Lamdanim Gilyon - English — Vayetze (2026-11-16)

נדבת לז"נ רב גדלי' בן רב שמעון מאקס זצ"ל
HASHK AFAH SPONSOR TEXT 646-598-4703 TO SPONSOR Y E A R LY S P O N S O R דקות בעיון כל יום15 הוא היה רגיל לומר צריך כל אדם ללמוד לכה"פ
Are you a
HASHKAFA FROM HG"R GERSHON RIBNER SHLITA
Why Contemporary Times Call
Lamdan?
for Large-Scale Full-Time Learning
QUESTION ?
Should learning full-time for the long term be reserved for yechidim, or is THIS WEEK'S LIVE SHAILA
it for everyone? If someone doesn’t have the ability to learn full-time,
should he stick with it? ו יצא תשפ"ז לפ"ק
ANSWER
There are two different questions here. The first is a general question. Is full-time learning PA R S H A H S P O N S O R TEXT 646-598-4703 TO SPONSOR
for everyone? The second is about someone who’s not being matzliach in learning and
doesn’t have what it takes.
I have a question for the person who doubts his ability to learn. Is there anyone who tries to
make money and, after minimal exertion, gives up and says, “I’m just not cut out for making
money. I don’t have the ability”? Or will his hope of achieving his dream and his deep need to
make money keep him trying again and again, exerting himself more and more until he “The Kiddushin Conundrum” (Mishmeres Chaim)
achieves his aim?
We were all created for amal haTorah, and our Creator does not make mistakes. Every
machine that Hashem created for learning should be highly efficient. Yes, it may be difficult, Regarding all Birchos HaMitzvos, the Beracha must be recited Over
and it requires great effort, but that is the only way to be koneh Torah. One who gives up L’Asiyasan, before the performance of the Mitzvah. If one forgot to
does so only because he does not believe in Torah enough to keep exerting himself until he
achieves proficiency in learning, not because he lacks the ability. make the Beracha beforehand, he may still recite it afterward only
As for the present kollel system, in which multitudes are encouraged to learn full-time, how
did we come to extend it beyond yechidim? For hundreds of years, most of us lived in places if the Mitzvah is a Mitzvah Nimsheches, one that continues to be
like Galitzia, Hungary, Russia, Poland, and Germany, where Yiddishkeit did not mean sitting
and learning. By age 16 or 17, every young man was in the workforce, helping provide for the
fulfilled. For this reason, the Acharonim explain that if one forgot
family. Only a select few, those who showed particular promise of becoming a rav and a gaon to make a Beracha on Tefillin before putting them on, he may
baTorah, stayed in full-time learning. For hundreds of years, this was considered the highest
level of Yiddishkeit in galus. recite the Beracha all day long, as long as he is wearing them. The
What has changed that we need thousands and thousands of kollel men today, all dedicating question is, why don’t we say the same regarding Kiddushin? The
their lives to full-time learning? Originally, when the Satmar Rav came to America, he could
not understand the need for kollel. At the time, he believed that young men should marry at Yesod of the Mitzvah of Kiddushin is the creation of Ishus, and the
18 or 19 and go to work. He was building a community in the traditional way, the way
Yiddishkeit had always been. Ishus certainly continues to exist afterward. It should be
Throughout galus, wherever we were given equal rights or at least recognized as citizens, considered the ultimate Mitzvah Nimsheches! Why, then, does the
there was complete and utter assimilation. When the French offered us full equal rights,
some Gedolei Yisrael advised against joining Napoleon, no matter what he was offering, Rambam (Hilchos Ishus 3:23) pasken that if the Chosson did not
because they foresaw total assimilation, which is what eventually followed. recite the Birchas Eirusin before the Kiddushin, he may not recite
Today in America, we enjoy far more rights than we have at any time since we had our own
malchus, b’zman haBayis. We are enjoying more freedom on every level. However, it afterward?
Yiddishkeit is thriving. What is saving us from assimilation? It’s never been this way.
Throughout the ages, it was only the oppression that kept us segregated and productive in
our own way. In the past, wherever we had rights, as we did in prewar Germany, there was .ריטב"א מכות ח בית יוסף או"ח סימן תל"ב רמב"ם הלכות אישות פרק ג הלכה כ"ג
rampant intermarriage and assimilation.
