Samcheinu B'Yeshuosecho Inyan - English — Toledot (2026-11-09)

פרשת תולדות תשפ"ז בס"ד
נכתב לע"נ אבי מורי ר' מנחם מענדל בן ר' מאיר גראססבערגער ז"ל נלב״ע י״ט אדר תשפ״ו
ואמי מורתי מרת מרים בת ר' גדלי'ה ע"ה נלב״ע כ״ג תשרי שמחת תורה תשפ״ב
Written By R’ YZ Grossberger. To comment or receive, please email
sbalhatorah@gmail.com / +447941163001
Yaakov Ovinu’s Extraordinary Avoda – And Ours!
The Parsha begins with the Torah telling us that Yitzchok and Rivka davened to
have children, and twins – Yaakov and Eisov were born to them. The Torah then
continues and describes the difference between Yaakov and Eisov. Yaakov is
referred to as an איש תם יושב אהלים- a straightforward man who sat in the
Yeshiva of Shem V’Ever learning Torah whereas Eisov was an איש יודע ציד איש
שדה- a man who knew how to trap animals - a man of the fields. They both grew
up and on the day of Avrohom’s death, Eisov came home tired from hunting and
asked Yaakov to have some of the lentil soup that he had been cooking. He gave
it to him and in return, he sold the Bechora to Yaakov. Life continued, Yaakov
devoted himself to his learning, the story of the wells happened with Yitzchok,
Eisov married, and then the Torah tells us how Yaakov with the encouragement
of Rivka succeeded in taking the Brochos that Yitzchok had planned to give to
שמחנו בישועתך על התורה
Eisov. Now a vast change took place and because Yaakov took these Brochos
from Eisov, he had to flee from his wrath. And so, he headed to the house of
Lovon Ho’Arami where he married, worked very hard and eventually built Klal
Yisroel.
Why the difficulty?
Reb Shimshon Pincus zt”l in תפארת תורהoffers a deeper insight into why Yaakov
Ovinu had to leave behind his life of Torah learning and flee to the house of
Lovon. If we suggest that it’s because Yaakov needed to get married, we can
ask, why Yaakov had to endure so much hardship in the process, first having to
flee from his own brother, and then going through tremendous difficulties in the
house of Lovon until he succeeded in establishing Klal Yisroel. The question is
strengthened when we consider that we are talking about Yaakov Ovinu who is
referred to as the chosen one of the Ovos HaKedoshim, so why the need for him
to go through so much difficulty to reach the exalted goal of establishing Klal
Yisroel?
The Middoh of Tiferes
The answer, which we will elaborate on, is that Yaakov’s flight to the house of
Lovon involved far more than simply going there to get married and establish
Klal Yisroel. Let’s explain. Reb Shimshon brings that Avrohom Ovinu embodies
the Middoh of Chesed, and Yitzchok the Middoh of Gevura – strength. He then
makes an interesting point, that just as Avrohom and Yitzchok are considered to
be the Ovos in the Middos of Chesed and Gevura, so too Yaakov and Eisov were
supposed to be the Ovos in the Middoh of Tiferes. How?
Because the Middoh of Tiferes actually contains two aspects - Chesed and
Gevura. The Chesed aspect is fulfilled through Asei Tov – doing good, this would
1
בס"ד
be brought about through Yaakov devoting himself exclusively to Torah and
Mitzvos. This is the greatest Chesed since it brings so much Brocha to the
world. The Gevura aspect of the Middoh of Tiferes – the Sur Mera is to stay
away from sin and overcome the challenges of the outside world. This aspect
was given to Eisov to fulfill. As a result, both Yaakov and Eisov would be
regarded as Ovos in the Middoh of Tiferes and they would bring about a new
Shleimus in this Middoh.
