The Wall St. Torah Journal — Toledot (2026-11-09)

’יוצא לאור ע”י כולל ‘משפטי מרום
ניו יורק,בביהמ”ד ‘גבורה’ בעיר מנהטן
Gevurahkollel@gmail.com
The Wall St. Torah JOURNAL
An informative project by the Gevurah Shul Kollel for monetary matters and contemporary Halacha
Year 2| Issue 7
חשון שנת תשפ”ז לפ”ק
Was the sale between Yakkov and Eisav valid? necessities of life; it is not a general permission to
sell anything that does not yet exist.
The Ohr HaChaim applies this principle
Rav Moshe Shmiel Rieger to Eisav, who declared, Hinei anochi holech
lamus—“I am at the point of death” (Bereishis
“Tell me, Shimon,” Yehudah asked his brother, the view attributed to the Rosh, that Eisav’s
25:32). Eisav was desperately hungry, and his
“would you be interested in purchasing my share shevuah contributed to the validity of the sale.
circumstances resembled those of the poor
of our father’s estate?” Yaakov insisted, Hishava li kayom - swear to me
fisherman. The sale of the bechorah could
Their father was still alive and owned this day (Bereishis 25:33), and Eisav swore to
therefore be understood in light of the special
several valuable properties. Yehudah, in need of him. Since he swore to him that he is selling it,
allowance of kedei chayav.
immediate funds, offered to sell Shimon whatever the kinyan works.
This answer would not ordinarily apply to
he would eventually inherit in exchange for a The Rivash rejects this explanation, how can a
Yehudah. Although he wanted immediate funds,
substantial payment. shevuah help to exercise a kinyan on something
there is no indication that he would have been
The brothers agreed on a price, and Shimon paid that yet exists.
unable to obtain food or meet his basic needs
the money. However, when their father eventually
Before Matan Torah is different without selling his future inheritance.
passed away and the estate proved to be worth a
The Rivash therefor explains that the sale took
fortune, Yehudah regretted his decision. A General Inheritance or a Specific
place before Matan Torah, and we cannot assume Property
“I am sorry,” Yehudah told his brother, “but
that the restrictions governing davar shelo ba
our agreement was never valid. At the time of the There is, however, another important
la’olam applied then in the same manner.
sale, I owned nothing in our father’s estate. How distinction.
could I sell something that did not yet belong to Perhaps this machlokes can be understood The Shulchan Aruch rules that one who says,
me?” through two approaches to the problem of davar “What I will inherit from my father is sold to
Shimon disagreed. “But we find an explicit shelo ba la’olam. According to one approach, the you,” has not effected a valid sale, since the
precedent in Parashas Toldos! Yaakov Avinu problem is semichas da’as: the purchaser does inheritance has not yet come into his possession
purchased the bechorah from Eisav. Chazal not fully rely on acquiring something that does (C. M. 211:1).
explain that the bechorah included the double not yet exist. According to another approach, a
The Rema, however, cites an opinion that
portion of inheritance and the right to burial in kinyan requires an existing object upon which to
distinguishes between selling a >page 2
Me’aras HaMachpeilah. Yet Yitzchak Avinu was take effect.
still alive! Surely this proves that one can acquire A shevuah might strengthen his confidence in
rights that have not yet come into his possession.” the transaction, adding semichas da’as, however Daily Shiurim at the Gevurah
a shevuah cannot supply that missing object to
Yehudah remained unconvinced. “Perhaps
form a ma’aseh kinyan.
Shul:
there was something unique about the sale of the
bechorah. We cannot necessarily derive the laws In any event, neither the shevuah nor the
Rivash’s explanation concerning the period before
Shiur in Chok Gemara – Sotah
of monetary transactions from that incident.”
Matan Torah would help Shimon and Yehudah.
L’Yisrael 2:15 PM
Unable to resolve their dispute, the brothers
They made no shevuah, and their transaction took 8:00 AM by R. Yosef Cohen
agreed to present their case before a Dayan.
place after Matan Torah. by Reb Dov Ber
The Dayan listened carefully. “Your question Gemara - Oraysa
Zyskind
touches upon a fundamental sugya in Choshen The Need for Basic Livelihood 5:30 PM
Mishpat. The Rishonim and Acharonim indeed The Ohr HaChaim offers another explanation Chumash by Reb Dov Ber
discuss how Yaakov could acquire the bechorah based on the Gemara in Bava Metzia (16a), which Following Zyskind
when the ordinary rule is ein adam makneh davar discusses a poor fisherman who sells whatever he Shacharis
shelo ba la’olam—one cannot ordinarily transfer will catch in his net. Such a transaction may be Contemporary
by R. Hillel Gross
something that has not yet come into existence as permitted because of kedei chayav—the need to Halacha
a transferable asset (Bava Metzia 16a). sustain oneself. Daf Yomi Every Monday,
“Let us examine several of the answers and see
Chazal made this special allowance because, 1:20 PM 2:15–2:30 PM
whether they apply to your case.”
