HaIchud B'chidud Divrei Torah - English — Toledot (2026-11-09)

בס"ד
Shiurim of the Ichud B’chidud are available פרשת תולדת תשפ"ז
on Torah Anytime by R’ Yitzchok Aryeh Epstein
This week’s Shiurim can be accessed at
4:24 הדלקת נרות
https://www.torahanytime.com/#/lectures?v=491161 8:35/9:11 סזק"ש
https://www.torahanytime.com/#/lectures?v=491411 זמניםare for Lakewood, NJ
718-298-2077 press 9 491161# or 9 491411#. Volume 28 Issue 06
דברי תורה ~ פרשת תולדת
בראשית כ"ה כ"ו...ויאמר עשו אל יעקב הלעיטני נא מן האדם האדם הזה כי עיף אנכי על כן קרא שמו אדום
The ילקוט מעם לועזasks, from the end of the פרשהwhere we see the distinct way that עשו & יעקבspoke, we notice that יעקבsaid נא,
please, נואbut עשוspoke gruffly. So how is it that we find here by the בכורהthat עשוsaid ?נאThe ילקוטanswers that נאhere means “raw”!! As
in !אל תאכלו ממנו נאThis פשטwas made famous by ר' שלום שוואדראן זצ"לwho asked 2 additional questions. First, cooked עדשיםare not red but
greenish-brown? Also, if you want to show that he was a בעל תאוה, then he should be called הלעיטני, why was he called ?אדוםIf נאmeans raw,
then the beans were still red! We emphasize his name “red” as he demanded the beans raw-red! He was a בר דוסאי, and ate his food raw!
בראשית כ"ה כ"ו...ויאמר עשו אל יעקב הלעיטני נא מן האדם האדם הזה כי עיף אנכי על כן קרא שמו אדום
The משגיחReb Mattisyahu Salomon שליט"אtold me that many years ago, he was by מרן ר' לייזר שך זצוק"לand one of the ‘ראש ישיבהs
grandchildren came into the room while he was talking to the ראש ישיבהand הרב שךpulled out from his “candies” a RED candy. (He always gave
out candies to the children for being good etc. &to encourage לימוד התורהwhich is sweet like candy)!! הרב שךtold the boy, “you want RED,
right?” The Mashgiach wanting to learn ( )גדול שמושהasked, Isn’t the ראש ישיבהtraining him to be like ר' לייזר ??עשוanswered him, there is
nothing wrong with red!! Every child wants red!! That’s natural!! The טענהon עשוwas that he’s not six years old anymore, he’s 15!! It’s time to
grow up! Stop fantasizing and living like a happy go lucky child. Start using your mature brains, realize there is a בורא עולםand act according to
his will!! (This story was eventually printed in )ס' תורתך שעשועי פ' תולדת דף ע"ה
בראשית כ"ה כ"ז...ויגדלו הנערים ויהי עשו איש יודע ציד איש שדה ויעקב איש תם יושב אהלים
רש"יtells us עשוtricked his father into thinking that he was an erenster בחורby asking him ''שאלות. The example רש"יbrings is היאך
מעשרין את המלח ואת התבן, how does one go about tithing salt & straw. Who says it needs to be tithed? His question should have been האם
& מעשרין מלח ותבןif the answer is in the affirmative, you take off 10%! What’s the big ?שאלה
The ( רמב"ם )מלכים פ"ט ה"אsays that until אברהםcame along, there were only 7 מצוות בני נח. אברהםadded שחרית & מילה, and יצחק
added …מנחה & מעשרThe מפרשיםask, Didn’t אברהםalready give מעשרto ?מלכי צדקThey answer that יצחקgave מעשר דגןand אברהםgave מעשר
כספים. What’s the difference? מעשר דגןis 10% of the yield of the crops that one gathers. One may not deduct his expenses, rather the 10% is of
the entire yield. However by מעשר כספים, one first deducts his expenses off the total amount of money he earned, and of what is left, one gives
10%. ‘עשוs question to יצחקwas HOW do I figure the מעשרon salt & straw? Salt is mined from the ground & straw grew like crops. Is its דיןlike
the מעשר דגןof יצחקwith no deducting costs, or like מעשר כספיםof אברהםwhich first deducts expenses??? ()אבני שהם
As an aside, when one gives מעשר, he gains as חז"לtell us, one doesn’t lose by giving מעשר. So if one has $100 and he gives $10, he
now has $110 ($10 in )עולם הבא, and he didn’t lose anything so he still has $100. This is מרומזin the beginning of the next פרשה. א'עשר'נוis 570.
10% of 570 is 57. א'עשר'נוis 570+57!!! ()הג"ר נתן קלוגמן שליט"א
בראשית כ"ז מ"ד...וישבת עמו ימים אחדים עד אשר תשוב חמת אחיך
The פסוקis relating that ’רבקהs instructions to יעקבwas to stay by ’לבןs home ימים אחדיםliterally translated, a few days. But was that
’רבקהs true intent? A few days? Did she really think עשוwould cool off after just a few days? How many days exactly?
רש"יhere just says – מועטיםa few. However רש"יin next week’s פרשה, in פרק כ"ט פסוק י"חexplains the פסוקof אעבדך שבע שנים, that
this was the ימים אחדיםhis mother intended as it says !ויהיו בעיניו כימים אחדיםSo here רש"יseems to say ימים אחדיםis 7 years! In fact, I found the
מדרש רבה ס"זsays ר' חנינא בר פזיlearns it out ימים אחדים – ימים אחדים, just like there it’s 7 years, so too here it’s 7 years!
The חזקוניlearns it was 2 years as מיעוט ימיםis 2! The אבן עזראlearns that ימיםmeans years like we find by גאולת שדה. And אחדיםmeans
less than 10!
The חתם סופרhas a different idea about the length of time רבקהwanted יעקבto remain by לבן. He asks, if the ברכותthat יצחקwas giving
that evening were the ברכותhe received from his father אברהם, how dare עשוeven think that these ברכותare becoming to him?! עשוwent OTD
and caused אברהםto die 5 years early! As the אבות הקדושיםwere supposed to live 180 years each. אברהםwas נפטר5 years early in order not to
bear witness to עשוhis Einikle going OTD! And he should get ’אברהםs ?ברכותWhat nerve!
