Rav Yaakov on the Parshah — Toledot (2026-11-09)

ב״ה
RAV
YAAKOV
ON THE PARSHAH
TOLDOS תשפ״ז
A selection presenting the penetrating insights of Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky on Parshas Toldos.
The Av of Few Talmidim
The Torah tells Avraham’s and Yaakov’s lives at length but says little about Yitzchak’s.
Why did Yitzchak draw so few followers, and what did he leave the Jewish people?
ְוֵא ֶּל ה ּת ֹוְל ֹדת ִיְצ ָח ק ֶּב ן ַא ְב ָר ָה ם sitting in his yeshivah and spreading Torah, until the
knowledge of Hashem grew among his sons and those
These are the generations of Yitzchak the son of
who joined them, and a nation that knew Hashem came
Avraham. (Bereishis 25:19)
into being. About Yitzchak he writes almost nothing:
ְוָיַׁש ב ִיְצ ָח ק ְמ ַל ֵּמ ד ּוַמ ְזִה יר, “Yitzchak sat, teaching and
A lthough Parshas Toldos is centered on the life of
Yitzchak, the Torah tells us remarkably little
about him when we compare him to the other
warning,” and Yitzchak taught Yaakov and appointed
him to teach. Avraham and Yaakov influenced the
whole world and raised many talmidim. Yitzchak had a
Avos. Avraham’s life fills a large part of three parshiyos. yeshivah to pass on his father’s mesorah, but he did not
The Torah describes his work with people and recounts raise many talmidim. His outstanding talmid was
his experiences at length. Yaakov’s life fills most of the Yaakov.
second half of Sefer Bereishis. Yitzchak lived longer
than either of them, until after the sale of Yosef, yet the The difference lies in the way each of the Avos reached
Torah gives us only a few details of his life. those around him. Each had his own path in bringing
emunah in Hashem into the world: Avraham through
The Rambam does the same (Hilchos Avodah chesed, Yitzchak through gevurah, and Yaakov
Zarah 1:3). He describes at length how Avraham went through emes.
from city to city and from kingdom to kingdom, calling
out in the name of Hashem, until thousands and tens of We are used to picturing Avraham as one who opened
thousands gathered around him. He describes Yaakov his home to guests and shared his bread with them,
and then, when they thanked him, taught them to
Selected excerpts from the forthcoming work, Rav Yaakov on the Parshah. Questions, comments, or to subscribe: RavYaakovOTP@gmail.com
RAV YAAKOV ON THE PARSHAH TOLDOS תשפ״ז
thank Hashem instead. This is true, but it is not the Yitzchak himself reached that level, for at the Akeidah
whole of it. All of Avraham’s avodah was rooted in his he gave over his life willingly and with joy to fulfill the
overwhelming awe at the unceasing chesed with which will of Hashem. It is no surprise, then, that his path did
Hashem created His world. The chesed Avraham did not attract many, and only a few joined it. His
with people mirrored the chesed of Hashem with His outstanding talmid was Yaakov, ִא יׁש ָּת ם ֹיֵׁש ב ֹאָה ִל ים, and
creations. When his guests were moved by his it was Yaakov who carried Avraham’s mesorah forward
kindness and wished to thank him, he explained that all in his own way.
his deeds were simply his way of serving Hashem.
Yitzchak, too, sanctified the name of Hashem in his
Since Hashem is the source and essence of chesed, His
generation. Avimelech came to make a covenant with
servant must serve Him through chesed, in the sense
him, saying ָר אֹו ָר ִא ינּו ִּכי ָה ָיה ה׳ ִע ָּמ ְך, “We have clearly
of ָמ ה הּוא ַר חּום ַא ף ַא ָּת ה ַר חּום, “just as He is merciful, so
seen that Hashem was with you” (26:28). But not every
you be merciful.” A life built on chesed and compassion
person is suited to an avodah of mesirus nefesh.
is deeply attractive. Every person by his nature is drawn
to it and wants a share in it. That is why tens of But this was so only in the days of the Avos themselves.
thousands joined Avraham. 1 For the future of Klal Yisrael and its founding as the
chosen nation, Yitzchak’s influence was no smaller than
Yaakov built his avodah on the study of Torah and the
Avraham’s or Yaakov’s. Each of the Avos planted his
search for absolute truth, as the pasuk says,
middah permanently in the nature of the Jewish
ִּת ֵּת ן ֱא ֶמ ת ְל ַיֲעֹקב, “Grant truth to Yaakov” (Michah 7:20).
people. Yitzchak’s middah, self-sacrifice and mesirus
Truth may not seem to attract people the way a life of
nefesh al kiddush Hashem, also took root in the Jewish
chesed does. Yet it too has a strong pull, for even the
soul, and from then until today it is this middah that has
smallest child can tell truth from falsehood, and anyone
given Klal Yisrael the strength and courage to give their
is moved when he meets pure emes. So Yaakov too
lives for the sanctification of His Name.
gathered a great following who learned from him how
to serve Hashem.
