Lehisvada - English — Vayetze (2026-11-16)

Sanhedrin Daf 95
Aggadic Teachings
Efshar she’avarti al makon she’hispallelu avoisai
, אבישי בן צרויה הא דאמרן. ואבישי בן צרויה, ויעקב אבינו, אליעזר עבד אברהם, שלשה קפצה להם הארץ, תנו רבנן.בסנהדרין דף צ"ה
, ויצא יעקב מבאר שבע וילך חרנה, דכתיב, יעקב אבינו. למימרא דההוא יומא נפק, דכתיב ואבוא היום אל העין,אליעזר עבד אברהם
בעי, אפשר עברתי על מקום שהתפללו בו אבותי ואני לא התפללתי בו, כי מטא לחרן אמר,וכתיב ויפגע במקום וילן שם כי בא השמש
מיד ויפגע במקום, קפצה ליה ארעא, כיון דהרהר בדעתיה למיהדר,למיהדר
-א-
Why didn’t Yakov daven the first time he passed by Har Ha’Moriah
The first time he passed by kefitzas haderech and did not supernaturally fast, when he passed by the place
realize that this place was Har Ha’Moriah / Before reaching where his forefathers had davened, he was unaware
Charan he was afraid of Esav and was too unsettled to have that he was there. That’s why he later wanted to
davened properly / He did not see it as appropriate to daven return.
while passing by incidentally while on his way to Haran /
This was orchestrated from Above as a lesson for future However, the Maharal there offers another expla-
generations to show the importance of sincere regret for nation, even if we assume that Yacov did not get to
not having davened properly. Charan by kefitzat haderech. He writes that Yakov
ערוגת הבושם, חידושי הרי"ם,מהר"ל מפראג did not daven on his way to Charan because he was
Many ask: Why indeed didn’t Yakov Aveenu daven afraid that Esav might still be chasing him. Due to
the first time he passed by the place where his fore- his fear, he would be unable to focus properly on his
fathers had davened? Why did he only regret it later, davening. But once he arrived in Charan, he thought
when he reached Charan, saying, “Could it be that that Esav would no longer be pursuing him, because
I passed by the place where my forefathers davened, he knew that he had already arrived in Charan. That’s
and I did not daven there?” And only then did he why he then wanted to return to the place where his
experience kefitzas haderech (miraculous contraction forefathers had davened. (See the Re’em there, who
of the road), bringing him back to the place where his writes that there are different opinions in the Mid-
forefathers davened. Several explanations have been rash whether Yakov’s trip to Charan was by kefitzas
given for this. haderech or not.)
The Maharal1 explains, based on a Midrash2 that In Likutei HaRim3 another reason is given. Yakov
states that Yakov’s trip to Charan took only one day, did not want to daven at a holy place simply because
as he experienced kefitzas haderech. Since he traveled he happened to be passing by. Kedushah requires
פרשת השבוע 1
Sanhedrin Daf 95
Aggadic
Shabbos Teachings
Daf Lamed Ches
proper preparation, and he did not want his tefillah to He explains that this entire sequence was orches-
L’halacha the Rishonim disagree concerning whether we pasken On the other hand, the Biur HaGra there goes to great lengths and
be an incidental benefit of his trip to Charan. Instead, trated from Above as a sign for future generations.
like Rebbi Meir or Rebbi Yehudah. The Rif 9 asserts that the halacha concludes like Rebbi Meir. The Mishna Berurah 18 cites this opinion
he traveled
follows onward
Rebbi Yehudah, andwithout
the Ran 10stopping. However,
explains his reasoningonce
to be Hashem
of orchestrated
the Gra and for Yakov
how he follows to passofbyTosafos
in the footsteps withoutand his
he had
because Rav passed
publiclyby withoutasdavening,
darshened such. Thishebeing
madethea special
case the davening,who
colleagues then regretlike
all pasken it, Rebbi
and Meir
thenthatcome
even back byit is
b’mayzid
follows suit. Theatsame is raised only assur to eat from food cooked on Shabbos until Motzei Shabbos.
halacha
effort to return, which pointbyheboth the kefitzas
had Rambam 11 and
had- kefitzas haderech, to serve as a lesson for the Jewish
Ramban as well. Additionally, the Beis Yosef writes that the
12 13 This applies even to the one who cooked it, and b’shogeig everyone
wordserech to Rosh
of the come back.toAnd
14 seem he concludes
lean this way too. that this is an people
can - Maasei
partake avosimmediately
from the food siman l’banim: If there
on Shabbos itself.will be
The Mishna
important lesson for everyone. See notes [1] times when
Berurah asserts they
that inshould need davened
a time ofhave but failed
one is allowed to this
to rely on
On the other hand, Tosafos in Chullin 15 asserts that the halacha where the food was cooked b’shogeig.
follow Rebbi Meir, and his reasoned is because this question:
is how Rav do so properly, their sincere regret can still bring
The Arugas Habosem 4
also raises this Thethe
implication of his words is that it is specifically with regards
instructed his students. Additionally, the Beis Yosef 16 brings this back spiritual light and power of that lost tefil-
Why
b’shem bothdidn’t Yakov
the Smag and Sefer to daven the
stopHaTerumah first time, and
as well. to shogeig that one can rely on Tosafos to pasken like Rebbi Meir.
lah. He continues further: If, after the sacred days of
On the other hand, b’mayzid on wouldn’t be allowed to rely on Rebbi
why did he later regret it? Furthermore, why did his
The Shulchan Aruch 17 determines like the opinions of the Rif, the month
Meir’s opinionof Tishrei,
allowing theacook
person realizes
to partake fromthat theyondid
the food Motzei
decision
Rambam, to return
and Rosh to paskencause HarYehudah
like Rebbi HaMoriah
(as weto miracu-
have already Shabbos. With regard to a mayzid we must act stringently like Rebbi
not daven properly, as called for in these holy days,
lously come toward him? Why couldn’t he simply Yehudah who holds that the food is perpetually assur.
mentioned).
they might feel that the opportunity is lost since
walk back on his own?
- ב-those special days have passed. However, this is not
Maiseh Shabbos with regard to a Melacha where nothing is done to the object itself
Notes
Where one was motzi something from one reshus to the speaking, the issur of Maiseh Shabbos is not something specific to
Hashem
other, orchestrated
if such a thing isYakov’s
assurtrip to Charan
because of by kefitzatShabbos
Maiseh haderech/ kefitzascreating
Bishul haderechan upon
issur leaving
for one Be’er
to eatSheva, arrivingoninShabbos.
food cooked Charan On
so that he wouldSpecifics
not stop toindaven
this inyan
at Har Ha’Moriah because the
instantly. As a result, when Yakov passed by Har Ha’Moriah, he any
contrary, it applies to any Melacha. If someone transgresses
according to-Yakov’s of thecompletely
was unawareitofisit,then
Melachos Shabbos forbidden
because for already
he was him to benefit
in Cha-from
רבנו יונהgreat
,'תוסkedushah, it was,טורfitting
, חיי אדם,רמ"א - for him to go
what he did. Additionally, in the Shulchan Aruch 19 the Mechaber
ran as soon as he left Be’er Sheva.
