Sparks of Light - Spinka - English — Toledot (2026-11-09)

בס"ד
Sparks of light Parshas Toldos נקודות של אור
Year 5 -Vol. 9
A Foundational Article on the intricacies of life, which we were privileged to hear from The Spinka Rebbe Shlita.
The Guide to Effective Listening You just stand there helpless. You have no idea what
☞ Introduction: ☜ is right to say or what should not be remarked upon.
It happened during one of life’s most challenging Do they want me to give advice — or just listen?
periods. Should I enlighten them regarding their mistakes — or
Everything seemed dark; the whole world felt as if it let them wallow in them?
were against you. No one understood you, everyone Does he want me to fight for him — or should I stop
was full of demands, and there was zero empathy for him from fighting?
what you were going through.
How do we avoid the same mistakes that were made
And you — you were just looking for one person
with us when we sought to share — mistakes that
willing to give you an ear and a heart, to listen to what
destroyed our trust and our ability to unburden
you were experiencing, to hear the hesitations, the
ourselves to another person?
fears, and the deepest secrets weighing on your soul.
To understand the "do's and don'ts," let us construct
And so, after much deliberation, you decided to
an imaginary hallway with two rooms:
approach someone who seemed loyal and loving, and
you asked to share it with him. In Room #1 sits the destructive listener.
That’s it. In Room #2 waits the helpful listener.
Up to this point, it is a common denominator for all of In the hallway, two people are waiting. Each enters a
us. Who hasn't had a period like that? different room, seeking to share what they are going
But from this point forward, each of us has a different through.
experience.
☞ Step One: Observation ☜
There are those among us who never want to
remember that mistake called "sharing." Room #1:
Instead of empathy — they received contempt. He enters, his eyes swollen from tears.
Instead of listening — they received advice at the level I gesture for him to sit down. A wonderful sensation
of a GPT bot. spreads through my bones. I am trusted. I am loved.
Instead of compassion — they received judgment. There must be something special about me — after all,
And then there are those who will never forget the people are willing to open up to me.
wonderful "angel" who was there for them — who I straighten up in my chair, curiosity burning within
listened, didn't criticize, offered gentle guidance, and me. I maintain a stoic expression, not revealing the
in short — fulfilled the role perfectly. pleasure filling my heart.
And now, you find yourself on the other side. No matter what he tells me, one thing is clear: He is
On the side of the listener. worth less than I am!
Standing before you is another person asking to tell, to If he feels the need to consult with me — I must be
share, to vent. wiser than him.
Perhaps it is your child, who dares to come and tell you If he has become entangled in a complication — he
what is troubling their heart. must be weaker than me, or perhaps more foolish.
Perhaps it is your wife, who just wants a moment of Now, all that remains is to see how I can emerge as
sincere listening regarding the events of the past day. the smartest person in this conversation. I hope I have
Perhaps it is a brother or a friend who sees you as a advice that will enlighten him. Who knows, perhaps
loyal person with a good heart and wants to pour out years from now he will be interviewed in some
their soul. magazine and point to me as the one who changed his
But you, life with a single tip…
Page1
Toldos Sparks of light - נקודות של אור בס"ד
Room #2: talks and talks, searching for my eyes, my heart, a
He enters, looking a bit apprehensive. listening ear.
It is clear that he is going through something; it isn't But why should I give it to him? What will I even gain
hard to notice. from it?
But wait — before I begin dealing with him — am I not
Room No. 2:
going through things myself?
He opens his heart. At first with hesitation, then in a
Am I always calm? Do I never find things difficult?
flood.
He is a human being, and so am I.
He tells me what he is going through, and I try to
We all go through things, and more importantly: we are understand the exact point that is weighing on him.
all watched over by the same loving Father. What specifically hurts him — and what is merely
He is not "problematic," and I am not perfect. We are background scenery for the purpose of understanding
both puzzle pieces in one great Divine story. Right the story.
now, he is likely coming here to seek help, and I will My eyes are fixed on him, my mouth is locked, my
be here in the capacity of a listener, and perhaps a ears are in a state of total listening, and my mind is
helper. entirely focused on the words being cast into the air.
But either way — we are both nothing more than
Divine channels. My mouth and my heart are a ☞ Step Three: Alertness☜
channel, and if the Creator wills it, He will grant me the Room No. 1:
merit of passing help to him through me. The words continue to flow. What time is it now?
