Rebbe Responsa - English — Toledot (2026-11-09)

REBBE
RESPONSA
The Rebbe's English Letters
Awaiting Children
Guidance and encouragement for couples
waiting to have children
Issue 183
Inside: “Is There Any Hope?” • Spiritual and Medical
Treatment • Not the Last Word • A Woman Who Can’t
Have Children • Unexplained Miscarriage
Rebbe Responsa flyer · back · trim 5.5×8.5 in · ⅛ in bleed
Rebbe Responsa
The Rebbe’s
English Letters
Now on the Web
Explore Today
RebbeResponsa.com
Rebbe Responsa | 2
ב”ה
A Word from the Publishers
We are pleased to present Issue 183 of Rebbe Responsa, a
collection of the Lubavitcher Rebbe’s English letters.
In this week’s Torah portion, Toldos, Yitzchak and Rivkah are
finally blessed with children, twenty years after their marriage.
This week’s booklet presents letters to couples awaiting that
blessing. The letters address doing everything possible in the
natural way while trusting in G-d; choosing a doctor and responding
to his prognosis; the spiritual steps one can take, foremost among
them Taharas Hamishpacha; miscarriages that doctors cannot
explain; and the place in Jewish life of a woman who cannot have
children.
All letter titles, summaries, and footnotes were added by the
publisher.
* * *
We are proud to announce the launch of our new website,
RebbeResponsa.com. Previously available exclusively on the app, the
full collection of over 5,500 English letters can now be searched,
browsed, and shared directly online.
May the study of these letters hasten the coming of Moshiach
speedily in our days.
The Rebbe Responsa Team
Rosh Chodesh Kislev, 5787
To receive a free digital copy of Rebbe Responsa every week:
Email: Editor@RebbeResponsa.com | WhatsApp: chat.rebberesponsa.com
Previous issues are available on RebbeResponsa.com/weekly
3 | Toldos
Table of Contents
A Spiritual Treatment ............................................................ 4
A childless couple: each mitzvah carries its own blessing, and Taharas
Hamishpacha is connected to the blessing of children; the advantage
of learning its beauty from a young couple; observance brings success
in medical treatment
“Is There Any Hope?” ............................................................. 6
Following unsuccessful treatment: doing everything to have children
in the natural way while trusting in G-d; choosing doctors by skill and
current knowledge, not only observance; Taharas Hamishpacha and
faith as vessels for blessing
Asking Forgiveness, Learning Chassidus ......................... 8
Married nearly eight years without children: seeking forgiveness if the
marriage caused hurt to another girl or anyone else; consulting a
specialist; studying Chassidus as a segulah for children
Unexplained Miscarriage...................................................... 9
Miscarriages with no medical cause: how Taharas Hamishpacha
affects the body; why the connection isn’t always apparent; why
observance is wise even without certainty; repentance, unlike
medicine, works retroactively
Not the Last Word ................................................................. 13
When a doctor doubts more children are possible: unexpected happy
developments and the progress of medical science; “think well and it
will be well”
When Unable to Have Children ......................................... 15
A woman unable to bear children asks her role: man and woman have
distinct roles as head and heart; when circumstances prevent a
mitzvah, the thought counts as the deed; asking questions while
keeping naaseh first; women’s lib
Rebbe Responsa | 4
1
A Spiritual Treatment
A childless couple: each mitzvah carries its own blessing, and Taharas
Hamishpacha is connected to the blessing of children; the advantage of
learning its beauty from a young couple; observance brings success in
medical treatment
By the Grace of G-d*
11th of Kislev, 5736
Brooklyn, N.Y.
Blessing and Greeting:
I duly received your letter in which you write that you have been
married for four years and have not yet been blessed with children.
By way of preface, I want to point out that G-d's Mitzvoth should, of
course, be observed for their own sake, and not for the sake of a reward
and the like, and as our Sages of blessed memory declare,1 that a Jew
should be careful to observe every Mitzvo, big and small alike.
Nevertheless, each Mitzvo has a special significance of its own. Thus,
the blessing of children is connected with the meticulous observance
of the laws and regulations of Taharas Hamishpocho in every detail, just
as, for example, the Mitzvo of Tzedoko is connected with the blessing
for Parnosso, etc.2
No doubt you are aware that there are various booklets in English
in which the laws and regulations of Taharas Hamishpocho are set forth
Published: Teshurah (Lew, 6 Elul 5762).