[ ]בAlthough both our Mishna and Gemara only rather
to Har Ha’Moriah with preparation and intent, than just
make reference to brings this concept of not being able to eat what one cooked on
passing byitand
cooking on Shabbos, daveningmade
is already thereknown
incidentally.
from the Tur that This explains
Shabbos, and the why RemaYakov
addssaid,
that “’Efshar’ she’avarti altomakon
this is applicable the other
this concept of Maiseh Shabbos doesn’t
מים חיים בארdifferentiate. Practically she’hispallelu
Melachos as well.
avoisai,
– “‘Could it be’ that I passed by the place
where my forefathers davened?” There are two types of kefitzas
[1] The Be’er Mayim Chaim also raises the question: WhyNOTEShaderech: One occurs when the land in the middle is broken
didn’t Yakov initially think to daven when he passed by Har
off, bringing two distant locations together. The other happens
Ha’Moriah,
If a Maiseh Shabbosand why did heb’hana’ah
is assur later regret
/ Two it?aspects
He also to notes
Maisehthe concerning where one toivels vessels on Shabbos. We say there that if done b’shogeig
Shabbos, and the difference between Mevashel and other Melachos / when
he a person’s
may use them, andsteps miraculously
b’mayzid not. As such, itlengthen,
is clear thatallowing themShabbos
the issur Maiseh to
unusual wording of Yakov: “Efshar she’avarti al makon she’his-
Something cooked on Shabbos is given similar status to other traveleven
applies greatto distances quickly.
benefit through something’s usage, and not just an issur achilah.
pallelu avoisai
forbidden foods /–Where
“Could oneit cooked
be thatwater
I passed
and itbygot thecold
place
againwhere
/
Where one cooked
my forefathers water for
davened?” Whywashing
did he anduseit got
thecold again term
uncertain Yakov’s
On regret
the other for not davening
hand, concerning Bishul there there would element.
is an additional only makeWhen one
cooks on Shabbos the meat gets a din of basar tereifah
sense if his kefitzas haderech was by the lengthening of his m’drabbanan. As such, it
- שו"ת מנחת שלמה-
efshar (could it be) instead of simply saying in a straightforward becomes assur for consumption just like all other forbidden foods. Because of this
[1] The Minchas Shlomo 31 comments on this that the Tur writes how the din Maiseh steps, because he had physically passed through Har Ha’Mo-
the Magen Avraham 34 asserts that even the pot it was cooked in becomes assur as
manner, “Hinei avarti - “I have passed by”? Additionally, why
Shabbos applies to all Melachos making it assur to benefit from the act performed. riahOne
well. without realizing
then needs it. However,
to do hagalah hisitkefitzas
on the potif and haderech
is necessary even if awas
24 hour
didn’t
He points outHashem cause
that according thethe
to this sunissur
to Maiseh
set early while
Shabbos Yakov
isn’t was at
specifically an
period passes
by the landmaking
in theit no longer abeing
middle Ben Yomo. Although
removed, therehe
then would
hadhave logically
never
issur Har Ha’Moriah the first time, rather than only doing so difficult
achilah (eating) but also an issur ha’na’ah (benfit). However, this is when been room to say that after 24 hours the pot should only give off negative tastes
to understand. In Bava Kama 32 we see that even Rebbi Yochanan Hasandler who truly passed through there at all, and there would be no reason
through which one doesn’t benefit, nevertheless we see clearly that the Chachamim
he later returned? Furthermore, why, when Yakov was return-
holds Maiseh Shabbos is assur min hatorah, nevertheless this is only an issur achilah for regret.
made Therefore,
the issur he expressed
Maiseh Shabbos uncertainty:
by Bishul comparable to all“Efshar - Couldfoods.
other forbidden
inganfrom
and not issur Charan, didithe
ha’na’ah, and have to travel
is something allfrom
learnt out thepesukim.
way to Now,Bais ifEil?
this
is true (that the issur is only an issur achilah and not an issur ha’na’ah) for Rebbi
it be that I passed by?” He was unsure whether his journey not
The same way by other issurim the pot is also assur for use even when hada Ben
Why didn’t Har Ha’Moriah move to him in Charan, just as it Yomo, so too this follows for Maiseh Shabbos as well.
Yochanan Hasandler who holds that Maiseh Shabbos is assur min hatorah, then it truly taken him over that place.
did later when he set out to return?
must certainly should be the case for both Rebbi Meir and Rebbi Yehuda who hold With this in mind we can now explain what is said in Bava Kama that even
Therefore, when he later regretted not having davened at
the issur The
is merely m’drabbanan.
Be’er Mayim Chaim As such,explains
it is difficult
thatto Yakov
understand how wecer-
Aveenu can according to Rebbi Yochanan Hasandler the issur is only an issur achilah and not an
say it is assur to benefit from all types of Maiseh Shabbos. Har Ha’Moriah
issur ha’na’ah. Whatand
this decided
means to sayto return, Hashem
is that although did not
the food get theimme-
status of a
tainly intended to daven when passing through Har Ha’Moriah, diatelyassur,
maichal movenevertheless
the mountain this onlytomakes
him itbecause
forbidden Hashem wanted
for consumption and not
To answer he asserts that in truth there are two forms of the issur Maiseh
knowing it was a place of prayer for his forefathers. However, benefit.
him toItgodoesn’t
therebecome like Arlah,
intentionally, forKlayim, or Hekdesh
the purpose where benefit
of davening there. is also
Shabbos. Therefore, although by all the Melachos one does on Shabbos there is an
forbidden. However, this is said specifically with regard to benefit that one could
issur Hashem orchestrated
to benefit from eventsthisdifferently.
them, nevertheless doesn’t pose Due to Yakov’s
a contradiction great
to what the However, once he reached Bais Eil and Hashem saw his sincere
have enjoyed even before the Maiseh was performed. This is because it isn’t caused
Gemarakedushah, it would
in Bava Kama says have beenhow
concerning somewhat improper
a Maiseh Shabbos for assur
is only him tofor
intent
by by making
the forbidden Melachathesucheffort to travel
as where toward
one benefits Hargiving
through Ha’Moriah,
the food to his
consumption and not benefit. We will now bring a brief account of his words.
stop and daven at Har Ha’Moriah merely incidentally, as an friend
Hashem considered it as if he had already traveled the done
as a gift, or to his animal to eat. As long as these things are in a way
full dis-
The first thing to know is that by all Melachos Shabbos whenever the Melacha where one doesn’t benefit from the Bishul itself, we then say that although the
aside of his trip to Charan, which was primarily for the pur- tance. At that point Hashem shortened his trip and brought
actually activates the object for benefit, then it most certainly is assur to benefit from Chachamim gave it the status of forbidden food, nevertheless this only makes it assur
pose Shabbos.
the Maiseh of finding a wife.
Examples As the
would most
include wherespiritually
one heats up elevated
water for of the
bathing Har
for hisHa’Moriah
consumption andto him, reducing
not benefit. On thethe length
other of hisis trip.
hand, there Yakovwhich
also benefit
Avos,
purposes, or it was more
launders fitting
clothing forInhim
to wear. suchtocases
go there with
it is assur to purpose
benefit fromand
the one is only
indeed capable of having
recognized it and through
davened thethere.
act of However,
Bishul that was
theperformed.
first timeSuch
act of issur although in both situations the issur is purely benefit related. This is benefit is most definitely assur being that it is only had through the act of issur, and
intent, specifically to seek out the presence of Hashem - just he passed by there, he did not recognize it because Hashem
because it is assur to use something if the usage only comes through benefitting from this is clear from what the Mishna teaches that one may not use vessels which he
asthe
one of Avraham
Melachos and Yitzchak
Shabbos. hadfordone
The source this iswhen they
from the traveled
Mishna there33
in Terumos did notonwant
toiveled him to daven there incidentally during his trip at
Shabbos.
purposefully. To ensure this, Hashem orchestrated that he had that time.
