Uz Yivka — Toledot (2026-11-09)

ס"ד that if you miss doing a ברית מילהon the eighth day then
you have missed the boat. There is a fascinating מדרשthat
– פרשת תולדות תשפ"זThe Big Bris Balagan
does seem to imply exactly that!
About a year ago we received a phone call from a
We read in this week’s סדרהof the birth of עשו:
couple who had been blessed with a baby boy. They really
wanted the circumcision to be on the eighth day, “like it says "“ – " ַויֵּצֵ א הָ ִראׁשֹון אַ ְדמֹונִ י כֻּּלֹו כְּ אַ דֶּ ֶרת ֵׂשעָ ר וַיִּ ְק ְראּו ְׁשמֹו עֵ ָׂשוThe first
in the bible”. As soon as they quoted the bible we asked one emerged red, entirely like a hairy mantle, so they named
them if they were Jewish, “No we are Torah Christians”. him ”עשו.
We immediately knew this community as we have Says4 the מדרש: when יצחק אבינוsaw him he assumed from
done jobs for them in the past1. We proceeded to book them his complexion that he was not fit to have a ברית מילה. We
in for the circumcision – although they weren’t quite sure see this in the ' גמwhich tells of a story of a woman whose
how to work out which day was day eight! We tried to first two sons died as a result of their ברית מילה. She brought
explain to them the principle explained in the גמראof 'מקצת her third son to רבי נתןwho observed that the baby was red.
' – היום ככולוpart of a day – even just a few minutes before He advised the mother to wait until his blood is absorbed
sunset - constitutes the first full day of the count. The Torah into his flesh5. She waited until his blood had settled and
is quite a closed booked without the תורה שבעל פהwhich then went ahead with the ברית. The boy survived and was
they clearly don’t use!2 named after רבי נתן הבבלי. That a baby must not have a ברית
if he is red is paskened6 in שולחן ערוךnext to the הלכהof a
A booking was taken and they then proceeded to
baby looking yellow.
complete the boking form. It then transpired that the baby
had lost too much weight, and the day-eight-circumcision After a year or two, יצחקrealised that there was nothing
and to be cancelled. wrong with his ‘red son’ and this was just his complexion.
Nevertheless, he didn’t go ahead a give him a ברית מילהas
A week or so later we chased them to see if they
he reasoned now that I have missed the eighth day, I will
wanted to rebook. Their response left us a bit dumbstruck!
wait until he gets to thirteen – the age that ישמעאלhad his
“Hi sorry for the delayed response, we are thinking ברית. When עשוturned ' 'בר מצוהand was summoned to his
because it’s not the 8th day if this is still something we want בריתhe objected.
to do. Trying to figure our what’s the best thing to do
This is פשטin the פסוקin יחזקאלwhich talks about the End
biblically x”
of Days when Hashem will slay ''שעִ יר ֵׂ a.k.a. ֵׂשעָ ר( עשוmeans
Fair point if all you have in your hand is a bible hairy in the פסוקquoted above, and ’עשוs homeland is
which says to circumcise on the eight day – which )שעִ יר.
ֵׂ The prophet says to עשו, " ָ"אם ל ֹא דָ ם ָׂשנֵאת ִ – “was it
presumably means, not day seven and not day nine!3 not blood that you hated?”. Surely עשוhas no issue with
As a postscript: the booking was eventually retaken. blood? When יצחקblesses עשוtowards the end of the סדרה
Am not sure who their ‘local orthodox Rabbi’ is (perhaps he is told, "“ – "וְעַ ל חַ ְר ְּבָך ִת ְחיֶהand by your sword you shall
aish.com or chabad.org!) but they worked out that the bible live”. Explains the מדרשthat the blood that עשוabhors is
wants you to be circumcised even if you miss the eighth day. referring to the blood of ברית מילהwhich עשוrejected7.