1
Avos 2:1.
2
For letters on the correlation between Tzedakah and Parnassa, see Rebbe
Responsa issue 68, “Charity Brings Wealth”.
Explore More: For additional letters on the connection between Taharas
Hamishpacha and the blessing of children, see below, letters 2 and 4; Rebbe
Responsa, letters dated 19 Tammuz, 5720; Rosh Chodesh Elul, 5727; 5 Nissan,
5730; 3 Adar, 5734; 24 Adar II, 5741; 3 Teves, 5744; 12 Kislev, 5745; 21 Tammuz,
5746.
For additional Hebrew and Yiddish letters, see Igros Kodesh, vol. 7, p. 321 (Letter
2,177); vol. 8, p. 22 (Letter 2,266); vol. 14, p. 340 (Letter 5,110, concerning the
absence of sons); and vol. 22, p. 266 (Letter 8,459). Regarding the merit of
building a mikveh and the blessing of children, see vol. 6, p. 202 (Letter 1,719); et
al.
5 | Toldos
clearly. In addition, it would be well to talk these things over personally
with a Rov or orthodox young couple, of which there should be quite a
number in Manchester. The benefit of discussing this with a young
couple who are meticulous observers of Taharas Hamishpocho has the
additional advantage of learning the beauty and holiness that go with
the observance of these laws, and how it strengthens the relationship
and the peace and harmony in the family, and so forth. Furthermore,
although G-d desires that a Jew should do everything possible in the
natural order of things, and seek medical advice where necessary, it is
certain that the observance of the Mitzvoth in itself brings G-d's
blessings for Hatzlocho in the medical treatment, if such is required.
May G-d grant that you should have good news to report in all
above.
With blessing
M. Schneerson
Rebbe Responsa | 6
2
“Is There Any Hope?”
Following unsuccessful treatment: doing everything to have children in
the natural way while trusting in G-d; choosing doctors by skill and
current knowledge, not only observance; Taharas Hamishpacha and
faith as vessels for blessing
By the Grace of G-d *
12th of Tishrei, 5721
Brooklyn, N. Y.
Greeting and Blessing:
I received your letter of September 16th, in which you write about
the medical treatment which your wife has been receiving, with no
apparent results.
You ask what else you should do, and if there is any hope, etc.
Generally speaking, the Jewish approach is well-known from our
Torah, which is called Toras Chaim, the Law of Life, meaning also simply
that it is the guide to the daily life. This approach is that it is always
necessary to do everything possible in the natural way, but at the same
time to be strong in one's faith in G-d, Whose benevolent Providence
extends to every one individually, and Who is the Essence of Goodness,
that He will send His supernatural blessings through the natural
channels. Much has been said on the matter of G-d's benevolent
Providence, as it extends to every particular in one’s life, in the
literature of Chassidus. I trust you know that we have recently observed
the 200th anniversary of the Baal Shem Tov's completion of his life's
work, leaving us the great heritage of the Chassidic teachings and way
of life. It would be well for you to acquaint yourself more closely with
them.
From the above, you will gather that my view is that you should
continue to consult specialists in the field. As for your writing that you
have been limiting yourselves to doctors who are Shabbos observers, it
is not advisable to limit one's self that way, for the first consideration in
seeking medical advice is the degree of experience and skill of the
Source: Typed copy.
7 | Toldos
specialist. Only if two specialists have the same medical rating,
preference should be given, of course, to a doctor who is also an
adherent of the Torah and Mitzvoth, in which case all his dealings are
on a superior level.
While on this subject, I would like to point out that it is especially
important to consult a doctor who is up-to-date in regard to the latest
developments and advancements that have been made in the particular
field, since almost every day some new discoveries are made, and no
one can foresee what the next day may bring.
I trust that you and your wife are conducting your daily lives in
accordance with the Torah and Mitzvoth, which are the channels and
vessels to receive G-d’s blessings in every respect. Of particular
importance in your case is the observance of the laws and regulations
regarding Taharas Hamishpocho. Not less important is to have
complete faith in G-d, since such faith is in itself also a channel and
vessel to receive G-d's blessing. And, as we are now in an auspicious
part of the year, and in days of Divine benevolence and mercy, may
G-d grant the fulfillment of your heart’s desire for good.