פרשת השבוע 2
Sanhedrin Daf 95
Aggadic
Shabbos Teachings
Daf Lamed Ches
so. The mere thought of regret itself is very valuable pasuk,5 Va’yishkon betach badad ein Yakov el eretz
On the other hand, from the Poskim it isn’t so cut and dry that which happened on Yom Tov. His point is to show that there truly is
and can draw back the spiritual power of the tefillah. dagan vetirosh. ‘And Yisrael dwells securely, alone, as
the issur Maiseh Shabbos applies to all of the 39 Melachos. It no issur Hotza’ah applicable. On Yom Tov such an act is completely
Thisclear
becomes is why
fromHashem
them thatorchestrated for Yakov
there is a possibility to excluded,
some are pass by Yakov’s
muttar. Heeye
evenlooks toward
adds that theitland
of course wouldofbegrain
assurand
to eatwine’ .
the fruits
and without
we will now davening
go on to in the place where his forefathers
elaborate. ifThis
they means
were actually removed can
that Yisrael into always
a public be
domain on Shabbos
secure, even ifitself
davened, just like the din by Mevashel. The Magen Avraham 25 cites the words
The Chayei later
Adamregretting it, and
20asserts that thenMaiseh
the issur see theShabbos
miracleis they
of did not daven properly, because their regret can
Tosafos.
of kefitzas
applicable haderech.
specifically This wasismeant
where something done to as
theaobject
sign itself.
for allA still restore the lost power of the tefillah. Ein Yakov
physical
future generations that if Bnei Yisrael regretfood
change has to happen such as the result of cooking their or The Ramban 26 answers Tosafos’s question using a different
anything comparable. On the other hand, when one is Motzi alludes to
approach. He what
writes happened
that althoughwith Yakov,
all types that at
of Maiseh first, are
Shabbos
missed tefillos, the spiritual effect of their tefillos can
something from one domain to another where the actual object isn’t assur on Shabbos itself but
in order to prevent their benefit (such as what
he did not daven, once he regretted it, Hashem
still be
physically restored.
affected, if done b’shogeig it can be used on Shabbos itself one cooked, took Ma’aser off from, or anything comparable),
and even by the person who committed the act. If done b’mayzid it
showed him that He still desired his tefillah and
nevertheless the fruits here are different. They began in the person’s
is assurBased onothers,
even to this, the Arugas
but only untilHabosem explains
Motzei Shabbos. the
He does brought
house, werehim backtoby
removed kefitzas
a public area,haderech.
and then brought back to the
conclude though that one should be stringent with all Issurei Torah house. As such, there is no reason to assur them. They didn’t come
just like by Mevashel. The Biur Halacha 21 cites his words plainly to the house through issur Shabbos being that they actually originated
without bringing any opposition. there. No benefit is had from a Maiseh Shabbos at all.
However, the truth is that this matter is already broached by the– ב- He then adds that of course if they were to remain in the public
Rishonim. It all begins with the Gemara in Eiruvin 22 which teaches domain (without being returned to the house) it would be assur to eat
A remnant of kedushas Bais Hamikdash is retained in our Shuls
how if fruits were removed from their techum and later returned, even them. Consuming them there would be to do so through the means of
if this was done b’mayzid there is no loss to their location. What this issur Shabbos. On the other hand, when returned to the house one can
means is that even if they were returned b’mayzid it is still permissible eat them there being that no benefit is had from a Maiseh Shabbos.
Whether Yakov’s kefitzat haderech was by Har Ha’Moriah Rashi there on the words ‘V’zeh Shaar hashamyim’
for them to be consumed in their place.
being uprooted and brought to him, or by him being brought WhatRashi
where becomewrites
clear from ‘Bais Hamikdash
thatTosafos, shelRamban
the Rashba, and maalah is that
Tosafos there 23 questions why the fruits should be permissible for concerning where one actually transgresses the issur Hotza’ah
to Har Ha’Moriah / In the times of the Bais Hamikdash it is mechuvan k’neged Bais Hamikdash shel matah’ - the
consumption when returned b’mayzid from outside the techum. We d’oraisa, there it would be assur for him to benefit through the issur
aligned with the upper Bais Hamikdash and in the times of Heavenly Bais Hamikdash is aligned with the
upper Shabbos.
know that one may not eat food which was cooked b’mayzid on Maiseh
galus the upper Bais Hamikdash is moved to align with
Shabbos. He answers that cooking is different because it involves the the lower Bais Hamikdash. Similarly, Rashi in Parashas
Batei of
transgression Keneisiyos and Batei
a Melacha Midrashos
D’oraisa wherever
relating they are His
to Shabbos. On the other hand, the Ritvah b’shem Rabbeinu Yonah asserts that
Mishpatim
concerning
9
both pasuk
onthetheissur ‘L’havi’achah
Hotza’ah el ha’makom
and techumin there is no
intention is to point out how the issur relating to techumin is merely
m’drabbanan. Inלדוד theקרן
case discussed
,מבעלזא מהר"יnothing was ,רש"י
הרה"ק,רמב"ן removed from a asher hachinosi
application to –
Maiseh ‘to bring
Shabbos. you
This to
is the place
because the I have
issur ofpre-
Maiseh
private domain into a public one, rather from one techum to another. Shabbos is something that was initiated where
pared’, Rashi writes that this refers to the statement an actual change
Such anTheact isRishonim
assur only m’drabbanan. happens to the object itself. The term Maiseh refers to a physical
offer two explanations for Yakov change, that ‘Bais Hamikdash
and this shel maalah
issur is dubbed mechuvan
Maiseh Shabbos k’neged
to allude to areas
Aveenu’s
The kefitzas
Chiddushei HaRashbahaderech.
there 24 explains in greater detail. He Bais Hamikdash
where physical changeshel matah’
happens to .an object. However, where all one
writes that Bishul is different being that a Melacha D’oraisa is does is transgress the issur Hotza’ah and no change happens to the
transgressed. On the other hand,6 the Gemara is discussing a case
Rashi, in Chumash explains that the mountain object However, in Parashat
itself, as such there is noBeshalach 10
reason to assur the pasuk
onbecause of Maiseh
Har Ha’Moriah was uprooted and transported to ‘Tevi’aimo ve’sita’aimo b’har nachalascha machon
where Yakov was standing. Rashi gives the sameNOTES NOTESl’shivtecha’ – ‘You will bring them and plant them on
explanation
Through inhowour
this he raises one gemara.
