gilyoines.com

Parsha Perspective

Week: Vayetze (2026-11-16)

Parsha Perspective — Vayetze (2026-11-16)

Open the PDF Download

Text of this gilyon

‫בס״ד‬ ‫פרשת ויצא‬ Parsha ‫כוחה של הודאה והנהגה אמיתית‬ Perspective ‫ ותהר עוד ותלד בן ותאמר הפעם אודה את השם על כן קראה שמו‬:‫בראשית כט לה‬ The ability to acknowledge one's mistakes is a virtue for every ‫יהודה ותעמד מלדת‬ individual, but it is especially critical for those entrusted with positions of leadership. An individual who refuses to recognize his I n this week’s ‫פרשה‬, we read of the birth of ‫יהודה‬, whose name was inspired by ‫’לאה‬s declaration, ‫ הפעם אודה את השם‬this time I will give thanks to ‫השם‬. errors and correct course risks harming himself and those affected by ‫ בס״ד‬refuses to acknowledge his his decisions. A leader who stubbornly mistakes, however, risks inflicting damage on an entire community or society. It is said that “A good general is not one who never makes a The word ‫ אודה‬is commonly understood as an expression of praise mistake, but one who has the wisdom to recognize it and the courage or thanksgiving. ‫ רש"י‬explains that ‫’לאה‬s gratitude stemmed from her to change course.” recognition that, with the birth of her fourth son, she had received more than her expected share of the twelve ‫שבטים‬. Had the ‫ שבטים‬been The ‫ גמרא‬in ‫ הוריות‬teaches, ‫אשרי הדור שהנשיא שלו מביא קרבן על שגגתו‬ divided equally among ‫’יעקב‬s four wives ‫ בלהה‬,‫ לאה‬,‫רחל‬, and ‫זלפה‬, each praiseworthy is the generation whose leader is willing to acknowledge would have borne three sons. With ‫’יהודה‬s birth, ‫ לאה‬had been blessed his wrongdoing and bring a ‫ קרבן חטאת‬for his transgression. with more than her allotted portion, prompting her to offer special thanks to ‫השם‬. The ‫ גמרא‬goes a step further, highlighting another essential dimension of leadership: the power of personal example. If a ‫נשיא‬, despite his ‫ מעתה עלי להודות‬,‫רש"י הפעם אודה שנטלתי יותר מחלקי‬ elevated position and authority, is willing to humble himself and acknowledge his failings, how much more so will ordinary members However, the ‫ תרגום יונתן‬in ‫ פרשת ויחי‬introduces another dimension to of the community be inspired to do the same. A leader's willingness the name ‫יהודה‬. The word ‫ אודה‬can also be understood as an expression to admit error thus serves a dual purpose: it enables him to correct of ‫הודאה‬, the willingness to acknowledge one's mistakes and admit his own mistakes while cultivating a culture of humility, honesty, and wrongdoing. When confronted with the incident involving ‫ תמר‬we accountability among those he leads. find that ‫ יהודה‬showed moral courage by publicly acknowledging his responsibility and declaring, ‫צדקה ממני‬, she is more righteous than I. ‫ ת"ר אשר נשיא יחטא אמר ריב"ז אשרי הדור שהנשיא שלו מביא קרבן על‬:‫הוריות דף י‬ The ‫ תרגום יונתן‬connects this remarkable act of admission to the ‫ברכה‬ ‫שגגתו אם נשיא שלו מביא קרבן צריך אתה לומר מהו הדיוט ואם על שגגתו מביא קרבן‬ that ‫ יעקב‬bestowed upon ‫יהודה‬, through which he was designated for ‫צריך אתה לומר מהו זדונו‬ kingship. It was precisely this ability to acknowledge his own failings, even at the expense of his personal dignity, that distinguished ‫ יהודה‬and The ‫ מלבי"ם‬emphasizes that this very quality enabled ‫ דוד המלך‬to retain made him uniquely suited to the responsibilities of leadership. his kingship despite his transgression. ‫דוד המלך‬, a descendant of ‫יהודה‬, ‫ יהודה אנת אודיתא על עובדא דתמר בגין כן לך יהודון אחך‬:‫תרגום יונתן בראשית מט ח‬ demonstrated the same willingness to