The only thing saving us is the koach haTorah that comes from thousands of yungerleit
sitting and learning every day. The koach haTorah raises the level of kedusha and subdues
the forces of evil and contamination. People sense it’s something very real and are drawn to
the truth and shleimus of the Torah. This is what is saving Klal Yisrael. Even working baalei
batim are learning much more than ever before, all because of the hashpa’ah from the huge
Do you have a Send it to
movement in Klal Yisrael dedicated to full-time learning. Without this, it would be Mishmar Shailah lamdanim@mishmarshaila.com
to challenge the
impossible to enjoy our rights without assimilation. We need our young men to learn so that
we can withstand the difficulty of being accepted while staying insulated in our world. for a chance to be featured in a
Oilam with? future newsletter!
Zechus Harabbim!
Sponsor this week’s Lamdanim Inc newsletter or HaRav Gershon Ribner’s Hashkafa and connect to thousands of Lomdei
Torah. Dedicate L’iluy Nishmas, L’kovod a Simcha, or to share in the Zechus of the tremendous Rischa d’Oraisa.
Reserve your sponsorship today! (646) 598-4703
FOR COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS ON THE HASHKAFA MIMEON KODESH, TEXT 848-216-6466
TO HEAR THE SHAILA EXPLAINED CALL 917.810.2517
WANT TO BE MEHANEH YOUR OILAM WITH THIS NEWSLETTER? TEXT 646-598-4703 TO SUBSCRIBE TEXT "START" TO 917.810.2517 | HAVE A MEHALECH? SUBMIT IT TO "646-598-4703" BEFORE SUNDAY 1:30 P. M. EST
SEFER SPONSOR SEFER SHEMOS IS SPONSORED ר' חיים צבי בן ר' משה
Haaros
Perhaps the Chiluk is between a Mitzvas aseh, which requires the creation of a
positive Kiyum, and an Issur, which demands Shelilah, the absence of a
Recent week's question & answer
prohibited act. By Shevisas Behemto, the Torah is saying that no part of an
animal belonging to a Yid may perform Melachah. Even if he owns only part of
the animal, that portion is still included in the prohibition, and he must ensure
When Is “Yours” Entirely Yours? (Mishmeres Chaim) that it does not work. By Tzitzis, however, we are trying to create a positive
Chiyuv on a Cheftza. Such a Chiyuv requires a complete Beged that can be
QUESTION considered the Kesus of the Yid. When half the Beged belongs to a Goy, the full
Cheftza necessary to generate that positive Chiyuv is lacking. Thus, a negative
The Minchas Chinuch in Musach HaShabbos asks the following question: prohibition can apply even to partial ownership, while a positive Chiyuv may
Regarding Tzitzis, the Torah writes “Kesuscha,” your garment, and require the entire Cheftza to belong to the Yid. - S. Yachnes
therefore a Talis that is owned in partnership between a Yid and a Goy is
Patur from Tzitzis, just as we find regarding Lulav that a Lulav owned • The Vort may be that by certain Mitzvos, the entire Cheftza shel mitzvah must
B’shutfus with a Goy is not Kosher, since it is not entirely “Lachem.” If so, be attributable to the Yid, without the Goy's ownership being involved. By
why does the Shulchan Aruch (O.C. 246:3) Pasken that a Yid who owns an Tzitzis, if part of the Talis belongs to a Goy, the Yid does not have a complete
animal in partnership with a Goy is Chayiv in Shevisas Behemto on Talis that is Ra'ui for the Mitzvah. There is no Mitzvah on half a Talis, and the
Shabbos? The Torah writes “Behemtecha,” your animal, and we should same concept applies to an Esrog. By Shevisas Behemto, however, the
likewise say that this only applies when the animal belongs entirely to obligation is fundamentally different. The animal is required to refrain from
the Yid, and not when he has a Goy as a partner! (Indeed, R’ Akiva Eiger, working, and that obligation is not undermined by the fact that another person