Rivka seeks advice
When we look into the beginning of the Parsha, we note this point being made
clearly. The posuk tells us that Rivka became very concerned about the child
she was carrying, because whenever she passed a house of idol worship, the
child wanted to exit the womb, and the same happened whenever she passed
a Beis HaMedrash. This troubled her greatly, and so she went to the Beis
HaMedrash of Shem to seek his advice. Shem answered her through Ruach
HaKodesh that she was carrying twins; one child would devote himself to
שמחנו בישועתך על התורה
learning Torah whilst the other would face the challenges of idol worship, etc.
What was the comfort?
The question is, originally Rivka was very worried because this child of hers
wanted to exit both when she passed houses of idol worship and the Beis
HaMedrash, implying that her child would do both - serve idols and learn
Torah. It’s obvious that such a child isn’t going to be much of a credit to his
parents and we can understand why Rivka was anxious about her situation.
But now that Shem had revealed to her that she was carrying twins and one
child would devote himself to learning Torah whereas the other would face
the challenges of idol worship, why would Rivka be any less worried? True
she would have one son who was a great Tzaddik but why was it a comfort to
Rivka to be told that she would also have a son who would face the challenges
of idol worship? So why did Shem seek to reassure her with such an
explanation, when being told that her child could potentially become a great
Rosho is hardly news that any mother would find comforting?
Eisov’s true purpose
The answer is as we learnt above because this indeed was Eisov’s true
purpose - to spend his life refraining from sin and overcoming the challenges
of Sur Mera. If Eisov would succeed in doing so, he too would attain an
amazing level of Shleimus. This clarifies why Shem shared this news with her,
to encourage and calm her that Eisov also had a great potential to fulfill in this
world, and if he were to succeed, he would be classed as one of the Ovos in
the Middoh of Tiferes.
We can add that this also explains why Yaakov and Eisov wanted to exit the
womb whenever they passed a Beis HaMedrash or a place of idol worship
2
בס"ד
respectively, since they were both keen to get on with their purpose in life -
Yaakov to devote himself to Asei Tov through learning Torah, and Eisov by
facing the challenges of idol worship and reaching his Shleimus in Sur Mera. In
fact, this is the reason why Yitzchok wanted to give Eisov the Brochos since he
would be spending his time interacting with the world and so would require a
Brocha in Gashmiyos to have success in his Avoda.
The difference between Avrohom, Yitzchok and Yaakov
Based on this differentiation between Yaakov and Eisov, we can now explain the
following. Reb Moshe Feinstein zt”l in ) דרש משה (י"חobserves that unlike
Avrohom who was challenged with the ten Nisyoinos, and Yitzchok who faced
the challenge of the Akeida, the posuk doesn’t tell us that Yaakov was given any
specific challenges from Hashem. Rather, the posuk notes that he was an איש
תם יושב אהלים. The question is why didn’t he receive any specific challenge?
Yaakov’s image is on the Kisei HaKovod
שמחנו בישועתך על התורה
The answer is that Yaakov’s purpose was to strengthen the Asei Tov by devoting
himself exclusively to learning Torah, and in this he succeeded tremendously.
As a result, he reached the greatest spiritual heights to the point where an image
of his face is on the Kisei HaKovod. This is apparent from next week’s Parsha
where we learn how Yaakov rested on Har HaMoriah and in his dream he saw
the Malochim ascending and descending the ladder. Why were they doing so?
Chazal tell us that they were gazing at Yaakov’s face in this world and then
ascending to gaze at his image in the next world on the Kisei HaKovod.
Therefore, there was no need to give him any other challenges since he reached
phenomenal heights through learning Torah. Reb Moshe emphasizes how this
truly highlights the greatness of those who exclusively sit and learn Torah and
the awesome heights that they attain by doing so!
What went wrong?
Indeed, Yaakov succeeded in his mission of Asei Tov but unfortunately, Eisov in
his mission of Sur Mera didn’t, and this explains why Yaakov’s mission in life
changed so dramatically after he received the Brochos.
Let’s preface it with the following anecdote heard many years ago from Reb
Shlomo Brevda zt”l. He was discussing the importance of putting efforts into
learning, davening and achieving Middos Tovos. He then drove home his
message by saying: “There are no freebies in life.” Because if a person truly
wants to have success, he must work hard and then he will receive the Siyata
Dishmaya to succeed.