We know from a few ’רש"יs that יעקבat this juncture of getting the ברכותwas 63 years old. Since יצחקwas 60 when יעקבwas born, יצחק
was now 123. He said לא ידעתי יום מותיas he was within 5 years of his mother’s lifespan. ( שרהwas נפטרat 127). עשוsaw that his father thinks
he’s about to die, which would make אברהםliving for 52 years more than יצחקso he didn’t cause אברהםto die early at all! Therefore עשוsaid,
יקרבו ימי אבל אבי, if my father dies shortly, then I didn’t cause an early demise for & אברהםthe ברכותare rightfully mine! So now that יעקבstole
MY ברכות, !ואהרגה את יעקב אחיAnd of course if my father outlives אברהםby even 1 year, then I’ll be מודהthat the ברכותare rightfully ’יעקבs, as
I can’t get the ברכותof אברהםwhom I caused to die early! The problem is that no one would know if יצחקwould out live אברהםfor another 53
years as 123 + 53 = 176! (1 year more that אברהםlived). Zugt der חתם סופר, ימים אחדיםis 53 years! Stay by לבןfor 53 years unless I call you back
earlier, which she did! And the cherry on the top is, the גימטריאof אחדיםspelled חסרwithout the ' יis 53!
'בראשית כ"ו י......כמעט שכב אַחַ ד העם
רש"יexplains that אחד העםrefers to the king as he was !המיוחד בעםHowever, what is ’רש"יs הכרחthat it is referring to אבימלךin the
first place? Here is the !!חשבוןWhen יצחק & רבקהcame to גרר, they told everyone that they were brother and sister. Little did they know that
no one believed them, as they all heard the gossip that the לצני הדורwere preaching that מאבימלך נתעברה שרה. Since אברהם & שרהcan’t have
kids, and they didn’t have a boy when שרהwas 90, surely they didn’t have a girl when שרהwas 127! So they must be husband-wife, not brother-
sister! However, there was one person in גרר, that did not believe the לצניםas he knew the truth, as he– אבימלךknew that he did not marry שרה.
If so, יצחקdid indeed come from שרה & אברהםthrough a !נסSo what is such a חידושthat 40 years later, ' דcan’t make another & נסthey should
have a girl? So maybe they are brother-sister, & then I, אבימלךcan marry !רבקהSo the only one that could have been נכשלin this חטאwas
!אבימלךSo now that we established that the פסוקis referring to אבימלך, and the תורהuses a לשוןof אחד העם, it must mean !!!המיוחד בעם
:ב"ב ט"ז- בא על נערה מאורסה....ה' עבירות עבר אותו רשע באותו יום.
' & תוסthe תוס' רי"דboth learn that עשוwas עוברthis עבירה, !כפשוטוBut the פרי מגדיםin ' הל' פסח תע"ו משב"ז גbrings a יד יוסףthat explains
this יעקב !גמרא ע"פ דרך הדרשprepared for עשוa pot of !'לחם' & עדשיםThe לחםhe prepared was none other than מצותfor the סדרthat
night !ליל פסחHe made these מצותfor his OTD brother who he knew would otherwise not eat מצהthat night. But עשוdidn’t save them
for the סדרbut rather ate them up immediately as he was starving! The ירושלמי פסחים פ"י ה"אtells us, האוכל מצה בערב פסח כבא על ארוסתו
בבית חמיו. This is what חז"לmean, !שבא על נערה מאורסהThe ראשוניםexplain that they are both similar as both are מותרonly after one
makes !שבע ברכותBefore מצה, we say יין קידוש זמן כרפס יין המוציא ועל אכילת מצה. So too a כלהis מותרafter the ז' ברכותof נישואין. We
actually have 9 ברכותas we also have על נטילת ידים & אשר גאלנו. מהר"י ויילdoesn’t count זמן & כרפסas שהחיינוcan be made & אפ' בשוק
כרפסis only said !כדי שישאלו התינוקות
ג- בראשית כ"ז כ"ב- ולא הכירו כי היו ידיו כידי עשו אחיו שעירות.וימשהו ויאמר הקל קול יעקב והידים ידי עשו
The אור החיים הקדושasks why יצחקrelied on the סימןof hairy hands over the סימןof voice recognition? The אור החייםanswers that voices
can easily be manipulated and sound otherwise. But hairy hands, either you have them or you don’t. So therefore יצחקrelied on the hair סימן.
The תירוש ויצהרuses a different approach. The פסוקsays before in ' פסוק וthat ורבקה אמרה אל יעקב בנה לאמר הנה שמעתי את אביך מדבר אל
& עשו אחיך לאמרthe מפרשיםask, usually when the תורהuses the word לאמרit’s instructing us to repeat it further but that meaning is not feasible
here. The מפרשיםalso ask why wasn’t יצחקworried that יעקבwould find out about the ברכותceremony & try to grab it before עשוcould get it?
The answer is that of course יצחקwas worried that יעקבwould find out about it & try to get the ברכותfor himself. But one thing יצחקknew
was that if יעקבwould try to be an impostor & act like עשו, but he would have to change his voice & talk like עשו. The . גמ' מכות י"אteaches us
that there are 2 types of talking דיבור & אמירה. The גמראsays that the פסוקby מתן תורהsays כה תאמרו לבית יעקב ותגיד לבני ישראלthat אמירהis a
soft speech & reserved for women and דיבורis a tougher speech reserved for men.
We now can understand what רבקהwas saying. ורבקה אמרה אל יעקב בנה לאמרRivka was giving instructions to יעקבhow to talk, to use a
‘soft talk’ a ‘ ’לאמרtalk, an !אמירה רכהDon’t change your voice & talk gruff like !עשוWHY? הנה שמעתי את אביך מדבר אל עשו אחיך לאמר, because I
overheard your father יצחקgiving instructions to עשוto ''לאמר, to talk with an ' !'אמירה רכהAs since יעקבwill definitely talk like עשו, so you יעקב
talk like yourself, & then יצחקwill think you’re עשוand he will Bentch you.
