Olas Shabbos Minkatch - English — Toledot (2026-11-09)

:
ב”ה
THE
MINKATCHER
REBBE SHLITA
PARSHAS TOLDOS
TRANSLATED FROM
עולת שבת
A COMPILATION OF THE
REBBE’S DIVREI TORAH
THIS PUBLICATION HAS BEEN SPONSORED
BY:
THE GLUCK FAMILY
לעילוי נשמת
אביהם
ר׳ חיים יצחק אייזיק
ב״ר אהרן ע״ה
נפטר כ״ג מרחשון תשפ״ז
תנצב״ה
Year V
2 The Minkatcher Rebbe on Parshas Toldos
PARSHAS TOLDOS
ּתֹוְלדֹות ִיִ ְְצ ָָחק ֶּּבן ַַא ְְב ָָר ָָהם
ְ ְוְ ֵֵא ֶּּלה
.הֹוִליד ֶאֶ ת ִיִ ְְצ ָָחק ִ ַַא ְְב ָָר ָָהם
And these are the generations of Yitzchak the
son of Avraham: Avraham fathered Yitzchak.
(Bereishis 25:19)
WHEN ESAV MOCKS, YAAKOV
ADDS
Rashi explains that the “generations of Yitzchak” with which Parshas Toldos
opens are “Yaakov and Esav, who are spoken of in this parshah.”
Rashi then addresses the seemingly superfluous conclusion of the pasuk,
“Avraham fathered Yitzchak,” and explains:
The ליצני הדורwere saying that Sarah had conceived Yitzchak from
Avimelech. After all, she had lived with Avraham for many years and
did not bear children with him. So what did Hashem do? He shaped
Yitzchak’s face to closely resemble Avraham’s so that everyone would
attest that אברהם הוליד את יצחק.
This raises two questions.
Translated and Published ( פרשת תולדות תשפ"זYear V) 3
First, the mockery of that generation, together with the miracle by which
Hashem put an end to it, occurred when Yitzchak was born. Thus, the
appropriate place for the Torah to relate this episode would have been in
Parshas Vayeira, where his birth is recorded. Why, then, does the Torah wait
until Parshas Toldos, many years later, to mention it?
More fundamentally, leitzanus seems to be nothing more than idle talk,
a passing remark without substance or validity. Someone utters a foolish
comment, others laugh, and the moment passes. Why should the Torah,
whose eternal words illuminate every generation, preserve such insignificant
speech within its sacred text?
The Hidden Weapon of Esav
The answer lies in recognizing that leitzanus is far more than the words
themselves suggest. What appears to be harmless, even amusing frivolity
conceals a far more formidable spiritual force. Beneath its humor and
lightheartedness lies the hostility of a kelipah whose influence can be
devastating. It has the power to undermine one’s entire emunah, weaken his
resolve in avodas Hashem, and even dislodge words of Torah he has already
acquired and absorbed. As the Midrash (Shir HaShirim Rabbah 1:2) teaches,
יוצא כנגדו דבר של תורה,“ – נכנס ללב דבר של ליצנותWhen a word of mockery
enters the heart, a word of Torah leaves in exchange.”
Moreover, the spiritual root of this kelipah lies in Esav and Edom, which in itself
signals its danger. The Midrash (Bamidbar Rabbah 11:1) expounds the pasuk
(Mishlei 3:34), “ – אם ללצים הוא יליץIf it concerns the mockers, He scorns
them,” and explains, “These are the Edomim, who are called mockers, for
they mock the Yidden every day over the troubles that come upon them.”
This mockery of Malchus Edom over Malchus haKedushah has persisted
throughout the entire galus and will continue until the fulfillment of the pasuk
(Ovadiah 1:21), – ועלו מושיעים בהר ציון לשפוט את הר עשו והיתה לד׳ המלוכה
“And saviors shall go up on Har Tzion to judge the mountain of Esav, and the
4 The Minkatcher Rebbe on Parshas Toldos
kingship shall be Hashem’s.” Only then will Edom's dominion finally end, and
Hashem's sovereignty will be openly revealed in the world.
