gilyoines.com Back to the site · חזרה לאתר

HaIchud B'chidud Riddles - English — Vayetze (2026-11-16)

Publisher: HaIchud B'chidud Riddles - English

Week: Vayetze (2026-11-16)

HaIchud B'chidud Riddles - English — Vayetze (2026-11-16)

Open the PDF Download

‫בס"ד‬  ‫פרשת ויצא תשפ"ז‬ 4:19 ‫הדלקת נרות‬ 8:40/9:16 ‫סזק"ש‬ ‫ זמנים‬are for Lakewood, NJ Volume 28 Issue 07 ‫דבר תורה‬ '‫בראשית כ"ח י‬..‫ויצא יעקב מבאר שבע וילך חרנה‬ About 200 years ago, there lived a wealthy Yid who left over in his ‫צוואה‬, a tremendous ‫ קרן‬to do a lot of good things for ‫כלל ישראל‬. Among them, he appointed an executor to take from the ‫ פירות‬of the ‫( קרן‬interest) and support a future ‫ פוסק‬in ‫כלל ישראל‬. They were to find an extremely intelligent ‫בחור‬ between the ages of 10 & 15, who had a big ‫ חשק‬to become great, and support him with 200 ‫ זהובים‬per year to help him learn & grow in ‫ תורה‬till he’s 25 years old, and by then he will be ready to be a ‫ פוסק‬in ‫כלל ישראל‬. One major stipulation in this agreement was that the ‫ ישיבה‬that he goes to must be an out-of- town ‫ישיבה‬. The ‫ אפוטרפסים‬did a major search in the entire country, & found a very special boy, a son to one of the ‫ רבנים‬of the country who was ‫מסכים‬ to let his son learn out of the country!! Sure enough, the ‫ בחור‬went to this ‫ ישיבה‬in ‫ אשכנז‬and truly Shteiged wonderfully!! After a year and a half, the ‫ראש‬ ‫ ישיבה‬of that ‫ ישיבה‬was ‫נפטר‬. The ‫ ישיבה‬fell apart, and most of the ‫ בחורים‬went home, and so too did our special ‫בחור‬. He brought home with him a ‫ יתום‬who he befriended in ‫ ישיבה‬who now became his full time ‫חברותא‬. The ‫‘בחור‬s father Farherred them & was very impressed with their knowledge & the father now told the ‫ אפוטרופסים‬that he doesn’t agree to send them again to an out-of-town ‫ !!ישיבה‬He says they were ‫ יוצא‬that ‫ חלק‬of the ‫צוואה‬. He also claims that he’ll learn with them and in 5 years they will be ‫ בקיאים‬in ‫ אורח חיים‬and ‫ !!יורה דעה‬Another benefit he claims is that, with these 200 Zehuvim, the ‫ נפטר‬will be getting double ‫ זכותים‬for he can support both his son and the ‫ יתום‬with this money. Now the ‫ אפוטרפסים‬have a bona fide ‫ !!שאלה‬Are they ‫ מחוייב‬to start their search all over again, or can they continue to give the money to this ‫??בחור‬ Since everyone in the country knew who the father was, they decided to send this ‫ שאלה‬to the ‫!!חתם סופר‬ The ‫ חתם סופר‬divides their ‫ שאלה‬into 5 ‫חלקים‬. 1. ‫ בכלל‬is there a ‫ מעלה‬in an out-of-town ‫ ישיבה‬that the ‫ גביר‬was so adamant about? 2. Did they fulfill this ‫ חיוב‬with a year and a half? 3. Is the fact that now it will support 2 people, beneficial for keeping it by them? 4. Is it stealing from a ‫ בחור עני‬because someone else would be getting the money?? 5. Is there a problem here with ‫??מצוה לקיים דברי המת‬ In the first ‫שאלה‬, if ‫ בכלל‬there is a ‫ מעלה‬of an “out-of-town ‫ ?