When I turned up to perform the circumcision they made Seemingly the מצוהto do a ברית מילהis either on day eight
sure to put on display all their ‘Jewish artifacts’ including a as אברהםwas commanded to perform on his son יצחק. The
shofar which the mother told me she is still struggling to next opportunity for a בריתis aged thirteen as this was the
blow. I didn’t tell her I have been a בעל תוקעfor nearly 20 age that אברהםwas commanded to give a בריתfor ישמעאל. I
years as I had no interest in teaching her how easy it is to suppose if both of these opportunities have passed the next
blow. available age would be ninety-nine – the age אברהם אבינו
Seeing as the next major Yom tov was Pesach she was when he was commanded to perform on himself a
told me they were unsure how they would be getting !ברית
unleavened bread for Passover. Not sure why she couldn’t The כלי חמדהhas lengthy piece to explain this !מדרשHow
call it Matzah!? She then asked me; “Will you be eating could יצחקneglect the מצוהof ברית מילהonce he
unleavened bread on Passover this year”. ascertained that עשוwas just naturally red? Allow me to
“Absolutely! The six hundred and thirteen share a little of his ‘shtickle torah’.
commandments in the Torah are not multiple choice you He begins by quoting the opinion of the רוקחwho says that
know!” I responded. the מצוהof ברית מילהthat is incumbent on the father is only
While we may chuckle at their '( 'הוה אמינאinitial thought) on the eighth day. If the father does not manage to do the
בריתon day eight then from day nine onwards it is merely a would we then perform the בריתand risk the life of the
' – 'תשלומיןto ‘pay up’ that which he missed. child?
The כלי חמדהinitially challenges this שיטה. The גמרא According to he כלי חמדהthe רמב"םis enunciating the exact
discusses the laws of being – עולה רגלmaking the pilgrimage יסודthat he used to explain the opinion of the רוקח. The
journey to the בית המקדשon יום טוב. In a case of someone רמב"םis teaching us that when a child cannot have a ברית
who was ‘lame’ on the first day יום טובand therefore was on day eight due to ' 'פיקוח נפשit is not an exemption like a
exempt from the מצוהof being עולה רגל. But on the second lame person on first day יום טוב. It is merely because we are
day had healed and was no longer a halachic ‘lame’. He upholding a more pressing מצוהof " – "וָחַ י בָּ הֶ םwe are to live
does not have to be – עולה רגלi.e. there is no ' 'תשלומיןsince through them i.e. the מצותare to be kept but not to the
he was not ‘in the parshah’ of being עולה רגלon day one. point that we must let ourselves die performing them. This
understanding is crucial because then after the illness has
If as the רוקחclaims, the מצוהof ברית מילהis only a ''תשלומין
passed he can say there is ' 'תשלומיןand the father must
from day nine onwards then granted if he didn’t do the ברית
catch up and now on day nine and onwards perform the
for example he couldn’t get a Mohel or he wanted a ‘Sunday
ברית.
Bris’ he can ‘pay up’ and ‘catch up’ on day nine and onwards
but if the baby was ill on day eight – like the case of the man The כלי חמדהnow gives his first ‘chap’ to explain the מדרש
who was lame – then there is no subsequent ''תשלומין. The we began with. Before the giving of the תורהthere was no
baby and the lame person were never שייךto the מצוהat its מצוהof "הם ֶ ָּ "וָחַ י בinstructing us as a מצוהthat danger to life
appointment time and therefore have no ''תשלומין takes precedence to any other מצוה. That one could not
afterwards. perform the בריתwhile the baby is ill (red or yellow) is not
because you would be keeping another – מצוהthere is no
According to the רוקחwe might have a way to explains
other מצוה, the Torah hasn’t been given yet! It’s purely a
’יצחקs lack of performing the ברית מילהon יצחק. However,
logical8 '( 'פטורexemption) not an upholding of a ''מצוה. In
the כלי חמדהrefutes this understanding.
which case it is the same as a lame person on day one who
The כלי חמדהclaims that the lame person who is exempt has a '( 'פטורalbeit one given by the Torah). So indeed יצחק
from the מצוהof begin עולה רגלcould if he wanted to once he had missed the eighth day had no reason to ‘make
arrange himself to be taken in a cart or via crutches to get up’ and do the בריתunder the ' 'תשלומיןinstruction, just as
himself to the בית המקדש. That he is not considered ‘in the the lame person who heals on day two has no ''תשלומין.