It follows then that the objective of Esav and Edom goes much deeper than
ridiculing the suffering of the Jewish people. It is to attack the very foundation
of their longing for the Geulah, to weaken their emunah peshuta in the coming
of Moshiach and the rebuilding of the Beis HaMikdash. By mocking the
promise of redemption, making it seem distant, unrealistic, or even laughable,
they work to extinguish the anticipation that keeps a Yid connected to the
future revelation of Malchus Hashem.
We find this expressed in the experience of Dovid HaMelech, who declared
(Tehillim 119:51), “ – זדים הליצוני עד מאד מתורתך לא נטיתיThe arrogant have
mocked me greatly; from Your Torah I have not turned aside.” The Midrash
(Socher Tov 119) explains, “What is ‘they mocked me’? They would ridicule
me and say, ‘He Who exiled you will not bring you back.’” The Yerushalmi
(Shekalim 2:5) likewise relates, “What would the brazen ones of the generation
do? They would go to the windows of Dovid and say to him, ‘Dovid, when will
the Beis HaMikdash be built?’”
Their words were not simply intended to embarrass Dovid or provoke him.
They struck at the very yearning that animated his life. They sought to ridicule
his emunah in the Geulah and turn his longing for the Beis HaMikdash into a
source of discouragement.
This phenomenon is certainly not confined to Dovid HaMelech's generation.
Chazal teach (ibid.), “ – אין דור שאין בו ליצנים כדורו של דודThere is no
generation that does not have mockers like the generation of Dovid.” So long
as Esav’s nation maintains its dominion in the world, the kelipah of mockery
and cynicism remains active. Even when its outward expressions may seem
trivial, disguised as nothing more than a lighthearted moment of fun or wit,
its underlying effect remains the same: to deride kedushah and weaken our
emunah in the coming of the righteous redeemer and the rebuilding of the
Beis HaMikdash.
Translated and Published ( פרשת תולדות תשפ"זYear V) 5
Why the Torah Remembers the Mockery
We can now appreciate why leitzanus cannot be dismissed as mere
foolishness, and why simply avoiding the company of scoffers is not nearly
enough. For the danger of mockery lies not in the words themselves, but in
Esav and Edom, the spiritual forces that animate those words and give them
their destructive power.
This is why the Torah records the ridiculous claim that Sarah conceived by
Avimelech. The mockery was indeed fleeting and without substance. Yet the
force from which it emerged was neither fleeting nor insignificant. Therefore,
the Torah was compelled to address—and diminish— this shameful leitzanus,
leaving an enduring warning for every generation not to underestimate its
influence, but to recognize its source and actively uproot its power.
Perhaps this also accounts for the Torah's decision to relate the episode
specifically in Parshas Toldos. At the time of Yitzchak's birth, Esav had not
yet entered the world, and so leitzanus had not yet drawn its vitality from him.
But in Parshas Toldos, which is about “Yaakov and Esav, who are spoken of in
this parshah,” the kelipah that stands against Yaakov's kedushah took on its
full expression, and so the Torah pauses here to teach us how to eradicate it
completely.
Finding Strength in Torah
This understanding also helps explain the episode that follows. The pasuk
relates (Bereishis 25:22), “The children struggled within [Rivkah], and she
said, ‘If so, why am I this way?’ And she went to inquire of Hashem.” Rashi
explains that the pain of her pregnancy led Rivkah to seek relief at the beis
medrash of Shem.
Perhaps the struggle Rivkah experienced was not merely a physical
discomfort, but a deeper spiritual conflict: the growing opposition between
leitzanus rooted in Esav, and kedushah and emes rooted in Yaakov. Even
before their birth, these two forces were already contending in her womb,
6 The Minkatcher Rebbe on Parshas Toldos
reflecting the great spiritual confrontation that would accompany their
descendants throughout the generations.
