gilyoines.com Back to the site · חזרה לאתר

Limudei Moshe — Vayetze (2026-11-16)

Publisher: Limudei Moshe

Week: Vayetze (2026-11-16)

Limudei Moshe — Vayetze (2026-11-16)

Open the PDF Download

‫למודי משה‬ S ‫ · פרשת ויצא‬5787 1£ N O U D erp TA G G ISSUE 351 · PARSHAS VAYEITZEI · 3₪ oc I E $· yp N O T S ·2 DE ‫על הפרשה ועניני הזמן‬ HALACHAH · DIVREI TORAH · RIDDLES THIS WEEK'S HALACHIC DISCUSSION What Material Must a Kippah Be Made From? Everyone knows a man should cover his head... but with what? Must it be a black velvet kippah? Can it be crocheted? Leather? Paper? Cardboard? Could a nylon shopping bag count? The answers may surprise you. See inside. ‫לעילוי נשמת מורנו ורבינו‬ ‫הגה"צ רבי עזריאל הלוי ראזענבוים זצ"ל‬ My first maggid shiur in yeshivah, to whom I owe a tremendous debt of gratitude for helping me discover the sweetness and geshmak of learning Gemara. May he be a melitz yosher for Gateshead Yeshiva, the entire Gateshead kehillah, and all of Klal Yisrael. Free to read, not free to produce. Any amount helps. All giving options and dedications are on the back page. Insights Into Halachah What Material Must a Kippah Be Made From? Over the past few weeks, we have discussed the importance of head coverings for Jewish men. We examined the sources and underlying reasons, considered whether covering one's head is an absolute obligation or a middas chasidus, and explored the question of how much of the head must be covered. This week, we turn to a different but equally relevant question: What material should a head covering be made from? The head coverings worn in earlier generations differed significantly from those commonly worn today. In Talmudic times, people generally wore large head coverings, such as the kumta, sudra, sadina, afrakasta, and sayna, as well as other garments that covered the entire head. In later generations, however, observant Jews adopted the custom of wearing the smaller head covering known as a kippah or yarmulke. Today, head coverings are manufactured from a wide variety of materials. This raises the question of whether all such materials serve equally well as valid head coverings and whether they share the same halachic status. Some kippot are made of cloth, others of leather, while many are woven or crocheted, often with substantial openings between the stitches. What does halachah say about such coverings? Similarly, it is necessary to examine the status of paper and cardboard head coverings, as well as nylon coverings such as those frequently provided at the entrances to holy sites for Jews who are not accustomed to observing Torah and mitzvos. Are such ~1~ coverings considered a valid kisui rosh according to halachah? Furthermore, could one fulfil the requirement of head covering by simply placing a nylon bag over his head? These questions, and many others, will be discussed in the following pages. Achaz Covered His Head Before Yeshayahu with a Perforated Washerman's Vessel The Navi relates (Yeshayahu 7:1-3): “And it came to pass in the days of Achaz son of Yosam son of Uziyahu, king of Yehudah, that Retzin king of Aram and Pekach son of Remalyahu, king of Yisrael, went up against Yerushalayim to wage war against it, but he was unable to prevail against it. And it was reported to the House of David, saying: 'Aram has allied itself with Ephraim'; and his heart and the heart of his people trembled as the trees of the forest tremble before the wind. And Hashem said to Yeshayahu: 'Go now toward Achaz, you and She'ar- Yashuv your son, to the end of the conduit of the upper pool, to the road of the Washerman's Field.'” Rashi offers two explanations of the phrase "the Washerman's Field." His first explanation, based on Targum Yonasan ben Uziel, is that it refers to the field where launderers would spread garments out to dry. Rashi then cites a second interpretation from Chazal. According to this explanation, Achaz humbled himself before Yeshayahu and placed upon his head an ochla de-katzrei, a washerman's vessel. This was a perforated utensil used by launderers for sprinkling water onto garments. Understanding the Incident When Pekach ben Remalyahu, king of Yisrael, together with Retzin, king of Aram, advanced against Yerushalayim, HaKadosh Baruch Hu sent Yeshayahu HaNavi and his son, She'ar-Yashuv, to reassure Achaz that he had no reason to fear the invading armies. ~2~ Yeshayahu was therefore instructed to proceed to the conduit of the upper pool, a channel through which water from outside the city walls was brought into a reservoir within Yerushalayim. Nearby was the road leading to the Washerman's Field, where the city's launderers would wash garments using the waters of the pool. Apparently, Achaz had gone there to supervise the water supply and ensure that the city would have sufficient reserves during the anticipated siege. When Yeshayahu and She’ar-Yashuv arrived, Achaz felt ashamed in the presence of the Navi. In an attempt to conceal his identity, he placed upon his head a perforated washerman’s vessel fashioned like a sieve, hoping that Yeshayahu would not recognize him. Regarding this episode, the Gemara states (Sanhedrin 104a): “Why was Achaz not included among those who have no share in the World to Come?” Rabbi Yirmiyah bar Abba answered: “Because he stood between two righteous men, Yosam and Chizkiyahu." Rav Yosef offered a different explanation: “Because he possessed shame before Yeshayahu." The Gemara derives this from the pasuk: “Go now toward Achaz ... to the road of the Washerman's Field.” The Gemara then asks: "What is the significance of the term 'washerman'?" One opinion explains that Achaz concealed his face and slipped by unnoticed. Another opinion explains that he placed upon his head an ochla de-katzrei and passed by. Rashi explains: "Ochla de-katzrei refers to a perforated vessel used by washermen, through which water is sprinkled upon garments. Achaz overturned this vessel onto his head so that Yeshayahu would not recognize him, because he was ashamed before him." Elsewhere, however, Rashi provides a fuller description (Shabbos 123b): ~3~ "Ochla de-katzrei was a copper vessel perforated throughout like a sieve. Washermen would place it upon garments and sprinkle water through it. Others explain that fragrant spices were burned beneath it while garments were placed above it, allowing the fragrance to rise through the perforations." Rabbeinu Nissim Gaon (Shabbos 123b) offers another explanation. According to him, it was a gourd-shaped vessel that was completely perforated and used by washermen to sprinkle water upon garments. This fascinating passage will prove highly relevant to our discussion, for it may provide an important indication as to whether a head covering containing numerous openings can nevertheless be regarded as a valid kisui rosh. Proof from the Episode of Achaz that a Perforated Covering Constitutes a Valid Head Covering The Chasam Sofer (Likkutim, vol. VI, siman 2) was asked about woven hats fashioned in a lattice-like manner, containing numerous openings through which the hair protrudes. The question was whether one may daven while wearing such a covering, or whether it should be regarded halachically as though the head were uncovered. In his Teshuvah, the Chasam Sofer cites the ruling of the Terumas HaDeshen (siman 10), who brings proof for permitting the recitation of Hashem's Name while wearing woven straw hats from the Gemara in Kesubos (72b). The