Hoping to hear good news from you, and wishing you and your wife
a happy New Year,
With blessing,
Rebbe Responsa | 8
3
Asking Forgiveness, Learning
Chassidus
Married nearly eight years without children: seeking forgiveness if the
marriage caused hurt to another girl or anyone else; consulting a
specialist; studying Chassidus as a segulah for children
By the Grace of G-d*
6 Teveth, 5713
Brooklyn 13, N.Y.
Rev. …
Sholom u'Brocho:
I received your letter of 28th of Kislev, and was pleased to learn that
your wife has recovered thank G-d. I was also glad to read that you are
keeping up the Shiurim and your wife keeps up the Tzedoko. This will
certainly keep the channels open to receive and enjoy G-d's blessings.
You write that you have been married for nearly eight years but have
not been blessed yet with children. I trust that when you got married
there was no circumstance involving any insult to a Jewish girl or other
Jewish person, for if there was anything of this kind, 'Mechilah'
(forgiveness) should be obtained from the injured party. I trust,
however, that this is not the case. Hence, you ought consult a good
specialist in the field.
I would suggest that you include in your studies a Shiur that leads
to the love and fear of G-d, I mean a Shiur in Chassiduth, for this is a
Segulah to be blessed with children, of which we know on the authority
of the Old Rabbi, author of the Tanya, founder of Chabad. 3
Source: Carbon copy.
3
Me’ah She’arim 38a (Maamarei Admur HaZakein HaKetzarim, p. 460).
Explore More: For additional instances the Rebbe recommends the study of
Chassidus to a husband not yet blessed with children, see Igros Kodesh, vol. 5,
letters 1244 and 1387; vol. 6, letters 1576 and 1686; vol. 8, letter 2436, et al. (see
also vol. 7, letter 1920 and vol. 14, letter 5111).
Regarding difficulty having children or miscarriages and ascertaining whether a
hurt caused in connection with a shidduch requires obtaining forgiveness, see
9 | Toldos
Although Chanukah has passed, I am sending you the enclosed
excerpt from a Chanukah Message, since the message and inspiration
of Chanukah should last all year round. I trust the message will prove
useful to you in your educational work.
With blessing,
By [secretary]
4
Unexplained Miscarriage
Miscarriages with no medical cause: how Taharas Hamishpacha affects
the body; why the connection isn’t always apparent; why observance is
wise even without certainty; repentance, unlike medicine, works
retroactively
By the Grace of G-d*
4th of Menachem Av, 5718
Brooklyn, N. Y.
Mr. Nathan Vogel
76, Wellington St., East
Salford 7, Lancs.
England
Greeting and Blessing:
I am in receipt of your letter, in which you write about the condition
of health [of]… 'תי, and the mishaps that occurred to her in the form of
miscarriage, etc.
Generally speaking, such mishaps as you describe in connection
with…, are explained in the Holy Books to be the result of the
unobservance of the laws of Taharas Hamishpocho. For, these laws, as
all the other laws of the Torah, were given not for the benefit of the
Creator, but for the benefit of the observer, and for his good health,
both physically and spiritually. They are meant for the good and happy
life of man, not only in after life, but simply also in this life. Therefore,
also Igros Kodesh, vol. 6, p. 266 (Letter 1,772); vol. 8, p. 193 (Letter 2,436); vol. 14,
p. 340 (Letter 5,110); vol. 18, p. 32 (Letter 6,535); and vol. 22, p. 266 (Letter 8,459).
____________________________________
Source: Photocopy of the original.
Rebbe Responsa | 10
when a person lives in a way which involves a contravention of the laws
of the Creator, it is not surprising that this brings about regrettable
effects. As cause and effect are connected, so it is to be expected that
where the laws are connected with certain organs of the body, the
breach of these laws affect those organs in particular. For instance, the
dietary laws are connected, of course, with the digestive organs, and
the laws of Taharas Hamishpocho are connected with the reproductive
organs; hence, they unfortunately suffer from the lack of observance of
the respective laws. The very fact that the physicians do not find any
organic reason for the mishap of the person in question, only confirms
the suspicion that the mishaps are directly connected with the breach
of the said laws.