acknowledge wrongdoing that ‫ויתקרון יהודאין על שמך ידך יתפרעון לך מבעלי דבבך למפתק גירין להון כד יחזרון קדל‬ had distinguished his ancestor. When confronted by ‫נתן הנביא‬, he did ‫קדמך ויהון מקדימין למישאל בשלמך בני אבוך‬ not attempt to justify his actions or shift responsibility elsewhere. Instead, ‫ דוד המלך‬immediately declared, ‫חטאתי להשם‬: I have sinned This sentiment is echoed by the ‫מדרש לקח טוב‬, which also explains against Hashem. that the name ‫ יהודה‬reflects the courage to acknowledge wrongdoing and accept responsibility for one's actions. It was precisely this In contrast, when ‫ שאול המלך‬was confronted by ‫ שמואל הנביא‬over his moral courage, demonstrated by ‫ יהודה‬in his admission concerning failure to fulfill Hashem's command concerning ‫עמלק‬, he initially ‫תמר‬, that earned him the respect and recognition of his brothers, who sought to justify his actions and deflect responsibility. This failure accepted him as their leader. His willingness to admit his failings did to readily acknowledge his wrongdoing contributed to his loss of the not diminish his stature; on the contrary, it was the very quality that kingship. established his fitness for leadership. The contrast between these two kings underscores a fundamental ‫ שנא' הפעם אודה את‬.‫ על שהודת לאה אמו‬.‫ יהודה שמו הודאה‬.‫ יהודה אתה יודוך אחיך‬:‫מדרש לקח טוב‬ principle of leadership: the ability to acknowledge one's mistakes is .‫ לפיכך אתה יודוך‬.‫ והוא בעצמו הודה במעשה תמר ולא בוש‬.(‫ה' על כן קראה שמו יהודה )בראשית כט לה‬ not a sign of weakness, but an essential qualification for retaining the ‫ שאתה מלך עליהם‬.‫ ולפיכך יודוך אחיך‬.‫כלומר אתה הודת על האמת והצלת את תמר מלישרף‬ trust and authority of leadership. BASED ON THE CHUMASH SHIUR OF R' AVROHOM AARON ELIAS ADDITIONAL SHIURIM AVAILABLE AT CHUMASHSHIUR.COM ‫בס״ד‬ Parsha Perspective ‫ ששאול נתן אמתלאות על חטאו‬,‫ זה היה ההבדל בין דוד ובין שאול‬.‫ ויאמר דוד‬:‫מלבים‬ A similar point is made by ‫רבינו יונה‬, who explains that the objective ‫ ודוד הודה תיכף ולא השיב‬,‫ כג( ואון ותרפים הפצר‬,‫ כמ"ש )ש"א טו‬,‫ולכן נגזר עליו עונש‬ of a ‫ חכם‬is not to win arguments or vindicate his own position, but ‫ והודיעו הנביא שהשם קבל תשובתו‬,‫שעשה הכל בהיתר‬ to arrive at the truth. When presented with a compelling argument that exposes an error in his reasoning, he does not stubbornly The idea expressed by the ‫ מלבי"ם‬is found earlier in the ‫מדרש תהילים‬, defend his original position merely to preserve his pride. Rather, which applies the words of ‫ משלי‬of ‫ מכסה פשעיו לא יצליח‬to ‫שאול המלך‬, he willingly acknowledges his mistake and embraces the truth. who sought to justify his wrongdoing, while associating ‫ דוד המלך‬with For a genuine ‫חכם‬, conceding an argument is not a defeat; the ‫ומודה ועוזב ירוחם‬, praising his willingness to acknowledge his mistakes pursuit of truth, rather than the preservation of one's ego, is the and repent. ultimate measure of ‫ חכמה‬and intellectual integrity. ‫ ויאמר‬.‫ דבר אחר מכסה פשעיו זה שאול שנאמר ומה קול הצאן הזה באזני‬:‫מדרש תהילים‬ ‫ גם כי יחכם לידע להשיב מרוב טענותיו ושכל‬.‫ ומודה על האמת‬:‫רבינו יונה‬ ‫ ומודה ועוזב ירוחם זה דוד שאמר ויאמר דוד לאלקים הלא אנכי‬.‫שאול מעמלקי הביאום‬ ‫ ולא יעשה כן אם יראה לו כי‬.‫דבריו ויכול לסתור טענת חברו כי לא נחכם כמוהו‬ ‫ מיד אמר לו גם השם העביר חטאתך‬.‫חטאתי תהי נא ידך בי‬ ‫האמת עמו אך יודה לדבריו ולא יחוש מן הנצחון וכבוד הוא אליו כי היא מדה נאה‬ ‫ והגולם לא יחשוב בזה והדבר הוא אליו לבזיון כשהוא מנוצח‬.