“ישיבה‬The ‫ חתם סופר‬brings the famous ‫ גמ' מגילה סוף פ"א‬that says ‫גדולה ת"ת יותר‬ ‫מכיבוד או"א‬, because ‫ יעקב‬was away for 36 years and was only punished for 22 years. For 14 years, he wasn’t punished!!!! So the ‫ גמרא‬is trying to bring a ‫ראיה‬ that for the 14 years that ‫ יעקב‬learned in ‫ישיבת עבר‬, he wasn’t punished & ‫גדולה ת"ת יותר מכא"א‬. Fregt der ‫חתם סופר‬, ‫מהיכי תיתי‬, maybe he was punished for those 14 years & ‫גדולה כאו"א יותר מת"ת‬, and I have another 14 years for you! Maybe, ‫ גדולה פרו ורבו יותר מכא"א‬since the 7 years for ‫ & לאה‬the 7 years for ‫ רחל‬were in order to be ‫ & מקיים פרו ורבו‬those were the 14 years that he wasn’t punished for! Doesn’t the ‫ תורה‬tell us by ‫פרו ורבו‬, ‫על כן יעזב איש את אביו ואת‬ ‫ !!!אמו ודבק באשתו‬The ‫ חתם סופר‬answers, that he could have been ‫ מקיים פרו ורבו‬while at home (doing ‫ כאו"א‬too), but he caused himself to do it on the run because he started up with ‫עשו‬. He deserved to get punished a little for it. But to learn in an out-of-town ‫ישיבה‬, that great level of learning, one cannot achieve in an “in-town ‫“ישיבה‬. Therefore, ‫ יעקב‬couldn’t stay at home and do ‫ כיבוד אב ואם‬if he wanted to get this great ‫ מדרגה‬of ‫תורה‬. We see that since he didn’t get punished for these 14 years, we see the great ‫ מעלה‬of an out-of-town ‫( !!ישיבה‬The ‫ מהרש"א‬in ‫ סנהדרין י"ט‬says that ‫ ישיבת עבר‬was in-town, also in ‫!)באר שבע‬ (In the end, the ‫ חתם סופר‬says that they should stay with these two Gevaldige ‫בחורים‬, by being ‫ מצטרף‬all of the above reasons!!! Please look up this ‫ חתם סופר‬in '‫)שו"ת חת"ס חו"מ תשובה ח' & ט‬. ‫ חידות‬ON ‫פרשת ויצא‬ These ‫ חידות‬are intended only for people who feel they know ‫ פ' ויצא‬in their sleep so they have no need to learn it again! 1. On what day of the year were ‫ רחל & לאה‬born? 2. What 3 ‫ הלכות‬do we learn from the stone under ‫’יעקב‬s head? (Heard from ‫ר' יצחק איזבי זצ"ל‬.) 3. How many rungs were on the ladder & how wide was it? 4. In what way are the stones that ‫ יעקב‬put by his head different than stones found in Lakewood? 5. ‫ויצק שמן על ראשה‬. If ‫ אליפז‬cleaned him out & left him just with his stick, where did he get oil from? 6. What body part mentioned twice in ‫ פ' ויצא‬is immortal & why? Where is it located in the body? 7. What did the ‫ דודאים‬that ‫ ראובן‬brought ‫ לאה‬look like? 8. Which ‫ פסוק‬in ‫ חומש שמות‬is the proof that ‫ רחל‬didn’t lie to her father? 9. ‫ ומי שאין לו בנים‬,‫ סומא‬,‫ מצורע‬,‫ עני‬-‫ד' חשובים כמת‬. Where do we find this concept 4 times in ‫?פ' ויצא‬ 10. Which 2 items mentioned in ‫ פ' ויצא‬did ‫ לבן‬get punished with, later on in life? ANSWERS 1. The ‫ סדר עולם פ"ב‬says that ‫ לאה & רחל‬were born on the same day that ‫ יצחק‬Bentched ‫יעקב‬. The ‫ ברכות‬were given on ‫ליל פסח‬, so their birthday was ‫ !ט"ו ניסן‬In ‫ב"ר וישלח ל"ה י"ט‬, we find this same concept a little differently. ‫ לבן‬at the time of the ‫ ברכות‬had no children & he was at least 90 years old. (‫ יעקב‬left ‫ באר שבע‬to go to ‫ חרן‬when he was 63. ‫ רבקה‬was 23 when she had ‫ יעקב‬so she was 86 when ‫ יעקב‬left. And ‫ לבן‬was charge d'affaires making decisions for ‫ רבקה‬when she was 3!) The ‫ ס' הישר‬says ‫ אשת לבן‬was an ‫ !עקרה‬The ‫ ילקוט מעם לועז‬says that ‫’לבן‬s wife’s name was ‫ דינה‬while the ‫ ס' הישר‬says her name was ‫ !