without the ability to sell his future catch, the by Reb Baruch by Rabbi Levi
Does a Shevuah Make a Difference? fisherman might have no money to purchase food Karfunkel Yitzchak Osdoba
In Shu”t HaRivash (328), the questioner cites that day. The leniency enables him to obtain the
1
that the merchant did not actually lose the higher
Fair market value of an Esrog: Before or after Sukkos market value.
Is an Esrog Like Wine on Market Day?
Rav Leibel Gelkopf
Most likely the same reasoning applies to an
Reuven owned a store selling Esrogim. One day, Shimon entered the esrog. Its high price before Sukkos results largely
store and accidentally knocked an esrog off the table, rendering it pasul. from seasonal demand. If the seller is left with other esrogim of the
Shimon immediately offered to pay for the damage. Reuven, who was busy, same quality after Yom Tov, perhaps the damaged esrog would also have
told him they would settle the matter after Yom Tov. remained unsold, and Shimon should not have to pay the higher price.
After Sukkos, Shimon returned to pay. However, he noticed that Reuven There is, however, room to distinguish between the cases. Wine can
still had many esrogim of the same quality as the one he had damaged. still be sold after market day, albeit at a lower price. An esrog, by contrast,
Reuven had been unable to sell them before Yom Tov. is generally purchased for the mitzvah before Sukkos; afterward, there
is practically no market for it. Perhaps the fact that the seller has unsold
Shimon now had a claim: “Why should I pay the price of an esrog before esrogim after Yom Tov does not determine their value, since the relevant
Sukkos? You were left with many esrogim that you could not sell anyway. market price is the price at which esrogim are sold before Sukkos.
Even if my esrog had remained intact, you probably would not have sold
The Nesivos HaMishpat (C. M. 304:2) discusses a related case involving
it. And even if you had sold it, you would still have had another esrog left
chametz that was damaged during Pesach. Since chametz cannot be sold
in its place. What loss did I actually cause you?”
during Pesach but is held until after Yom Tov, the damager must pay
Is Shimon’s argument valid, or must he pay according to the esrog’s according to the price at which it is normally sold. The Nesivos compares
value at the time it was damaged? this to someone who steals an item in the wilderness, where it cannot be
The Value of an Object That Has Not Been Sold sold locally, but can be taken to the marketplace and sold there. As the
Nesivos explains, the value assigned to an item in the wilderness certainly
As a general rule, one who damages another person’s property must pay
does not affect its price.
according to its value at the time and place of the damage. The fact that the
owner might not have succeeded in selling the item does not ordinarily Nevertheless, there is a possible distinction: chametz during Pesach
exempt the damager. cannot be sold at all, whereas an esrog after Sukkos is still an object that
can be sold, although its market has largely disappeared.
An esrog, however, presents an interesting question. Its price rises
dramatically before Sukkos, when demand is high, but after Yom Tov, Land in Tishrei: A Relevant Comparison
many esrogim remain unsold and have little commercial value. Perhaps, The Gemara (B. K. 7b) discusses a case in which a creditor may collect
then, if the esrog remained unsold even after Sukkos, this demonstrates land in Tishrei according to its higher Nisan value. The Chiddushei HaRim
that its true value was much lower than its pre-Sukkos price. (B.K. ibid), along with the approaches discussed in Divrei Yechezkel
A similar case is discussed in the Shulchan Aruch (C. M. 304:5), based (siman 46) and Even HaEzel (Sechirus 3), explains that land differs from
on the Gemara in Bava Metzia (99b), regarding a hauler who dropped a wine. While wine can be sold throughout the year, there are times when
barrel of wine from a merchant, and it broke. Suppose the barrel is worth land is not normally purchased. Its value may therefore be determined
five zuz on market day, when prices are high, but only four zuz on other according to the season in which it is ordinarily sold.
days. This comparison may be particularly relevant to an esrog. Just as land is
The halachah distinguishes between two situations. If the merchant generally sold in its appropriate season, esrogim are generally purchased
receives payment for the damage on market day and has no other wine before Sukkos, and there is practically no market for them afterward.
to sell, he may collect the higher value. However, if he has other barrels of
Halachic Conclusion
wine available and they remain unsold, he receives only the lower value.