7
who cooks on Shabbos makes the food assur for theNow,mountain of this
on the surface Your inheritance,
is difficult theWhen
to understand. place Youreturns
the water haveto its
consumption just like other maichalos assuros. As such, the food becomes forbidden madecold
original forstate,
Your dwelling’,
it comes out that oneRashi explains
isn’t benefitting from thethat ‘Bais
Maiseh Shabbos
to eat even where one doesn’t benefit from the Bishul such as in a case where it was at all. As such, it is hard to hear why it should be assur to drink the water then. If
However, the Ramban disagrees with Rashi. He
already roasted prior to being cooked. Although he would have preferred to eat Hamikdash shel matah mechuvan k’neged Bais Hamik-
one warms up water using Arlah oil or Klayim wood and then the water gets cold
argues
roasted and notthat since
cooked meatour
and gemara
there is noteaches that
real benefit fromthree indi- again,
the Melacha, dashtheshel din maalah’
isn’t for it to–bethat
assurthe lower
to drink. One Bais Hamikdash
is allowed is that
to drink it being
nevertheless the act of Bishul transforms the meat into forbidden food just like all
viduals experienced kefitzas haderech - Eliezer, the
other maichalos assuros. On the other hand, concerning different forms of benefit
there
aligned with the upper Bais Hamikdash. The ques- the
is no longer any benefit had from the Arlah or Klayim. This being the case
same should apply to Maiseh Shabbos as well.
they servant
are only assurof Abraham,
if made possiblyYakov, and Avishai,
purely through the act of the sonitself.
Melacha of tion arises: Why does Rashi sometimes say that the
However, if one was capable of having a certain benefit even before the act was As a result, we are forced to say that something cooked on Shabbos is given the
Tzeruiah - it must have occurred in the same manner status lower of aBais Hamikdash
maichal is aligned
issur for the entire with
day. It doesn’t upper Bais
thea difference
make then if one
committed, then such a thing remains permissible. This applies even to food as the
for all
forbidden three.
status is only And so, regard
given with just as consumptionkefitzas
to itEliezer’s haderech actually
and not benefit. Hamikdash,benefits fromandtheotheraveirahtimes
or not. he says that
Therefore, even the
whereupper
the cooking
was
He thenthat he traveled
continues that althoughfrom
we only Eretz Yisrael
find this tobetween
difference Charan in happened
an issur Bais
that
through a Goi, since while the water was hot it was assur to drink being
theHamikdash is aligned
Goi was his shaliach, as such itwith
becomestheassur
lower BaisShabbos.
the entire Hamik-
achilah and issur ha’na’ah within the words of Rebbi Yochanan and not Rebbi
one day, so too, Yakov’s kefitzas haderech was that he
Yehudah, nevertheless it truthfully applies to Rebbi Yehudah as well. dash?
This then has a practical application where one cooks water on Shabbos for the
arrived at Har Ha’Moriah quickly. Why would we purpose of bathing. Although in doing so he transgresses an issur Torah,
He then uses this concept to explain what the Beis Yosef asserts b’shem the
35
assume
Rashba. The BeisthatYosef the mountain
discusses a case whereitself was
one tells uprooted
a Goi and
to make a fire and
The since
nevertheless Keren L’David
bathing is merely a answers
form of benefit, asas follows.
such it wouldThe be muttar
boil water for him on Shabbos. He writes that if the water got cold it would still be Gemara
to in
use the water Masechet Megillah
as soon as it cools down. When 11
interprets the
cold again there nopasuk
longer12is any
moved toward him?
assur for him to drink it. Not only that, if the water had previously been boiled and benefit had from the Maiseh Shabbos. There isn’t reason to say that because it was
then reverted to this state, even to those who hold even by liquids that there is no
‘Va’ehi
assur whilelahem l’mikdash
hot it should be assurme’at’
the entire– ‘IShabbos.
shall This
be for them said
is something
The
Bishul after Keren
Bishul, L’David
nevertheless 8
defends
it would still be assur toRashi’s by since
drink the water noting
it was a small with
specifically sanctuary’ as orreferring
regard to eating drinking andtonot‘Bateibenefit. Keneisiyos
[See more what he
cooked by a fire on Shabbos. has to say there.]
פרשת השבוע 3
Sanhedrin Daf 95
Aggadic Teachings
u’Batei Midrashos sheb’Bavel’. The synagogues and Hamikdash is aligned with the lower Bais Hamikdash
study halls in galus are called ‘Mikdash Me’at’, a min- to teach that when Klal Yisrael is in galus and they
iature Bais Hamikdash. Since the Bais Hamikdash establish Mikdash Me’at, shuls, wherever they are,
was destroyed, the Batei Keneisiyos u’Batei Midrashos Hashem moves the upper Bais Hamikdash to align
sheb’Bavel, our shuls, retain a remnant of the holiness with the Mikdash Me’at, the Batei Keneisiyos u’Batei
of the Bais Hamikdash. Midrashos sheb’Bavel.
Accordingly, in Parashas Beshalach, since the And so, the Keren L’David explains: It is there-
pasuk speaks about the Bais Hamikdash in Yerusha- fore that Rashi explains that the kefitzas haderech of
layim, Rashi says that the lower Bais Hamikdash Yakov Aveenu was that Har Ha’Moriah was brought
is aligned with the upper Bais Hamikdash above it. to him - unlike Eliezer, where he was brought to
However, in Parashas Vayeitzei Rashi discusses the his destination, Charan – because as Yakov said,
times of galus, when the Jewish people are outside of V’zeh shaar ha’Shamayim, he saw ‘Bais Hamikdash
the Land of Israel, as Yakov was at that time in Cha- shel maalah mechuvan k’neged Bais Hamikdash shel
ran, which is Chutz La’Aretz. Indeed, the Midrash13 matah’, alluding to the times of galus when the upper
teaches that Yakov Aveenu was shown the churban Bais Hamikdash is moved to align with the Mikdash
(distruction) of the Bais Hamikdash. Similarly, in Me’at. It is therefore that in Yakov’s case Har Ha’Mo-
Parshas Mishpatim the pasuk14 Hinei Anochi sholei’ach riah was uprooted and brought to where Yakov was
malach alludes to the times of galus, as Rashi there at that time.
explains. Therefore, Rashi says that the upper Bais
מראי מקומות
) בראשית כח יז (ד"ה כי אם.6 דברים לג כח.5 ) פרשת ברכה (ד"ה וישכון.4 על התורה פ' ויצא.3 ' בראשית רבא ס"ח ח.2 ) (ד"ה אפשר: חידושי אגדות חולין דף צ"א.1
שמות כג כ.14 בראשית רבה ס"ט.13 יחזקאל יא טז.12 . דף כ"ט.11 שמות טו יז.10 שמות כג כ.9 פ' ויצא.8 ) (ד"ה קפצה: בסוגיין צה.7
4
פרשת השבוע
Bechoros 55
Immersing in rivers during times of increased rainfall
דאמר רב, ופליגא דרב. מסייע ליה לשמואל דאמר שמואל נהרא מכיפיה מיבריך. שמימיו פרים ורבים, למה נקרא שמו פרת:בבכורות דף נ"ה
.אמי אמר רב מיטרא במערבא סהדא רבה פרת
סבר לה כרב דאמר רב אמי אמר רב מיטרא במערבא, מקוה ביומי ניסן. ומפצי ביומי תשרי,אבוה דשמואל עביד להו לבנאתיה מקוה ביומי ניסן
.' וכו. ומפצי ביומי תשרי. והוו להו מי גשמים רובא, שמא ירבו נוטפין על הזוחלין,סהדא רבה פרת
-א-
Erecting a mapatz in the river to make it an ‘ashburan’.