‫ומקובלת‬ The ‫ גמרא‬in ‫ סוטה‬states that both ‫ יהודה‬and ‫ ראובן‬acknowledged their wrongdoing and, in that merit, were ‫ זוכה‬to be ‫נוחל חיי העולם הבא‬. A powerful illustration of this principle is found in the ‫ גמרא‬in Additionally, ‫ יהודה‬merited kingship in this world as a reward for his ‫עירובין‬, which recounts how ‫ רבא‬publicly acknowledged an error willingness to admit his mistake. in a halachic ruling he had previously taught. When his ruling was challenged based on a ‫ברייתא‬, he did not attempt to defend ‫ ראובן‬.‫ מה היה סופו נחל חיי העולם הבא‬,‫ יהודה הודה ולא בוש‬:‫מסכת סוטה דף ז עמוד ב‬ his position or evade the question. Instead, he assembled his ‫ ומה שכרן מה שכרן כדקא אמרינן‬.‫ מה היה סופו נחל חיי העולם הבא‬,‫הודה ולא בוש‬ audience and openly declared,‫ דברים שאמרתי לפניכם טעות הן בידי‬the ‫ להם לבדם נתנה הארץ ולא עבר זר בתוכם‬,‫ מה שכרן בעולם הזה‬:‫אלא‬ words I previously taught you were mistaken. The ‫ משנה‬in ‫ אבות‬further underscores the importance of acknowledging ‫ אמר‬.‫ דרש רבא חצר שנתקלקלה במימי גשמים מביא תבן ומרדה בה‬:‫עירובין קד‬ the truth. It enumerates seven characteristics of a ‫ חכם‬and seven ‫ אינו מרדה לא בסל ולא בקופה אלא‬- ‫ והתניא כשהוא מרדה‬,‫ליה רב פפא לרבא‬ contrasting characteristics of a ‫גולם‬. Among the defining qualities of ‫ דברים שאמרתי לפניכם טעות‬:‫בשולי קופה! הדר אוקים רבא אמורא עליה ודרש‬ a ‫ חכם‬is ‫ומודה על האמת‬, the willingness to acknowledge the truth, even ‫ וכשהוא מרדה אינו מרדה לא בסל ולא‬:‫ ברם כך אמרו משום רבי אליעזר‬,‫הן בידי‬ when doing so requires admitting one's own mistakes. Conversely, ‫בקופה אלא בשולי קופה‬. the inability to concede the truth characterizes a ‫גולם‬. The ‫ משנה‬thus teaches that true wisdom is measured not merely by one's knowledge The ability to acknowledge one's mistakes, accept responsibility, or intellectual abilities, but also by the humility and integrity to and correct course is thus not merely an admirable character trait, recognize when one is wrong. but an indispensable quality of sound leadership. It is unfortunate ,‫ ועל מה שלא שמע אומר לא שמעתי‬... ‫ שבעה דברים בגולם ושבעה בחכם‬:‫ז‬:‫אבות ה‬ when people find themselves led by political leaders who seem ‫ וחילופיהן בגולם‬,‫ומודה על האמת‬ incapable of recognizing past errors, accepting responsibility for their mistakes, or acknowledging the consequences of their The ‫רמב"ם‬, in his ‫פירוש המשניות‬, elaborates on this quality, explaining decisions. Bravado, bluster, and an unwillingness to concede that a ‫ חכם‬readily acknowledges his error upon recognizing that he is error may project an image of strength, but they are no substitute mistaken. Rather than defending an untenable position, he accepts the for wisdom, humility, and responsible leadership. True strength truth, even when it contradicts his previous understanding. He does not lies not in insisting that one is always right, but in possessing resort to spurious arguments, deflection, or intellectual maneuvering the courage to admit when one is wrong and the resolve to make designed to confuse the issue and obscure the truth. the necessary corrections. May we be ‫ זוכה‬to live in a generation worthy of the ‫’גמרא‬s praise,‫אשרי הדור שהנשיא שלו מביא קרבן על‬ ‫ ולא יתעקש אבל כשישמע האמת יודהו ואפילו במה שולא‬:‫רמב"ם פירוש המשנה‬ ‫שגגתו‬, a generation blessed with leaders who have the humility to ‫ ואפילו במה שאפשר לו לדחות ולחלוק ולהטעות‬,‫ אבל כשישמע האמת יודהו‬,‫יתעקש‬ acknowledge their mistakes, the integrity to accept responsibility, ‫ וזהו אמרו ומודה על האמת‬,‫לא ירצה לעשותו‬ and the courage to change course when necessary. BASED ON THE CHUMASH SHIUR OF R' AVROHOM AARON ELIAS ADDITIONAL SHIURIM AVAILABLE AT CHUMASHSHIUR.COM