עדינה‬Says the ‫ מדרש רבה‬that when ‫ יצחק‬said the words ‫וקח לך אשה משם מבנות לבן‬, at that moment ‫ אשת לבן‬became expecting twins! However, ‫ רבינו בחיי‬learns that ‫ רחל & לאה‬were born years later & when ‫ יעקב‬arrived in ‫בית לבן‬, ‫ רחל‬was 5 years old! That is why ‫ יעקב‬offered to work 7 years as she would then be ‫ ראויה‬to have children. When ‫ יעקב‬left ‫באר שבע‬, they weren’t born yet & that’s why ‫ יעקב‬went to learn in ‫ ישיבת עבר‬for 14 years! 2. 1. In ‫שו"ע או"ח סי" תקנ"ה ס"ב‬, the ‫ רמ"א‬tells us that there is a ‫ מנהג‬to sleep with a stone under your head on ‫ט' באב‬. The reason for this is that ‫יעקב‬ ‫ אבינו‬slept on a stone and the ‫ מדרש‬tells us that he saw the ‫ חורבן‬at that time. 2. There is a ‫ דין‬that ‫ אין מורידין מקדושה חמורה לקדושה קלה‬- one may not use something with a greater ‫ קדושה‬for something which requires a lesser ‫קדושה‬. For this reason, the ‫ תפילין‬worn on the head may not be used as ‫ תפילין‬to be worn on the arm. For this reason, if the ‫ רצועה‬of the ‫ תפילין של יד‬tears, the ‫ מגן אברהם‬says you may not be able to switch around the strap so that what was at the bottom wrapped around the fingers will now be near the top, near the ‫ בית‬itself. The ‫אליה רבה‬, however, says that it is ‫ מותר‬to reverse the strap and he proves it from ‫'יעקב‬s stone. When ‫ יעקב‬took one stone and put it under his head, the other stones started to argue that they should be the ones under ‫'יעקב‬s head. '‫ ד‬made a miracle and they all became one big stone. Let's analyze this. We now have one big stone which is made up of many smaller stones. However, ‫'יעקב‬s head is only resting on one part of the big stone. The other stones, which are connected to this part, still don't have ‫'יעקב‬s head resting on them. So, what did they gain by being connected? It must be, says the ‫אליה רבה‬, that when they're all connected together, they are all considered as one and what happens to one happens to all. In other words, they all have the same ‫קדושה‬. Therefore, the ‫ רצועה‬has the same ‫ קדושה‬all over - on the top and on the bottom - and there is no problem with switching the top to the bottom or vice versa. However, the ‫ שערי תשובה‬disagrees and says that since this was a ‫נס‬, it is ‫ שייך‬that what happened was not that the stones were all connected together but rather they were all mixed together and that every part of the huge stone was made up of fragments of each of the other stones. In addition, he says, you can't bring proof from ‫אגדה‬. '‫עיין בשע"ת סי" מ"ב אות ב‬ 3. The ‫ חתם סופר‬asks, how could ‫ יעקב‬have slept on the stone? The ‫ מדרש‬says that the stones were the same ones used as a ‫ מזבח‬for ‫ יצחק‬at the ‫עקידה‬. If so, it would be ‫ אסור‬for ‫ יעקב‬to use it for his personal purposes. However, ‫ רש"י‬says that the stones were placed around his head not under it. From this we see that just using it for protection is not considered ‫ מעילה‬- using something of ‫הקדש‬. ‫ ובמה שכתוב עלי‬.'‫שו"ת חתם סופר או"ח סימן מ‬ :‫יניח צדיק עיין בחתם סופר על התורה בהג"ה ובמהרש"א חולין צ"א‬ 3. From the ‫ רד"ל‬on ‫ בר"ר פס"ח י"ב‬is ‫ משמע‬that he is learning that the ‫ מדרש‬holds there were 3 rungs on the ladder. The ‫ רמב"ם‬in ‫מורה נבוכים ח"ב פ"י‬ brings from the ‫ מדרש תנוחומא‬that there were 4 rungs on the ladder. The ‫ רמב"ן‬brings the ‫ & רמב"ם‬the ‫ & כלי יקר‬the ‫ילקוט ראובני בשם המגלה עמוקות‬ also says 4 rungs. However, the ‫ רמ"א‬in his ‫ מחיר יין על מגילת אסתר א' י"ד‬brings the ‫ רמב"ם בשם קצת נוסחאות‬that there were 7 rungs on the ‫ !