1. Avraham’s eishel for guests was not merely a means of bringing
Yitzchak’s middah was different. His avodah was built them under the wings of emunah, the way missionaries lure
on din and mishpat: a person’s purpose on earth is to people to their corrupt beliefs with food and drink. It all flowed
live every stage of his life according to the exact laws of from his love of chesed. If he wanted to do good for people in
their physical needs, all the more did he want to do them the
Hashem’s will, without ever turning aside, with no room eternal good of recognizing the fundamental truth of all life. This
for compromise. Few people are prepared to undertake is the right path for us as well: out of love for every Jew and a
an avodah of such exacting discipline and self-sacrifice. desire to do him good, we should try to bring him close to Torah
and to knowledge of the truth.
Selected excerpts from the forthcoming work, Rav Yaakov on the Parshah. Questions, comments, or to subscribe: RavYaakovOTP@gmail.com
RAV YAAKOV ON THE PARSHAH TOLDOS תשפ״ז
The Two Years That Saved Yaakov
Esav left the beis medrash at thirteen, but the change in him showed only two years
later. What happened in those two years, and what do they teach about the importance
of learning Gemara?
ַוִּיְג ְּד לּו ַה ְּנָע ִר ים ַוְיִה י ֵע ָׂש ו ִא יׁש ֹיֵד ַע ַצִיד ִא יׁש one of many supports of his emunah, so even his
grandfather’s early death could not shake him. 1
ָׂש ֶד ה ְוַיֲעֹקב ִא יׁש ָּת ם ֹיֵׁש ב ֹאָה ִל ים
The boys grew up, and Esav became a man who knew At thirteen, the brothers had begun to take different
hunting, a man of the field, and Yaakov was a paths. Only at fifteen, when Avraham died, did the full
wholesome man, dwelling in tents. (Bereishis 25:27) extent of that difference become apparent. Avraham
died at a hundred seventy-five, and the twins were born
T
when he was a hundred sixty, as the pesukim show, so
he wording of the pasuk implies that until they they were then fifteen. Hashem shortened Avraham’s
grew up, both of them dwelt in the tents of years precisely so that he would not see Esav go bad.
Torah. Chazal read the pasuk ַוְיִה י ֶה ֶב ל ֹרֵע ה ֹצאן, As long as the difference could not yet be clearly seen,
“Hevel became a shepherd, and Kayin worked the land” there was no need to take years from him.
(4:2), the same way: Hevel too had worked the land, and
only later left it. So too here. Both brothers learned Two full years passed from the time Esav began to turn
Torah until they came of age at thirteen. Then Esav away until the change in him became evident. We learn
turned away to other things and Yaakov to Torah. from this that the fall in his madreigah, which began
when he left the beis medrash, did not fully settle into
Two years later, when they were fifteen, Avraham Avinu his nature until he reached the age the Mishnah names:
died. On the day of his burial, Yaakov remained in his ֶּב ן ֲח ֵמ ׁש ֶע ְׂש ֵר ה ַלְּגָמ ָר א, “At fifteen, for Gemara”
righteousness, while Esav in one day became a (Avos 5:21). Only then did the change in Esav become
murderer, an adulterer and a kofer (Bava Basra 16b). plain, because at that age a person’s mind has
Chazal explain why it all happened in a single day developed enough for him to distinguish between
(Bereishis Rabbah 63:11). When Esav heard that good and evil.
Avraham had died, he said: midas hadin has struck
even Avraham, so there is no judgment and no Judge. When a fifteen-year-old bochur, just beginning to
Avraham had in fact died before his time. By the years mature, is immersed in the study of Gemara, all his
allotted to him, he should have lived five more years. growing up is guided and directed by Torah, and he is
Yaakov accepted this judgment. Esav lost his faith over assured of growing as he should. But if, chas v’shalom,
it. he comes to maturity without the guidance of Gemara,
he becomes an Esav at fifteen.
