Ohr Yosef - English
Text of this gilyon
Ohr Yosef Jealousy and Forgiveness Vayeitzei p1
Jealous of What?
After Yaakov married Leah and Rachel, Leah had four sons, one after
another, while Rachel had none. The Torah tells us (Bereishis 30:1): ו ְַּת ַקנֵּא
ָרחֵּ ל בַ אֲ ח ָֹתּה: Rachel was jealous of her sister.
Chazal tell us that Rachel was not jealous of Leah’s children. She was
jealous of Leah’s goodness. She said to herself: Leah must be a better
person than I am, and that is why she has children and I do not.
This was not the jealousy we usually know. Rachel did not want what her
sister had. She wanted to be as good as her sister was. If there is such a
thing as a good jealousy, this is it. And yet, as we will see, even this
jealousy came at a price.
Two Hard Conversations
Rachel turned to Yaakov and cried, “Give me children, or I am as good as
dead.” Yaakov’s answer is startling. He became angry and said, הֲ ַתחַ ת
ֹלהים ָאנֹכִ י
ִ ֱא: Am I in place of Hashem? He is the One who has kept you
from having children.
Chazal say that Hashem was not pleased. “Is this how you answer
someone in pain?” He said to Yaakov. Then Yaakov told Rachel to look at
his grandmother Sarah, who brought another wife into her home.
Why would Yaakov speak this way to Rachel, of all people? Why didn’t he
just daven for her?
The second conversation is just as puzzling. Years later, Rachel asked Leah
© 5787 Yosi Rabinowicz. This weekly can be obtained by email from
gilyonOhrYosef@gmail.com or downloaded from www.ladaat.info
Translations are loose, and based upon The Living Torah by Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan
Ohr Yosef Jealousy and Forgiveness Vayeitzei p2
for some of the flowers Leah’s son had brought home, and Leah
answered, ישי
ִ הַ ְּמעַ ט ַק ְּח ֵּתְך ֶאת ִא: Isn’t it enough that you took my
husband?
Took her husband? It was the other way around. Yaakov was supposed
to marry Rachel, and he gave her secret signs so that Lavan could not trick
him. When Lavan brought Leah instead, Rachel gave her sister the signs,
so that Leah would not be embarrassed. Rachel did not take Yaakov from
Leah. She gave him to her. How could Leah say such a thing?
What Was Holding Things Back
It seems that Rachel’s jealousy, even though it was over goodness, was
holding back blessing in Yaakov’s home. Not only from Rachel. After her
fourth son, Leah stopped having children too.
Rachel never meant any harm. She wished her sister nothing but good.
She was simply in pain, feeling that she did not measure up. But that
feeling of “I am missing something” has a way of spreading.
Now we can understand Yaakov. He was not refusing to daven. He was
telling Rachel that the key was in her own hands. “Look at Sarah,” he was
saying. “She brought another woman into her home, with a full heart.”
Rachel had already done that once, when she gave Leah the signs. Yaakov
was asking her to finish what she had started: to let go of the jealousy,
and to be truly happy for her sister with every child she had. He knew his
words would hurt, but he meant them for her good.
And we can understand Leah. Each time Leah had a son, she hoped the
child would bring her husband closer to her. When she stopped having
Ohr Yosef Jealousy and Forgiveness Vayeitzei p3
children, she felt that something of her husband had been taken from
her. She was not accusing her sister. She was asking her to let go.
Why Jealousy Does Harm
I heard from my rebbe, Rabbi Avigdor Miller, that the word ִקנ ְָּאה,
jealousy, comes from ִק ְּניָן, owning. A jealous person is someone who
wants to own. Whatever they have is never enough, and whatever
someone else has feels like something taken from them. So, a jealous
person is always missing something, and that feeling of lack does damage,
to them and to the people around them.
With physical things, what one person has, the other does not. If you take
the last seat, I have to stand. But spiritual things are like light. When one
candle lights another, the first candle loses nothing, and the whole room
becomes brighter.
Yaakov’s home was built entirely for the sake of Heaven. In a home like
that, there is no “less for me” when someone else has more. That is why
Rachel could give Leah the signs: she knew nothing would be lost. And
that is why even Rachel’s small feeling of “I am missing something” was
enough to dim the light.
The Night Everything Changed
When Leah said, “Isn’t it enough that you took my husband?” Rachel
finally understood. She answered, ָלכֵּן י ְִּשכַב עִ מָ ְך הַ ַל ְּילָה: then he will be
with you tonight. This time she gave with her whole heart, and that’s
when Leah conceived Yissachar.
Then Leah returned the kindness. Chazal tell us that when Leah was
Ohr Yosef Jealousy and Forgiveness Vayeitzei p4
expecting again, she realized that if this child were a boy, her sister would
have fewer sons than even the maidservants. So, Leah davened for her
sister, and the baby was born a girl, Dinah.
Right after that, the Torah says, ֹלהים ֶאת ָרחֵּ ל
ִ ֱ ַויִזְּ כֹר א: Hashem
remembered Rachel, and Yosef was born.
Two sisters made room for each other, and the blessing came back to
both of them.
Their Light Is Our Light
Most of us are not jealous of anyone’s goodness. Our jealousy is usually
over smaller things: a neighbor’s success, a friend’s simcha, someone
else’s home, children, or parnassah. If even Rachel’s pure jealousy could
hold back blessing, how much more can ours.
The way out is the one Yaakov showed Rachel. When we see someone
else blessed, we can choose to be truly happy for them. Their light does
not dim ours. It makes the whole room brighter. And very often, as Rachel
found, being happy for someone else is what opens the door to our own
blessing.
May we merit to look at others with a generous eye and to share in each
other’s joy, until Hashem remembers all of us as He remembered Rachel,
with the coming of Moshiach, בִ ְּמהֵּ ָרה בְּ יָמֵּ ינּו, amen.