סולם‬The ‫ רמב"ם‬there says that only 2 ‫ מלאכים‬went up the ladder side by side while 2 more ‫ מלאכים‬were coming down, side by side & when they met, it was 4 ‫ מלאכים‬across on one rung! We know from the ‫ נבואה‬of ‫יחזקאל‬, that a ‫ מלאך‬is 2000 ‫ פרסאות‬wide which is ⅓ of the world. If so, the ladder was 8000 ‫ פרסאות‬wide! This 64,000,000 ‫ אמות‬or 32,000 ‫מיל‬. 4. The .‫ גמ' כתובות קי"ב‬tells us that ‫ ר' חנינא‬was ‫ מתקל מתקליה‬which '‫ תוס‬explains, that when ‫ ר' חנינא‬went from ‫ בבל‬up to ‫ & ארץ ישראל‬he wanted to know if he was already in ‫ארץ ישראל‬, he would pick up stones & weigh them. If they were light, he knew he wasn’t in ‫ א"י‬yet as ‫ אבני ארץ ישראל‬are heavier than ‫ !אבני חוץ לארץ‬When they became heavier, he would kiss them! ‫ ר' יהונתן אייבשיץ‬says that’s why ‫ יעקב‬took ‫ מאבני המקום‬as since he had ‫ קפיצת הדרך‬from ‫ חוץ לארץ‬to ‫הר המוריה‬, he didn’t know if he was back in ‫ ארץ ישראל‬yet. ‫ויקח מאבני המקום‬, he weighed the stones & he knew! 5. The ‫ פענח רזא‬answers that ‫ אליפז‬left him with his ‫ מקל‬which was hollow & ‫ יעקב‬always stored oil in it in order to always be able to learn when it’s dark! However, in '‫ פרקי דר' אליעזר ל"ה & בר"ר פס"ט ח‬both say that '‫ ד‬sent him down oil from ‫ !שמים‬The ‫ ש"ך עה"ת‬agrees & says when ‫ יעקב‬poured out the oil, the ‫ כד‬refilled automatically with heavenly oil! He took it along with him & this was the oil they used for the ‫משכן‬, the ‫כלים‬, the ‫מזבח‬, ‫ & אהרן ובניו‬the ‫ !מלכים‬This was also the ‫ כד שמן‬of the ‫אשה הצרפית‬. In the 400-year-old (:‫ס' ברכת שמואל )מקץ כ"ה‬, he adds to the ‫ ש"ך‬that this was the ‫ פח שמן‬found by the ‫ & חשמונאים‬it is still ‫ גנוז‬for the ‫עתיד‬, ‫!בקרוב בימינו‬ 6. ‫ ר' אלעזר מגרמיזא עה"ת‬writes on the ‫ פסוק‬of ‫ ולוז שם העיר לראשונה‬that the ‫ לוז‬bone is the ‫ שורש‬of the person & when a person dies & decomposes, the ‫ לוז‬bone remains untouched! It doesn’t get burned, ground or smashed! From it, the person will have ‫ !תחיית המתים‬The '‫ & בית יוסף או"ח ש‬the '‫ ט"ז שם ס"ק א‬bring from the ‫ שבלי הלקט‬that it’s also called ‫ & ניסכא‬it only has ‫ הנאה‬from the ‫ סעודה‬of ‫ !מוצאי שבת‬The '‫ אליה רבה ס"ק ג‬says that when ‫ אדם הראשון‬ate from the ‫ עץ הדעת‬on ‫ערב שבת‬, the entire body had ‫ הנאה‬from it except the ‫ לוז‬bone which only eats on ‫ !מוצ"ש‬Therefore, the entire body was punished with ‫ מיתה‬except the ‫ לוז‬bone! ‫ רש"י‬on '‫ בר"ר פכ"ח ג‬says the ‫ לוז‬bone is on the bottom of the spine. The ‫ ערוך‬agrees. However, the ‫ אריז"ל‬in (‫ & ליקוטי תורה )פ' שופטים‬the ('‫ אור החמה )נח ט‬say that it is located in the area of the ‫!