What made the difference was the two years Yaakov
had spent learning Torah after Esav left. They kept him
whole, so that he did not question Hashem’s ways. 1. Avraham’s death affected both of his grandsons, but in opposite
ways. Esav was lost because of it. Yaakov was lifted up that very
Esav’s emunah had already been weakening for some day, and that is the day he acquired the bechorah. When
time, and what still held him to it was his bond with his tzaddikim leave the world, the children and grandchildren who
grandfather. When Avraham died, he was left with hold onto their ways can rise to great heights, if they draw
strength from the awakening that the loss brings.
nothing. For Yaakov, his bond with Avraham was only
Selected excerpts from the forthcoming work, Rav Yaakov on the Parshah. Questions, comments, or to subscribe: RavYaakovOTP@gmail.com
RAV YAAKOV ON THE PARSHAH TOLDOS תשפ״ז
The Word Given to Rachel
The Avos kept the whole Torah before it was given, yet Yaakov married two sisters. Why
did he marry Rachel after Leah, and what does that tell us about the weight of a
promise?
ֵע ֶק ב ֲאֶׁש ר ָׁש ַמ ע ַא ְב ָר ָה ם ְּב ֹקִל י ַוִּיְׁש ֹמר accepted? The Ramban himself says that Yaakov was
bound by his promise (48:7): Leah was the wife he
ִמ ְׁש ַמ ְר ִּת י ִמ ְצ ֹוַת י ֻח ּק ֹוַת י ְותֹו ֹרָת י
married first, in heter, and Rachel he took because of
Because Avraham listened to My voice and kept My his love for her, through the vow he had made to her.
charge, My mitzvos, My chukim and My teachings.
(Bereishis 26:5) The Ramban’s question was a different one. If the Avos
accepted upon themselves to keep the entire Torah,
T
why did Hashem arrange events so that Yaakov would
he Ramban writes that Avraham Avinu learned be forced to marry two sisters? To this he answers that
the entire Torah and kept it, but that he kept it their acceptance was to keep the Torah only in Eretz
only in Eretz Yisrael. Yaakov, outside the land, Yisrael.
married two sisters, for the mitzvos are “the law of the
God of the land.” It must be so. If the question were how Yaakov could
marry Rachel, it would not help to answer that the Avos
It is clear that the Ramban was not asking how Yaakov kept the Torah only in Eretz Yisrael. Yaakov intended to
could marry Rachel after he had already married Leah. return to the land as soon as he could, and in the end
There is no question about that. Yaakov had promised he did. His obligation to Rachel was a different matter. It
Rachel that he would marry her, and he had made did not depend on where he was, but on the word he
explicit terms with Lavan, ְּב ָר ֵח ל ִּב ְּת ָך ַה ְּק ַט ָּנה, “for Rachel, had given. 1
your younger daughter” (29:18). Once he had done so,
he was obligated to marry her. Could chumros that he
took upon himself, keeping the Torah before it was 1. For this reason, when people ask me about breaking off a
shidduch, I answer that once there has been a vort, they must
given, permit him to break the word he had given go to a din Torah.
Rachel? Why should she suffer for stringencies he had
Selected excerpts from the forthcoming work, Rav Yaakov on the Parshah. Questions, comments, or to subscribe: RavYaakovOTP@gmail.com
RAV YAAKOV ON THE PARSHAH TOLDOS תשפ״ז
Deep Wells
The Ramban says Yitzchak’s three wells hint at the three Batei Mikdash. Why does the
Torah need to tell us about them at such length, and what made the third well different?
ַוִּיְק ָר א ֵׁש ם ַה ְּב ֵא ר ֵע ֶׂש ק ִּכי ִה ְת ַע ְּׂש קּו ִע ּמ ֹו Avraham was very rich (13:2), yet no one envied him. On
the contrary, the people said to him,
He named the well Esek, because they had contended
ְנִׂש יא ֱא ֹלִק ים ַא ָּת ה ְּב תֹוֵכנּו, “You are a prince of God
with him. (Bereishis 26:20)
among us” (23:6). But they did envy Yitzchak, and they
told him, ֵל ְך ֵמ ִע ָּמ נּו, “Go away from us, for you have
T he Ramban writes that the Torah speaks at
length about the wells, though the simple story
brings no benefit and no great honor to
become much mightier than we” (26:16). As long as his
wealth stayed in its place, in the grain of his fields
(26:12), they did not envy him. Once he had flocks of
Yitzchak. There is a hidden matter within it, hinting at sheep and herds of cattle (26:14), the envy began. As
the future. A well of living water alludes to the house of Chazal say, ָיָא ה ֲעִנ ּיּוָת א ְל ִיְׂש ָר ֵא ל, “Poverty becomes the
Hashem that Yitzchak’s descendants would build. The Jewish people” (Chagigah 9b).