The water passes through the holes in the mat / An imperceptible which is not standing still. But Shmuel disagrees and
flow / A mapatz made of fabric through which no water passes / holds that there is rain, the welling of the deep increases
The Disqualification of zochalin in a river is not from the Torah / even more, and we find that the river grows in times of
The disqualification of zochalin in a mikvah is said only when all rains, not only from the rain, but even more from the
the water is flowing like a spring, and not when there is a flow deep, and it is like a spring which purifies even flowing.
through a crack in the mikvah wall
And the Rambam writes that a river whose major-
שבט הלוי, בית שלמה, גידולי טהרה, דברי מלכיאל, עין יצחק, שו"ע,רמב"ם
ity is rainwater, only purifies in an ashburan, therefore,
The discussion in our Gemora is also brought in he must surround it with a mapatz (a kind of mat) or
Shabbos1 and in Nedarim2, and this halacha is cited in something similar until the water collects and he can
the Rambam3 and in the Tur Shulchan Aruch4. immerse in it. Meaning that he rules like Rav that one
The discussion in Gemora, according to most Ris- must not immerse in rivers when they are mostly rain-
honim, is about whether to prohibit immersing in rivers water, and he ruled that it can be permitted by putting a
due to the disqualification of zochalin (flowing water). mapatz to collect the water. Meaning that he understood
For while spring water purifies even flowing, rainwa- that Shmuel’s father made a mapatz for his daughters on
ter only purifies when collected and in an ashburan (a Tishrei in order that the waters will be still. [See further
place where waters stand still). Therefore, rivers flow- in the Kesef Mishnah there].
ing during a time when we aren’t worried that there is The Shulchan Aruch brings two opinions, the Mech-
increased rainwater in them, it is permitted to immerse aber writes like the Rambam that if it is mostly rainwater,
in them even when they are flowing, like by a spring. it only purifies in an ashburan, and not flowing. There-
But in a time when we are concerned that there is an fore, he surrounds it with a mapatz, a kind of mat, to
increase of rainwater in the river, Rav holds that ‘when collect the water. And the Rema brings that some permit
you see that the Euphrates River grows larger than usual, to immerse in them even when they are mostly rainwater
it is proof of rain in Eretz Yisrael’, and it is therefore pro-
דף היומי
because the majority of the growth of the river is from
hibited to immerse in it, since they are mostly rainwater its source, and he writes that this is the tradition in most
1
Bechoros 55
Immersing in rivers
Shabbos Daf Lamed Ches
places that have no mikvah, and one should not protest on how erecting a mapatz in the river helps remove the
L’halacha the Rishonim disagree concerning whether we pasken On the other hand, the Biur HaGra there goes to great lengths and
against those who are lenient, because they have upon disqualification of zochalin, since the water still passes
like Rebbi Meir or Rebbi Yehudah. The Rif 9 asserts that the halacha concludes like Rebbi Meir. The Mishna Berurah 18 cites this opinion
whom Rebbi
follows to rely.
Yehudah, and the Ran 10 explains his reasoning to be through
of the Grathe andgaps
how inhe the mapatz.
follows in theAnd he writes
footsteps that and
of Tosafos thishis
is
because Rav publicly darshened as such. This being the case the
And regarding this matter of immersing in a river because the
colleagues who prohibition
all pasken likeofRebbi
immersing
Meir thatineven
a flowing
b’mayzidriver
it is
halacha follows suit. The same is raised by both the Rambam 11 and only assur to eat from food cooked on Shabbos until Motzei Shabbos.
during12increased rains, the the
Rishonim when it is mostly rainwater is not biblical but rabbinic,
Ramban as well. Additionally, Beis Yosefand Achronim
13 writes that the This applies even to the one who cooked it, and b’shogeig everyone
go deep
words into
of the detail,
Rosh 14 seemand much
to lean thisof it was
way too. already brought forpartake
can biblically, once
from the foodthe rainwater
immediately attaches
on Shabbos toThe
itself. theMishna
river
in ‘Lehisvada’ on Shabbos which asserts
Berurah has thethatstatus of aofspring,
in a time need oneitispurifies
allowed toevenrely when
on this
On the other hand, Tosafos in 65 and15on
Chullin Nedarim
asserts that the40 and
halacha where the food was cooked b’shogeig.
shouldRebbi
follow not Meir,
be repeated.
and his reasoned is because this is how Rav it is flowing, only that it is disqualified rabbinically, and
instructed his students. Additionally, the Beis Yosef 16 brings this The itimplication
since of his words
is only rabbinic, is that
they it islenient
were specifically
on with regards
erecting a
Andboth
b’shem regarding
the Smagthat
and one
Sefercan erect a mapatz
HaTerumah as well. and permit to shogeig that one can rely on Tosafos to pasken like Rebbi Meir.
mapatz, even though the water passes through the gaps.
On the other hand, b’mayzid on wouldn’t be allowed to rely on Rebbi
theThe
disqualification of zochalin, the Poskim ask that the
Shulchan Aruch 17 determines like the opinions of the Rif, Meir’s
And opinion allowing theBeis
the Teshuvos cookShlomo
to partake11from the food
explains in on Motzei
another
water still
Rambam, andpasses
Rosh tothrough the
pasken like gaps
Rebbi Yehudah mapatz,
in the(as we haveand of
already Shabbos. With regard to a mayzid we must act stringently like Rebbi
mentioned).
what use is it. And there are several approaches, as will mannerwho
Yehudah what
holdsthe
thatRambam and the Shulchan
the food is perpetually assur. Aruch
be explained. wrote that he can erect a mapatz in a river with increased
- ב-rainwater to collect the water, for the Rosh12 cites an
The Teshuvos MaisehEin Shabbos
Yitzchakwith 5
explains
regard the to a matter
Melacha where opinion nothing
that aismikvah done tocracked the object in one itselfof its walls such
according to what the Shulchan Aruch writes that if the 6
that the the water is leaking, is no longer considered ashbu-
mikvah is punctured and the water is slowly leaking little speaking,
Where one was motzi something from one reshus to the
ran, but
issur of Maiseh Shabbos is not something specific to
zochalin, and
other, if such a thing is assur because of Maiseh Shabbos / Bishul creating an issur forisone invalid.
to eat foodAndcooked the Rosh disagrees
on Shabbos. On
by little, or slowly being absorbed
Specifics in this inyan into the ground, it is the contrary, it applies to any Melacha.
and writes that the statement that a mikvah, as opposed If someone transgresses any
kosher, because- the flow is imperceptible
רבנו יונה,' תוס, חיי אדם, רמ"א, טור-
7
. He therefore of the Melachos Shabbos it is then forbidden for him to benefit from
to a spring, does not purify when it is zochalin, comes to
what he did. Additionally, in the Shulchan Aruch 19 the Mechaber
writes that erecting a mapatz in
[ ]בAlthough both our Mishna and Gemara only make reference to
the river works even exclude
brings mikvahofthat
thisa concept notisbeing
in itsable entirety
to eatcontinuously
what one cooked flow-on
thoughcooking theonwater
Shabbos,stillitpasses
is already through
made knownit, becausefrom the theTurflowthat Shabbos, and the Rema adds that this
ing like a spring, but a mikvah that is generally still, only is applicable to the other
this concept of Maiseh
is imperceptible. And Shabbos doesn’t differentiate.