Although Shimon’s argument has a basis in the halachos of a barrel of
The Lechem Mishneh (Sechirus 3:3) explains that when the merchant wine, it appears that he must pay according to the esrog’s market value
has other wine available, it becomes clear that the broken barrel would not before Sukkos. The key distinction is that wine continues to have a
have been sold on market day anyway. Since it would have been sold later, market throughout the year, even when its price drops, whereas an esrog’s
when the price was lower, the damager pays according to that lower value. principal market exists before Sukkos. The fact that Reuven was left with
The Chazon Ish (B.K. 6:14), however, explains that this distinction other esrogim after Yom Tov does not necessarily prove that the damaged
applies specifically to merchandise whose value fluctuates at a particular esrog had little value when it was broken.
time, such as wine on market day. Regarding ordinary objects, whose Accordingly, the stronger argument is that Shimon must compensate
prices do not change according to a fixed schedule, the damager generally Reuven according to the price at which an esrog of that quality was sold
pays their value at the time of the damage. before Sukkos, rather than its negligible value afterward, similar to land,
This establishes that, in certain circumstances, a damager may argue which is valued according to Nisan, the season when it is customarily sold.
>page 1 general future inheritance and The Halachic Conclusion undertake a binding obligation to bring about the
selling a specific property, such as The Dayan turned to the brothers. “We have transaction in the future.
a particular field that the seller expects to inherit. seen several explanations for the sale of the “However, you never discussed such an
According to that opinion, identifying a particular bechorah: the fact that it occurred before Matan obligation. Your agreement was simply that
property can make a difference to the validity of Torah, the role of Eisav’s shevuah, the special Shimon would purchase whatever Yehudah
the transaction. allowance of kedei chayav, and the distinction would inherit from his father. Accordingly,
between a general inheritance and a specific the sale as described does not take effect
Thus, had Yehudah sold Shimon a particular property. under the ordinary rules of davar shelo ba
house that he expected to inherit, the discussion “There are also circumstances in which, la’olam, and Shimon has no claim to the
would be different, and the opinions cited by the although a kinyan on davar shelo ba la’olam does inheritance on the basis of this agreement
Rema would have to be considered. not take effect as an ordinary sale, a person may alone.”
2
Democracy for Sale: The Halachic Price of a Bribery in his own interest?
The Divrei Malkiel explains the Maharam’s
Rav Yosef Yitzchak Meisels ruling in light of the Rosh, his talmid. The Rosh
writes in his teshuvos that without majority rule,
It’s election season in both Israel and America, and there has been communal affairs would become impossible,
reports about certain candidates allegedly buying votes with money. as a single individual could hold the entire community hostage. The
Without getting into whether any of these allegations are true, let us majority must therefore prevail (Rosh, Klal 6, no. 5).
examine the question from a halachic perspective, starting with the
The Divrei Malkiel says that this is the basis for the Maharam’s
basics:
ruling. The members of a kehilla entered into their partnership
Where do we find elections in halacha? understanding that it could not function if every decision required
The source is the Maharam of Rothenburg, as cited by the Rema unanimity. They therefore agreed to abide by the majority. This
(Shulchan Aruch, C. M. 163:1). He discusses a city that could not agreement, however, rested on a condition: each member must vote
reach a consensus on major issues, including choosing its communal for the good of the kehilla, not for his own personal benefit. The
leaders and how to build their shul. He rules that all the taxpayers cherem ensures that this condition is upheld.
should gather and decide by vote. Before voting, each participant Now that we understand the halachic framework for voting, we can
accepts a cherem, similar to a shevuah, committing himself to vote delve into the subject of vote-buying.
not in his own interest, but in the interest of the public. It is, in a The Chasam Sofer (Shu”t C. M. siman 160) discusses a case in
sense, a direct democracy, in which every major decision is put to a which people were paid to elect one candidate among four others
referendum. running for a rabbinical position. He concludes that if the bribery is
The Maharam’s ruling is based on the concept of partnership: the confirmed, the votes cast as a result of it are void. His first reason is
members of the kehilla are partners, and decisions are decided by the Rema’s ruling in Choshen Mishpat 163, based on the Maharam
majority vote. mentioned above: a vote must serve the public interest, not the
voter’s own. Someone who accepts a bribe for his vote clearly did
The Divrei Malkiel (vol. I, siman 35) points out that the Maharam’s
not have the public’s interest in mind.
ruling requires explanation. According to the halachos of partnership,
there is no concept of majority rule. Rather actions deemed necessary The election must therefore be held again, but those who accepted
can be enforced even if some partners object, but when something is bribes are excluded from the new vote, even if they return the money,
not essential, even a majority cannot necessarily force the minority to because they have already become close to the briber, on par with the
accept its wishes. Thus, if partners disagree about which candidate is high bar that dayanim are held to.
best for the partnership or the best way to build the shul, the majority He adds, even if a majority accepted bribes, the new election will
cannot simply impose its view on the minority. be decided by a minority, even though the result may not reflect
Additionally, why is the cherem necessary? Why can’t someone vote what the majority actually wanted. His reasoning is that there is
no alternative: those who sold their votes
Q &A
have forfeited their voting rights, and the
Double Parked! remaining voters must decide the election.