It might be asked: If there is such a direct connection between the
laws and the physical health, is it not to be expected that those who
observe the laws should be immune to unfortunate mishaps, while
those who do not observe the laws should always suffer the
consequences? However, a little reflection will reveal that this is no
argument or excuse to be lax in observing the laws. For, firstly, physical
ailments or mishaps may be connected with inborn organic defects, or
with accidents. On the other hand, one can never be certain that a
person who appears to be strictly observing the laws, does so really in
fact, for no one will publicize one’s failure.
At any rate, even if the observance of the laws would not be an
absolute insurance, but only a partial one, one would still be wise and
justified to observe them. By way of illustration: In recent years parents
have been strongly urged to give their children polio shots. And,
although the incidence of polio is perhaps one in a thousand, or even
much more rare than this, nevertheless parents will be wise to take this
precaution, even where the chance is so remote.4 How much more so
would parents be wise to take the precaution, by the observance of the
Divine Commandments, where the breach of them unfortunately brings
dire consequences at much closer range.
It is not my purpose just to preach. However, when I am asked for
help or advice, I must state the facts clearly. I wish to add that no matter
what the past has been, repentance is always effective, and even more
effective than the best medicine. For, whereas medicine cannot act
retroactively, repentance can. If the woman and her husband in
question will resolve from now on to observe the laws fully, with sincere
4
See also letter dated 1 Adar I, 5722. Regarding the Rebbe's advice on the shot
see S. B. Wineberg, Healthy in Body Mind & Spirit (SIE, 2006), vol. 2, pp. 129ff.
11 | Toldos
regret for the past failing, the Almighty, Who is the Essence of
Goodness, will surely accept their sincere repentance and will forgive
them for the past, and bless them in the future.
I hope you may have good news to report in connection with the
above.
With blessing,
By Nissan Mindel
Inasmuch as the problem was brought to my attention by yourself,
the letter is written to you and not to the party concerned. But,
needless to say that you can convey the contents of my letter to the
said party.
As requested, I will remember your wife in prayer when visiting the
holy resting place of my father-in-law of saintly memory, that the
Almighty bless her to complete her pregnancy, and that she have a
normal delivery and give birth to a healthy child.5
5
In a follow-up letter dated 9 Elul, 5718, the Rebbe writes:
“As for the best way of influencing her in the right direction, obviously a personal
conversation is more desirable than a letter. But if that is impossible, then there
is no other choice but to try writing to her, unless you know someone in the
place where she lives who could speak to her and try to influence her in the right
direction.
“In your letter you ask how can my statement that every addition in Torah and
Mitzvoth brings additional Divine blessings, be reconciled with the Rabbinic
statement that there is no reward for a Mitzvah in this world. In this connection
let me point out to you the following: Firstly, that the said Rabbinic statement
obviously does not refer to such Mitzvoth which are mentioned in the Mishna
and Braysa which we say during the morning blessings, whose fruits are enjoyed
in this world. Secondly, and this would refer specifically to the terms "vessel"
and "channel," which I used, in the sense that even though this does not create
the reward of the Mitzvah, nevertheless the very performance of the Mitzvah
removes the obstacles that would have otherwise been created through the
non-performance of the Mitzvah, preventing the flow of G-d's kindness to reach
the person. This, therefore, refers to the flow of G-d's benevolence of the kind
which is given even to children and to other people who are not duty-bound to
observe Mitzvoth. In other words, G-d is always ready, willing and able to bestow
blessings upon His creatures, whether merited or not, but the sin of commission
or omission acts as a barrier. Therefore, the more Mitzvoth one performs, the
more obstacles and barriers are removed to receive the flow of G-d's
benevolence.”
Rebbe Responsa | 12
Explore More: For additional English letters to women who had suffered
miscarriages, see Rebbe Responsa, letters dated Rosh Chodesh Elul 5727 and 3
Iyar 5725.
13 | Toldos
5
Not the Last Word
When a doctor doubts more children are possible: unexpected happy
developments and the progress of medical science; “think well and it will
be well”
By the Grace of G-d
10th of Adar, 5720
Brooklyn, N.Y.
Mr. Elazar Kalman Tiefenbrun
23B. Springfield
London, E.5
Greeting and Blessing:
I received your letter of the 3rd of Adar, as well as the previous one,
wherein you write about the Bris of your son, and the name given him
of Yosef Yitzchok. I reiterate again my blessing to you and your wife to
bring up your son to a life of Torah, Chuppah and Good Deeds in good
health and prosperity.
