gilyoines.com Back to the site · חזרה לאתר

Uz Yivka — Toledot (2026-11-09)

Publisher: Uz Yivka

Week: Toledot (2026-11-09)

Uz Yivka — Toledot (2026-11-09)

Open the PDF Download

‫ס"ד‬ that if you miss doing a ‫ ברית מילה‬on the eighth day then you have missed the boat. There is a fascinating ‫ מדרש‬that ‫ – פרשת תולדות תשפ"ז‬The Big Bris Balagan does seem to imply exactly that! About a year ago we received a phone call from a We read in this week’s ‫ סדרה‬of the birth of ‫עשו‬: couple who had been blessed with a baby boy. They really wanted the circumcision to be on the eighth day, “like it says "‫“ – " ַויֵּצֵ א הָ ִראׁשֹון אַ ְדמֹונִ י כֻּּלֹו כְּ אַ דֶּ ֶרת ֵׂשעָ ר וַיִּ ְק ְראּו ְׁשמֹו עֵ ָׂשו‬The first in the bible”. As soon as they quoted the bible we asked one emerged red, entirely like a hairy mantle, so they named them if they were Jewish, “No we are Torah Christians”. him ‫”עשו‬. We immediately knew this community as we have Says4 the ‫מדרש‬: when ‫ יצחק אבינו‬saw him he assumed from done jobs for them in the past1. We proceeded to book them his complexion that he was not fit to have a ‫ברית מילה‬. We in for the circumcision – although they weren’t quite sure see this in the '‫ גמ‬which tells of a story of a woman whose how to work out which day was day eight! We tried to first two sons died as a result of their ‫ברית מילה‬. She brought explain to them the principle explained in the ‫ גמרא‬of ‫'מקצת‬ her third son to ‫ רבי נתן‬who observed that the baby was red. '‫ – היום ככולו‬part of a day – even just a few minutes before He advised the mother to wait until his blood is absorbed sunset - constitutes the first full day of the count. The Torah into his flesh5. She waited until his blood had settled and is quite a closed booked without the ‫ תורה שבעל פה‬which then went ahead with the ‫ברית‬. The boy survived and was they clearly don’t use!2 named after ‫רבי נתן הבבלי‬. That a baby must not have a ‫ברית‬ if he is red is paskened6 in ‫ שולחן ערוך‬next to the ‫ הלכה‬of a A booking was taken and they then proceeded to baby looking yellow. complete the boking form. It then transpired that the baby had lost too much weight, and the day-eight-circumcision After a year or two, ‫ יצחק‬realised that there was nothing and to be cancelled. wrong with his ‘red son’ and this was just his complexion. Nevertheless, he didn’t go ahead a give him a ‫ ברית מילה‬as A week or so later we chased them to see if they he reasoned now that I have missed the eighth day, I will wanted to rebook. Their response left us a bit dumbstruck! wait until he gets to thirteen – the age that ‫ ישמעאל‬had his “Hi sorry for the delayed response, we are thinking ‫ברית‬. When ‫ עשו‬turned '‫ 'בר מצוה‬and was summoned to his because it’s not the 8th day if this is still something we want ‫ ברית‬he objected. to do. Trying to figure our what’s the best thing to do This is ‫ פשט‬in the ‫ פסוק‬in ‫ יחזקאל‬which talks about the End biblically x” of Days when Hashem will slay '‫'שעִ יר‬ ֵׂ a.k.a. ‫ ֵׂשעָ ר( עשו‬means Fair point if all you have in your hand is a bible hairy in the ‫ פסוק‬quoted above, and ‫’עשו‬s homeland is which says to circumcise on the eight day – which ‫)שעִ יר‬. ֵׂ The prophet says to ‫עשו‬, " ָ‫"אם ל ֹא דָ ם ָׂשנֵאת‬ ִ – “was it presumably means, not day seven and not day nine!3 not blood that you hated?”. Surely ‫ עשו‬has no issue with As a postscript: the booking was eventually retaken. blood? When ‫ יצחק‬blesses ‫ עשו‬towards the end of the ‫סדרה‬ Am not sure who their ‘local orthodox Rabbi’ is (perhaps he is told, "‫“ – "וְעַ ל חַ ְר ְּבָך ִת ְחיֶה‬and by your sword you shall aish.com or chabad.org!) but they worked out that the bible live”. Explains the ‫ מדרש‬that the blood that ‫ עשו‬abhors is wants you to be circumcised even if you miss the eighth day. referring to the blood of ‫ ברית מילה‬which ‫ עשו‬rejected7. When I turned up to perform the circumcision they made Seemingly the ‫ מצוה‬to do