Now the ’אור החייםs קשיאis answered! יצחקdid indeed set up 2 סימניםto protect his plan! The Hair on the hand & the soft demeanor of
talking which יעקבused. (This similar to the בית הלויwho asks if it was קל קול יעקב, why did he give the ברכותeven though it was ?ידים ידי עשוHe
answers like we said that this was ’יצחקs original plan! So everything matched was they made up, !הקל קול יעקב והידים ידי עשוSo he gave him the
)!ברכות
The פלאis, when עשוultimately makes his appearance, he speaks harsh & gruff like & עשוnot soft like ?יעקבThe פשטmust be that עשו
was such an איש שדה, he just plain out couldn’t speak like יעקבeven if the ברכותdepended on it!
' בראשית כ"ג ד- ויאמר האתה זה בני עשו ויאמר אני. ויאמר יעקב אל אביו אנכי עשו בכורך. מי אתה בני,ויאמר הנני
This interrogation is mind boggling. He asked him if he’s & עשוhe answered indeed he is. So why is יצחקasking him again if he is עשו, if
he’s חוששthat he’s lying, what will asking him again the same question help? And if he accepted the truth the first time, then why ask it again?
The שבט סופרanswers that by the ברכותwe see that יצחקBentched יעקבthinking he was עשו, two times. Once ויברכהוafter he confirmed
that it was & עשוonce after reconfirming it, he Bentched him again as it says ויגד וישק וכו' ויברכהו ויאמר. So why was there this double ?ברכהZugt
der שבט סופר, after the first time that יעקבsaid he was עשו, his father יצחקwasn’t 100% sure that it truly was עשוso he only gave him a little
מקצת ברכה. He saved the bulk of the ברכותfor after he verified the facts. יצחקfigured that after this lad got ברכותthe truth would come out as
there would be no need to continue with the feigning. Once יצחקwas convinced that it truly was עשו, he gave him the rest of the ברכות.
The אבני שהםanswers as follows. The ספורנוsays on the פסוקof ולא הכירו כי היו ידיו כידי עשו אחיו שערות ויברכהו, that יצחקgave ' 'עשוa ברכה
for being חושד בכשריםthat he accused him for pretending to be עשוas חז"לtell us ולא עוד אלא צריך לברכו,!החושד את חבירו בדבר שאין בו צריך לפייסו
So the first ויברכהוis going on יעקבwho יצחקnow thinks is somewhere in ישיבהbut since he was חושדhim, he had to Bentch him as the hairy
hands proved that this son was not יעקב. In fact, יצחקrealized after he now Bentched יעקבthat he Bentched יעקבin front of !עשוAnd what was
this son’s reaction? Nothing! Not one sound! Not one complaint! But if this son is truly עשו, there should have been fireworks! He should have
yelled & screamed, WHY ARE YOU BENTCHING !יעקבIf so, this son can’t be & עשוmust be !יעקבHe therefore was again מסופקso he asked him
again, ? האתה זה בני עשו אם לא
בראשית כ"ה כ"ט....ויזד יעקב נזיד ויבא עשו מן השדה
יעקבcooked lentils…says the מדרש רבה ס"ג י"א, when עשוcame by, he asked, יעקבwhy today a lentil dish? יעקבanswered, שמת אותו
)אברהם אבינו( !זקןWhen עשוheard the news, he said יעקב ?באותו זקן פגעה מדת הדיןsaid yes. עשוreplied, if so, then there can’t be reward for
doing deeds & no !תחיית המתיםThe question is, why דוקאis ’אברהםs death causing עשוto become a ?כופר
The : גמ' ב"ב ט"זtells us what happened to עשוon this momentous day. The ' גמthen asks why אבליםeat lentils? The ' גמanswers that
in the West ( )ארץ ישראלthey said בשם רבה בר מרי, that just like an עדשהdoesn’t have a mouth (fissure like other legumes), so too an אבלhas no
mouth but rather sits quietly. דבר אחר, just like the עדשהis round, so too אבילותis round to symbolize that people come & go, live & die! מאי
?בינייהוIf you can serve the אבליםeggs! רש"יexplains, that eggs have no mouth but are not round!
The פנינים יקריםexplains the מחלוקתthat they’re arguing if there can be !מיתה בלא חטאThose that say the reason for eating lentils is
because lentils have no mouth, holds that no one dies without doing a חטא, so the אבלhas no mouth to open to ' דwith טענות ח"וas the נפטר
had to have done some !חטאBut according to the answer that the אבליםeat lentils is due to the fact that they’re round, & it symbolizes that
that is the way the world works round & round, they will hold &יש מיתה בלא חטאthe person may have died due to the “ !”נחשThis leaves anאבל
with a מקוםto ח"וbe מהרהר אחר הנהגת הקב"ה, therefore we serve him lentils to tell him it’s all ’אדם הראשוןs fault & so is the way of the world!
עשוwas asking יעקב, why are you serving lentils & not eggs? יעקבanswered him, שמת אותו זקןthat a צדיקdied! He didn’t die due to his
own עבירותrather due to the חטאof the !נחשTherefore I’m serving דוקאlentils & not eggs! But עשוwho was on the brink, was '&מהרהר אחר ד
became a !!כופר
'בראשית כ"ז א...ויהי כי זקן יצחק ותכהין עיניו מראת
רש"יsays, דבר אחר כדי שיטול יעקב את הברכות. הקב"הmade יצחקblind in order that יעקבshould get the ברכות. But לכאורה, why? Hashem
can’t get יצחקto give יעקבthe ברכותwithout making יצחקblind? What is the connection between the blindness of &יצחקthe ברכותgoing to
?יעקב
ר' אברהם פלגיanswers the following. The ' מדרש רבה ס"ז דsays, when עשוsaw that יעקבtook away the ברכותfor himself, he began
scratching his throat like if he was laughing & he began to spit saliva out of his mouth. What is פשטin this ?מדרשWhat was עשוtrying to do?
The : גמ' ב"ב קכ"וtells us, בוכרא הוא ומסי רקיה, he is a &בכורis using his saliva as a cure for the eyes! ( )רשב"םThe ' גמthen says, ,גמירי
בוכרא דאמא לא מסי רקיה, !בוכרא דאבא מסי רקיהOnly the saliva of a בכורfrom the father heals the eye, but if the בכורis only a בכורfrom the mother,
then it doesn’t heal the eye.