So, what did Rivkah do? She knew Torah was the only answer because Torah
and leitzanus cannot occupy the same space. When words of Torah take root
in the heart, they displace the influence of mockery. In fact, the same Midrash
(Shir HaShirim Rabbah, ibid.) which teaches that a word of Torah leaves the
heart for every word of leitzanus that enters it also teaches the reverse: אם
“ – נכנס דבר של תורה ללב יוצא כנגדו דבר של ליצנותIf a word of Torah enters the
heart, a word of mockery leaves it in exchange.”
This is why whenever Rivkah passed the entrances of the yeshivos of Shem
and Ever, Yaakov would push to emerge (Rashi). He was drawn toward the
place of Torah because there lay the source of strength with which he would
ultimately confront the kelipah of Esav.
Dovid HaMelech exemplified the same approach when he declared, “The
arrogant have mocked me greatly; from Your Torah I have not turned aside.”
He did not allow their ridicule to draw him away from Torah. On the contrary,
his steadfast attachment to Torah helped him overcome them.
The scoffers would come and stand beneath Dovid's windows, calling out to
him and asking when the Beis HaMikdash would finally be built. They knew
how deeply he yearned for it. They knew that he had devoted himself to
preparing the gold, silver, and stone for its construction, and that despite all
his preparations, he had been told that he would not be the one to build it.
Their intention was to turn his greatest longing into an instrument of pain, and
to make him feel the frustration of a dream that would remain unfulfilled.
And yet, the Yerushalmi (Shekalim, ibid.) relates that Dovid declared,
“Although they intend to anger me, I swear that I rejoice in my heart,” as the
pasuk states (Tehillim 122:1), “ – שמחתי באומרים לי בית ד׳ נלךI rejoiced when
they said to me, ‘Let us go to the house of Hashem.’”
Translated and Published ( פרשת תולדות תשפ"זYear V) 7
Although he knew that he would neither merit to build the Beis HaMikdash
nor to bask in the radiance of Torah and Kedushah that permeated there,
dreaming and yearning for it was a chizzuk in itself. Through immersing himself
in Torah at the beis medrash, which is essentially a mikdash me'at, where the
kedushah of the Beis HaMikdash itself is present, he was able to draw an inner
strength, as the pasuk states (Tehillim 19:9), “ – פקודי ד׳ ישרים משמחי לבThe
mitzvos of Hashem are upright, gladdening the heart.”
Rivkah Imeinu, too, when she went to the beis medrash of Shem and
encountered the atmosphere of Torah and its accompanying simchah, felt
the struggle within her subside and sensed Yaakov yearn to emerge.
More than Resistance
However, there is a deeper dimension to overcoming the kelipah of leitzanus.
It is not always enough to remain steadfast in one's existing commitment to
Torah. As the opposition of Esav and Edom intensifies, one must also intensify
their dedication in response, doing more than before and increasing their
efforts in Torah and avodas Hashem with renewed strength.
This is the meaning of the Gemara (Gittin 7a), “Rise early and stay late at
the beis medrash on their account, and they will come to an end of their
own accord.” The answer to those who seek to undermine kedushah is
not argument or confrontation. It is to rise earlier, remain later, and increase
one's engagement in Torah. Through this added commitment, the forces of
opposition gradually lose their hold and dissipate on their own.
Perhaps this is also the deeper meaning of the sequence of pasukim in which
Dovid HaMelech describes his response to mockery (Tehillim 119:50-51). He
first declares, “ – זאת נחמתי בעניי כי אמרתך חיתניThis is my comfort in my
affliction, for Your word has given me life,” and immediately continues, זדים
“ – הליצוני עד מאד מתורתך לא נטיתיThe arrogant have mocked me greatly;
from Your Torah I have not turned aside.”
8 The Minkatcher Rebbe on Parshas Toldos
At first glance, these two statements seem to convey the same thought. But
perhaps the apparent redundancy reveals an additional response. Although
the Torah was always his source of life and comfort, when the mockery
intensified, he did not content himself with the level of Torah study that had
sustained him until then. He responded by strengthening his commitment,
refusing to deviate from Torah for even a moment.