Gemara teaches that although a married woman's obligation to cover her hair has a basis in the Torah, a kalta nevertheless suffices as a valid covering. The Terumas HaDeshen explains that a kalta contains numerous openings and is not completely woven throughout, yet it is still regarded as a legitimate head covering. If so, woven straw hats, whose weave is generally denser and more substantial, should certainly be permitted. ~4~ It would therefore appear that coverings similar to a kalta, despite containing numerous openings, retain the status of a valid head covering. At the conclusion of his Teshuvah, the Chasam Sofer rules that one may recite berachos, mention Hashem's Name, and daven while wearing such woven hats. As additional support, he cites the episode of Achaz, writing: “The primary purpose of covering the head is to demonstrate submission and humility. The pasuk states (Yeshayah 7:3), 'To the road of the Washerman's Field,' and Rashi explains that Chazal expounded that Achaz humbled himself before Yeshayah and placed upon his head an ochla de-katzrei, a perforated vessel used by washermen to sprinkle water upon garments. It therefore appears that placing such an article upon one's head is sufficient to demonstrate humility. True, Rashi in Sanhedrin explains the matter somewhat differently, and that proof may therefore be challenged to a degree. Nevertheless, in my humble opinion, the primary ruling remains that it is permissible to recite Hashem's Name and to daven while wearing a woven cap resting upon the head." The Apparent Contradiction in Rashi Regarding Achaz's Head Covering The Chasam Sofer notes an apparent inconsistency in Rashi’s comments. In his commentary to Yeshayah, Rashi writes: "Our Sages expounded that Achaz humbled himself before Yeshayah and placed upon his head an ochla de-katzrei, a perforated vessel used by washermen for sprinkling water upon garments." From this formulation, it would appear that the very act of placing the vessel upon his head was itself an expression of humility and submission. However, in Sanhedrin (104b), Rashi explains: “Ochla de-katzrei refers to a perforated washerman's vessel through which water was sprinkled upon garments. Achaz overturned this vessel upon his head so that Yeshayah would not recognize him, for he was embarrassed before him.” According to this explanation, Achaz's objective was not to express honor or reverence, but rather to conceal his identity. ~5~ The Chasam Sofer understood these two comments as difficult to reconcile. Rashi in Yeshayah seems to portray the head covering as a display of humility before the Navi, whereas Rashi in Sanhedrin appears to explain that Achaz covered himself merely in order to hide from him. Rav Aryeh Wasserman shlita, in his Otzar HaKippah (vol. I, p. 309), suggests a straightforward resolution. One may ask: Why did Achaz choose specifically a perforated washerman's vessel? If his intention was simply to demonstrate humility, there would seemingly have been far more respectable ways to do so. Conversely, if his goal was merely to hide, why employ such an unusual object? The answer is that, as Rashi explains in Sanhedrin, Achaz wished to avoid being recognized by Yeshayah because he was ashamed before him. At that moment, however, he happened to be standing near the Washerman's Field, where launderers worked and spread garments to dry. Since no more suitable covering was readily available, he seized the washerman's vessel and placed it upon his head in order to conceal himself. Accordingly, when Rashi in Yeshayah states that Achaz "humbled himself" before Yeshayah, he is not describing a formal gesture of honor. Rather, the humility lay in the shame and embarrassment that motivated him to hide. Thus, the two explanations are entirely consistent. In both places, Rashi is describing the same phenomenon: Achaz's sense of humiliation before the Navi. A Difficulty from the Incident of Rabbi Elazar ben Charsom The Margenisa de-Rabbi Meir (Rav Meir Shapiro of Lublin, Berachos 60b) challenges the ruling of the Chasam Sofer. The Yerushalmi (Yoma 3:6) relates that Rabbi Elazar ben Charsom possessed an extraordinarily valuable tunic and ascended to perform the Avodah while wearing it. His fellow Kohanim, however, removed him from service because his body appeared visible through the garment. To demonstrate that the ~6~ garment itself was not defective, he filled it with water and circumambulated the Mizbe'ach seven times. The difficulty is readily apparent. The Chasam Sofer maintains that a head covering containing openings nevertheless retains its status as a valid covering. Yet Rabbi Elazar ben Charsom was prevented from performing the Avodah precisely because his garment contained openings through which the body could be seen. The Yerushalmi would seem to indicate that an article containing substantial openings may lose its halachic status as a covering. The Margenisa de-Rabbi Meir leaves this question unresolved. The Resolution of the Minchas Machavas The Minchas Machavas (vol. I, siman 62, ois 4) resolves the difficulty by drawing a distinction between two fundamentally different halachic categories. In the case of Rabbi Elazar ben Charsom, the issue was one of tznius. Although he was technically clothed, the visibility of the body through the garment detracted from the standard of modesty required of clothing. The garment therefore lacked the degree of tznius necessary for its purpose. A head covering, however, serves an entirely different function. Its primary purpose is not modesty, but rather the cultivation of yiras Shamayim and the recognition that the Divine Presence rests above a person. Consequently, once the head is covered in a meaningful manner, the objective of kisui rosh has been achieved, even if openings remain within the covering. According to this distinction, a perforated head covering may be perfectly valid, notwithstanding the fact that a similarly perforated garment could present a problem in the realm of tznius. This approach provides a compelling defense of the Chasam Sofer's position and supports the view that woven or crocheted kippot, despite containing visible openings, may nevertheless constitute a valid halachic head covering. ~7~ Questioning This Distinction Nevertheless, the distinction proposed by the Minchas Machavas is not entirely straightforward. One of the classic explanations for the obligation of head covering is itself rooted in the concept of modesty. The Sefer HaMenuchah (Hilchos Tefillah 7:4), in his commentary on the berachah of Oter Yisrael BeSifarah, writes: “Covering the head constitutes a person's dignity and modesty.” Similarly, the Malbim (Artzos HaChaim, siman 8, Eretz Yehudah §4) writes that uncovering one's head and exposing normally covered areas of the body stem from a common principle. He notes that the Rambam grouped together the impropriety of exposing one's head and exposing one's body. Accordingly, uncovering the head contains an element of immodesty comparable to exposing other parts of the body that are ordinarily kept covered. If so, the distinction of the Minchas Machavas becomes difficult to sustain. If both areas of halachah are rooted, at least in part, in the concept of tznius, why should a perforated head covering be valid, while a perforated garment may be deficient? The Fundamental Difference Between a Garment and a Head Covering In order to resolve this issue