Eisov was tasked with an incredible Avoda of facing up to the challenges of the
outside world and overcoming them by being Sur Mera. However, despite being
given this opportunity, which would undoubtedly have brought him great success
3
בס"ד
had he put in the effort, he chose instead to indulge in the pleasures of this
world, which led him to sin.
“Can’t be bothered” mode
The posuk (ל-כ"ט: )כ"הsays: “And Yaakov boiled a soup and Eisov came in
from the field and he was exhausted. Eisov said to Yaakov, “Pour into me now
some of that very red stuff for I am exhausted.” Rashi points out that Eisov
was exhausted because he had murdered that day. In fact, the Gemora in
): בבא בתרא (טזbrings that Eisov sinned five times on that day, he behaved
immorally, he killed Nimrod, he denied Hashem, denied Techias HaMesim
and despised the Bechora. He did the first three sins before he ate from the
soup. Reb Simcha Zisel Broide zt”l in ) ספר שם דרך (קפ"בpoints out that the
final two sins of denying Techias HaMesim and disparaging the Bechora were
a direct result of his exhaustion. He explains that by twice describing Eisov as
exhausted, the Torah is teaching us a fundamental lesson: that when a person
is in a state of exhaustion – referring here to feelings of lethargy, laziness or a
שמחנו בישועתך על התורה
lack of motivation – he is never far from sin. As a result of Eisov feeling so, he
fell further and sinned by denying Techias HaMesim and disparaging the
Bechora!
Yaakov is full of energy
In contrast, we find in next week’s Parsha, Yaakov Ovinu, who despite having
had very little sleep over the previous years, was able to single-handedly
remove the stone covering the well when he saw Rochel approaching,
enabling her to draw water for her sheep. This seems rather surprising as we
would have expected Yaakov to be exhausted and unable to lift the stone,
while Eisov, being a man of the field, would surely have been the stronger of
the two. Why, then, do we find the exact opposite, Yaakov is full of energy
and strength, but Eisov seemingly lacks the strength to lift a bowl of soup to
his mouth?
The answer is because one who is always engaged in learning and doing
Mitzvos becomes invigorated through it, as the posuk (ל"א:' )ישעי' מtells us:
וקויי ה' יחליפו כח- those who hope to Hashem receive renewed energy and
become strengthened, whereas a person who is lazy and lethargic eventually
becomes pulled down to indulge in this world and falls into sin.
The difference between Yaakov and Eisov
This, in essence, describes the difference between Yaakov and Eisov. Eisov
can’t be bothered and so he falls into sin whilst Yaakov pushes himself
continuously to greater heights in Avodas Hashem and doesn’t fall into sin. A
classic example of this is found in the following anecdote told over regarding
the Noda BiYehuda zt”l. When he was on his deathbed, the Chevra Kadisha
4
בס"ד
advised him to say Viduy. His reply was “I don’t need to because I was so busy
with my learning that I never had time to sin!”
Dovid HaMelech and Eisov
To further illustrate this point that if Eisov would have pushed himself to
overcome his challenges in Sur Mera, he could have had great success, there is
a very interesting Ba’al HaTurim on the posuk ויצא הראשון אדמוני:)כ"ה: (כ"ה- The
first one - Eisov was born looking ruddy – red. He brings the following. There are
two places in Tanach where the expression Admoni – ruddy is used; once here
and the second regarding Dovid HaMelech in )י"ב: שמואל א' (ט"זwhere it says that
Dovid was Admoni - ruddy looking with fair eyes. What is the connection between
the two?
He explains that when Shmuel HaNovi first saw Dovid, he noticed that he was
ruddy and said that he would be a spiller of blood like Eisov. Therefore, the posuk
continues by saying that he had fair eyes which is a reference to the Sanhedrin
who are the Einei HoEidoh - the eyes of Klal Yisroel, meaning that Dovid would
שמחנו בישועתך על התורה
only spill blood with the permission of the Sanhedrin.