With regard to the doctor's opinion relating to the possibility of
your wife having more children in the future,6 I believe I already wrote
to you that in such matters there can always be unexpected happy
developments, especially also since medical science is making progress
by leaps and bounds. I believe that the doctors will also confirm this
attitude. At any rate, you surely know of the advice of our Rabbis, "Think
well and it will be well."7
As we are now in the auspicious month of Adar, which has been
historically a fortunate one for the Jewish people as a whole, and for
Source: Photocopy of the original.
Mr. Elazar Kalman Tiefenbrun (1929–2018) was a British-born Chabad artist and
communal activist. Beginning in the late 1950s, he corresponded with the Rebbe
and developed a close connection with Chabad, becoming a prominent figure in
London’s Lubavitch community. For additional letters addressed to him, see
letter dated 2 Kislev, 5718 and as referenced there.
6
Mrs. Tiefenbrun appears to have had complications during her pregnancy (see
letter dated 3 Shevat 5720).
7
See Igros Kodesh of the Rebbe Rayatz, vol. 1, letter 485.
Rebbe Responsa | 14
Jews individually, I hope and pray that it bring you and yours an
additional measure of success, materially and spiritually.8
Hoping to hear good news from you, and wishing you a happy and
inspiring Purim,
With blessing,
M. Schneerson
8
The Tiefenbruns were later blessed with more children, and lived to see
grandchildren and great-grandchildren.
15 | Toldos
6
When Unable to Have Children
A woman unable to bear children asks her role: man and woman have
distinct roles as head and heart; when circumstances prevent a mitzvah,
the thought counts as the deed; asking questions while keeping naaseh
first; women’s lib
By the Grace of G-d
13th of Iyar, 5737
Brooklyn, N. Y.
D. L. Halper
c/o WRVR
85 Claremont Avenue
New York, N.Y. 10027
Blessing and Greeting:
Your letter (post-dated April 18) reached me with some delay.
First, many thanks for your good wishes in connection with my
birthday. I can best reciprocate in the words of our Sages, "One who
blesses others is himself, or herself, blessed by G-d, the Source of all
blessings." 9 Accordingly, may G-d bestow His generous blessings on
you in all needs.
Now with regard to your question about the woman's role from the
viewpoint of our religion, or, as you refer to it, 'orthodox' Judaism,
Dr. Donna (D’vorah Leah) Halper (b. 1947) is a former radio DJ and music director
who went on to become a radio consultant and a media historian. She later
earned a doctorate in communication and taught media studies.
Behind the Letter: In 1976, she was rushed to the hospital and had life-saving
surgery that left her unable to have children. She was not Orthodox but had deep
respect for Orthodox Judaism, and she began a long correspondence with Rabbi
Kasriel Kastel of the Lubavitch Youth Organization. In it she asked what role
Judaism gives a woman who cannot be a mother in the traditional sense. Rabbi
Kastel encouraged her to put her questions to the Rebbe. She doubted that the
Rebbe would answer her. (Interview with Dr. Halper, My Story, vol. II (JEM, 2022),
pp. 341–349.)
9
Sotah, 38b.
Rebbe Responsa | 16
I must first point out that the division of Judaism into 'orthodox,
conservative, reform,' etc. is a purely artificial one, for all Jews have one
and the same Torah, given by the One and Same G-d, though there are
more observant Jews and less observant Jews. To tag on a 'label' does
not, of course, change the reality.
As for the attitude of Judaism to the woman, it has also been
frequently pointed out that those who think that the Torah places the
woman in an inferior role to that of the man labor under a
misconception, for it has no basis in truth. Man and woman are like the
head and the heart in the physical body: both are equally vital, though
each has entirely different functions, and only the normal functioning
of both together ensure a healthy body. The same is true of the role of
the man and woman in Jewish life, and, indeed, in any healthy human
society.
It follows that the heart need not feel inferior to the brain, although
in certain aspects it depends on the brain, just as the brain need not
feel inferior to the heart because in certain respects it depends on the
latter. Similarly in Jewish life there are duties and functions which G-d
has allotted to the woman and those allotted to the man.