When עשוrealized that יעקבtook the ברכות, he told his father, I’ll prove to you that I’m the בכור, as I’ll cure your eyes & make them see
again through my saliva. He began to spit, but it didn’t help! Why? Because we know that עשוwas really not a בכור מן האבas רש"יtold us )כ"ה
( כ"וthat he who enters first goes out last. So although עשוwas a פטר רחם, but he wasn’t a בכור ליצירהnor a &בכור לאביוtherefore his saliva didn’t
cure יצחק.
This is what רש"יmeans that ' דmade יצחקblind in order that יעקבshould get the !ברכותAs when יצחקrealized that יעקבtook the &ברכות
he was & ויחרד יצחק חרדה גדולה עד מאדhe began to hear עשוbeginning to scratch his throat to get saliva to cure יצחקto prove that he is the
&בכורworthy of receiving the ברכות, & it didn’t work, יצחקwondered why!? It must be that עשוis NOT a !בכורIf so, יעקב !גם ברוך יהיהwho is the
בכור, rightfully came & took the !ברכות
'בראשית כ"ז א...ויהי כי זקן יצחק ותכהין עיניו מראת
רש"יsays that when יצחקwas tied up on the מזבחby the עקידהand his father אברהםwanted to Shecht him, at that time הקב"הopened
up the skies which enabled the מלאכיםto see what was transpiring, and they began to cry. Their tears came down & landed on ’יצחקs eyes,
which was the cause for יצחקto become blind. The question is, does הקב"הreally have to open up the שמיםfor the מלאכיםto see what’s going
on, on this world? Of course they can see, so why did the רבש"עhave to open up the skies?
The פסוקby מתן תורהtells us that there too the שמיםwas opened. ... ויראו את אלקי ישראל ותחת רגליו כמעשה לבנת הספירand רש"יthere
says that Hashem put the brick there during שיעבוד מצריםto remind Himself of the צרותthe Yidden were going through, working hard with bricks
all day. The question is, why did He need a brick made out of sapphire, a plain brick couldn’t suffice?
In the ספר קבלת שבתin his דברי שלוםwritten by ר' שלמה יאנאווסקי105 years ago, he writes that he saw in a ספר, that a תלמידof the רמב"ן
got deathly ill & the רמב"ןcame to visit him & saw that he was dying. The רמב"ןtold him, that in שמיםthere is a היכלcalled כסאות למשפט, and
the שכינהis amongst them. Here is a קמיעwhich you shall give to the watchman & he will open all the gates until you’ll gain entry to that hall.
When you get there, you’ll ask הקב"הthe following questions, which I have written on this paper, about the way He runs the world in regard to
the Yidden. You shall return to me with the answers! The תלמידwas נפטרand returned shortly to the רמב"ן. He told the רמב"ןthat the קמיע
worked wonders & opened all the gates, but when I came near the שכינה, everything became so clear that all your questions aren’t shver! It is
only in this world, an עלמא דשיקראthat things are not clear that we don’t understand what’s פשט, but in the עולם האמת, it’s crystal clear.
Zugt Reb Shmuel Berenbaum זצוק"ל, the . גמ' סנהדרין מ"וsays that when a Yid is בצער, Hashem says קלני מראשי קלני מזרועו. So the רבש"ע
keeps a brick in front of Him to remind Him of the שיעבודbut it’s made of sapphire as the צרותare very special & worthwhile for the Yidden &
that’s how the רבש"עcopes with the pain. Therefore the רבש"עhad to open the skies so the מלאכיםcan understand why the ' 'עקידהon this
world is a !נסיוןAs in שמיםwhere there is no &בחירהthey just follow orders, so the מלאכיםcan’t understand what the big deal is?! Now that the
sky is open & they realize how the world works, the מלאכיםcan now begin to understand the נסיוןof &אברהם אבינוthey begin to cry where their
tears fall onto ’יצחקs eyes.
With this מהלך, we can understand too why by הגרit says, ויקרא מלאך אלקים אל הגר מן השמים, from where else is the מלאךcalling her if
not from the & שמיםwhy is he asking why she’s crying, her son is about to die?! The answer is, that the מלאךwas looking at הגרwith a ‘שמים
look’ and in שמיםthere is no reason to cry as there all is clear why everything is really in our best interests!
'בראשית כ"ז א......ויהי כי זקן יצחק ותכהינה עיניו מראות
The . גמ' מגילה כ"חsays that from this פסוק, we see that it is אסורto gaze at a רשע, and if one does so, he will become blind. We see this
from the fact that יצחקbecame blind after gazing at his son עשוthat was a רשע. The ' גמasks, is that the reason that he became blind? Didn’t 'ר
יצחקsay that a person shouldn’t take a curse of a הדיוטlightly, since we see that אבימלךcursed שרהand it was מקוייםin her son? אבימלךsaid
אל תקרי כסות אלא כסיית עינים, ?הנה הוא לך כסות עיניםThe ' גמanswers, הא והא גרמא ליה- both things caused it. If both things caused it, then what
is the '‘גמs ראיהthat if one is מסתקל בפני רשעhe becomes blind, if it was only caused by the curse too?
The באר יוסףanswers as follows. Why did יצחקgaze at his son? Because he thought that he was a !צדיקHad he known the truth that he
was indeed a רשע, he never would have gazed at עשו. The fact that this piece of information was concealed from יצחקwas due to the curse of
אבימלך. The . גמ' ב"ק צ"גtells us that ‘אבימלךs curse was that since you concealed from me the truth that שרהwas a wife of אברהםand not a
sister, you too shall fall into such a trap of having vital information concealed from you. This curse was fulfilled on יצחקas the true character of
עשוwasn’t revealed to him thereby causing him to gaze at a רשעwithout knowing that that person was a רשע. This is what the ' גמanswers הא
והא גרמא ליה, that the curse caused יצחקto be & מסתקל בפני רשעtherefore he became blind. Now the ' גמhas a bona fide ראיהfrom יצחקthat
it is אסורto be !מסתקל בפני רשע
בראשית כ"ז ל"א......יקם אבי ויאכל מציד בנו
יעקבasks his father to get up from his couch and sit & eat the food he brought. עשוwho was renowned for his כיבוד אב, tells his father to get up
& eat, is he insinuating that יצחקshould eat standing? ’יצחקs finishing his meal with יעקב, presumably he was sitting at a table! (See )ב"מ מ"א
The משנהat the end of מס' סופריםtells us that one time אברהם אבינוscreamed at אליעזר – עוגand caused his tooth to dislodge. Since
he was an עבד כנעני, he went free. However, אברהםtook the tooth and carved a chair out of it, in which he would sit! Fregt ר' חיים קניבסקי
שליט"א, that לכאורהthe tooth belongs to the עבדas he’s already free at the time it comes out! How could he use the tooth as a chair?