a ‫ ברית מילה‬is either on day eight sure to put on display all their ‘Jewish artifacts’ including a as ‫ אברהם‬was commanded to perform on his son ‫יצחק‬. The shofar which the mother told me she is still struggling to next opportunity for a ‫ ברית‬is aged thirteen as this was the blow. I didn’t tell her I have been a ‫ בעל תוקע‬for nearly 20 age that ‫ אברהם‬was commanded to give a ‫ ברית‬for ‫ישמעאל‬. I years as I had no interest in teaching her how easy it is to suppose if both of these opportunities have passed the next blow. available age would be ninety-nine – the age ‫אברהם אבינו‬ Seeing as the next major Yom tov was Pesach she was when he was commanded to perform on himself a told me they were unsure how they would be getting ‫!ברית‬ unleavened bread for Passover. Not sure why she couldn’t The ‫ כלי חמדה‬has lengthy piece to explain this ‫ !מדרש‬How call it Matzah!? She then asked me; “Will you be eating could ‫ יצחק‬neglect the ‫ מצוה‬of ‫ ברית מילה‬once he unleavened bread on Passover this year”. ascertained that ‫ עשו‬was just naturally red? Allow me to “Absolutely! The six hundred and thirteen share a little of his ‘shtickle torah’. commandments in the Torah are not multiple choice you He begins by quoting the opinion of the ‫ רוקח‬who says that know!” I responded. the ‫ מצוה‬of ‫ ברית מילה‬that is incumbent on the father is only While we may chuckle at their '‫( 'הוה אמינא‬initial thought) on the eighth day. If the father does not manage to do the ‫ ברית‬on day eight then from day nine onwards it is merely a would we then perform the ‫ ברית‬and risk the life of the '‫ – 'תשלומין‬to ‘pay up’ that which he missed. child? The ‫ כלי חמדה‬initially challenges this ‫שיטה‬. The ‫גמרא‬ According to he ‫ כלי חמדה‬the ‫ רמב"ם‬is enunciating the exact discusses the laws of being ‫ – עולה רגל‬making the pilgrimage ‫ יסוד‬that he used to explain the opinion of the ‫רוקח‬. The journey to the ‫ בית המקדש‬on ‫יום טוב‬. In a case of someone ‫ רמב"ם‬is teaching us that when a child cannot have a ‫ברית‬ who was ‘lame’ on the first day ‫ יום טוב‬and therefore was on day eight due to '‫ 'פיקוח נפש‬it is not an exemption like a exempt from the ‫ מצוה‬of being ‫עולה רגל‬. But on the second lame person on first day ‫יום טוב‬. It is merely because we are day had healed and was no longer a halachic ‘lame’. He upholding a more pressing ‫ מצוה‬of "‫ – "וָחַ י בָּ הֶ ם‬we are to live does not have to be ‫ – עולה רגל‬i.e. there is no '‫ 'תשלומין‬since through them i.e. the ‫ מצות‬are to be kept but not to the he was not ‘in the parshah’ of being ‫ עולה רגל‬on day one. point that we must let ourselves die performing them. This understanding is crucial because then after the illness has If as the ‫ רוקח‬claims, the ‫ מצוה‬of ‫ ברית מילה‬is only a '‫'תשלומין‬ passed he can say there is '‫ 'תשלומין‬and the father must from day nine onwards then granted if he didn’t do the ‫ברית‬ catch up and now on day nine and onwards perform the for example he couldn’t get a Mohel or he wanted a ‘Sunday ‫ברית‬. Bris’ he can ‘pay up’ and ‘catch up’ on day nine and onwards but if the baby was ill on day eight – like the case of the man The ‫ כלי חמדה‬now gives his first ‘chap’ to explain the ‫מדרש‬ who was lame – then there is no subsequent '‫'תשלומין‬. The we began with. Before the giving of the ‫ תורה‬there was no baby and the lame person were never ‫ שייך‬to the ‫ מצוה‬at its ‫ מצוה‬of "‫הם‬ ֶ ָּ‫ "וָחַ י ב‬instructing us as a ‫ מצוה‬that danger to life appointment time and therefore have no '‫'תשלומין‬ takes precedence to any other ‫מצוה‬. That one could not afterwards. perform the ‫ ברית‬while the baby is ill (red or yellow) is not because you would be keeping another ‫ – מצוה‬there is no According to the ‫ רוקח‬we might have a way to explains other ‫מצוה‬, the Torah hasn’t been given yet! It’s purely a ‫’יצחק‬s lack of performing the ‫ ברית מילה‬on ‫יצחק‬. However, logical8 '‫( 'פטור‬exemption) not an upholding of a '‫'מצוה‬. In the ‫ כלי חמדה‬refutes this understanding. which case it is the same as a lame person on day one who The ‫ כלי חמדה‬claims that the lame person who is exempt has a '‫( 'פטור‬albeit one given by the Torah). So indeed ‫יצחק‬ from the ‫ מצוה‬of begin ‫ עולה רגל‬could if he wanted to once he had missed the eighth day had no reason to ‘make arrange himself to be taken in a cart or via crutches to get up’ and do the ‫ ברית‬under the '‫ 'תשלומין‬instruction, just as himself to the ‫בית המקדש‬. That he is not considered ‘in the the lame person who heals on day two has no '‫'תשלומין‬. ‫’פרשה‬, a '‫ 'בר חיובא‬is because the ‫ תורה‬explicitly exempts ‘Catch up’ is only if you were ‘in the ‫ ’פרשה‬at the onset. The him. Since at the time when he is ‫ מחויב‬in the ‫ מצוה‬he is lame person and the red baby (prior to the giving of the exempt he does not have any '‫'תשלומין‬. Torah) go under the radar and do not have to ‘make up’ for But suppose someone who would be endangering himself if what they missed. he were to come to the ‫בית המקדש‬. Obviously he would be Good Shabbos, Yaakov exempt because '‫ – 'פיקוח נפש‬preservation of life overrides To receive this weekly or for comments please email me on virtually any ‫מצוה‬. If the situation would change on the next yshibbert@gmail.com day he would certainly be ‫ חייב‬now on day two to be ‫עולה‬ ‫ רגל‬as a '‫ 'תשלומין‬of the first day. He wasn’t ‘out the ‫’פרשה‬ Torah-Christians - ‫לך תשעט‬-‫ ע' מה שכתבתי לביתי פרשת שלח‬1 on day one like the lame person. He was merely an ‫'עוסק‬ King Henry - ‫ פרשת כי תצא תשפ‬,!Authentic Kabbalah - ‫ ע' מה שכתבתי לביתי פרשת יתרו תשפב‬2 '‫ – במצוה פטור מן המצוה‬someone who was adhering to Torah Two Times - ‫ פרשת וילך תשפ‬,VIII Gemora ‫ב שמסביר את הגמ' בשבת קלב "האי שמיני מיבעי ליה למעוטי‬:‫ וע' יד המלך על הרמב"ם הל' מילה א‬3 another ‫( מצוה‬preserving life) which thereby frees him from ‫ ואכתי מיבעי ליה חד למעוטי שביעי וחד למעוטי תשיעי דאי מחד הוה אמינא שביעי הוא דלא‬...‫שביעי‬ this ‫)עולה רגל( מצוה‬. Just like if on day one he was involved in "...‫מטא זמניה אבל משמיני ואילך זמניה הוא‬ ‫כה‬:‫ הובא דעת זקנים לבעלי תוס' בראשית כה‬4 ‫( פדיון שבוים‬helping the release of captives) on day two he ‫ אבל לא ראיתי מה שהמוהל‬,‫ וכמה פעמים נשאלתי לראות ילד שהוא אדום ביותר‬.‫ צ"ב מהו המציאות‬5 would have to ‘pay up’ and be ‫עולה רגל‬. !‫רואה‬ ‫ סימן שלא נפל בו דמו ואין מלין אותו עד שיפול בו דמו‬,‫ "קטן שהוא ירוק‬,‫ סימן רסג‬- ‫ שו"ע יורה דעה‬6 This differentiation will help us understand the wording the ,‫ אלא בין עור לבשר‬,‫ סימן שלא נבלע דמו באבריו‬,‫ וכן אם נמצא אדום‬.‫ויחזור מראהו כמראה שאר הקטנים‬ ‫ רמב"ם‬uses to teach the law of pushing off a ‫ ברית‬due to the ‫" ויש לעיין מהו המציאות "שלא נפל בו‬...‫ וצריך ליזהר מאד באלו הדברים‬.‫ואין מלין אותו עד שיבלע בו דמו‬ ‫ וכמה פעמים נשאלתי על ידי מוהלים אחרים לראות ילד שלהם‬.‫דמו" וכן שכהדם נמצא "בין עור לבשר‬ health of the baby. The ‫ רמב"ם‬writes, “we only circumcise a !‫ אבל לא ראיתי מה שהמוהל רואה‬,‫שהוא אדום ביותר‬ child who has no illness since the danger to life takes ‫יג וז"ל "הה"ד (יחזקאל לה) כי לדם אעשך ודם‬:‫ ע' בתורת שלמה אות קלג שמציין בראשית רבה סג‬7 ‫ירדפך אם לא דם שנאת ודם ירדפך ועשו הוא שונא את הדם ר' שמואל בר נחמן אמר זה דם בכורה‬ precedence over everything and it is possible to circumcise ‫ ובהמשך הוא מפרש שזה לא נימול הוה פירושו שהוא משוך‬."...‫וקרבנות ר' לוי אמר זה דם של מילה‬ at a later date while it is impossible to bring even a single ‫ערלתו וז"ל "ובדרשת אבן שועיב מביא דרש הנ״ל בשם מדרש רבי שמעון בן יוחאי וסיים וזהו שאמרו עשו‬ ‫ ובס׳ חצי מנשה מביא מכת״י עה״ת אמרו רבותינו עשו משוך בערלתו היה משמע‬.‫משוך בערלתו היה‬ Jewish soul back to life”. Ask many ‫מפרשים‬: why does the ‫שלא נמול כי דברי המעשה שהיה מושך הבשר כדי שלא יראה מהול דבר תימא היא וכי אפשר לעשות כן‬ ‫ רמב"ם‬add the clause regarding being able to do the ‫ברית‬ .‫אלא ודאי משוך בערלתו שלא היה נמול" עכ"ל‬ once the illness has passed? If the illness would not pass .‫ הוספה שלי בהבנת דברי הכלי חמדה‬8