Vayomer Eliyahu - English — Toledot (2026-11-09)

ערב שב"ק פרשת
By Rabbi Eli Meyer Smith Shlit”a
Rosh Hakollel of Bais Ulfana Lehoroa »
שנת תשפ "ז
«Email rabbi@yeshivasrebchaim ozer.com
בס"ד
The Yeshua Arises Even From Events That Appear Bad!
›› Why Did Esav Disgrace the Bechorah? status, he was able to receive the brachos of Avrohom, as
the Ramban explains that he needed to be the bechor in
The pasuk in this week’s Parshah (Bereishis 25-32-34) order to get the brachos. Thus, everything that occurred
states: “And Esav said, ‘Behold, I am going to die. What was for Yitzchok’s benefit. He lost his wealth so that
do I need the bechorah for?’ And Yaakov said, ‘Swear to Yaakov and his descendants should have these blessings,
me today.’ And he swore to him, and he sold the bechorah rather than Esav and his descendants.
to Yaakov. And Yaakov gave Esav bread and a pot of
lentils. And he ate, and he drank, and he stood up and ›› Even When Things Look Bad, They are Good!
went. And Esav disgraced the bechorah.” The Ramban explains the reason why Yitzchok Avinu
The Ibn Ezra writes that the reason Esav didn’t care went blind in a similar way. He asks why this great tzadik
about the first-born status was that Yitzchok was not deserved such a fate, and answers that Hashem made it
wealthy. Since there was not going to be a large happen so that Yaakov could receive the brachos. Again,
inheritance, Esav didn’t care if he lost the first-born’s right we see that something which seemed bad – Yitzchok’s
to a double portion. blindness - was actually beneficial to him, as it allowed the
blessings to be transmitted to Yaakov, and not to Esav.
He proves that Yitzchok did not have much money
from the fact that there wasn’t much food in his house. If The Baalei Tosafos use the same idea to explain the
there had been, Esav wouldn’t have needed to trade pasuk (Bereishis 26:35) that says that Esav’s wives were a
anything for a pot of lentils, as there would have been source of pain for Yitzchok and Rivka. They write that
something around for him to eat. Furthermore, Yitzchok Hashem caused this to occur so that they would be
would not have needed Esav to bring him food, and he unwelcome in Yitzchok’s home. Therefore, they were not
wouldn’t have loved him for this reason. around to hear Rivka speaking to her son about the plan
to take the brachos, and they couldn’t reveal the plot to
The Ramban strongly disagrees with this explanation Esav. Once again, we see that the pain the wives of Esav
and brings numerous proofs from pesukim that Yitzchok caused Yitzchok was ultimately for his benefit.
was not poor. One of his proofs is from the verse (Bereishis
25:11) that states: “And it was after the death of Avrohom. This concept should be a source of encouragement
And G-d blessed Yitzchok, his son.” He writes that this for us all. When one goes through challenges and hard
blessing included an increase in wealth, property, and times, he should remember that whatever Hashem does
honor. If so, how could he have suddenly become poor? is for the good. He should recognize that even the things
that seem bad to him now are really for his benefit.
He adds that it is true that some tzadikim lose their Sometimes, one can see the good in a short time, and
wealth, but this would not occur to one who was blessed sometimes he might not see it until a long time has
by Hashem. Therefore, he offers another explanation as passed, but one can be assured that whatever Hashem
to why Esav didn’t care about the bechorah. causes to happen to him will be for his benefit in the end.
›› Hashem Caused the Bechorah toGo to Yaakov! ›› The Bad of Avimelech Turned Into Good
The Kesav Sofer zt”l explains the Ibn Ezra by saying The pasuk states (Bereishis 26:29) that when Yitzchok
that even though Yitzchok had been blessed by Hashem Avinu made a covenant with Avimelech and his men, they
with wealth, He caused him to lose it. Hashem did this said: “If you do not harm us, as we have not touched you,
specifically so that Esav wouldn’t want the and as we have done with you only good.”
bechirah because there would be no The Baal Haturim writes that Avimelech
inheritance in any case, and he would be wanted to hurt Yitzchok, but Hashem
willing to sell it to Yaakov for a pot of lentils. orchestrated events to benefit Yitzchok, just
as He transforms all bad things into good.