The truth is the : גמ' קידושין כ"דsays there is a ' מחif an עבדthat is going out בשן ועיןneeds an additional גט שחרורor not. 'ר' עקיבא & ר
אליעזרsay he needs a גטwhile ר' מאירsays no! So according to ר' עקיבאthe עבדstill needs a גט, so he is not yet free, so the אדוןgets to keep the
tooth! But לפי ר' מאיר, he’s free מידso how could the chair be used? But למעשהwe pasken like ר' עקיבא.
We have mentioned in the past that the נשמותthat the אבותhad were & נשמות כלליותthey learned תורהfrom the כחof their
descendants that were within them. ( קרחhad שמואל, כליותיו של אברהם לימדוהוetc.) ר' צדוקbrings from the אריז"לthat that that עשוfooled יצחק
was with the תורהthat spewed from עשוwas from ר' מאירhis אייניקלas we know that ר' מאירwas a יצחק & גר אדומיsaw the ניצוציתof ר' מאיר
in & עשוthat is why he wanted to bentch !עשוThat was the ציד בפיו, the תורה שבעל פהof ר' מאירthe "!"סתם משנה ר' מאיר היא
We also know that the פסוקtold us ויתן אברהם כל אשר לו ליצחקincluding “the chair”! So now עשוcomes in to find יצחקsitting in “the
chair”!(משנה סופרים-כל ימיו.. יצחק )ישב עליוhad no problem sitting in the chair as the הלכהis like ר' עקיבא & ר' אליעזר. BUT עשוhas a problem
with “the chair” as he goes with ר' מאירwho holds the עבדis free right away. So the tooth belongs to אליעזר, and you can’t sit in the chair so
!!!יקום אביGive me the ברכותfor my אייניקלאךthat are the !עיקר תורה
'בראשית כ"ז מ....ועל חרבך תחיה
The מדרשin פסיקתא רבתי כ"אtells us that when הקב"הwanted to give the תורה, he went first to עשוoffering him the תורה. עשוasked,
what does it say in the תורה, !לא תרצחBut my father already Bentched me with !ועל חרבך תחיהHowever, this מדרשis very שווער, as even if they
don’t accept the תורה, there still exists an איסור שפיכת דמים, in the 7 מצוותthat they’re obligated as they are !בני נחAnd the 7 מצוותare even
more חמורas one gets killed if they’re עובר, even without !התראה
The ספר עונג נפשanswers with the .גמ' ב"ק ל"ח. The פסוקsays וזרח משעיר למו, the מפרשיםask why does the תורהmention only & שעיר
פארן, didn’t ' דvisit & offer the תורהto all the nations? They answer that indeed ' דvisited all the nations, but the nations wanted to first see what
עשו & ישמעאלwere going to do as they are children of !אברהם & יצחקIf they accept, then we will also. However, if they reject the תורה, then so
will we. Therefore the תורהmentions just these two, as everyone was תלויin them!
באמת, what was ’יצחקs כוונהin his ברכהof ועל חרבך תחיהto עשו, if it was one of the ?ז' מצוות בני נחIt must be, that יצחקmeant that עשו
should kill those that bow to ע"זand they’re חייב מיתה, those bad people, you עשוshould kill, but ח"וnot other good בני נחthat keep the ז' מצוות
בני נח. Now we can understand ’עשוs refusal of the תורה. עשוclaimed that if he doesn’t accept the תורה, then neither will other nations, and
some will bow to ע"זand we will kill them, so there is a מקוםfor my father ’יצחקs ברכהto be חל. However, if I do accept the תורה, and the other
nations will follow my lead, then no one will bow to ע"זand there will be no way that I can be מקייםmy father’s ברכהof !ועל חרבך תחיה
בראשית כ"ה כ"ח...ויאהב יצחק את עשו כי ציד בפיו
חז"לtell us that יצחקhad the מידהof גבורה, פחד יצחק. Yet we find that עשוbrought his wives into his parent’s home & allowed them to
do all types of !עבירותThey were מקטירto their & עבודה זרהtheir smoke blinded !יצחקNot only does he not throw them out of his house but he
loves עשוeven more! Unconditional love?! In fact, I saw that the ש"ך עה"תsays that כי ציד בפיוis going on יצחק !יצחקkept עשוsomewhat in check
by speaking to him בלשון רכהin order to ‘catch him’ & bring him back On The Derech!
The תרגוםsays that כי ציד בפיוmeans, he provided יצחקwith food from what he hunted! Did יצחקreally need his food? Did he love עשו
more than יעקבbecause of this food? We know צדיקיםwho’d starve to death if no one mentioned to them food! Was יצחקany smaller?
We must also understand; why didn’t he throw עשוout of his house? Didn’t he have a מסורהfrom his father, when ' דtold him כל אשר
אברהם & תאמר אליך שרה שמע בקולהthrew his son out of the house? לכאורה, we have הדרכהfrom שמיםhow do deal in this situation? If you’ll tell
me, אדרבה, by ישמעאלthere was a & נבואהby עשוthere wasn’t, that גופאis Shver! Why באמתwas there no נבואהhere by עשוto chuck him?
(Maybe an answer might be, ישמעאלwas trying to be משפיעon יצחקto do עבירותbut by יעקב, he was old enough not to learn from him)!