and, more broadly, to understand the halachic status of the various materials from which head coverings are fashioned, it is necessary to establish a fundamental distinction between the halachic definition of a garment and that of a head covering. The Mishnah in Keilim (28:9) teaches: “A garment of a woman who likes to go outdoors (a zonah) fashioned like a lattice-work net is tahor." The Bartenura explains that this garment contained numerous openings, resembling a net through which the flesh remained visible. The Mishnah further states: “One who fashions a garment from a net is tahor.” ~8~ Again, the Bartenura explains that since the body remains visible through the netting, the article does not attain the status of a garment and is therefore tahor. From these sources it emerges that an article fashioned like a net, through which the flesh remains visible, lacks the halachic status of a beged. With this background, we may better appreciate the ruling of the Chasam Sofer. A woven head covering containing substantial openings, and certainly one in which the open areas exceed the woven areas, would seemingly fail to qualify as a garment. Yet the Chasam Sofer nevertheless rules that it remains a valid head covering. How can this be? The answer must be that the laws of kisui rosh do not require the covering to possess the formal halachic status of a beged. Indeed, the Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chaim 91:4) rules that when one person places his hand upon another person's head, this is considered a valid head covering. A human hand, however, certainly does not possess the halachic status of clothing. Evidently, the essence of kisui rosh is not the existence of a garment, but rather the existence of a covering that expresses reverence, humility, and submission before Heaven. By contrast, in areas of halachah that require a bona fide garment, a net-like object through which the flesh remains visible cannot suffice because it lacks the status of a beged. It is true that we noted above that one of the reasons for head covering is modesty. Nevertheless, it appears that the concept of modesty in the context of kisui rosh differs fundamentally from the concept of modesty that governs bodily exposure. The Rambam writes (Hilchos De'os 5:6): “Talmidei Chachamim conduct themselves with exceptional modesty. They do not expose their heads nor their bodies.” ~9~ Likewise, the Rambam writes in Moreh Nevuchim (III:52): “The great sages of our people refrained from uncovering their heads, because the Shechinah hovers over a person and shelters him." We see that although the Rambam associates head covering with modesty, he simultaneously links it to awareness of the Shechinah and the pursuit of kedushah. The modesty reflected in covering the head is therefore not merely a function of concealment, but an outward expression of reverence for the Shechinah. Accordingly, the standards governing bodily concealment and those governing head covering need not be identical. Since the modesty associated with kisui rosh stems from sanctity and awareness of Hashem's Presence, it does not require the same degree of physical coverage demanded by the laws of bodily exposure. This understanding explains why the Chasam Sofer permits a head covering containing substantial openings. Even if such an item would not qualify as a halachic beged, it nevertheless fulfils its essential role as a head covering and serves as a visible expression of humility before Heaven. Summary of the Chasam Sofer's Leniency Regarding Perforated Head Coverings To summarize, the Chasam Sofer rules that a woven head covering fashioned in a lattice-like manner, containing numerous openings through which the hair is visible, may be worn while davening and while reciting berachos. One need not be concerned that such a covering constitutes gilui rosh. The underlying rationale is that the laws of kisui rosh do not require the covering to possess the formal halachic status of a beged. Rather, any article that functions as a genuine covering and serves to express submission before Heaven is regarded as a valid head covering. Nevertheless, the Toras Chaim (Sofer, Orach Chaim 91:2) cites this ruling of the Chasam Sofer and notes that common practice does not fully reflect this leniency. He writes that where straw hats are loosely woven, it is customary ~ 10 ~ to insert an inner lining beneath them. However, he adds that this practice represents a measure of midas chassidus rather than a strict requirement. Head Covering by Means of a Straw Basket Containing Openings The Terumas HaDeshen (siman 10), already cited by the Chasam Sofer, discusses a closely related question. It was commonly claimed that hats woven from straw do not constitute a valid head covering for the purposes of tefillah or the recitation of berachos when they are the sole covering on the head. The question was whether this concern had any basis. The Terumas HaDeshen responds that such a concern appears entirely unfounded. He reports having heard that a prominent authority had once been asked this question and ruled leniently, although no explanation was given for the ruling. The Terumas HaDeshen then provides his own proof. The Gemara in Kesubos (72b) teaches that a woman's biblical obligation of hair covering may be fulfilled with a kalta. Since a kalta resembles a basket and contains numerous openings, we see that an item need not resemble an ordinary textile garment in order to qualify as a valid covering. Certainly, then, a tightly woven straw hat, whose weave is denser and more substantial, should be considered an effective head covering. The Terumas HaDeshen further cites the Gemara in Shabbos (120b), which discusses a case in which Hashem's Name is written on a person's flesh and he must immerse in a mikveh. The Gemara permits him to cover the writing with reeds (gemi), because one may not stand exposed before the Divine Name. From this it is evident that reeds are regarded as a halachically effective covering. If reeds suffice in that context, straw should likewise suffice for purposes of kisui rosh. ~ 11 ~ Accordingly, the Terumas HaDeshen concludes that both reeds and straw constitute valid materials for head covering. Indeed, based upon this ruling, the Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chaim 91:4) explicitly rules that hats woven from straw are considered proper head coverings. The Vilna Gaon (§4) supports this ruling from the Tosefta (Berachos 2:14), which teaches: “If a person finds himself standing naked in a field or while engaged in labor, he may cover himself with straw, reeds, or any similar material and then recite the appropriate passage." The Tosefta explains that although Chazal taught that it is undignified for a person to remain naked, such materials nevertheless constitute valid coverings. If straw is sufficient with respect to covering ervah, it can certainly serve as a valid head covering. The Gra further cites the Gemara in Berachos (24b), where Rav Huna teaches that if one's garment is wrapped around his waist, he may recite Krias Shema. Likewise, cloth, leather, or sackcloth tied around the waist suffices for Krias Shema, though not for tefillah unless the heart is also covered. Once again, we find that a wide variety of materials may function halachically as valid coverings. Head Coverings Made from Various Materials Having established the fundamental principles of