reveal the Truth garments of Eisav, her older son, which were with her in
her house, and clothed Yaakov, her younger son.” Here is
We will begin to answer these questions by introducing a a summary of what he writes:
marvelous explanation found in the immaculate teachings of
According to the text, Rivkah dressed Yaakov herself;
the Sefas Emes (Toldos 5633):
he did not dress himself; this was seemingly inappropriate
Regarding the matter of Yaakov taking the berachos with respect to “kibud eim.” He suggests a deeper,
by means of deception with Hashem’s approval: We can concealed reason for this. There were two reasons why
learn from here that in order to achieve the truth, we are, Yaakov and Eisav were conceived as twins. Firstly, so that
indeed, allowed to do so by means of deception . . . since Eisav would absorb all of Yaakov’s negative characteristics.
the essential desire to arrive at the truth is in no way Secondly, so that Yaakov would also inherit Olam HaZeh,
considered “sheker” (a lie or deception); on the contrary, which was designated as Eisav’s portion. Thus, Eisav
this constitutes the tikun of “sheker” . . . using deceptive received the bad portion of Yaakov, and Yaakov received
Parshas Toldos 5787 | 2
the good portion of Eisav. This division was accomplished also referred to as the devil (demon) that causes a person
by Rivkah while they were inside her. to sin; it is the yetzer hara within him. The good part is
the yetzer hatov that habituates a person to occupy himself
This is the deeper meaning of the depiction at the end
with Torah, mitzvos, and good deeds . . .
of the parsha (Bereishis 28, 5): “The mother of Yaakov
and Eisav.” Rashi writes that he does not know what this Mordechai and Esther knew how to use the Ineffable
comes to teach us. I believe that it teaches us that as Name to separate the bad from the good; they used it to
their mother, she contained and designated the character separate the evil part, the “beged” and demon, from Esther.
traits of both of them. For this reason, she herself clothed It truly resembled Esther in all ways. Achashveirosh
him (Yaakov) in Eisav’s clothes, so that he would feel to had intimate relations with that evil part. Therefore,
the touch like Eisav. Thus, he would also receive the Daryavesh is called the son of Esther, even though he was
berachos of Olam HaZeh belonging to Eisav, since they born from the demon, because that demon was originally
befitted Eisav more than Yaakov. By dressing up as Eisav, part of Esther.
she prepared the way for him to receive the berachos of
Olam HaZeh. Understood in this light, we can begin to comprehend
to some small degree the remarkable insight of the Shela
His primary garments, however, were the coveted hakadosh. When Rivkah Imeinu overheard Yitzchak Avinu
garments of Adam HaRishon, which reflected his tikun.
instructing Eisav to prepare delicacies for him, so that he
They were fashioned in Gan Eden; this is why the scent
could bless him, she realized that Yitzchak was addressing
of Gan Eden accompanied him. Wearing Eisav’s garments
the good that still remained in Eisav. Yitzchak figured that by
symbolized that he had drained the good designated for
giving him the berachos, it would enable Eisav to empower
Eisav out of him, while they were twins in their mother’s
the good within him to dominate the bad and make him
stomach. From this perspective, he was telling the truth
completely good.
when he said, “I am Eisav, your firstborn; I have done as you
instructed me.” This is similar to what the Zohar writes in Rivkah, however, was aware of Eisav’s true nature and
parshas Ki Seitzei concerning Esther HaMalkah. knew that he had no intention of performing teshuvah.
Therefore, she wisely stripped away his sacred “levush”—his
Elaborating on the Insight good portion—which he had —ָּב ַַגדbetrayed and rejected in
of the Shela HaKadosh ָ
favor of a life of evil. This is the deeper meaning of the passuk:
We will now delve deeper into the comments of the Shela ""ותקח רבקה את 'בגדי' עשו בנה הגדול 'החמודות' אשר אתה בבית. They
hakadosh regarding Yaakov’s declaration to Yitzchak: "אנכי עשו were precious and coveted due to the good within him; Eisav,
"בכורך. As we learned in last week’s essay on Chayei Sarah, however, had transformed them into garments of mutiny and
the Amudehah Shivah presents in the name of the Arizal a betrayal—“begadim.” In this vein, the text continues: "ותלבש
discussion concerning the assertion of the Zohar hakadosh that "—את יעקב בנה הקטןRivkah clothed (" )"ותלבשYaakov, specifically
Esther sent a female demon to Achashveirosh in her place: referring to the holy “levush”—the good qualities that Eisav
had rejected.