Last but not least, the : גמ' שבת פ"טtells us that לעתיד, ' דwill say to אברהם, אברהם & בניך חטאו ליwill answer, ימחו על קדושת שמך-!רבש"ע
' דthen said the same thing to יעקבwho could have said to 'ד, my children also gave me heartache, yet I had רחמנותon them. However, יעקב
answered like ד' !אברהםthen said, !לא בסבי טעמא ולא בדרדקי עצהHe then went to & יצחקSaid, בניך חטאו לי. יצחקanswered, בני ולא בניך, are they
not Your children too?! When they said, נעשהbefore נשמע, You called them !בני בכוריAnd now they’re not your children? עיי"ש
This גמראis a !פלאImagine, אברהםwho is the עמוד החסד, has no defense for !כלל ישראלLet them be erased! יעקבtoo, is the מידהof
תפארתwhich is רחמים, can’t offer any protection for his sons! דוקא, our father יצחק, who is מדת הדין, is מצליחin warding off '’דs ?טענות
The מפרשיםexplain, (see )עיון יעקב, יצחקsaw ברוח הקודשthat לעתיד, ' דwill come with a טענהof & בניך חטאוhe will have to be their סניגור.
He therefore was מקדיםthe medicine to the wound! יצחקtherefore loves עשוso he should have a טענהready in his !פיוI also had a son who was
a & רשעI still loved him! You too הקב"ה, even though they sinned, please continue to love them! !?בני הם ולא בניך
This was the reason why יעקב & אברהםrefrained from being a סניגורfor !כלל ישראלWhen אברהםhad a son who was חוטא, he threw him
out! יעקבtoo didn’t want דינהafter she was defiled & put on her a & קמיעsent her to שמעון ולוי !מצריםalso got their נזיפה, 'ארור אפם וכו. The only
one of the אבות הקדושיםthat had a & בן סוררnot only wasn’t thrown out but was unconditionally loved was !יצחקWhy did he act that way? כי
!ציד בפיוSo he can protect כלל ישראלin the future! This is also the reason, why הקב"הdidn’t tell יצחקto throw out עשוlike He did by !ישמעאל
Only someone with the מידהof גבורהcan be סובלthis situation! We find this by הקב"הtoo as the אנשי כנסת הגדולהreintroduced saying in שמונה
עשרה, הגבור והנוראas they explained, the גבורהof ' דis that He is !כובש את יצרו ונותן ארך אפים לרשעים
בראשית כ"ה כ"א...ַויֶּﬠְ תַּ ר יִצְ חָ ק ַלד' לְ ֹנ ַכח ִא ְשׁתּוֹ כִּ י ﬠ ֲָק ָרה ִהוא ַויֵּﬠָ תֶ ר לוֹ ד' וַתַּ הַ ר ִרבְ ָקה ִא ְשׁתּוֹ
רש"יon וַיֵּﬠָ תֶ ר לוֹuses a triple explanation, נתפצר ונתפייס ונתפתה לו. ' דwas prevailed upon & he was conciliated and was
persuaded by יצחק. ר' שלמה סובל זצ"לasked ר' יוסף חיים זוננפלד זצוק"ל, why in the world do we need to say all these לשונותof persuasion, why
can’t יצחקDaven & ' דshould give the green light? Also is )קושיית הגר"א קוטלר עיין לקמן( שווער, בשלמאthe לשוןof נתפצר & נתפייסas יצחקtried to
get ' דto agree, but the לשוןof נתפתהconnotes that ' דreally really didn’t want & had no agree. Why wouldn’t ' דwant?
The פסוקsays ('ויזד יעקב נזיד וכו' ויאמר עשו אל יעקב הלעיטני נא מן האדם האדם הזה )שם ל. In רש"יon that פסוק, we see a מדרשthat
says ולכן בישל. לפיכך קיצר הקב"ה חמש שנים משנותיו, ואין זו שיבה טובה שהבטיחו הקב"ה, שלא יראה את עשו בן בנו יוצא לתרבות רעה,ואותו היום מת אברהם
יעקב נזיד של עדשים שזה מאכל אבלים. We see from this מדרשthat ’אברהםs lifetime was cut by five years due to the הפקרותof עשו. If עשוwould
have entered the world at the proper time, which was five years later, then אברהםwould have been able to live out his full 180 years just like
!יצחקWhy was עשוborn five years early? Because הקב"הgave in to ’יצחקs תפילות, as יצחקDavened to ' דto cure רבקהfrom her state of being an
!עקרהOn the spot, ר' יוסף חיים זוננפלדadded a ראיהto his פשטsaying that the גימטריאof ' ויעתר לו הis !חמש שנים
When ר' יהודה לייב שינקר, an אייניכלof ר' יוסף חייםtold this Vort with the גימטריאto מרן הג"ר אהרן קוטלר זצוק"לwhose יאר צייטis
this שבת, ר' אהרןcouldn’t contain his & התפעלותhe said, I guarantee that this גימטריאwas said ר' אהרן !ברוח הקודשthen added, this is פשטin
רש"יthat ' דwas !נתפתהEven though that He wanted to give אברהם180 years but he cut off 5 years to acquiesce to ’יצחקs plea.
I just want to share with you an unrelated Vort I heard from הג"ר אריה מלכיאל קוטלר שליט"אat my youngest brother’s בר מצוה.
A person is born with a & יצר הרעgets his יצר טובwhen he becomes בר מצוהat 13. How then can we understand that עשוwas born with a יצר
& הרעacted like a צדיקas he couldn’t be distinguished from & יעקב אבינוwhen he got his יצר טוב, he became a ?רשע
He answered that of course a person has a יצר טובwhen he’s born but that יצר טובis his father’s יצר טוב. At 13 he gets his own
עשו !יצר טובwas able to fight his יצר הרעwith his father’s !יצר טובBut once he got his own יצר טוב, it was no match against his own !יצר הרע
Therefore, he became a !רשע
כ"ז ל"ח...וישא עשו קלו ויבך...בראשית כ"ה ל"ד...ויעקב נתן לעשו לחם ונזיד עדשים ויאכל וישת
The אלשיךasks, we find that יעקבgave עשוwhat to eat, bread & lentil soup and we see that עשוate it as it says ויאכל. But what
did he give עשוto drink? It says בפירושin the פסוק, ''וישת, & he drank! Drank what? The אלשיךanswers, that עשוwas a man who strived to be
ממלאall his תאוותin this world. So he always had in his pocket a bottle of wine, so if he decided on a whim to become שיכור, he didn’t have to
go look for wine! So after he ate ’יעקבs bread & soup, he washed it down with his own wine!
ר' יחזקאל אברמסקי זצוק"לgave a שמוזin the & סלובדקה ישיבהhe repeated this אלשיך. But he asked, what is this אלשיךtelling us?