kisui rosh, we may now return to the question with which we began: Do all materials used for head coverings possess the same halachic status? Among the common examples are: • Cloth head coverings. • Leather head coverings. • Cardboard or paper head coverings. ~ 12 ~ • Nylon head coverings. Can all of these materials be treated identically, or do some possess a stronger halachic standing than others? This question will form the focus of the next section A Head Covering Made of Leather The Rambam writes (Hilchos Keilim 1:11): “Anything woven, whether from wool, linen, hemp, silk, or other materials that grow from the earth, is termed a beged with respect to the laws of tumah, and felted materials likewise possess the status of garments." The source of this ruling is the Gemara in Shabbos (27a), where the Tanna D'Bei Rabbi Yishmael teaches: “Beged teaches only wool and linen. From where do we derive camel hair, rabbit hair, goat hair, silk, and similar materials? The Torah therefore states: 'or a garment' (o beged).” All of the materials included by this expanded definition originate either from the animal kingdom or from the plant kingdom. Silk, for example, is produced by the silkworm and therefore derives from a living source. Accordingly, one might argue that the Torah's extension of the term beged applies specifically to materials that originate from either animal or plant life. A leather head covering clearly derives from an animal source. Consequently, it certainly possesses the capacity to serve as a valid head covering, even if kisui rosh does not actually require the formal status of a beged. Indeed, the Torah states: “Hashem Elokim made for Adam and for his wife garments of skin and clothed them” (Bereishis 3:21). The Radak, citing Pirkei D'Rabbi Eliezer (Perek 20), explains that these garments were fashioned from the skin of the snake. Hashem removed the snake’s skin and clothed Adam and Chavah with it. Others maintain that the garments were made from the hides of animals. Thus, we find explicit precedent in the Torah for garments made of leather. ~ 13 ~ Moreover, even if leather were not technically classified as a beged, it would unquestionably qualify as a valid head covering. A leather covering creates the sense of dignity, humility, and submission that lies at the heart of kisui rosh. Paper and Cardboard Head Coverings The same would apply to cardboard head coverings. Since cardboard is generally produced from processed wood fibers originating in the plant kingdom, it may certainly serve as a valid head covering. Even if one were to question whether cardboard possesses the formal status of a beged, it nevertheless fulfils the fundamental purpose of head covering by fostering hachna'ah and an awareness of the Divine Presence. A Head Covering Made of Nylon As noted previously, the Gemara in Shabbos (27a) teaches: “Beged - I have only wool and linen. From where do we derive camel hair, rabbit hair, goat hair, silk, kalech, and serikin? The verse therefore states: 'or a garment' (o beged).” All of the materials included through the Torah's expanded definition originate from either the animal kingdom or the plant kingdom. They therefore enter the classical halachic category of a beged. Nylon, however, is manufactured from petroleum, which is a mineral-based substance. Consequently, it would appear not to fall within the classical halachic definition of a beged with respect to the laws of tumah. Nevertheless, as demonstrated above from the ruling of the Chasam Sofer, the laws of kisui rosh do not require that the covering possess the formal halachic status of a beged. Rather, any covering that expresses reverence, humility, and submission before Heaven constitutes a valid kisui rosh. Accordingly, although a nylon head covering may not qualify as a beged for purposes of the laws of tumah, it may certainly serve as a valid head covering. ~ 14 ~ A Head Covering Made from A Plastic Bag There is, however, room to distinguish between a head covering specifically manufactured for this purpose and an ordinary plastic bag placed upon one's head. A nylon kippah is designed and worn as a recognized form of kisui rosh. It functions as a proper head covering and fosters the sense of humility and reverence that underlies the practice. Such a covering may certainly be worn. An ordinary plastic bag, however, may stand on different footing. In such a case, it is generally evident that the object was not placed upon the head as an expression of dignity or reverence. Consequently, if a person finds himself without a proper head covering, it would seem preferable to cover his head with his hand than to place a plastic bag upon it. One might argue that if covering the head with one's hand is effective, then surely a nylon bag should be no less effective. However, this comparison is open to challenge for several reasons: 1. According to the Taz, covering one's head with one's hand serves primarily to remove the appearance of following the practices of the gentiles, but does not necessarily constitute a complete fulfilment of the requirement of kisui rosh. 2. Covering one's head with one's hand does not suffice for tefillah. 3. According to the Bach, the hand is effective only when it covers the head together with the sleeve, thereby creating the semblance of a genuine covering. 4. When a person places his hand upon his head, observers recognize that he is distressed at being without a proper head covering and is attempting, however imperfectly, to preserve the dignity of kisui rosh. By contrast, placing a plastic bag upon one's head generally conveys frivolity rather than reverence. ~ 15 ~ The Underlying Principle of Head Covering What emerges from the foregoing discussion is that the essence of kisui rosh does not depend upon the object possessing the formal halachic status of a garment. Rather, the defining requirement is that it function as a covering that engenders hachna'ah and yiras Shamayim. Accordingly, any covering that is generally perceived as inconsistent with dignity, reverence, and submission before Heaven may perhaps fail to qualify as a proper kisui rosh, even if it technically covers the head. The practical application of this principle may depend upon the stature of the individual, contemporary standards of dignity, and the manner in which the covering is perceived by others. The matter therefore warrants further analysis. Unity Within Diversity The Torah states: “Bilam raised his eyes and saw Yisrael dwelling according to its tribes, and the spirit of G-d came upon him" (Bamidbar 24:2). Rashi explains: “He saw each tribe dwelling separately and not intermixed. He observed that their entrances were not aligned opposite one another, so that one person would not peer into the tent of his fellow.” At first glance, this emphasis on separation appears difficult to reconcile with the ideal of Jewish unity. In truth, however, the opposite is the case. Even at Kriyas Yam Suf, the sea did not split into a single path, but into twelve distinct pathways corresponding to the twelve tribes. Yet this division in no way diminished the unity of the nation. On the contrary, all twelve tribes shared one purpose and one destiny: to serve HaKadosh Baruch Hu and to receive His Torah. The same principle is reflected in the arrangement of the degalim in the wilderness. The Torah states: “Each man by his banner, according to the ~ 16 ~ insignias of