And if not? Then not. Wow, it’s already late; I have so many things to do.
Hashem loves him no less than He loves me. What is the point of sitting here and listening? What
He will surely send him help — either through me or am I, a psychologist? Am I getting paid here on an
in another way. hourly basis?
He adds a few more sentences, emphasizing certain
☞ Step Two: Listening ☜ parts. Excuse me, but my mind cannot contain all the
Room No. 1: burden being poured out here.
He begins to speak, and the wheels of my mind It also seems to me that he is exaggerating a bit. My
immediately start turning. face tells the story. A twitch of disbelief is reflected in
The only question standing before my eyes is: How do my expression. Oh, come on, why complicate life?
I benefit from this situation? How do I inflate my ego Why turn every grain of sand into a mountain?
here? I think and think, and there is no one to tell me that
It goes like this: behind all my reactions hides a bloated ego, which
If the story is juicy — I categorize it in my archives. realizes that it will not produce any profit from this…
Soon I’ll head out to Mincha and Maariv, and I’ll have
Room No. 2:
something to tell people.
My eyes are still fixed on him, my phone is on silent, no
If the story is boring — I yawn internally, nodding my
nodding "hello" to anyone right now, no urgent
head vigorously so as not to appear cold or indifferent.
matters. There is a neshamah here that needs me; I
If it reminds me of something I went through myself
have a role to play.
— I rush to interrupt him, telling him enthusiastically:
I am present in the room, one hundred percent
"You think that’s the worst? Listen to what I went
presence. I don't miss a single detail of his words —
through not long ago..."
and I certainly do not belittle what he feels. My face
If I feel I have a lead — I also cut him off, rushing to
radiates respect for his feelings. What does it matter
give him the brilliant solution that will change his life.
what I think about the situation he is describing? He
And he, didn't come here to get my interpretations!
Nebach,
Page 2
Toldos Sparks of light - נקודות של אור בס"ד
☞ Step Four: Focus☜ When he speaks to me about challenges and
Room No. 1: emotions I have never experienced — I don’t know
I don’t believe what he’s saying. what that feels like!
How is he not ashamed?! And here, one of two things happens:
Is he blind? Doesn’t he notice that those around him Either I minimize what he is feeling, because it seems
are suffering because of him? Doesn’t he realize he’s to me that he is exaggerating a bit, and that what he is
also to blame for the situation? going through isn't really that difficult to overcome.
He continues his story, describing how he reacted with Or I listen, but remain distant, cold and detached from
rage to what the other person did to him. the story he is telling.
I bite my lips in shock. What about him? Anger! The Room No. 2:
worst thing in the world! “Kol hako’eis k’ilu oved Hashem has not tested me with every trial in the world.
avodah zarah” (anyone who becomes angry is as if he But that does not contradict the fact that everyone
served avodah zarah)! has their own difficulties, and one cannot belittle
He hit his child out of frustration? Give me a break, anyone or what they are going through.
what happened to having a little patience for Therefore, when he reaches the inner, emotional,
children? painful points of the story — my heart suddenly opens.
He didn't answer his parents' phone calls for two True, my home is stable, but do I never have a sense
weeks? Terrifying quotes about one who disrespects of instability?
the honor of his parents float before my eyes.
True, my children bring me much nachas, but do I not
All I want to do is shake him, grab his attention, and feel shame in other areas of my life?
scream: "Hey, man, look at what’s happening around
I identify with what he is going through, with what he
you! Get out of your bubble!"
is feeling, and my heart fills with compassion.
Room No. 2: This compassion turns, imperceptibly, into an internal
It’s true. There are parts of what he is sharing that — tefillah, without words.
had he come to consult with me beforehand — I would Ribono Shel Olam, help him bear the pain, reach stable
have told him to act differently. ground; help him get through this without leaving scars
It is also possible that he bears some guilt, that there on his soul.
are victims on the other side of this story as well. And this tefillah is the tefillah of "Hamispallel b'ad
If they were to come to me, I would give them my full chaveiro v'hu tzarich l'oso davar" (one who davens for
attention. his fellow man while needing that same thing himself):
But right now, he is the one standing before me! I, too, need this stability in my own areas; I, too, hope
Only him, his emotions, and his experience of the story to pass through the transitions of my life without
— that is all that matters at this moment! unnecessary traumas.