on the contrary, from whatPracticallywe said Melachos as well.
that some water is flowing out of its side, the mikvah is
that erecting a mapatz in the river works, we can prove kosher to immerse in the water standing still. He proves
like the Shulchan Aruch that an imperceptible flow isNOTESthis from what we learn in the Mishnah in Mikvaos13 that
notIfconsidered
a Maiseh Shabbos a flow,is assurforb’hana’ah
when erecting/ Two aspects by atomat,Maiseh it is concerning
a streamwhere one toivels vessels on Shabbos. We say there that if done b’shogeig
of water descending from the mountain can be
Shabbos, and the difference between Mevashel and other Melachos / he may use them, and b’mayzid not. As such, it is clear that the issur Maiseh Shabbos
impossible the water will not pass through,
Something cooked on Shabbos is given similar status to other and even so, blocked
applies even towith
benefitvessels
through to slow the
something’s flow
usage, of the
and not just anwater so that
issur achilah.
theforbidden
Rambam foodsand the Shulchan
/ Where one cooked water Aruch and rule
it gotthat
cold it works
again /
it won’t be zochalin,
On the other hand, concerning andBishul
we see therethat
is an even though
additional element.the When ves-
one
Where one cooked water for washing and it got cold again
to remove the concern- שלמה of zochalin.
שו"ת מנחת-
And it is difficult to cooks on Shabbos the meat gets a din of basar tereifah m’drabbanan. As such, it
sels are not sealed together such that no water escapes, it
becomes assur for consumption just like all other forbidden foods. Because of this
sayThethat
[1] they
Minchas meant
Shlomo 31 that the
comments on thismat must
that the be thick
Tur writes how theenough
din Maiseh is sufficient,
the Magen Avraham andasserts
34 as long as he
that even immerses
the pot it was cooked in ina place
becomeswhereassur as
that no
Shabbos water
applies to allflows
Melachos through,
making it assurfor if so, they
to benefit from should have well.
the act performed.
One then needs to do hagalah on the pot and it is necessary even if a 24 hour
the water is still, even though it flows out from the side,
He points out that according to this the issur Maiseh Shabbos isn’t specifically an
period passes making it no longer a Ben Yomo. Although there would have logically
specified
issur this, and
achilah (eating) alsoan that
but also it is not(benfit).
issur ha’na’ah realistic thatthisnois water
However, difficult it isroom
been nottoinvalidated
say that after 24 zochalin.
ashours the pot should only give off negative tastes
will
to flow through,
understand. In Bava Kama andweweseemust
32
sayRebbi
that even thatYochanan
since the flowwho
Hasandler is through which one doesn’t benefit, nevertheless we see clearly that the Chachamim
madeAnd theMaiseh
BeisShabbos
Shlomo writes that towhat theforbidden
Rambam
holds Maiseh Shabbos is assur min hatorah, nevertheless 8this is only an issur achilah
the issur by Bishul comparable all other foods.
imperceptible,
and not an issur ha’na’ah, it isandnotit is disqualifying.
something learnt out from pesukim. Now, if this
The
wrotesame way
that bya other
river issurim
mostly the pot is also
consisting assur for
of use even
rainwater when not
can a Ben
be
is true (that the issur is only an issur achilah and not an issur ha’na’ah) for Rebbi
Yomo, so too this follows for Maiseh Shabbos as well.
And according to his view that using a
Yochanan Hasandler who holds that Maiseh Shabbos is assur min hatorah, then it mapatz works permitted by erecting a mapatz, is understood according
is because
must the flow
certainly should is imperceptible,
be the case for both Rebbi Meir one and Rebbimust usewho
Yehuda mats hold With this in mind we can now explain what is said in Bava Kama that even
to the toRosh’s view Hasandler
that thethedisqualification of zochalin
the issur is merely m’drabbanan. As such, it is difficult to understand how we can according Rebbi Yochanan issur is only an issur achilah and not an
with very thin gaps, because in
say it is assur to benefit from all types of Maiseh Shabbos. a regular mat, the flow in rainwater
issur ha’na’ah. What isthis
onlymeans if tohesayimmerses
is that although inthea place
food getwherethe statusthe
of a
visibly passing through it. maichal assur, nevertheless this only makes it forbidden for consumption and not
waterItflows a mapatz
doesn’t like
becomea likespring, and since erecting
To answer he asserts that in truth there are two forms of the issur Maiseh
benefit. Arlah, Klayim, or Hekdesh where benefit is also
Shabbos. Therefore, although by all the Melachos one9 does on Shabbos there is an
But the Teshuvos Divrei Malkiel cites this
issur to benefit from them, nevertheless this doesn’t pose a contradiction to what the opinion, stops
forbidden. the flow
However, of
this is the water,
said specifically it is
with considered
regard to benefit thatashburan,
one could
have enjoyed even before the Maiseh was performed. This is because it isn’t caused
and disputes
Gemara in Bava Kama it andsays writes
concerningthat how we mustShabbos
a Maiseh say that indeed,
is only assur for even
by though
the forbidden the such
Melacha water passes
as where through
one benefits throughthe gaps.
giving the food to his
consumption and not benefit. We will now bring a brief account of his words.
the mapatz must be tightly woven such that water won’t friendAnd as a gift, or to his animal to eat. As long as these
the Teshuvos Shevet HaLevi14 also explains the
things are done in a way
The first thing to know is that by all Melachos Shabbos whenever the Melacha where one doesn’t benefit from the Bishul itself, we then say that although the
immediately
actually activates thepenetrate,
object for benefit,andthenalthough the iswater
it most certainly assur towill pen-
benefit from Rambam
Chachamim and
gave statusMechaber
it thethe of forbidden food,according
neverthelessto the
this onlyRosh,
makes it and
assur
etrate
the Maisehafter some
Shabbos. time,
Examples wouldstill, when
include wherehe oneerects
heats up thewater mapatz
for bathing for his consumption and not benefit. On 15 the other hand, there is also benefit which
purposes, or launders clothing to wear. In such cases it is assur to benefit from the
writes that in the Rambam we can prove that he holds
one is only capable of having through the act of Bishul that was performed. Such
before immersing, they will be able to immerse before benefit
act of issur although in both situations the issur is purely benefit related. This is like the Rosh,
is most and
definitely assur this
beingisthat
also it is the opinion
only had through the ofactthe Mech-
of issur, and
דף היומי
the water
because penetrates
it is assur to use something through,
if the usage and
onlywater will be
comes through still. from this
benefitting is clear from what the Mishna teaches
aber in the Shulchan Aruch16 who wrote that a leak does that one may not use vessels which he
one of the Melachos Shabbos. The source for this is from the Mishna in Terumos 33 toiveled on Shabbos.