his fathers' houses, shall the Children of Yisrael encamp" (Bamidbar 2:2). The meforshim explain that each tribe possessed its own uniquely colored banner, corresponding to the color of its stone in the Choshen. Through these distinctions, every tribe could readily identify its own camp and banner. Yet these differences did not detract from the unity of Klal Yisrael. Diversity of appearance presents no threat to unity when all are united by a common purpose and a shared mission. The same may be said regarding head coverings. Different Jews may wear different styles of kippot. Some may wear cloth coverings, others velvet, leather, crocheted, paper, cardboard, or other varieties. These differences do not create division. So long as they conform to the requirements of halachah, and so long as their purpose is to cultivate genuine yiras Shamayim and the awareness that "the Shechinah rests above my head," they all serve the very same goal. For ultimately, the significance of a kippah lies not in the material from which it is fashioned, but in the message it conveys: that a Jew lives constantly in the presence of Hashem and carries that awareness wherever he goes. Divrei Torah to Enhance Your Shabbos Table The Influence of a Tzadik on His Surroundings ‫ויצא יעקב מבאר שבע וילך חרנה‬ “And Yaakov departed from Be'er Sheva and went toward Charan.” (Bereishis 28:10) Although Parshas Vayeitzei focuses primarily on Yaakov’s years in the house of Lavan, the very first pasuk of the parsha teaches a profound lesson about the influence a great person exerts upon his surroundings. ~ 17 ~ Rashi comments: “And Yaakov departed from Be'er Sheva” - The Torah need only have said, "And Yaakov went to Charan." Why does it emphasize his departure? To teach that the departure of a righteous person from a place leaves an impression. For when the righteous person is in the city, he is its glory, he is its radiance, he is its splendor. When he leaves, its glory departs, its radiance departs, its splendor departs. Similarly, regarding Naomi it says, "And she departed from the place." The Kli Yakar cites a striking question from Bereishis Rabbah: In the case of Naomi, we can understand how the city's splendor departed with her, for there were no other righteous individuals of her stature remaining there. In our case, however, Yitzchak and Rivkah were still living in Be’er Sheva. How, then, can Rashi say that with Yaakov’s departure the city lost its glory, radiance, and splendor? The Medrash answers with a remarkable statement: “The merit of one righteous person is not comparable to the merit of two righteous people.” Maran HaGaon Rabbi Shmuel Rozovsky zt"l, explained this Medrash as follows: The Medrash does not merely mean that two tzaddikim possess more merit than one, as a matter of quantity. The idea is far deeper. For if that were the entire explanation, the wording of Rashi would remain difficult. "Its glory departed, its radiance departed, its splendor departed" implies that all of the city's beauty disappeared with the departure of the tzaddik. Yet this is not literally true, for Yitzchak and Rivkah remained, and certainly continued to bring holiness and blessing to the city. Rather, every tzaddik possesses a unique form of greatness. Each contributes his own distinct radiance, splendor, and spiritual beauty. Just as no two righteous people are identical, so too no two individuals influence their surroundings in exactly the same way. ~ 18 ~ Every tzaddik enriches his environment through his own unique qualities, strengths, and avodah. Together, their combined influence creates the full measure of a city's spiritual glory. When one tzaddik departs, the particular light that only he contributed departs with him. It is only then that people fully appreciate what made him unique and what special dimension he alone added to the community, despite the continued presence of other great individuals. Rav Shmuel added that the same principle applies within every yeshivah. Every ben Torah contributes his own talents, character traits, strengths, and aspirations. Together, these blend into an atmosphere that elevates everyone around him. As long as everyone is together, it is often difficult to discern precisely what each individual contributes. Only when someone leaves does one begin to appreciate the unique role he played and the special contribution he made to the character and spirit of the beis hamedrash. Based on this idea, some explain an apparent contradiction between two statements of Chazal regarding the passing of a Talmid Chacham. The Gemara in Horayos (13a) states: "When a Chacham dies, we have no replacement for him." Yet the Gemara in Yoma (38b) teaches: "A righteous person does not depart from the world until another righteous person like him has already been created." At first glance, these statements seem contradictory. The answer is that although another person of comparable righteousness will indeed arise, for Hashem never leaves a generation without its spiritual leaders, the unique influence of the departed Talmud Chocham can never be duplicated. ~ 19 ~ His particular radiance, his individual style, his personal strengths, and the special impact he had upon his generation are irreplaceable. This is what Chazal meant when they said: "When a Chacham dies, we have no replacement for him." For every individual possesses a unique form of greatness and influence. Once he departs, no one can fully fill the void or reproduce the contribution that belonged exclusively to him. R’ Eliezer Turk shlita relates that a family simcha in his parents’ home Rabbi Shmuel Halevi Wosner zt"l attended, and he overheard him say: "People do not know even a small fraction of the tremendous love and closeness that I merited from Chazon Ish. There existed between us such a deep emotional bond that once, when I needed to leave the city one evening, the Chazon Ish said to me the next day: 'I felt that you were not in our city last night...'" Such is the influence of a great individual. His presence is felt. His absence is felt. Every person possesses a unique light that no one else can provide in exactly the same way. When There Is Achdus, There Is Room for Everyone ‫ וישם מראשותיו וישכב‬,‫ ויקח מאבני המקום‬,‫ וילן שם כי בא השמש‬,‫ויפגע במקום‬ .‫במקום ההוא‬ “And he encountered the place and spent the night there because the sun had set. He took from the stones of the place, placed them around his head, and lay down in that place.” (Bereishis 28:11) Rashi explains that Yaakov arranged the stones around his head as a protective barrier against wild animals. The stones began arguing with one another. Each one claimed: “Upon me the tzaddik should rest his head!” ~ 20 ~ Immediately, Hakadosh Baruch Hu merged them into a single stone. This is why the Torah later states: “And he took the stone that he had placed beneath his head.” The Sifsei Chachamim explains that Rashi is resolving an apparent contradiction. Initially the Torah speaks of “stones” in the plural, implying that there were many stones. Later it refers to “the stone”, implying there was only one. Chazal therefore teach that the stones quarreled and were subsequently fused into a single stone. Upon reflection, there is a fascinating lesson here. As long as the stones were separate, each one argued that the tzaddik should rest his head upon it. Yet the moment they became a single stone, the dispute vanished. At first