What are we supposed to learn from this Vort? ר' יחזקאלanswered, just like עשוwhose goal was to be ''א שיכורע גוי, made sure that he was well
prepared by always carrying around with him a bottle of wine, so too, a ''א ישיבה מאן, whose goal is to be & מרבה כבוד שמיםbe immersed in
לימוד התורה, should always walk around with a דבר הלכה, דבר תורהor a חידוש אין לערנעןto be prepared to fulfill his objective in this world! So now
you want to know what דבר תורהis in my pocket this week? I’ll share it with you.
When עשוrealized that he won’t be getting the ברכותfrom יצחק, he began to cry. חז"לtell us that Yidden in גלותeven until
today, suffer from those tears that עשוcried. Fregt der Rebbe ר' שמעלקא, since those tears of עשו, trillions & trillions of אידעשע טרערן זענן געגאסן
געווארן, (Yidden cried trillions of tears), so why can’t our tears wash away those few tears of ?עשוHe answers, that the ' גמtells us that מין במינו
אפילו באלף אינו בטלso tears can’t be מבטלother tears! But he asks, ?מין במינוHow can we say that ’עשוs tears & ’כלל ישראלs tears are the same
?מיןHe answers; let’s see what עשוwas crying about. The ברכותthat יעקבreceived were all about דברים גשמיות, תירוש, דגן, משמני ארץ,טל השמים.
יעקבdidn’t get דיקע ברכות- רוחניותuntil he left for חרן. So ’עשוs tears were דיקע טרערן-גשמיות, and what are our tears all about? Also דיקע-גשמיות
!טרערןSo they’re !מין במינוIf we were to begin crying דיקעטרערן-רוחניות, then it would be &מין בשאינו מינוsurely משיחwould come & all our צרות
would cease, !!במהרה ובימינו אמן
'בראשית כ"ז ט...ֲשׁר אָ הֵ ב
ֶ ﬠַמּים לְ אָ בִ י� ַכּא
ִ ֱשׂה ֹאתָ ם מַ ְט
ֶ שּׁם ְשׁנֵי גְּ דָ יֵי ﬠִ זִּ ים טֹבִ ים וְאֶ ﬠ
ָ לֶ� נָא אֶ ל הַ צּ ֹאן ו ְַקח לִ י ִמ
רש"יis bothered, how could רבקהtake two goats from her husband’s cattle without permission! רש"יexplains that it wasn’t
גזלas יצחקpromised in the כתובה, that רבקהhas a right to take two goats for herself, every day! One may wonder, what on earth was רבקהdoing
with two goats every day? That’s a lot of meat! The פ' חיי שרה- ילקוט מעם לועזsays that רבקהcontinued in ’שרהs ways & took over ’שרהs ישיבה
for !בעלי תשובהShe also continued in the family’s הכנסת אורחיםbusiness! יצחקprovided רבקהwith the food to enable all of אברהם אבינו & שרה
’אמינוs work to continue!
The ויחי יוסףadds, that since כל מה שקנתה אשה קנה בעלה, then any צדקהthat רבקהwould give to, would be on ’יצחקs account
in שמים. But רבקהwas a בעלת חסדin her own right! She wanted to do חסדon her own, from her own money & the זכותיםshould go into her
own account! ממילא, יצחקhad to give her two goats a day as her private fortune & she could do what ever she wants with it, including selling
them ( הג"ר אי"ל שטיינמן זצ"ל !)ס' נחלת יעקב בעמ"ס משאת בנימיןsays that if she didn’t utilize her two goats on any specific day, then she had credit
for the following day etc. to take four! And so on…
The BIG question is, where did this amount of ב' גדיי עזיםcome from? Why did he put that amount דוקא, into the ?כתובהI saw
a fabulous חשבוןfrom the אוסטרווצא גאוןin his !ספר אור תורה
רבקהbrought into her marriage expensive jewelry that she got from אליעזרas a מתנה גמורהeven before the אירוסיןwas agreed
to; a nose ring weighing a & בקעtwo bracelets weighing 10 זהב. Together it was worth about 280 דינרי זהב. The : גמ' כתובות ס"וsays that some
write into the כתובהa תנאיthat for every מנהthat the wife brings into the marriage, the husband agrees to give the wife every week 10 ( !זוזSee
תוס' רבינו גרשוןthere)! This is really a tenth of the !נדוניאThis is for the wife’s private usage! (See )רש"י. If so, רבקהdeserved 28 דינריםevery week
which was a tenth of the dowery. 28 דינריםdivided by 7 (days of the week), comes to 4 דינריםa day! A healthy גדי עזיםcost two דינריםas we find
in ''חד גדיא, חד גדיא,ממילא !דזבין אבא בתרי זוזי, the חשבוןis perfect! רבקהreceived in her כתובה, every day, two גדיי עזיםwhich is worth 4 זוזים
which is the exact amount that two goats cost!
בראשית כ"ה ל"א...ַויּ ֹאמֶ ר ַי ֲﬠקֹב ִמכְ ָרה כַיּוֹם אֶ ת בְּ כ ָֹר ְת� לִ י
עשוhad a hard day, as it says ויבא עשו מן השדה והוא עיף. עשוsees what יעקבis cooking & he demands of יעקב, הלעיטני, pour the
soup down my throat & יעקבsays, first sell me the בכורה. On the word עיף, רש"יsays, כִּ י ﬠָ יְפָ ה נ ְַפ ִשׁי לְ ֹה ְרגִ ים...ברציחה. It would seem that when עשו
was עיףfrom רציחה, that was his reason to help him out & pour the soup for him, כי עיף אנכי. I’m exhausted from killing people, which was what
he was busy with all day. The obvious question is, עשוnever advertised to the צדיקיםof his family about the underworld he truly lived in. On the
contrary, he had them thinking, (presumably יעקבtoo), that he was a real Derhoibeneh Mentch! Yet here, he spills the beans!? !רציחה !כי עיף אנכי
Also, asks the חתם סופר, the פסוקthat רש"יbrings is referring to the victim of רציחהand not about the רוצחhimself?!