Indeed, the sefer Gidulei Tahara also comments 10
not disqualify the mikvah unless it is left with less than
2
Bechoros 55
Immersing in rivers
Shabbos Daf Lamed Ches
forty se’ah, and we see that he holds that the fact itself indeed, according to the Rema it won’t help to erect a
thatOnwater
the other hand, from the Poskim it isn’t so cut and dry that
is flowing out of the mikvah doesn’t disqualify which happened on Yom Tov. His point is to show that there truly is
mapatz in the river, because if a leak disqualifies a mik-
the issur Maiseh Shabbos applies to all of the 39 Melachos. It no issur Hotza’ah applicable. On Yom Tov such an act is completely
it, and that
becomes is why
clear from they
them that wrote
there is athat they can
possibility someerect mats.
are excluded, vah, we
muttar. Hecertainly
even adds cannot permit
that of course a river
it would be with
assur rainwater by
to eat the fruits
Butwe
and thewillRema
now godisagrees
17
with the Mechaber and writes
on to elaborate. iferecting mapatz.
they wereaactually removed into a public domain on Shabbos itself
just like the din by Mevashel. The Magen Avraham 25 cites the words
thatThea leak on Adam
Chayei the side
20asserts thatmikvah
of the disqualifies
the issur it, andis
Maiseh Shabbos of Tosafos.
applicable specifically where something is done to the object itself. A
physical change has to happen such as the result of cooking food or The Ramban 26 answers Tosafos’s question using a different
anything comparable. On the other hand, when one is Motzi approach. He writes that although all types of Maiseh Shabbos are
something from one domain to another where the actual object isn’t- ב-assur on Shabbos itself in order to prevent their benefit (such as what
physically affected, if done b’shogeig it can be used on Shabbos itself one cooked, took Ma’aser off from, or anything comparable),
Erecting a mapatz that is susceptible to impurity.
and even by the person who committed the act. If done b’mayzid it nevertheless the fruits here are different. They began in the person’s
is assur even to others,
If it is necessary to erectbut
a matonly
thatuntil
is notMotzei Shabbos.
susceptible He does
to impurity house, were removed to a public area, and then brought back to the
and the Rambam permits it. And therefore, the Gidulei
conclude though that one should be stringent with all Issurei Torah house. As such, there is no reason to assur them. They didn’t come
/ The dispute if its existence must be in purity / Through building
just like by Mevashel. The Biur Halacha 21 cites his words plainly Tahara
to andthrough
the house the Levanon Neta
issur Shabbos write
being that that what the
they actually Shul-
originated
without in bringing
a river, theany
status of susceptibility to impurity is removed
opposition. chanNo
there. Aruch wrote
benefit is hadtofrom
erect a mapatz
a Maiseh in the
Shabbos river, means a
at all.
בית שלמה, לבנון נטע,גידולי טהרה
However, the truth is that this matter is already broached by the mapatz
He then thataddsis that
notofsusceptible
course if they towere
impurity,
to remain since hepublic
in the only
The sefer
Rishonim. It allGidulei Tahara
begins with 18
the Gemarawrites that what
in Eiruvin 22 whichis stated
teaches cites the
domain opinion
(without being notreturnedto stop
to the the house)flow withbesomething
it would assur to eat
how
thatifinfruits were removed
a river from their techum
with increased and laterhe
rainwater, returned,
erectsevena them. Consuming
susceptible to them there would be to do so through the means of
impurity.
if this was done b’mayzid there is no loss to their location. What this issur Shabbos. On the other hand, when returned to the house one can
mapatz
means to even
is that poolif the water
they were so it b’mayzid
returned stillashburan,
stands itinisan permissible But there
eat them in the beingTeshuvos
that no benefit Beis isShlomo
had from a he
25
is asked
Maiseh Shabbos. on
means
for them that
to behe shouldinerect
consumed mapatz that is not made for
their aplace. what the Mechaber wrote to erect a mapatz in the river to
What become clear from Tosafos, the Rashba, and Ramban is that
lying upon,
Tosafos which
there is notwhy
23 questions susceptible to impurity,
the fruits should for the
be permissible for collect thewhere
concerning water,one the mapatz
thatactually is susceptible
transgresses the issur toHotza’ahimpu-
Shulchan Aruch
consumption
19
when returned that a mikvah
wroteb’mayzid from outside thatthehastechum.
the dis- We rity, andthere
d’oraisa, it isitprohibited
would be assur to for
stop hima toflow using
benefit something
through the issur
know that one may not eat food which
qualification of zochalin, the flow should not be arrested was cooked b’mayzid on Maiseh Shabbos.
susceptible to impurity, as we see in the Shulchan Aruch.
Shabbos. He answers that cooking is different because it involves the
using something susceptible to impurity, because a
transgression of a Melacha D’oraisa relating to Shabbos. His And On he the responded
other hand, thein several
Ritvah b’shem ways,
Rabbeinu first Yonah
he wrote assertsthatthat
mikvah’sis to existence must thebe issurinrelating
purity, and notis using concerning both the issur Hotza’ah and techumin there is no
intention point out how to techumin merely the source for erecting a mapatz in the river is from the
In the case discussed nothing application to Maiseh Shabbos. This is because the issur of Maiseh
m’drabbanan.
something susceptible to impurity. Sowas tooremoved
is written fromina Rambam,
Shabbos and we cannot
is something that wasask on the
initiated whereRambaman actual that it is
change
private domain into a public 20 one, rather from one techum to another.
the sefer Levanon Neta , that this is why the Shulchan happens
Such an act is assur only m’drabbanan. susceptible to thetoobject impurity,
itself. Thesinceterm theMaiseh
Rambam refersdoesn’t hold
to a physical
Aruch writes that a mapatz is ‘similar to’ a mat, to say change, and this issur is dubbed Maiseh
that its creation needs to be in purity. Rather, you should Shabbos to allude to areas
The Chiddushei HaRashba there 24 explains in greater detail. He where physical change happens to an object. However, where all one
that one should not use an actual mat, because a mat is does
writes that Bishul is different being that a Melacha D’oraisa is ask on the Mechaber
is transgress the issurwho originally
Hotza’ah and no brought
change happens that there
to the
susceptibleOn
transgressed. to impurity
the other hand,and shouldthe Gemara not be used to create
is discussing a case are two
object itself,opinions
as such thereon whether
is no reason theto flow
assur can becausebe of arrested
Maiseh
a mikvah. using something susceptible to impurity, and why did
Indeed, this statement that a mikveh must be createdNOTES NOTEShe later write, without specifying, that it is permitted
in purity is he
Through this not agreed
raises how oneon whoby cookseveryone,
on Shabbos makesfor its source
the food is
assur for to Now,
stoponthe flowthis
the surface with a mapatz.
is difficult AndWhen
to understand. thetheBeis Shlomo
water returns to its
from thejustMishnah
consumption 21
where
like other maichalos Rabi
assuros. Yosei
As such, states
the food thatforbidden
becomes writescoldthat
any- original state,the Mechaber
it comes out that onecombined thefrom
isn’t benefitting opinions
the Maiseh thatShabbos it
to eat even where one doesn’t benefit from the Bishul such as in a case where it was at all. As such, it is hard to hear why it should be assur to drink the water then. If
thing roasted
already that ispriorsusceptible
to being cooked.to Although
impurity is nothaveused
he would to flow
preferred to eat is permitted to immerse in the river even during heavy
one warms up water using Arlah oil or Klayim wood and then the water gets cold
waterandthrough.