קשר של תפילין‬ 7. ‫ רש"י‬says it’s called in Arabic ‫ – יסמי"ן‬Jasmine! The ‫ יד רמה‬on :‫ סנהדרין צ"ט‬says that these ‫ עשבים‬are in the form of people! Every barren woman that consumes it gets children! The ‫ אבן עזרא‬says ‫ והם על צורת בן אדם‬as they have a head & hands! The '‫ בנין שלמה ח"ב ענינים שונים כ"ו א‬from ‫ר' שלמה‬ ‫ הכהן מוילנא‬says that “I myself saw ‫ דודאים‬that someone brought from ‫ יפו בארץ ישראל‬to Vilna, and they really look like people! Their head has a mouth, nose, forehead & an actual face! It also has hands & feet & even a thigh! From the back, they look like regular people! 8. The ‫ מסורות הש"ס‬brings in his (‫ ס' הפלאה שבערכין )ערך תרף‬a ‫ חידוש‬in the name of his sister ‫המלומדת מופלגת מאד ביראה ובחכמה מרת קרינדל ז"ל‬, that ‫ חס ושלום‬to say that ‫ רחל‬lied to her father! Rather, the ‫ פסוק‬says ‫ & מכשפה לא תחיה‬the .‫ גמ' סנהדרין ס"ז‬asks if man is also ‫אסור בכישוף‬, why does it say ‫בלשון נקבה‬, ‫ ?מכשפה‬The ‫ גמרא‬answers that ‫ רחל !מפני שרוב נשים מצויות בכשפים‬was talking about the ‫ & תרפים‬her ‫ כוונה‬was ‫ כי דרך נשים‬which is ‫מצויות בכשפים‬, I have, ‫ !לי‬I have the ‫ ר' ישעיה פיק !תרפים‬ends with, ‫!אמרתי לאחותי חכמה את‬ 9. 1) ‫ רחל‬said ‫ !הבה לי בנים ואם אין מתה אנכי‬2) ‫ויחבק לו וינשק לו‬, ‫ לבן‬saw that ‫ יעקב‬came empty handed & ‫ חז"ל‬tell us that ‫ אליפז‬was convinced by ‫ יעקב‬to take his possessions in lieu of killing him as ‫ !עני חשוב כמת‬3) The ‫ פסוק‬says ‫ רש"י & לולי אלקי אבי אלקי אברהם ופחד יצחק‬says even though '‫ ד‬is not ‫מייחד‬ His Name on a live ‫צדיק‬, but since ‫ יצחק‬was a ‫ & סומא‬a ‫ סומא‬is ‫ חשוב כמת‬it was ok! 4) ‫ יעקב‬said ‫את אשר תמצא את אלהיך לא יחיה‬. Why did he use ‫'לא‬ '‫ ?יחיה‬Why didn’t ‫ יעקב‬say '‫ ?'ימות‬I heard from my brother ‫ר' אהרן ברוך שליט"א‬, that the 1st ‫ שטיקעל תורה‬that ‫ לבן‬heard from ‫ יעקב‬was ‫עני חשוב כמת‬. (See (2)). ‫ יעקב‬knew that ‫ לבן‬didn’t forget that. If ‫ יעקב‬would say ‫ימות‬, ‫ לבן‬would tell him, I know what your ‫ ימות‬is all about!! ‫ממילא‬, ‫ יעקב‬had to be very explicit, ‫!לא יחיה‬ 10. The ‫ דעת זקנים‬says on the ‫ פסוק‬of '‫עד הגל הזה וגו‬, that since ‫יד העדים תהיה בו בראשונה‬, a person who is ‫ משקר באמונתם‬will get punished through the ‫ עדים‬as we see in the .'‫ גמ' תענית ח‬with the story of the ‫( !בור & חולדה‬A girl got stuck in a well & a boy bailed her out with a promise from that she’ll marry him. The 2 ‫ עדים‬were the ‫ באר‬and a ‫חולדה‬. He went away & forgot about it married someone else & had 2 children. One fell into a ‫ & באר‬died. The other got bitten by a ‫& חולדה‬ died. The wife demanded an explanation & he remembered his promise & the ‫ עדים‬that took revenge. He divorced her, found that girl as she was still waiting for him & married her. They had many children together & he became wealthy). Here too, when they made the ‫ברית‬, they put a ‫ חרב‬into the pile of rocks for ‫ !עדות‬Therefore, ‫ בלעם‬who was ‫לבן‬, got punished with both! ‫ & ותלחץ את רגל בלעם אל הקיר‬that ‫ קיר‬was the ‫גל אבנים‬. He also got punished with a sword as it says ‫!ואת בלעם בן בעור הרגו בחרב‬ BE A PARTNER WITH THE ‫איחוד בחידוד‬ If you have any comments or answers to the ‫ חידות‬or the ‫דבר תורה‬, please email me at ichudbchidud@gmail.com. If you would like the English or Hebrew ‫ איחוד בחידוד‬emailed to you at no charge, please send us a request at ichudbchidud@gmail.com !! If you have a great ‫ חידה‬on a future ‫פרשה‬, you may submit it with the answer & we will try to include it.