Rav Eliezer Gordon of Telz (Teshuvos
Q: If a car is double-parked and I This principle also applies when a car
Rav Eliezer, Chelek I, Siman 4) discusses
cannot get through without scratching blocks one’s driveway, one may enter or
a similar case of bribery and strongly
it, may I continue driving? Similarly, if exit his driveway even if doing so causes
disagrees on two points. His first objection
someone repeatedly parks in front of my damage to the obstructing car, provided
concerns the status of the innocent voters
driveway, may I take action to move his there is no other reasonable way to proceed
who supported the same candidate as those
vehicle if it may cause him damage? and the action is solely to remove the
who accepted bribes.
A: One may not damage another person’s obstruction.
Rav Eliezer Gordon argues disqualifying
property, even if the other person wronged Similarly, if someone is double-parked the bribe-takers vote does not change the
him, and one who causes damage is and one urgently needs to proceed, with no fact that the majority’s opinion was in favor
obligated to pay. Therefore, one may not other way to get through, he may continue of Candidate A. Even if the majority’s
damage a car parked in front of his driveway driving even if this will scratch the other candidate cannot be installed because those
merely to teach the owner a lesson. person’s car, provided he is acting solely to voters must be penalized, their opinion
However, there is a halachic principle remove the obstruction. remains the majority opinion.
of — עביד איניש דינא לנפשיהone may take
, סימן ד’ ס”א. שו”ע חו”מ סימן שע”ח ס”ו:מקורות Consequently, even if there was only one
the law into his own hands to protect his
ועיי”ש בנה”מ סק”א. innocent voter who supported Candidate
own rights. This means that when someone
A alongside the bribers, that voter cannot
takes or prevents him from accessing what
be penalized for their wrongdoing. Since
belongs to him, he may take action to Monetary Sha’alos? Please email
his opinion aligns with the majority,
recover or protect his rights, even if doing wallstreethalacha@gmail.com and we will be
he can argue that he is not obligated to
so causes damage to the other person. happy to address them iy”h.
accept Candidate B, whose >page 4
3
Can a Seller Keep The Deposit after a failed deal? But in a to keep the deposit, that would override
regular case Asmachta.
where the money The Rema (Choshen Mishpat 207:15), adds
Rav Boruch Krausz is held in escrow, that it is not necessary to actually appear before
the seller cannot a Beis Din Chashuv in order to make a Kinyan.
In a typical major sale, especially in a real demand that the It is sufficient if the contract itself states that
estate transaction, the buyer gives the seller deposit be paid to him. Furthermore, even if the such a kinyan was made, based on the principle
a substantial deposit when entering into the buyer requested that the money be released from of Hoda’as Ba’al Din, meaning that a person
contract. If the buyer later fails to complete escrow to the seller without realizing that this is believed when he makes a statement that
the purchase, the seller may want to keep the situation is an Asmachta, and the seller already obligates him.
deposit. received the money, he must return it to the buyer. The Rema adds an even broader point:
The halachic question is: is the seller actually This is because it is considered a Mechilah B’ta’us even if the buyer never explicitly instructed
allowed to keep it? (see Choshen Mishpat 207:10), meaning that if the that the contract should state that he made a
buyer had known that halacha does not require kinyan in a Beis Din Chashuv, that may still be
Let’s examine the issue. him to give the money, he would not have given it. sufficient. Since he agreed that a contract would
The Gemara Bava Metzia 66b teaches Tosfos in Bava Metzia 66a writes that be written, and he knows that it is common
“Asmachta lo kanya” — an Asmachta is not Minhag, or common industry practice, can practice for the drafter to include such a clause,
legally binding. In the way the Rambam defines override Asmachta. The Chasam Sofer (Choshen the clause is effective even if the buyer never
Asmachta, and as ruled in Choshen Mishpat 207:2, Mishpat 66) cites Tosfos and adds an important personally read the contract and only the
any monetary commitment a person makes for qualification: this only applies when the minhag witnesses signed it. The Sma 43 appears to
the future, which depends on certain conditions is actually to pay the Asmachta. However, if the disagree with this last point
being met, is not binding. of the Rema, but the minhag
The reason is that when a today is to follow the ruling
person agrees to a future יומא טבא לרבנן of the Rema (Rav Dov Kahan,
financial obligation tied to a Dayan, Beis Din Maysharim,
condition, his mind has not The participants of the daily Oraysa Gemara Shiur given at the Gevurah Shul,
Lakewood).