In fact, this yesod is alluded to in the opening words of our parshah, ואלה
תולדות יצחק. The Midrash (Shemos Rabbah 30:3) teaches that the word
ואלהimplies an addition to what preceded it. With the birth of Esav, and
the appearance of leitzanus, Yaakov was called upon to bring forth a new
dimension of Torah and avodas Hashem. He could not remain at the level
of his predecessors alone. He had to build upon the holy foundation laid by
the Avos and reach even further, rising beyond their madreigah. Indeed, he
ultimately merited to be regarded as the “choicest of the Avos” (Bereishis
Rabbah 76:1), attaining a state of sheleimus, as the pasuk declares (Bereishis
33:18), “ – ויבא יעקב שלםAnd Yaakov arrived whole,” and as the holy Zohar
(I:39a) describes him, “ – יעקב שלימאYaakov the complete one.”
It was precisely this capacity to add, grow, and rise beyond the level that came
before him that enabled Yaakov to withstand Esav's mockery. His strength
was not merely that he possessed the kedushah inherited from the Avos. It
was that, in the face of opposition, he continually brought forth new depths of
Torah and avodah. The more the kelipah of Esav sought to weaken him, the
more he was compelled to increase his own kedushah.
Through this koach of “adding to what came before,” Yaakov merited the
brachah from his father Yitzchak (Bereishis 27:28), ויתן לך האלקים מטל
השמים – “May G-d give you of the dew of the heavens.” Rashi explains, יתן
ויחזור ויתן– “May He give, and give again.” The brachah was not simply for an
abundance of blessing, but for an additional flow of blessing, each brachah
bringing another one.
It is therefore also significant that Yitzchak continued to bentch Yaakov with
the words (ibid. 27:29), “People shall serve you, and nations shall bow down
Translated and Published ( פרשת תולדות תשפ"זYear V) 9
to you; be a master over your brothers.” For by continually increasing his
engagement in Torah and kedushah, Yaakov was able to overcome Esav and
nullify the force of his mockery.
This is a lesson for every generation. When confronted with leitzanus, one must
neither downplay its danger nor get drawn into arguments. The true response
is to recognize its destructive power and strengthen one's connection to
kedushah; to turn toward the beis medrash, seek Hashem through the
guidance and influence of tzaddikim, and increase one's dedication to Torah
and avodas Hashem.
The mockery of our own generation may wear different garments. It may
ridicule a life devoted to Torah, the minhagim of our fathers, or the simple,
steadfast emunah of a Yid who continues to await the Geulah each day. Yet
beneath these changing expressions lies the same old kelipah of Esav and
Edom—and so the answer must remain the same as well. Another seder
in the beis medrash. An early morning shiur. One more blatt of Gemara. An
added measure of dedication to Torah and kedushah. Through this koach,
the children of Yaakov in every generation will be able to withstand the leitzim
of their time, weaken the power of their kelipah, and prepare the world for the
ultimate revelation of Malchus Hashem.
May it be His will that we merit to continually add to our Torah and kedushah,
particularly during the month of Kislev, when the Chanukah lights are kindled
in the manner of מוסיף והולך, adding another measure of light each night
(Shabbos 21b). May we be blessed with an abundance of brachah and
hatzlachah, for ourselves and for all of Klal Yisrael, as alluded to in the name of
the month, כסלו, whose gematria exactly equals אך טוב וחסד, until we witness
the complete nullification of Esav and Edom, when all mockery and opposition
will give way to the revealed sovereignty of Hashem, with the coming of Ben
Dovid, speedily in our days, through His abundant mercy and kindness.
10 The Minkatcher Rebbe on Parshas Toldos
Translated and Published ( פרשת תולדות תשפ"זYear V) 11
To receive our translations of Olas Shabbos directly to your inbox,
please email ‘Munkatch’ to: torah.subscribers@gmail.com
For sponsorship opportunities or to dedicate this publicationin honor of a
loved one, celebration, or Yahrtzeit, etc. please click on the link below.
https://tapcube.co/TORAH
12 The Minkatcher Rebbe on Parshas Toldos
