gilyoines.com

Dear Talmid - English

Week: Vayetze (2026-11-16)

Dear Talmid - English — Vayetze (2026-11-16)

Open the PDF Download

Text of this gilyon

Going to Yeshiva nowadays is almost a given. It has become the norm, and the natural next step a�er finishing school is to go to Yeshiva. Perhaps because this is simply what we do, and not necessarily the result of an ac�ve choice, we don't always stop to think about what being in Yeshiva actually does for us. In this week's sedra, Yaakov takes stones and places them around his head. Rashi brings from the Gemara that the stones began quarrelling, each one wan�ng to be the one upon which Yaakov would rest his head. Hashem then made a miracle, and all the stones became one. What can we learn from this? There is a beau�ful Chasam Sofer (Toras Moshe) that I would like to share with you. He brings Rashi (Devarim 16:22), who explains that a ‫ מצבה‬was used numerous �mes by the Avos. However, later on, Hashem commanded us, "‫"לא תקים לך מצבה אשר שנא ה' אלקיך‬. A ‫ מצבה‬is not allowed, and one may only use a ‫מזבה‬. What changed? Why was a ‫ מצבה‬beloved in the �mes of the Avos, yet later became something that Hashem despised? The Chasam Sofer explains that a ‫ מצבה‬is made from one large stone, whereas a ‫ מזבח‬is made up of mul�ple stones placed together. The ‫ מצבה‬represents an individual serving Hashem on his own, while the ‫ מזבח‬represents a tzibbur of people serving Hashem together. Originally, in the �mes of the Avos, when there were only individuals, this was the appropriate form of Avodas Hashem. Hashem appreciated each of them for their own unique form of Avodah. However, once Yaakov established the twelve Sheva�m, the nature of our Avodah changed. From then on, Hashem wanted us to serve Him through a ‫ – מזבח‬with mul�ple people coming together to serve Him as one. The Chasam Sofer explains that this is what the Gemara is teaching us when it tells us that all the stones became one. The Ramban writes that the twelve stones represented the twelve Sheva�m that Yaakov would soon have, who would eventually unite to become one na�on. This was symbolic of the new form of Avodas Hashem: going forward, all twelve Sheva�m would work together in their Avodas Hashem, joining together to form one unified na�on. According to the Chasam Sofer, this teaches us that the appropriate form of Avodas Hashem nowadays is specifically through being part of a Yeshiva, rather than everyone serving Hashem as an individual, independently of one another. Some�mes, a bochur may be tempted to forge his own path and deviate from the Yeshiva's approach to learning or its established sedarim. However, this misses the point. As the Gemara tells us (Berachos 63b), "‫ – "אין התורה נקנית אלא בחבורה‬Torah is only acquired when it is learnt together as a chaburah. It is when everyone joins together that we can truly sh�eg. The same is true in the opposite direc�on. There are bochurim who are figh�ng an inner batle against fully conforming to the Yeshiva. They may even find themselves doing things they shouldn't, simply because they are desperately trying not to follow what everyone else in the Yeshiva is doing. This too is a big mistake. Whilst in Yeshiva, one of the best things a bochur can do is let go of that resistance and allow himself to be absorbed into the collec�ve avoda of the tzibbur. Of course, this doesn't mean that there is no room for individuality within the tzibbur. Everyone has their own unique teva and kochos and each person will ul�mately serve Hashem in their own way. However, this individuality needs to find expression within the framework of the Yeshiva and its seder hayom. Ul�mately, when we are part of a tzibbur and push ourselves to become fully immersed in it, we discover and develop kochos we may never have known we possessed. Being part of something bigger than ourselves pushes us to stretch ourselves and reach madreigos that we may never have thought possible. So, let us each bring our own individuality, but firmly place ourselves within the tzibbur. In doing so, we will be able to sh�eg together to tremendous heights! To join the hundreds of subscribers who receive this publication via email, email ‘subscribe’ to nezerweekly@gmail.com