I am currently focused solely on him. All other parties This compassion, this identification, connects us,
— please wait... creating a deep and healthy soul-connection.
☞ Step Five: Identification ☜ ☞ Step Six: Separation☜
Room No. 1: Room No. 1:
There are stories I am capable of understanding. Finally, he falls silent. He has finished recounting his
If he were to share with me, for example, the scroll of agony and hardship.
experience of waiting for children, I could understand Finally, I have been given the microphone.
him. I’ve experienced that too. I know exactly how it "Listen," I begin, launching into a long, well-
feels. constructed sermon.
But when he shares with me about a home falling I have convincing explanations that manage to
apart — I have no idea what to say to him! demolish the entire imaginary edifice he built here.
When my own family members share their concern for I explain to him exactly where he is wrong and why he
one of the children whom I happen to feel calm about is the one to blame.
— I feel no identification at all!
Page 3
Toldos Sparks of light - נקודות של אור בס"ד
There are parts where I actually encourage him to keep However, one must not move toward separation
fighting, explaining how wrong he is to give up. before being on his side, understanding him, and
Sometimes I choose to amplify his fears. Sometimes I remaining non-judgmental!
prefer to belittle them. Otherwise, it turns into an argument, and he will fight
Whatever helps me feel best about myself. with all his might to defend his theories.
Room No. 2: ☞ Step Seven: Assistance☜
Silence in the room. Room No. 1:
He is no longer speaking. I am waiting for this conversation to finally end. I’m
I am still not speaking. sitting on pins and needles. He isn’t willing to change;
Giving respect to his sharing. Fully present in the he isn’t willing to accept my advice. Why should I even
storm that grips him. continue this conversation?
I ensure that I identify with him completely, not judging The conversation ends. He leaves. He doesn't even
him or feeling wiser or purer than he is. say thank you for the hour I dedicated to him.
I tell him that I understand him perfectly, trying to And why the sour face?
discern if he also wants me to join him in the search for
What, doesn't he know the words of Shlomo
a solution.
HaMelech, “Anxiety in a man’s heart, let him relate it
Only if he does — I proceed to the stage of separation.
to others"?
Because we are all human,
And humans, by nature, when they experience pain Room No. 2:
— usually, in addition to the actual point of pain, When listening to another Yid — there is no clock!
there are also many interpretations, many unfounded It doesn’t matter if it is my child, a member of my
fears, and many one-sided perspectives. These add household, a friend, or a broken soul — I am with him
imaginings and a great deal of "hot air" to what they
now, dedicating all the time he needs to unburden
are experiencing — until it sometimes seems to them
himself.
that there is no way out of the tangle they are in.
This is what I would want others to give me when I am
And here I have a role,
in need.
Specifically, as one who stands to the side, seeing the
situation without experiencing the emotional burden, This is what the Ribono Shel Olam wants me to do
right now. Everything else can wait.
I can try, together with him, to distinguish between the
real and justified pain he feels — and the mistaken I do not demand that he change.
conclusions built around that pain. I do not demand that he reveal all his hidden secrets.
Out of an understanding that I, too, am sometimes in I am here for him, with devotion, ready to bear the
such painful and turbulent moments, I speak to both burden and ease his load in any way necessary.
of us and try to remind ourselves that in the very end, When he finishes and stands up, his face washed with
there is a Ribono Shel Olam who runs everything. We tears and a great light in his eyes, I send one more smile
must turn to Him from the meitzar (distress) and ask his way, reminding myself in my heart:
what He wants from us, and what He expects us to do
It isn't me! I am not the source of the healing; I am
now.
only fulfilling my role — and Hashem is the One who
This separation is light; it provides us with perspective,
puts the helpful words in my mouth!
restores us to our proper place, and releases us from
I am merely a channel!
so many unnecessary emotions.
Gedanken from the Spinka Rebbe Shlita.
Written in Hebrew by R’ Menachem Rubenfeld, and translated by Yissochor Raffles
Written entirely according to the writer’s understanding.
For suggestions and feedback or to subscribe please email. sparksoflightspinka@gmail.com
Please note that although this pamphlet comes out Be’ezras HaShem every week Le’chovod Shabbos,
the contents are not specific for any particular week and are applicable all year round!
Page 4