glance, this is difficult to understand. Even after becoming one stone, each side could still have argued: “Let the tzaddik rest his head on my side!” Yet no such argument occurred. Every part of the stone accepted that if the tzaddik's head rested elsewhere, that was perfectly fine. Why? The explanation, cited in the name of Rabbi Shimon of Vorka and others, is profound. Conflict can exist only where there is separation. When each individual thinks solely about himself, disputes naturally arise. Each person seeks his own honor and recognition. But when people become truly united, the entire dynamic changes. A united person does not ask, “What do I gain?” Rather, he asks, “What is best for the other person?” In a state of genuine unity there is no room for jealousy, competition, or resentment. ~ 21 ~ Thus, while the stones were separate, each demanded the privilege of supporting the tzaddik. Once they became one, they no longer viewed themselves as separate entities. Their interests became one and the same, and the argument disappeared. From here we learn a powerful lesson: When there is achdus, there is room for everyone. The Shechinah Dwells Where There Is Unity The Ramchal writes in Sefer HaMa'amarim that Hashem, Who is One, rests His Divine Presence only in a place of unity. As we declare in our tefillos: “You are One, Your Name is One, and who is like Your people Yisrael, one nation on earth.” The Shechinah dwells where Jews are united as one. Achdus Reflected in Halachah Rav Ben Zion Felman zt"l points out that this concept finds expression not only in aggadah, but even in halachah. The Sha'arei Teshuvah (O.C. 42), citing the Eliyah Rabbah, discusses a case in which the strap of the hand tefillin tears near the knot. One may reverse the strap and create a new knot from what had previously been the lower end. Why is this not considered lowering an object from a higher level of kedushah to a lower one? The answer is that the entire strap is viewed as one unit. Since it is all connected, there is no essential distinction between one section and another. The Eliyah Rabbah finds support for this from Yaakov's stones. Once all the stones became a single stone, it no longer mattered which specific section supported the tzaddik's head. Everything was part of one unified entity. When something is truly one, every part shares equally in its significance. ~ 22 ~ The Power of Unified Prayer The Rebbe of Ozherov zt"l writes a remarkable insight in his Haggadah Shel Pesach Esh Das. Before approaching Achashveirosh, Esther instructed Mordechai: “Go gather all the Jews.” Only afterward did she say: “And thus I shall come before the king.” Chazal teach that whenever the Megillah refers simply to "the king," it can allude not only to Achashveirosh but also to the King of Kings. The Ozherover Rebbe explains that Esther's confidence stemmed from the unity of Klal Yisrael. When the Jewish people stood united, she could appear before the Ribbono Shel Olam with confidence and plead for mercy even on behalf of those who were less deserving. Unity gave her the boldness to say: “And thus I shall come before the King.” We see something extraordinary from this. When there is achdus among Klal Yisrael, one can approach Heaven with unusual confidence that the tefillah will be accepted. Achdus Changes Reality Rav Ben Zion Felman zt"l would add an even deeper point. When people genuinely care for one another, not only do hearts expand, but reality itself seems to change. Unity creates space. Physically. Emotionally. Spiritually. When every person makes room for his fellow Jew, there is suddenly enough room for everyone. ~ 23 ~ Incredible Story Illustrating How Unity Expands Space Rabbi Ben Zion Felman zt"l related a remarkable story that powerfully illustrates the extraordinary power of achdus. Adjacent to the Heichal HaTalmud kollel in Tel Aviv stood a courthouse. One afternoon, as the avreichim were leaving the kollel, they noticed a bus parked outside with a police officer standing beside it. The officer approached them and asked if they would do him a favor by boarding the bus for a few minutes. The avreichim agreed. First, they filled all the seats. Then the officer asked them to continue boarding and stand in the aisles. More and more people crowded onto the bus until it appeared absolutely full. There seemed to be no room whatsoever for another passenger. The officer then counted everyone carefully and, once he finished, told them they were free to leave. Curious about what had just transpired, the avreichim asked the driver for an explanation. The driver revealed that a court case concerning him was currently underway. A police officer had issued him a substantial fine, claiming that he had transported eighty passengers on a bus licensed to carry only sixty-five people, including standing passengers. The driver appealed the fine, insisting that such a thing was physically impossible. Since the bus could only accommodate sixty-five people, he argued, the officer's claim had to be mistaken. The judge therefore ordered a practical test. People would board the bus until it reached maximum capacity, after which they would be counted. The result? Only sixty-five people fit onto the bus. ~ 24 ~ Satisfied that the driver's claim was correct, the judge dismissed the case and voided the fine. A short while later, however, the driver quietly confessed to the avreichim: “The truth is that I really did have eighty people on the bus that day.” They stared at him in disbelief. “But how is that possible?” The driver smiled and answered: “That trip was after a family simcha. Somehow, when people are coming back from a simcha, you can fit eighty people onto a bus.” The driver likely did not realize how profound his words were. The real explanation is that after a wedding or family celebration, people's hearts are united. Everyone has gathered for a common purpose: to share in the joy of the chosson and kallah. That atmosphere creates genuine togetherness. When such people board a crowded bus, no one is focused solely on himself. Each person instinctively makes room for the other. Everyone shifts a little, squeezes a little, and sacrifices a bit of personal comfort so that someone else will not be left outside. And suddenly, what seemed impossible becomes possible. A bus that ordinarily holds sixty-five somehow accommodates eighty. Rabbi Felman noted that this principle is explicit in the Gemara (Sanhedrin 7a). Chazal teach that when there is love between husband and wife, even a tiny dwelling is sufficient, and they feel no lack. Yet when there is discord, even a spacious home measuring sixty amos feels cramped and uncomfortable. The dimensions of the house have not changed. ~ 25 ~ The people have. When there is harmony, there is room. When there is selfishness, there is never enough room. This is the deeper meaning of the stones beneath Yaakov's head. As long as each stone stood alone, there was argument and competition. Once they became one, the dispute vanished completely. So too in life. When each person is occupied only with his own needs, conflicts are inevitable. But when people unite and think about one another, barriers disappear, tensions dissolve, and there is suddenly room for everyone. The lesson is clear: The more we strengthen achdus, the more we merit the Shechinah dwelling among us. The more we strengthen achdus, the more our tefillos are accepted. And the more we strengthen achdus, the more we discover that reality itself changes for the better. For when there is true unity, not only do hearts expand. Somehow, miraculously, the space expands as well. If a Person Doesn't Learn Mussar, He Remains the Same ‫ויהי כשמע לבן את שמע יעקב בן אחתו וירץ לקראתו ויחבק לו וינשק לו‬ .