yet reached the level of Daas extend their heartfelt Mazel Tov to our esteemed Maggid Shiur,
In conclusion, the practical
required for the agreement Reb Dov Ber Zyskind shlit”a, upon the way to override Asmachta is
to be fully binding.
A deposit forfeited if the
Siyum on Maseches Yevamos. for the seller to include in the
contract a clause stating that a
buyer backs out falls into May he be zoche to continue harbatzas Torah and being marbeh b’tzedakah u’chesed kinyan was made in a Beis Din
this category. It is a future for many more years, with continued hatzlacha, simcha and abundant nachas. chashuv with respect to all
loss, and it depends on the With heartfelt appreciation and warmest wishes, obligations in the agreement,
buyer’s failure to complete without needing to consult
The Oraysa Chaburah at the Gevurah Shul
the sale. Therefore, this is the buyer specifically for that
a classic case of Asmachta. wording.
As a result, in a standard For the reader’s convenience, here is the
situation, the seller is not allowed to keep the minhag is merely that people agree to pay, but
exact language that may be added to a contract
deposit once the contract falls through. in practice, when it comes time to forfeit the
in order to make an Asmachta halachically
deposit, people generally fight to avoid paying,
However, an important distinction must be enforceable:
then the halacha of Asmachta still applies.
made. “The parties hereby commit and confess that this
Based on the Chasam Sofer, it is difficult to
The above applies to the common case of establish that the common practice today is agreement was effected and finalized according
a real estate transaction where the money is that the seller is entitled to keep the deposit. to Jewish law by a formal Kinyan Agav Sudar,
held in escrow and has never actually reached Rather, what often happens is that the buyer intended to be effective immediately all in full
the seller’s hands. But if the money was given will raise whatever claim he can in order to accordance with all requisite procedures set out
directly to the seller, there is a Machlokes recover his deposit (Rav Dov Kahan, Dayan, in the code of Jewish law and with use of an object
between the Rambam, as cited by the Mechaber Beis Din Maysharim, Lakewood). valid to effect a kinyan sudar. The Kinyan was
in 207:11, and the Raavad, as cited by the Rema. made in a duly constituted Jewish court of law in
So what is the solution to override Asmachta?
accordance with each of the varying procedures
According to the Rambam, since the The Gemara Nedarim 27b states that required with all of the various Jewish Halachic
buyer knows the money has already reached if a Kinyan Sudar, the act of a Kinyan, is authorities. So that all Jewish Halachic authorities
the seller’s hands and understands that the made before a Beis Din chashuv, it overrides deem the convenance, waiver, and acquisitions
seller can simply keep it if the deal does not Asmachta. The Rosh explains that a Beis Din valid. Without any Asmachta claim of invalidation
go through, the level of Daas is sufficient to chashuv consists of three dayanim who are well and without any other claim of invalidation.”
remove the concern of Asmachta. versed in the laws of Asmachta. Therefore, in
Not sure if your contract is halachicly
the case of a real estate contract, if the buyer
Since this is a dispute among the Poskim, the enforceable? Please send an email to
appears before a Beis Din chashuv and makes
halacha is that the seller can say Kim Li like the wallstreethalacha@gmail.com and one of the
a kinyan obligating himself to allow the seller
Rambam and keep the deposit. Rabbonei haKollel will be able to assist bez”h.
<page 3 selection represents the should simply be returned and the election situation. The Chasam Sofer is willing to
minority opinion. held again, with everyone otherwise qualified let a minority decide the new election rather
to vote allowed to participate.
His second argument concerns the issue of than allow the bribery to succeed, while
closeness to the briber. He does not consider In conclusion, both authorities agree that a Rav Eliezer Gordon refuses to disregard
the mere fact that someone accepted a bribe vote bought with money cannot stand, since
the votes of innocent people and insists on
sufficient to disqualify him from voting again. it abandons the public interest on which
The eligibility bar is not that high for an the authority of majority rule rests. They returning the bribes and allowing everyone
individual voter, According to him, the bribes disagree, however, on how to correct the to participate in the election again.
4