’פרשה, a ' 'בר חיובאis because the תורהexplicitly exempts ‘Catch up’ is only if you were ‘in the ’פרשהat the onset. The
him. Since at the time when he is מחויבin the מצוהhe is lame person and the red baby (prior to the giving of the
exempt he does not have any ''תשלומין. Torah) go under the radar and do not have to ‘make up’ for
But suppose someone who would be endangering himself if what they missed.
he were to come to the בית המקדש. Obviously he would be Good Shabbos, Yaakov
exempt because ' – 'פיקוח נפשpreservation of life overrides
To receive this weekly or for comments please email me on
virtually any מצוה. If the situation would change on the next
yshibbert@gmail.com
day he would certainly be חייבnow on day two to be עולה
רגלas a ' 'תשלומיןof the first day. He wasn’t ‘out the ’פרשה Torah-Christians - לך תשעט- ע' מה שכתבתי לביתי פרשת שלח1
on day one like the lame person. He was merely an 'עוסק King Henry - פרשת כי תצא תשפ,!Authentic Kabbalah - ע' מה שכתבתי לביתי פרשת יתרו תשפב2
' – במצוה פטור מן המצוהsomeone who was adhering to Torah Two Times - פרשת וילך תשפ,VIII Gemora
ב שמסביר את הגמ' בשבת קלב "האי שמיני מיבעי ליה למעוטי: וע' יד המלך על הרמב"ם הל' מילה א3
another ( מצוהpreserving life) which thereby frees him from ואכתי מיבעי ליה חד למעוטי שביעי וחד למעוטי תשיעי דאי מחד הוה אמינא שביעי הוא דלא...שביעי
this )עולה רגל( מצוה. Just like if on day one he was involved in "...מטא זמניה אבל משמיני ואילך זמניה הוא
כה: הובא דעת זקנים לבעלי תוס' בראשית כה4
( פדיון שבויםhelping the release of captives) on day two he
אבל לא ראיתי מה שהמוהל, וכמה פעמים נשאלתי לראות ילד שהוא אדום ביותר. צ"ב מהו המציאות5
would have to ‘pay up’ and be עולה רגל. !רואה
סימן שלא נפל בו דמו ואין מלין אותו עד שיפול בו דמו, "קטן שהוא ירוק, סימן רסג- שו"ע יורה דעה6
This differentiation will help us understand the wording the , אלא בין עור לבשר, סימן שלא נבלע דמו באבריו, וכן אם נמצא אדום.ויחזור מראהו כמראה שאר הקטנים
רמב"םuses to teach the law of pushing off a בריתdue to the " ויש לעיין מהו המציאות "שלא נפל בו... וצריך ליזהר מאד באלו הדברים.ואין מלין אותו עד שיבלע בו דמו
וכמה פעמים נשאלתי על ידי מוהלים אחרים לראות ילד שלהם.דמו" וכן שכהדם נמצא "בין עור לבשר
health of the baby. The רמב"םwrites, “we only circumcise a ! אבל לא ראיתי מה שהמוהל רואה,שהוא אדום ביותר
child who has no illness since the danger to life takes יג וז"ל "הה"ד (יחזקאל לה) כי לדם אעשך ודם: ע' בתורת שלמה אות קלג שמציין בראשית רבה סג7
ירדפך אם לא דם שנאת ודם ירדפך ועשו הוא שונא את הדם ר' שמואל בר נחמן אמר זה דם בכורה
precedence over everything and it is possible to circumcise
ובהמשך הוא מפרש שזה לא נימול הוה פירושו שהוא משוך."...וקרבנות ר' לוי אמר זה דם של מילה
at a later date while it is impossible to bring even a single ערלתו וז"ל "ובדרשת אבן שועיב מביא דרש הנ״ל בשם מדרש רבי שמעון בן יוחאי וסיים וזהו שאמרו עשו
ובס׳ חצי מנשה מביא מכת״י עה״ת אמרו רבותינו עשו משוך בערלתו היה משמע.משוך בערלתו היה
Jewish soul back to life”. Ask many מפרשים: why does the
שלא נמול כי דברי המעשה שהיה מושך הבשר כדי שלא יראה מהול דבר תימא היא וכי אפשר לעשות כן
רמב"םadd the clause regarding being able to do the ברית .אלא ודאי משוך בערלתו שלא היה נמול" עכ"ל
once the illness has passed? If the illness would not pass . הוספה שלי בהבנת דברי הכלי חמדה8