‫ויביאהו אל ביתו‬ “And it came to pass, when Lavan heard the report about Yaakov, his sister's son, that he ran toward him, embraced him, kissed him, and brought him into his house” (Bereishis 29:13). ~ 26 ~ Rashi explains that Lavan ran to greet Yaakov because he assumed he was carrying wealth. After all, when Eliezer, Avraham's servant, arrived years earlier, he came with ten camels laden with riches. When Lavan saw that Yaakov had nothing with him, he thought perhaps gold was hidden in his clothing, so he embraced him. When he found nothing, he suspected that precious gems might be concealed in his mouth, and therefore he kissed him. How did Chazal know that this was Lavan’s motive? The answer lies in an earlier episode. When Eliezer arrived, the Torah explicitly records: “And it came to pass when he saw the nose-ring and the bracelets on his sister's hands...” (Bereishis 24:30). There the Torah clearly reveals that Lavan's enthusiasm was sparked by wealth. Chazal therefore understood that the same motivation was at work when Yaakov arrived. Rav Gedaliah Eiseman asks a penetrating question. Nearly a century had passed between these two events. Why can we not assume that this time Lavan ran because Yaakov was his beloved nephew? Perhaps he embraced and kissed him out of genuine affection for the son of his sister, whom he had not seen for many years. Why attribute the same selfish motive to him? The answer is both simple and profound. People do not change on their own. In Rav Gedaliah's words: “If a person does not learn mussar, he remains the same. He does not change by himself, even after ninety-seven years." People often imagine that simply growing older will make them wiser, more patient, kinder, or more refined. But age alone accomplishes none of those things. A person does not improve automatically. ~ 27 ~ If he does not work on himself, examine his character, and actively strive to grow, he will remain fundamentally the same person year after year. The calendar may change, his hair may turn gray, but his middos will remain untouched. That is the reality of human nature. True growth requires effort. True change requires introspection. True greatness requires mussar. Lavan’s behavior teaches a timeless lesson: the passage of time does not transform a person. Only the willingness to transform oneself can do that. Without deliberate growth, ninety-seven years later one can still be chasing the very same pursuits and driven by the very same motivations. The lesson for us is clear. We should never assume that tomorrow we will automatically become better than we are today. Growth is a choice. Growth is work. And if a person does not learn mussar and actively refine himself, he remains exactly where he began. Appreciating the Small Things in Life Feet - Our two perfectly matched feet enable us to stand upright, maintain our balance, and walk with ease. We use them thousands of times each day, yet rarely stop to appreciate the remarkable gift they are. The Mishnah teaches, “Who is rich (ashir)? One who is happy with his lot” (Avos 4:1). Rabbi Avigdor Miller zt"l pointed out that the word ashir can be viewed as an acronym for the priceless gifts we possess: einayim (eyes), shinayim (teeth), yadayim (hands), and raglayim (feet). True wealth is not measured by what we own, but by our ability to recognise and appreciate the countless gifts that Hashem has already given us. One who values these extraordinary blessings is truly rich. Based on Gifts from Hashem, pg. 34. ~ 28 ~ Pninim U'Peliyos on the Weekly Parsha Questions (For the answers see below) 1) In this week's parsha (Bereishis 28:20), Yaakov Avinu davens that Hashem should protect him and provide him "with bread to eat and clothing to wear." Why does he not also request "water to drink"? 2) In this week's parsha, Yaakov Avinu promises that if he returns home safely, "Of all that You give me, I will surely tithe to You" (Bereishis 28:22). The Da'as Zekeinim, citing a Medrash, learns from here that Yaakov instituted the practice of giving ma'aser kesafim. If money was stolen from a person and later recovered, must ma'aser be separated from those funds a second time? 3) In this week's parsha, we learn that when Yaakov arrived at the well, "there was a large stone upon the mouth of the well" (Bereishis 29:2). The obvious question is: Why did the shepherds place such a large and heavy stone over the well? 4) The Torah tells us (29:10) that when Yaakov saw Rachel approaching, he single-handedly rolled the massive stone off the mouth of the well. Yet the Torah never explicitly states that he replaced it afterwards. Did Yaakov leave the well uncovered, or did he return the stone to its place? 5) A part of the body mentioned in Parshas Vayeitzei is immortal. Which part is it, why is it immortal, and where in the body is it located? 6) Which three “dead” people in Parshas Vayeitzei were really alive? ~ 29 ~ Answers (For the questions see above) 1) i) At first glance, one might answer simply that the request for "bread to eat" includes a general request for sustenance, encompassing both food and drink, the essentials necessary for human survival. However, as we shall see, several fascinating explanations have been offered. ii) The Radak writes: “He did not ask for abundance, but only for his basic needs in order to live. As for water, there was no need to request it, because wherever a person goes, he can generally find water to drink without charge." According to the Radak, water was considered readily available and therefore did not require a special tefillah. iii) A remarkable teaching appears in Pirkei D'Rabbi Eliezer (Chapter 35): "Rabbi Akiva said: Wherever our forefathers travelled, the well travelled before them. Yaakov was seventy-seven years old when he left his father's home, and the well accompanied him from Be'er Sheva until Har HaMoriah." Some explain that this miraculous well accompanied the Avos for two purposes: 1. To provide for their physical needs. 2. To enable them to purify themselves whenever necessary. Accordingly, water was constantly available to Yaakov Avinu, and there was therefore no need for a special request that he be provided with water to drink. iv) Perhaps a fourth answer may be suggested based on a remarkable comment of the Netziv in Ha'amek Davar (Bamidbar 20:5). In Parshas Chukas, when Bnei Yisrael complained about the lack of water, the Netziv asks: Why was it necessary for the people to inform Moshe and Aharon of the problem? Surely they themselves knew that there was no water. The Netziv explains that the spiritual leaders of the generation, whose focus is not on the physical needs of the body, are granted a special measure of Divine Providence whereby they do not experience thirst. This is not an overt miracle ~ 30 ~ but a hidden form of Heavenly supervision bestowed upon those who fear Hashem. (See also the Netziv's comments in Shemos 15:22.) From the Netziv's words, it emerges that exceptionally righteous individuals may be granted a unique providential protection whereby they do not even feel thirst. Accordingly, it is possible that Yaakov Avinu himself did not experience thirst in the ordinary sense. Since he did not feel a need for water, he did not specifically daven for it. Instead, he requested only those necessities that required a special tefillah. 