The Arizal questions the plausibility of the assertion that
Achashveirosh never touched Esther, seeing as Daryavesh Therefore, when Yitzchak Avinu asked Yaakov to identify
HaMelech (Darius the Great), the son of Achashveirosh, is himself, he actually told the truth. Since he was now clothed
referred to as the son of Esther (V.R. 13, 5). He posits that with the good portion and qualities of Eisav, he answered
every single human being is composed of a good side and honestly: ""אנכי עשו בכורך. In other words, I am the one whom
a bad side. They resemble each other and are combined you addressed and instructed to prepare delicacies for you,
as one. The good part is referred to as a “levush,” whereas so that you could bless me. Thus, everything Yaakov said was
the bad part is referred to as a “beged.” The bad part is surprisingly truthful—“emes.”
Parshas Toldos 5787 | 3
Rivkah Extracted from Eisav the Holy Levush He “levushes” from Yitzchak and Rivkah, his parents. This led
Had Received from Her and Yitzchak Yitzchak to believe that there was still some good in Eisav.
Hence, he thought that by blessing Eisav with all the good
As a loyal servant in the presence of his master, I would influences of Olam HaZeh, it would inspire him to better
like to expand on the explanation of the Shela hakadosh based himself and serve Hashem properly. With this understanding,
on the teachings of the Arizal in Likutei Torah (Vayeira). He let us interpret the text: “And it was when Yitzchak had
enlightens us with regards to the mitzvah of “kibud av v’eim.” grown old, his vision became poor”—in other words,
He explains that every Jew receives a “levush” from his father he was oblivious to Eisav’s wrongdoings and evil ways;
and a “Levush” from his mother. All spiritual and material “he summoned Eisav, his older son”—he appealed to the
bounty a Jew receives in his lifetime comes exclusively from “levush” within him, the good he had instilled in his firstborn
these two “levushim.” All the mitzvos one does is due to the son; “and said to him, ‘My son’”—addressing the good part
“levush” one inherits from one’s father and mother. The of him; “and he responded to him, ‘Here I am’”—since he
“levush” assists one to perform mitzvos even when one is was in the habit of deceiving his father and pretending to be
too young to know what to do. This is especially true in the righteous, he answered "—"הנניI am here at your beck and call,
case of a “gilgul,” since previous iniquities do not allow the ready to do good. This encouraged Yitzchak to bestow the
person to perform a mitzvah; hence, that person requires berachos on him.
assistance from the “levush.” This also applies to a new,
This also provides us with a better appreciation of the
original neshamah that is not accustomed to Olam HaZeh. A
degree of Rivkah’s kedushah. She was not fooled by Eisav; she
man and woman form a partnership to provide their children
recognized his wickedness. This motivated her to ensure that
with this “levush.” This explains why the Torah is strict
he would not receive the berachos, and they would be given
with regards to the sanctity of marital relations. If parents
to the worthy recipient—namely, Yaakov. To accomplish
sanctifies themselves, they instill a holy “levush” in the child’s
this, her first step was to remove the holy “levush” Eisav had
neshamah which helps them serve Hashem. Even an elite
received from her. This is the underlying message of the
neshamah requires this sanctification; otherwise, it can harm
passuk: “Rivkah took the precious garments of Eisav—
him like the yetzer hara. Thus, if a child sins, it is attributable
'—'בגדי עשוher older son, which were with her in her
to his parents.
house.” The language of the passuk teaches us that Eisav had
This teaching of the Arizal provides us with a better transformed her “levush” into a “beged” by betraying and
understanding of Chazal’s statement (Kiddushin 30b): "תנו rejecting its good, positive influence on him; “and clothed
" הקב"ה ואביו ואמו,—רבנן שלשה שותפין הן באדםthe Rabbis taught: Yaakov, her younger son”—here the passuk employs the
There are three partners in the creation of a human term ""ותלבש, indicating that Yaakov was now adorned with
being—HKB”H, his father, and his mother. Not only are they the holy “levush” that had previously been part of Eisav.
partners in the formation of the human being, but they are also
When she removed her “levush,” simultaneously, she also
partners in the assistance that person receives from above to
removed Yitzchak’s “levush”; both were transferred to Yaakov.
serve Hashem. HKB”H gives the person the neshamah that
We can now interpret the continuation of the narrative (ibid.
enables him to serve Hashem, and his mother and father give
27, 21): "ויאמר יצחק אל יעקב גשה נא ואמשך בני האתה זה בני עשו אם
him the “levush” that enables him to fulfill the mitzvos.