Reb Elya Ber Wachtfogel Shlita in his ) ספר אמרי אור (ל"בexplains that we see
from this that Dovid HaMelech’s nature was the same as Eisov’s since we find
the same expression of Admoni – ruddy by both. Due to this, Shmuel HaNovi
presumed that he was a spiller of blood and certainly not suitable to be a king.
In truth, this wasn’t just because he was Admoni. Shmuel HaNovi is referred to
as being " "שמואל הרואה- he could actually see the inner nature of people, and
he saw that Dovid had an innate tendency towards bloodshed. However, the
difference between Dovid HaMelech and Eisov was that Dovid battled against
his nature and became the great Dovid HaMelech, whereas Eisov didn’t bother
to fight his nature and so remained Eisov the sinner.
Eisov loses the Brochos
Rivka Imeinu understood that since Eisov had chosen to indulge in the material
pleasures of this world rather than fight against his nature, there was no purpose
in him receiving the Brochos since receiving a Brocha to gain more success in
materialism would lead Eisov to fall deeper into sin. Rather, she wanted the
Brochos to go to Yaakov who would appreciate the importance of using
materialism for the higher goal of serving Hashem.
A new task for Yaakov
This had tremendous ramifications because the Brochos had originally been
intended for Eisov to help him succeed in his Avoda. Now that Yaakov received
them instead, he had to take upon himself Eisov’s Avoda too. Yaakov would no
longer be able to just sit and learn Torah and focus on Asei Tov to achieve the
Middoh of Tiferes but rather, he also had to take Eisov’s job of Sur Mera in order
to gain a Shleimus in the Middoh of Tiferes.
5
בס"ד
In practice this meant facing up to life outside the Beis HaMedrash with all its
temptations and struggles of materialism, and to succeed in elevating himself
above it all to achieve this level of Shleimus. And so, immediately after he
received the Brochos, Yaakov’s life changed drastically and he had to head
out to the house of Lovon and tackle the challenges of life outside the Beis
Hamedrash.
“”עם לבן גרתי
Despite the difficulties that Yaakov was confronted with in the house of Lovon,
the Torah tells us that upon his return, he sent a messenger to Eisov saying:
" "עם לבן גרתי- I have lived with Lovon. Rashi explains this to mean, “I have
kept all the Taryag Mitzvas there.” This demonstrates how Yaakov succeeded
in overcoming all the challenges of Sur Mera that are found outside the Beis
HaMedrash too. And due to his incredible efforts to achieve a Shleimus in
both aspects of the Middoh of Tiferes – the Asei Tov and the Sur Mera,
Yaakov’s name became synonymous with the Middoh of Tiferes for all time!
שמחנו בישועתך על התורה
Reb Shimshon Pincus zt”l adds how Yaakov Ovinu gained tremendously on
a spiritual level by taking on this Avoda. Not only did he now embody the
Middoh of Tiferes entirely, but he also gained the portion in Gan Eden that
had originally been reserved for Eisov had Eisov succeeded in his Avoda. No
doubt this was Rivka’s intention in convincing Yaakov to take the Brochos so
that he would gain the spiritual benefits of doing so too.
However, the implication for Klal Yisroel is that for all generations, this Avoda
of Sur Mera has been tasked to us too, and so we find ourselves in Golus
having to cope with all the different temptations offered by the outside world,
to succeed in overcoming them, as well as ensuring that we are truly
strengthening ourselves in our Torah learning and Mitzvos – the Asei Tov
aspect.
“No freebies”
This is our Avoda, and we can learn two important lessons from Eisov’s
failure. Firstly, we should reflect on how much he lost, both in this world and
the next, by failing to put effort into his Avoda of Sur Mera. Secondly, we must
realise that if we want to succeed, we cannot simply sit back and hope for
success. There are no freebies from Hashem! Only by working hard and
devoting ourselves wholeheartedly to our Avoda, just as Yaakov Ovinu did,
can we too succeed in our own individual Avoda of Sur Mera and Asei Tov!
***
6