roasted not cookedAnd meat the Rosh
and there is no writes
22 real benefit that
fromaccording
the Melacha, rainfall,
again, the dinaccording
isn’t for it to betoassur
the toopinion
drink. One that thetowater
is allowed drink itwelling
being that
nevertheless the act of Bishul transforms the meat into forbidden food just like all there is no longer any benefit had from the Arlah or Klayim. This being the case the
to Rabi
other Yosei
maichalos a mikvah
assuros. is only
On the other hand, created using things
concerning different that same
forms of benefit
from the deep also increases, and therefore, he is lenient
should apply to Maiseh Shabbos as well.
are are
they notonly
susceptible
assur if madetopossibly
impurity 23
. Indeed,
purely through the
the act of Beis
Melacha Yosef
itself. regarding arresting the flow using something susceptible
However, if one was capable of having a certain benefit even before the act was As a result, we are forced to say that something cooked on Shabbos is given the
brings that
committed, the aRambam
then such thing remainsexplains
permissible.Rabi Yosei’s
This applies evenstatement
to food as the
to impurity.
status of a maichal issur for the entire day. It doesn’t make a difference then if one
entirelystatus
forbidden differently,
is only givenand in histo opinion,
with regard it consumption itand
is permitted
not benefit. to actuallyHebenefits
further from the aveirah or not. Therefore, even where the cooking
writes that indeed, we should say that
happened through a Goi, since while the water was hot it was assur to drink being
make a mikvah
He then using
continues that something
although we only find susceptible to impu-
this difference between an issur
thethemat
that being
Goi was discussed
his shaliach, as suchisit one
becomesthatassuristhenot susceptible
entire Shabbos. to
achilah and issur ha’na’ah within 24the words of Rebbi Yochanan and not Rebbi
rity. And the Mechaber cites two opinions
Yehudah, nevertheless it truthfully applies to Rebbi Yehudah as well. regarding impurity,
This then has likea practical
we find 26
that where
application matsonebeingcooks used
water onfor shade
Shabbos for or
the
whether the flow in a mikvah can be stopped
He then uses this concept to explain what the Beis Yosef asserts b’shem the
35 via some- for building can be used as schach for the sukkah, and
purpose of bathing. Although in doing so he transgresses an issur Torah,is
Rashba. The Beis Yosef discusses
thing susceptible a case where
to impurity, thatonethe tellsRosh
a Goi toprohibits
make a fire and it, nevertheless
not
to
since bathing is merely a form of benefit, as such it would be muttar
use susceptible
the water as soonto impurity.
as it cools down. And he writes
When cold again therefurther,
no longer is that
any
boil water for him on Shabbos. He writes that if the water got cold it would still be
assur for him to drink it. Not only that, if the water had previously been boiled and benefit had from the Maiseh Shabbos. There isn’t reason to say that because it was
then reverted to this state, even to those who hold even by liquids that there is no assur while hot it should be assur the entire Shabbos. This is something said
דף היומי
Bishul after Bishul, nevertheless it would still be assur to drink the water since it was specifically with regard to eating or drinking and not benefit. [See more what he
cooked by a fire on Shabbos. has to say there.]
3
Bechoros 55
Immersing in rivers
even if he took a mat that is susceptible to impurity, still, this it no longer has the status as susceptible to impurity.
since it is impossible stop the flow of the water except by [1]
affixing it firmly so that the water will not flow, through
Notes
The difference between fixing a leaky mikvah using something And that mayim sheuvin are purified when they are in a kosher
susceptible to impurity and erecting a mapatz in a river mikvah, is said also when they come to the mikvah from a vessel
ישועות יעקב susceptible to impurity, meaning that this disqualification that the
water came from something susceptible to impurity which is con-
[1] The Yeshuos Yaakov explains that one can stop the river’s
2
sidered that it is impure, is also removed through hashakah in the
flow with a mapatz susceptible to impurity even according
mikvah, just like the disqualification of being drawn is removed,
to those who prohibit to fix a leak in the mikvah using something
that since the water that came from a vessel that is susceptible to
susceptible to impurity. This according to how he explains why
impurity is seeded within the mikvah, the disqualification of their
increased rainwater disqualifies the river for immersing in when
impurity is removed.
it is flowing, while even a thousand se’ah of mayim sheuvin (drawn
water) do not disqualify a mikvah of forty se’ah, that this is because And now it is resolved wonderfully why one can erect a mapatz
mayim sheuvin are disqualified in their essence by being detached, susceptible to impurity in the river to slow the flow, even though
and when they fall into the mikvah, they are ‘seeded’ (through a leak in a mikvah cannot be stopped with something susceptible
hashakah) into it and become attached to the water in the mikvah, to impurity, because when he erects a mapatz in the river, this
and they are no longer considered mayim sheuvin. But that rain- disqualification that the water being there is via something that
water only purifies standing still and not when flowing, is not a is susceptible to impurity, is removed through hashakah in the
disqualification in the water itself, only that the Torah stated that river’s water, just as mayim sheuvin, even coming from a vessel
rainwater that comes upon a person flowing doesn’t purify him, susceptible to impurity, is purified in a kosher mikvah through
because by rainwater the person needs to go into them in an ashbu- hashakah, because only the disqualification of zochalin is not
ran, and not that the water comes upon him flowing. And since it is removed through hashakah because it is a specific Torah law, and
no disqualification in the water itself, just that he is not purified if it if so, even if a leaky mikvah is not fixed using something suscepti-
is flowing, here it doesn’t help to mix the rainwater with the spring ble to impurity, erecting a mapatz in the water works, because this
water, because there is no disqualification that can be removed disqualification, that it is there because of something susceptible to
through seeding and hashakah, and even mixed with spring water, impurity, is purified through hashakah inside the river.
it is still rainwater, and they do not purify a person if they come
upon him flowing28.
מראי מקומות
מקורו בבית יוסף בשם שער המים להרשב"א.7 יו"ד סי' ר"א סעיף נ"א.6 ח"א יו"ד סי' כ"ב.5 ' יו"ד סי' ר"א סעיף ב.4 בפרק ט' מהלכות מקוואות הלכה י"ג.3 .' דף מ.2 . דף ס"ה.1
בפרק ה' משנה.13 בהלכות מקואות סי' י"א.12 )' יו"ד ח"ב סי' פ"ב (אות ד.11 ] על הלכות מקוואות [גבא סק"ז.10 ח"ג סוף סי' ס"ד.9 .)' וכן כתב במרחשת ח"א סי' ל"ט (אות ד.8
' בפרק ה.21 על הלכות מקואות שם.20 ' שם סעיף נ.19 ] [גבא סק"ז.18 ' בסעיף נ.17 ' שם סעיף נ.16 בפרק ט' מהלכות מקואות הלכה ט' והלכה ט"ז.15 ח" סי' ק"ו.14 'ו
יו"ד סי' ר"א סק"א (ד"ה.27 : בסוכה דף י"ט.26 ח"ב יו"ד סי' ס"א.25 ) שם בסעיף נ' (הנ"ל.24 וכ"כ בטור יו"ד סי' ר"א סעיף מ"ח.23 בהלכות מקואות סי' י"א.22 'דמקואות משנה ה
.] [והוא מפרש כן בדברי התרומת הדשן המובא בטו"ז שם סק"ג.28 )והנה
דף היומי
4