first well he named Esek, which alludes to the first Beis
HaMikdash, when the nations contended with us and Then Yitzchak dug a well and found living water. This
waged wars against us until they destroyed it. The was surely a gift from Hashem, and still they said, “The
second he named Sitnah, a harsher name, for the water is ours.” He dug another well, and when they
second Beis HaMikdash was the object of hatred all its quarreled over that one too, he named it Sitnah,
days, until it was destroyed and we were sent into a “hatred.” At first he had thought the quarrel came not
bitter galus. The third he named Rechovos. This is the from hatred but because they lacked water. But now
future Beis HaMikdash, which will be built without they already had a well of living water and were
quarrel or strife. quarreling anyway. They simply did not want him to
have water. Then he understood that he could not dig
Still, what does the Torah teach us by telling this at wells in their vicinity. He moved away and dug another
such length? What is it hinting at? well, and over that one they did not quarrel. The Torah
reveals the reason: the first well was dug close to the
To understand the connection to the Batei Mikdash, we
Pelishtim, and the second not much farther away. Only
first need to follow what changed from one well to the
the third time did he move far from them, and then
next. The same cause that brought strife over the wells
success came to him. 1
would later bring the churban. The Torah also shows us
that Yitzchak already bore the yoke of galus. Hashem So it was with the Batei Mikdash. In the time of the first
had told Avraham, ִּכי ֵגר ִיְה ֶיה ַזְר ֲע ָך, “Your descendants Beis HaMikdash there was Shlomo’s closeness with the
will be strangers in a land not theirs, and they will be nations. He turned to Chiram, king of Tzor, who sent his
enslaved and afflicted for four hundred years” (15:13). servants to help build it (Melachim I 5:16–23). This was
Chazal count the four hundred years from the birth of the cause of the churban. Since Shlomo’s way was to
Yitzchak. So we might wonder where we find that draw the nations close, he did not protest when his
Yitzchak suffered galus. wives built a bamah to Kemosh (ibid. 11:7), and he built a
house for the daughter of Pharaoh (ibid. 11:27, Rashi).
As is known, this brought on the rebuke of Yeravam,
Selected excerpts from the forthcoming work, Rav Yaakov on the Parshah. Questions, comments, or to subscribe: RavYaakovOTP@gmail.com
RAV YAAKOV ON THE PARSHAH TOLDOS תשפ״ז
and the kingdom of Yisrael was split in two But the third Beis HaMikdash will be built by Hashem
(Sanhedrin 101b). That led to the churban and the Himself, and then ִּכי ַע ָּת ה ִה ְר ִח יב ה׳ ָל נּו, “Now Hashem
galus. has made room for us” (26:22). Perhaps this too is
hinted at here. The first two wells were dug by
In the second Beis HaMikdash, too, the builders were
Yitzchak’s servants, but of the third it says ַוַּיְח ֹּפר, “he
Jews, but they built under the protection of the kings of
dug,” Yitzchak himself. It was done under his direction:
Persia and Madai (Ezra 1:2). This too caused the
he showed them the place, the conditions, and every
churban. Because of this dependence on foreign
detail. Then no one could lay a hand on it.
powers, and the closeness to the nations that came
with it, the Misyavnim arose from among the Jewish
people. After the victory of the Chashmonaim, when 1. We are living now in the time of chevlei Mashiach, the birth
they could no longer raise their heads, they shed that pangs of the Mashiach, a frightening time of which Chazal said,
“Let him come, but let me not see it” (Sanhedrin 98b). Even so,
form and took on the form of the Tzedukim. In the end we need not be filled with fear. On the contrary, we should take
the kingdom passed to the servants of Beis strength in knowing that this hard time can pass in peace, with
Chashmonai, and this brought the churban. little suffering. The hard period of ַוֲעָב דּום ְוִע ּנּו ֹאָת םbegan with
Yitzchak’s birth, yet in the merit of his greatness it did not come
upon him in full. All his “troubles” were that the people envied
him and wanted him gone, and he had to move to another place.
So too, one who strengthens himself in Torah and tefillah can
see the coming of Mashiach pass over him in peace and
tranquility, with little suffering.
Each Av’s Akeidah
Yaakov, the pillar of emes, received the berachos only by deceiving his father. Why did
Hashem arrange it that way, and what was the corresponding test of Yitzchak?