Once Yaakov acquired the first-born
}{א
Thus, Avimelech said, “If you do bad to us,” it will Golus Mitzrayim started upon the birth of Yitzchok,
certainly be transformed into good. The proof of this is whereas the actual bondage began after the last of his
that “we have not touched you”. Although we wanted to sons – Levi – died, 94 years after the nation went to Egypt.
harm you, Hashem did not allow it, and he transformed it
into good. Therefore, we are sure that He will also change
Accordingly, those 20 years of childlessness delayed
anything bad you want to do to us into good. the bondage by 20 years. If Yaakov had been born 20
years earlier, the Shevatim would also have been born 20
The Kedushas Levi zt”l explains that Avimelech years earlier, and the bondage would have started 20
wanted to kill Yitzchok. Still, Hashem didn’t allow it to years earlier. This is another example of how something
happen. Not only that, Hashem orchestrated events so that appears bad was actually good.
that Yitzchok benefited from Avimelech. He ended up
finding “meah she’arim”, many wells of water, sheep, and ›› Yitzchok’s Birth Was Delayed to Prolong
many possessions. When Avimelech saw this, he realized Avrohom’s Life!
that Hashem wants to provide benefit to Rashi states (Bereishis 25:30) that on the
everyone who trusts in him – even to day that Yaakov traded the pot of lentils to
wicked people like him! He told Yitzchok Esav for the bechorah, Avrohom died. It is
that even if he wanted to harm him, he “…Every second stated that he was meant to live five years
couldn't, because he believes in Hashem longer, but Hashem caused him to die so
and knows He will turn all evil intentions that Avrohom that he should not see his grandson, Esav,
against him into good.
and Sarah taking the wrong path in life.
›› Goodness is Found Amidst Pain This means that if Rivka hadn’t been
suffered saved
The pasuk in this week’s Parshah states childless for 20 years, Avrohom’s life
(Bereishis 27:1-2): “And Yitzchok was very old,
Klal Yisroel from would have been shorter. Thus, Yitzchok
and Rivka’s childlessness extended
and his eyes were blinded from sight. And a second of Avrohom’s life. When Yitzchok and Rivka
he called Esav, his older son, and he said to
him, ‘My son.’ And (Esav) said to him, ‘Here bondage in davened excessively, Hashem granted
I am.’ And he said, ‘Behold, I am old. I don’t their request to have children, and this
Egypt. We learn shortened Avrohom’s life by five years.
know the day of my death.’”
Sefer Peninim Yekarim Hachadash
from this that Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld zt”l sees a
hint to this from the fact that the words
quotes a Medrash (Bereishis Rabbah, Toldos every moment of “vaye’etar lo Hashem” (and Hashem answered
65:10) that states that Yitzchok saw the
Shechinah, and it was decreed that he pain saves a his prayer) have the same gematriah as
would die the same way that Nadav and “chameish shanim”. This indicates that the
future tefillah of Yitzchok took away five years
Avihu died when they gazed at the
Shechinah. He became blind because a generation from from Avrohom. When Rav Yosef Chaim
blind person is considered dead (Nedarim told this to Rav Aharon Kotler zt”l, Rav
64B), so he fulfilled the decree in that way.
suffering. If one Aharon declared, “I am certain that the
gematriah was said with ruach hakodesh!”
He asks why Yitzchok didn’t become blind would recognize
right away at the Akeidah, when he saw ›› Every Bit of Pain Provides
the Shechinah, and answers that at that this, it would Salvation!
time he had no children, and a childless
person is also considered dead. He didn’t
help to ease his At the Bris Bein Habesarim, Hashem told
need to be blind until he had children. pain…” Avrohom (Bereishis 15:13): “And I will enslave
them… for 400 years.” However, Hashem
This means that Yitzchok’s was “chisheiv es hakeitz”. He started the
childlessness saved him from blindness for calculation early to deduct 190 (keitz)
many years. And the blindness he subsequently years, so that they were only in bondage for 210 years.
experienced saved him from death. He writes that this
should teach a person not to cry and complain when he is Sefer Sifsei Kohen (Parshas Lech Lecha) states that these
lacking something – such as children or health – as it is years were deducted because Avrohom Avinu was pained
very possible that lacking one thing is saving him from a for 100 years until Sarah gave birth to Yitzchok, and Sarah
worse fate. was pained for 90 years. Their pain of 190 years served to
deduct 190 years from the pain of their descendants.
›› Yitzchok’s Childlessness Benefited Klal Yisroel
Every second that Avrohom and Sarah suffered saved
Yitzchok did not have children for 20 years after his Klal Yisroel from a second of bondage in Egypt. We learn
marriage. This was for his benefit, as the 400 years of from this that every moment of pain saves a future
}{ב
generation from suffering. If one would recognize this, it that when he looks through the hole, he isn’t seeing the
would help to ease his pain during difficult times. full picture, he will know that there must be a hand
holding the pen that he cannot see at this time, and he
›› Everything Hashem Does is For the Good! won’t get scared by the strange sight.