Where a person, for some reason, is unable to perform a certain
Mitzva or some of his or her functions, there is a ruling in the Torah,
Toras Emes (so called because all its teachings are true), "the Merciful
One excuses a person who is incapable of performing his, or her, duty."
Indeed, G-d who knows what is in the heart of everyone, and knowing
that were the person able, he or she would have performed it, considers
the thought in place of the deed.
Incidentally, it is noteworthy that of the various Divine names, it is
the name '( רחמנאMerciful One') that is used in the above ruling. This
pointedly emphasizes that all G-d’s precepts derive from His attribute
of mercy and lovingkindness, which, like all Divine attributes, is infinite.
It follows that where a person is precluded from performing a Mitzva
by circumstances beyond his or her control is completely excused and
exonerated.
Needless to say, one need not apologise for asking questions. On the
contrary, since Jews are described in the Torah as a 'wise and
understanding people,' it is desirable that questions which come within
the realm of human understanding should also be understood and not
left to faith alone, wherever this is possible. There is only one
prerequisite, which goes back to the time when the Torah and Mitzvos
were given at Sinai, namely that the Torah must be accepted on the
17 | Toldos
basis of Naaseh ('we will do') first, and then v’nishma (’we will
understand’) - meaning, that the performance of Mitzvos must not be
made conditional on the understanding of their deeper significance,
etc., nor must the vitality and enthusiasm of the performance be any
the less.
This basic principle and attitude is also a matter of common sense.
If the Torah is accepted as Divine - otherwise there is no point at all in
any questions and discussions, since if it is man-made one would be
free to do as one pleases - that is, given by a Supreme Being, Whose
Essence is beyond human grasp, it would be a contradiction in terms to
demand to know the meaning and significance of each Divine Mitzva
before performing it, for it would reduce the Supreme Being to the level
of the limited human intelligence, which, moreover, is subject to
development, since human understanding increases from day to day
with newly acquired knowledge and experience; yet he insists on
understanding it today, on his present level.
One might even add that there is a sound pragmatic, or 'business'
consideration involved, as, by way of a simple illustration, when one is
offered an opportunity to invest a dollar with a view to earning a
thousand dollars, though there may be a remote possibility of losing the
$1. A normal individual would certainly not hesitate to make his
decision. Similarly, when a Jew, on the basis of na'aseh before v'nishma,
invests in a relatively small effort by restricting himself in matters of
Kashrus and Shabbos observance, etc., and the Yetzer hara attempts to
distract him by saying, even if you live 120 years maybe you will never
fully grasp the significance of what you are doing — the most the person
will have lost would be having denied himself certain foods or some
convenience on Shabbos. On the other hand, if a person will wait with
the performance of Mitzvos until he will realize their significance, and
in the meantime will act like any gentile, he will deprive himself of the
eternal good which was his within easy reach, and when the time will
come and he will discover the truth, he will realize that he has lived in
transgression of the Divine Torah, with all the consequences therefrom.
Much more could be said on the subject matter, but I trust the above
will suffice. May G-d, whose benevolent Providence extends to each
and everyone individually, lead you in the path of Truth.
With blessing
M. Schneerson
Rebbe Responsa | 18
P.S. Since you refer to women’s lib, which has become so popular in
recent years, it baffles me that the thrust of the movement is centered
on the woman’s becoming similar to man -- and this is what is termed
’independence’ and ’feminist' pride, etc.!*
Note the Rebbe’s handwritten edit, switching the word “equal” to “similar”
The Letter’s Impact: Dr. Halper later recalled that, as the Rebbe advised, she
focused on the mitzvos she was able to do, and began keeping kosher (ibid).
Dedicated
in honor of the wedding of
Michel & Mushky
Chein
On the 1st day of
Rosh Chodesh Kislev , 5787
May you “build a truly Jewish home, a
Binyan adei-ad, on the foundations of the
Torah and Mitzvot as they are illuminated
with the inner light of Torah, namely the
teachings of Chasidus.”
Distribution of the Rebbe Responsa booklet has been made possible by
the generous support of the Baal Shem Tov Path Foundation
אימ˙י ˜א˙י מר לכ˘יפוˆו מעיינו˙יך חוצה
Reach out to dedicate an upcoming issue and help inspire countless Yidden worldwide:
Editor@RebbeResponsa.com | +1 (347) 788 1304