"—לאYitzchak said to Yaakov, “Come close, if you please,
Yitzchak Avinu Intended to Bestow the Berachos so I can touch you, my son; are you, indeed, my son Eisav
on the Good “Levush” within Eisav or not?” In other words: Are you the good “levush” of Eisav I
addressed previously and requested to prepare delicacies for
So, even though Eisav was a total rasha, and his divine me? "ויגש יעקב אל יצחק אביו וימשהו ויאמר הקול קול יעקב והידים ידי
neshamah had abandoned him, and all he was left with was ויאמר אתה זה בני, ולא הכירו כי היו ידיו כידי עשו אחיו שעירות ויברכהו,עשו
his animalistic soul, nevertheless he still had the two good "—עשו ויאמר אניso, Yaakov drew close to Yitzchak his father,
Parshas Toldos 5787 | 4
and he touched him and said, “The voice is the voice of As we explained, prior to his circumcision, Avraham still
Yaakov, but the hands are the hands of Eisav.” But he did possessed a negative side in the form of his foreskin. Sarah
not recognize him, because his hands were hairy like the wanted her maidservant Hagar to draw it out of him in the
hands of Eisav his brother; and he blessed him. He said, form of Yishmael. As a result, after his bris-milah, Avraham
“You are, indeed, my son Eisav!” And he said, “I am.” This would not have a negative part; he would be all good. With that
was indeed a truthful response, since he was adorned with accomplished, Sarah and Avraham would both be cleansed of
the good “levush” Yitzchak had imparted to Eisav. all bad and be ready and able to beget Yitzchak.
To summarize, Yitzchak asked Yaakov, “Who are you, Let us review the relevant text (ibid. 24, 67): "ויביאה יצחק
my son?” Yaakov answered his father, “I am Eisav, your האהלה שרה אמו ויקח את רבקה ותהי לו לאשה ויאהבה וינחם יצחק אחרי
firstborn.” He indicated that he now possessed the good "—אמוand Yitzchak brought her into the tent of Sarah, his
portion of Eisav, Yitzchak’s firstborn. He also indicated that mother; he took Rivkah, she became his wife, he loved
this is whom Yitzchak had addressed; as such, “I have done her, and thus Yitzchak was consoled for the loss of his
as you instructed me.” From this perspective, everything mother. Here Rashi cites the Midrash: “And he brought her
Yaakov said was completely truthful! into the tent”—and behold, she was “Sarah, his mother”;
in other words, she then became the image of Sarah, his
Rivkah Received from Sarah the Ability to mother. For the entire time that Sarah was alive, a candle
Separate the Good from the Bad burned from erev Shabbas to erev Shabbas, a berachah
was present in the dough, and a cloud was stationed over
It gives me immense pleasure to substantiate the
the tent. But once she died, they ceased; but when Rivkah
explanation of the Shela hakadosh based on our lengthy
came, they returned.
discussion last week for parshas Chayei Sarah referenced
above. The Amudehah Shivah taught in the name of the Arizal It is evident from Rashi’s comment that upon entering
that Sarah Imeinu separated the negative part of her from the the tent of Sarah Imeinu, Rivkah was imbued with Sarah’s
positive part by sending her maidservant Hagar away; Hagar kedushah. As such, she also possessed the capacity to extract
represented her bad, negative part. In similar fashion, Rivkah the good part of Eisav and transfer it to Yaakov and vice-versa.
Imeinu extracted the good part of Eisav and transferred Thus, we have gained wonderful insights from the incredible
it to Yaakov, while extracting the bad part of Yaakov and teachings of the Shela hakadosh regarding how Yaakov Avinu
transferring it into Eisav. received the berachos from Yitzchak Avinu.
Yoselovsky Family - לעילוי נשמת Family Madeb - לעילוי נשמת Arthur & Randi Luxenberg לזכות
his father Reb Shabsy their dear mother of their wonderfull parents, children and grandchildren
Ben Yitzchok Isaac ע"ה Lea bat Virgini ע"ה ר' יצחק יהודה בן ר' אברהם ע"הHis Father לעילוי נשמת
To receive the mamarim by email: mamarim@shvileipinchas.com
Parshas Toldos 5787 | 5