in his Teshuvos, at the end of Siman 9, is Mesupak whether a Talis owned also owns it. The Yid still has an animal in his possession that is Ra'ui to be held
in partnership with a Goy is Chayav in Tzitzis. The Be’er Heitev brings the back from Melachah. Therefore, even with a Goy as a partner, the Chiyuv of
Mashkeh Eliezer, who holds that it is Patur, while the Imrei Binah, O.C. 8, Shevisas Behemto remains. - Dovid Shunt, BMG
holds that it is Chayav.) What is the Sevara to say that Shutfus with a Goy • Mehalech #1: Perhaps the animal is forbidden to perform Melachah because of
exempts a Beged from Tzitzis, when, regarding Shevisas Behemto, the Maris ayin. When people see an animal belonging to a Yid working on Shabbos,
very same Shutfus does not exempt the animal? they may assume that the Yid is allowing his animal to perform Melachah, even
ANSWER if the animal is jointly owned with a Goy. Therefore, the Yid must prevent the
animal from working, despite the partial ownership. Mehalech #2: The Mitzvah
There is a fundamental Chiluk between the two Mitzvos. The Chiyuv of of Shevisas Behemto is fundamentally an obligation on the Gavra, the Jewish
Tzitzis is dependent on a Shiur – a Beged must be of a certain size to be owner, which extends to his animal. Just as the Yid himself is prohibited from
Chayiv in Tzitzis. When half of the garment belongs to a Goy, the Goy’s performing Melachah on Shabbos, he must also ensure that his animal refrains
portion cannot be counted toward the Yid’s Chiyuv at all, and what from Melachah. Since the obligation is on the owner, having a Goy as a partner
remains is only “half of a Beged”, which lacks the Chashivus of a Beged does not remove his personal responsibility. Mehalech #3: We find a similar
and does not reach the Shiur; therefore it is Patur. By Shevisas Behemah, concept in Tosfos in Pesachim 88a regarding a Chatzi ben chorin, chatzi eved.
however, there is no Din of Shiur whatsoever – the Torah does not require He cannot marry a Chatzi bas chorin, chatzi shifchah, because his free side
a “Chashuve Beheimah”, and therefore even half of an animal that would be interacting with her Shifchah side, and his Eved side with her free
belongs to a Yid obligates him in Shevisah. The Mishmeres Chaim adds side. We see that the restrictions associated with one portion of a person
that one should not ask from the Gemara in Chullin (135a), that a field remain fully applicable even though another portion has a different Halachic
owned with a Goy is Patur from Pe’ah even though Pe’ah has no Shiur, status. So too, by Shevisas Behemto, the animal cannot evade the restrictions
since the Imrei Binah distinguishes between a Chiyuv that stems from the of Shabbos merely because a Goy owns half of it. The Yid's portion remains
Cheftza (like Pe’ah, which is Patur with a Goy partner) and a Chiyuv that subject to the Chiyuv of Shevisah. - Sh. Y. R., Cedarhurst, NY
stems from the Gavra.
Mussar
Moment
THE
שו"ת רעק"א סוף סימן ט שו"ע או"ח סימן רמ"ו סעיף ג (מנחת חינוך מצוה ל"ב )מוסך השבת
עניני ציצית סימן ד,משמרת חיים חלק א (באר היטב או"ח סימן י )בשם משקה אליעזר
"Fresh butter doesn't have any smell, and if it smells like butter that is a sign that it's starting to
spoil. The same goes with a true Tzaddik - he has no ריח, and if a person has the ריחof a tzaddik -
that itself is a חסרון."
Halacha
- Rav Mordechai Zuckerman (Shma Bni 195)
Highlights
If someone ate a כזיתof מזונותand drank less than a רביעיתof wine, they LOMDUS SPONSOR TEXT 646-598-4703 TO SPONSOR
should include על הגפןin their על המחיה. Even though they did not drink the
Are you a
full שיעורof a רביעית, they include it since they are already חייבto say the ברכה FOLLOW US
for the מזונותfood.
Lamdan?
אגרות משה או"ח ח"ב סימן קט- TO SPONSOR A SHAILA LIELUEY NISHMAS
OR REFUAH SHELEIMA TEXT 646.598.4703