Zugt der חתם סופר, לולא דמסתפינא, I would say not like רש"י, and עשוwas עיף, not because he was a רוצחbut because he was a
victim of !רציחהMy dear brother יעקב, I went into the wilderness to hunt food, and was doing everything לשם שמים, but I was accosted by
gangsters, who wanted to kill me. They stripped me of all my belongings, and I escaped by the skin of my teeth, so please pour the soup down
my throat! The חתם סופרadds, it doesn’t only mean that I’m exhausted, hungry & thirsty, that I want מן האדם האדם הזה. חז"לtell us that פנחס
בן יאירsaid מיום עמדי על דעתי, I never relied on anyone for my needs, even my father! He earned all the money he needed for his own sustenance.
עשוwas being even more dubious than ever. He was saying to יעקב, you know I would never rely on anyone for any food. I work all day because
I’m a !נקי כפיםToday I was robbed of everything! Therefore, I have no choice, but to rely on others and therefore, הלעיטני נא מן האדם האדם הזה.
Why? !כי עיף אנכיI’ve been robbed by murderers!
יעקב אבינוdid a Shpitzel on עשו. He told עשו, I feel terrible that you are about to break your מנהגof not paying for the food that
you eat. But I have an עצהfor you! מכרה כיום את בכרתך לי. I have an עצהjust for today, !מכרה כיוםLike this, you can keep your Heiligeh !מנהגים
Now עשוwas backed up in a corner with no way out! He indeed has no possessions to pay for the soup, but he has the עשו !בכורהhad no choice
but to sell!
The question is, the חתם סופרhas the right to say דלא כרש"י, but he would NEVER say anything !דלא כהגמראYet, this רש"יis
indeed a גמראas we find in :ב"ב ט"ז, אמר רבי יוחנן חמש עבירות עבר אותו רשע באותו היום בא על נערה מאורסה והרג
( כט, בא על נערה מאורסה כתיב הכא )בראשית כה.ויבא עשו מן השדה וכתיב התם )דברים את הנפש וכפר בעיקר וכפר בתחיית המתים ושט את הבכורה
( כז, לא( כב,??? כי בשדה מצאה הרג את הנפש כתיב הכא עיף וכתיב התם )ירמיהו ד.אוי נא לי כי עיפה נפשי להורגים
Zugt הג"ר ארון רייך שליט"א, maybe this is what the חתם סופרmeans. It says עיףtwice here. First the תורהsays ויבא עשו מן השדה
והוא עיף. Then עשוsays, כי עיף אנכי. When the תורהsays עיף, it means רוצחas that is what עשוhad really been doing all day. But when עשוuses
the word עיף, he means that he was a victim of !רציחהTherefore, the חת"סis compatible with the גמרא.
'בראשית כ"ו ז...ְשׁי הַ מָּ קוֹם ﬠַ ל ִרבְ ָקה כִּ י טוֹבַ ת מַ ְראֶ ה ִהיא
ֵ ְשׁי הַ מָּ קוֹם לְ ִא ְשׁתּוֹ ַויּ ֹאמֶ ר ֲא ֹח ִתי ִהוא כִּ י י ֵָרא לֵא ֹמר ִא ְשׁ ִתּי פֶּ ן יַהַ ְרגֻ ִני אַ נ
ֵ וַיִּ ְשׁאֲלוּ אַ נ
יצחקmoved into גררand people began to ask him who the woman that was staying with him was. He answered that it was his
sister, as he was scared that he would be killed and he therefore lied, due to the סכנה. אבימלךnoted that he noticed that he was acting with her
like a husband-wife, and she was not his sister! אבימלךcalled יצחקand asked him point blank, she is your wife! Why did you say she’s your sister?
יצחקanswered, כי אמרתי, I’ll get killed because of her! אבימלךasks a second question, how could you do this to us, someone might have taken
your wife for a wife of their own, and that would be a large sin? What is אבימלךadding in the 2nd question, it seems like it’s a copy of the 1st?
Secondly, אבימלךsays, ואיך אמרת אחתי הוא, how could you say it’s your sister, he was really asking ‘why’? Why did you lie, not ‘how’?
In ' פסוק זit says פן יהרגני, the תורהis saying, maybe יצחקwill get killed, but says it as if יצחקis talking. It should say, ''כי אמר,
because יצחקsaid. Yet, the תורהleaves out those two words. Why?
The פוסקיםdiscuss a case where someone let on that something is אסור, yet later says that they never meant it to be אסור, but
said so for a reason. For example, someone says טמאה אני לךor I’m אסורto you, they can give an אמתלא, an excuse, why they said it and they are
not טמאor !אסורBut the גמראsays that if a woman is wearing her בגדי נדה, we can assume that she’s a נדהand one who is נכשלwith her would
get !מלקותThe ראשוניםsay that from the fact that there is מלקות, she can not back down with an אמתלא, as it doesn’t help.
The ' שו"ת רמ"א שאלה בsays, a woman gave birth to a baby in the 8th month & again the next two babies were born in the 8th
month & she understands that it’s due to עין הרע. She therefore wants to keep the next expectancy secret. Together with her husband’s
agreement, she says טמאה אני, so the close people won’t think she’s expecting another baby. Now they have a שאלהif she’s מותרto the husband
in privacy, as she really is !טהורהThe רמ"אbrings a ראיהfrom !יצחק & רבקהThey were מחזיקthemselves as brother-sister for thirty days, and if
a בן נחis אסור באחותו, then how could יצחק & רבקהstay in the same house together? אלא מאי, since they knew that they were really husband-
wife, it was !מותר
Fregt ר' מאיר שמחה זצ"ל, according to the ראשוניםwho hold that it’s אסור, how do they answer the ’רמ"אs ?ראיהHe answers,
!יש אמתלא ויש אמתלאSome excuses, we wouldn’t know until the woman says it. Yet sometimes, it’s so self apparent, that as soon as one hears
the excuse, it’s פשוטthat the person couldn’t say the truth! That’s exactly what happened to יצחק. יצחקhad his reasons for calling רבקהhis
sister, but once he said פן יהרגוני על דבר אשתי, it was so apparent, that of course there’s an !אמתלא
Therefore, the תורהleaves out the ''כי אמר, as it’s so פשוט, that he didn’t need to even say it! And the תורהdeliberately left it
out so we can realize that that’s why יצחקwas allowed to continue to live with !רבקה