This can be better understood by quoting the famous So too, if a person recognizes during his time of pain
words of Chazal, who relate (Brachos 60B) that it was that he cannot see the full picture and he trusts that
taught in the name of Rebbe Akiva that a man should Hashem is guiding events and orchestrating them for his
always accustom himself to constantly say, 'Whatever benefit, he will not be afraid, and his pain will subside.
Hashem does is good.” He once came to a town and
looked for lodgings but was refused. He said, “Whatever ›› One Who Trusts in Hashem is Surrounded by
Hashem does is good”, and he went and spent the night Chesed!
in the open field. He had with him a rooster, a donkey, and
a lamp. A gust of wind came and blew out the lamp; a This is as Dovid Hamelech says in Tehillim (32:10):
weasel came and ate the rooster; a lion came and ate the “There are many pains for a wicked man, but one who
donkey. He was left alone and empty-handed, but he said: trusts in Hashem is surrounded by chesed.” A rasha who
'Whatever Hashem does is good.” doesn’t trust in Hashem and doesn’t believe that
whatever He does is good is stopping his own salvation.
That night, armed robbers came and carried off the He only sees part of the picture and thinks that it is bad.
inhabitants of the town. Had his fire not burnt out, they Therefore, he will have to live with pain. But one who
would have seen him. Had his rooster and donkey been trusts Hashem and knows that he can only see part of the
alive, they would have made noise and alerted the picture accepts the fact that things certainly will play out
robbers to his presence. It was revealed that all these for his benefit. He is surrounded by chesed. He recognizes
occurrences that seemed bad were really for his benefit. that even in times of difficulty, Hashem is kind to him.
After all that happened to Rav Akiva, it would be ›› All Suffering is Chesed!
difficult to imagine that any of it was for his benefit. Rav
Akiva, however, had so much emunah that he was The Gemara (Pesachim 50A) states: “The next world is
confident that everything was orchestrated by Hashem not like this world. In this world on good tidings, we make
and must be for the good. He constantly said that a blessing of ‘Hatov Vehameitiv’. On bad tidings, we make
whatever Hashem does is good, so he fully believed that a blessing of ‘Dayan Ha’emes’. In the next world, there is
what was happening to him now was also good. only the blessing of Hatov Vehameitiv.” The Tzlach asks
that the Gemara seems to be saying that in the next world
And so it was. He was saved by the fact that he had we will recite Hatov Vehameitiv even on bad occurrences.
not been allowed in and that his fire went out and his How can we say that anything is “bad” in the next world?
chicken and donkey died and, therefore, the robbers did
not see or hear him. It was clearly proven that all the It is explained in the name of Rav Efraim of Brod zt”l
things that seemed bad were for his benefit. that in this world we are taught to say “everything
Hashem does is for the best” even when we cannot
›› The Words of the Chochomim are Pleasant
! understand why it is for our benefit. Therefore, we recite
the blessing of “the true judge.” In the future, we will
The verse (Koheles 9:17) states: “The words of the wise
understand how everything is good, and we will recite the
that are heard with ‘nachas’ more than the shout of a ruler
blessing upon this goodness that our eyes can see.
of fools.” Sefer Shar Bas Rabim says that this hints at the
fact that the “words of the wise” who say that “whatever The Ramchal (Sefer Da’as Tevunos, Siman 140) writes that
Hashem does is for the good” are heard with “nachas” – on that great day everything will become revealed, the
the word “nachas” being an acronym for “ner”, candle, entire sequence of events from the beginning of time will
“chamor”, donkey, and “tarnigol”, rooster – the items in be clear, and all will see how everything was orchestrated
the story of Rav Akiva which proved this concept. for our benefit. It will become obvious to all that
everything that occurred was for our good – and we will
Sefer Eileh Hadevarim adds two points. Firstly, a
therefore recite only the blessing of Hatov Vehameitiv.
person must fully believe that his pain is meant solely for
his benefit. Only if one trusts that whatever Hashem does This is also seen in the verse (Yeshaya 52:8): “For eye to
is good while he is immersed in his difficulty can he be eye they shall see when Hashem returns to Zion.” On that
assured that good will come out of it. Secondly, he day, our eyes will see how everything that He sent was
explains that the emunah is what eases the pain. He part of His great plan for our good.
compares this to a person who peeks through a keyhole
and sees a pen writing. It looks like the pen is writing on From all this, we learn that at times, things seem bad
its own, but that is only because the view is limited and he to him, but those things are also part of His Divine
can’t see the whole picture. Once the door is opened, he kindness. All we have to do is strengthen our emunah and
sees the hand holding the pen. If a person understands believe that “kol mah d’avid rachmanah l’tav avid.”
}{ג