2) The Sefer Chassidim (siman 144) writes: “Great is the mitzvah of giving ma'aser... A person should give a tenth of all profits that come to him, whether through interest, employment earnings, or any other gain that comes into his possession. If he finds a lost object or recovers stolen property, he should separate ma'aser from it.” Rabbi Reuven Margoliyos, in his commentary Mekor Chessed, explains that the Sefer Chassidim is referring to a case where the owner had already experienced yei'ush and abandoned hope of recovering the stolen property. Once the money is recovered after yei'ush, its return is considered a new gain and is therefore subject to ma'aser. In Vayishma Moshe (Vol. II, pg. 234), Rav Moshe Fried shlita records an interesting question that was posed to Maran Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv zt"l. A man had approximately one million dollars stolen from him. Several days later, the thief was apprehended and the money was recovered. The question was whether the owner was obligated to separate ma'aser again from the recovered funds. After all, the money had left his possession and had now effectively come to him anew. Rav Elyashiv ruled that no additional ma'aser is required, since these funds had already been tithed previously. ~ 31 ~ This ruling, however, applies only when the owner had not despaired of recovering the money. In such a case, the funds never truly left his halachic ownership, and their return is not considered new income. If, however, the owner had already experienced yei'ush, the situation is different. Once yei'ush occurred, the money is viewed as having effectively left his possession. Consequently, when it is later recovered, it is treated as newly acquired funds and is once again subject to ma'aser. This ruling is also cited in Shu"t Tzitz Eliezer (Vol. VI, siman 27). Practical Conclusion: If stolen money is recovered before the owner has experienced halachic yei'ush, no second ma'aser is required. If the owner had already given up hope of recovery and subsequently regained the funds, they are considered a new acquisition and should be tithed again. 3) i) The Rashbam explains that the well was covered to prevent people from falling into it and also to stop unauthorized individuals from drawing water. The Chizkuni offers the same explanation and adds that the stone also protected against buckets and other vessels accidentally falling into the well. ii) Rav Aharon Leib Steinman zt"l, in Ayalas HaShachar, cites the Rashbam and suggests an additional reason. The stone helped preserve the purity of the water and protected the well from snakes or other harmful creatures that might enter it. iii) The Netziv writes in Ha'amek Davar that the shepherds covered the well to prevent people from casting spells or performing acts of sorcery upon the water, practices that were common in those times. iv) Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch offers a fascinating social insight. Ordinarily, a public well would have been covered with a light cover so that anyone could access it easily. The unusually large stone reflected a lack of mutual trust among the local shepherds. Each feared that others might take more than their fair share of the communal water supply. ~ 32 ~ Therefore, the cover was made so heavy that it could only be removed when all the shepherds were gathered together. In this way, everyone could supervise the distribution of the water and ensure that no one abused the shared resource. According to Rav Hirsch, the massive stone was not merely a practical safeguard but a reflection of the social realities of the time. 4) Rav Avraham Yitzchak Sorotzkin shlita, Rosh Yeshivah of Telz in America, discusses this question and suggests that the answer may depend upon the two explanations offered by the Rashbam. If the stone was primarily intended to prevent people or objects from falling into the well, then once Yaakov removed it he would bear responsibility for the resulting hazard. Halachically, he would assume the status of a ba'al habor (one responsible for an open pit) and would be obligated to cover the well. According to this approach, we may reasonably assume that he replaced the stone, even though the Torah does not mention it explicitly. However, if the stone's primary function was merely to prevent unauthorized use of the water, the matter is less clear. In that case, Rachel herself would not ordinarily have been responsible for replacing the heavy stone. That task belonged to the shepherds. Returning the stone would therefore not have been a favor to Rachel but rather a benefit to the local shepherds. Accordingly, it is possible that Yaakov did not replace the stone immediately, since doing so would have primarily benefited the shepherds rather than Rachel. Rav Sorotzkin suggests that this may have raised the concern of lo sechanem, granting an unnecessary benefit to the local idolaters. Thus, whether Yaakov returned the stone may depend on the very purpose for which it had been placed there in the first place. 5) After Yaakov awoke from his dream, he named the place Beis El, but the Torah records (28:19) that the original name of the city was Luz. The Rokeach ~ 33 ~ writes that when a person dies and decomposes, his Luz bone always remains intact, and this bone will enable him to be resurrected when Moshiach comes. The Shibbolei HaLeket (130 quoted in Beis Yosef Orach Chaim 300) writes that this bone only receives sustenance from food eaten on Motzei Shabbos, which underscores the importance of eating Melaveh Malka each week. Accordingly, the Eliyahu Rabbah (Orach Chaim 300:3), explains that when Adam ate from the forbidden fruit on Erev Shabbos, his Luz bone got no pleasure from it, and it was therefore exempted from the curse of death that he received. Rashi and the Aruch both write that the Luz bone is found at the bottom of the spine, while the Arizal maintains that it is located in the area where tefillin is placed on the head. 6) The Gemara (Nedarim 64b) teaches that four groups of people are considered as if they are dead: a pauper, a metzora, a blind person, and someone who does not have any children. Parshas Vayeitzei contains examples of three of the four categories. Rashi says that Eisav commanded his son Elifaz to chase the fleeing Yaakov and kill him. Elifaz was hesitant to do so, so he instead took all of Yaakov’s possessions. Since a poor person is considered like he is dead, this was deemed a fulfillment of his father’s instructions to kill Yaakov. Rashi later writes that although Hashem does not associate His name with the living, no matter how righteous they are, He did use the expression “Elokei Yitzchak” – “G-d of Yitzchak” (28:13) while Yitzchak was still alive because he was blind, and a blind person is considered as if he is dead. Rochel begged Yaakov to give her children and said that without kids, she was like a dead person (30:1). (Parsha Challenge) ~ 34 ~ Please notifyPlease us when notify us you donate when you sothat donate so that wetrack we can canthetrack donationthe donation Sponsorships, dedications and questions: admin@limudaymoshe.com · +972 52-234-1957 Past issues: www.limudaymoshe.com