אּוַלי ְיֻמ ֵּׁש ִני ָא ִב י ְוָה ִייִת י ְב ֵע יָניו ִּכְמ ַת ְע ֵּת ַע arrange that the berachos come to Yaakov specifically
through falsehood and deception?
Perhaps my father will feel me, and I will seem to him a
deceiver. (Bereishis 27:12) The Ramban writes (25:34) that whoever asks why
Yitzchak’s eyes grew dim is asking a question of the
W e must understand why Rivkah told Yaakov to blind-hearted, for if it came about from Hashem, it was
deceive his father. Onkelos says she did so by so that Yitzchak would bless Yaakov. But this is
nevuah (27:13). Did Hashem have no other way astonishing. Had Hashem no other way for Yaakov to
for Yaakov to receive the berachos without having to receive the berachos except through Yitzchak’s
lie? This is especially hard to understand because blindness?
Yaakov is the pillar of truth in the world, as the pasuk Hashem tested Avraham Avinu with ten nisyonos until
says, ( ִּת ֵּת ן ֱא ֶמ ת ְל ַיֲעֹקבMichah 7:20). He kept so far from he rose to his exalted madreigah. Yaakov, too, had to
falsehood that in the episode of Dinah, when the pass a test that would show how great his madreigah
people of Shechem had to be dealt with through was and how deep his dveikus in Hashem. Avraham’s
cunning, Yaakov did not speak with them himself, but nisyonos all went against his nature and temperament.
left the matter to his sons. Why, then, did Hashem Avraham’s way was to make Hashem’s name known in
Selected excerpts from the forthcoming work, Rav Yaakov on the Parshah. Questions, comments, or to subscribe: RavYaakovOTP@gmail.com
RAV YAAKOV ON THE PARSHAH TOLDOS תשפ״ז
the world by revealing His chesed and goodness, as the l’shem Shamayim. Taking the berachos from Esav was
pasuk says, ( ֶח ֶס ד ְל ַא ְב ָר ָה םibid.). All the thousands and Yaakov’s Akeidah. Each of the Avos had to pass his own
tens of thousands he brought close to Hashem, he Akeidah, a test against his nature and essence, in order
brought through the chesed he did with people, to be counted among the fathers of the Jewish people.
explaining that his deeds flowed from the chesed of
If so, we must ask what Yitzchak’s test against his
Hashem.
nature was. The Akeidah did not go against his nature
So when Hashem came to test Avraham, to see and middah. On the contrary, Yitzchak represents din
whether he truly feared Him, He had to test him in ways and gevurah, ( ַּפ ַח ד ִיְצ ָח ק31:42), and his willingness to
that seemed to run directly against chesed. When give his life expressed the very middah of gevurah
Hashem told him, ֶל ְך ְל ָך ֵמ ַא ְר ְצ ָך, “Go from your land, through which he served Hashem. Where, then, was
from your birthplace, and from your father’s house,” he Yitzchak tested the way Avraham and Yaakov were?
had to leave his home and his elderly father, which
Perhaps Yitzchak’s Akeidah has not yet come, and it will
surely pained him. Later he was commanded to send
come in the future. The Gemara says (Shabbos 89b): In
Hagar and his son Yishmael away from his home in a
the future, Hashem will say to Avraham, “Your children
way that seemed cruel, and that could not have been
have sinned against Me.” Avraham will answer, “Master
pleasant for him to do. Above them all was the Akeidah,
of the world, let them be wiped out for the
where he had to offer his only son as a korban, against
sanctification of Your Name.” Hashem will say the same
his whole being and everything he stood for. The idol
to Yaakov, and he too will answer, “Let them be wiped
worshippers of those days sacrificed their own children,
out for the sanctification of Your Name.”
as the pasuk says, ִּכי ַגם ֶא ת ְּב ֵניֶה ם, “for even their sons
and their daughters they burn in fire to their gods” Then Hashem will say to Yitzchak, “Your children have
(Devarim 12:31). Avraham had always shown everyone sinned against Me.” Yitzchak will answer, “Master of the
that Hashem, Who is merciful and gracious, would world, are they my children and not Yours? When they
never ask such a korban of His creations, and now he said naaseh before nishma, You called them ‘My
had to do it himself. This is the highest level of nisayon firstborn son,’ and now they are my children and not
a person can face: to do something wholly opposed to Yours? If You bear all of it, good. If not, let half be on me
his own nature and essence, only to fulfill the will of and half on You. And if You say all of it is on me, I already
Hashem. Only after Avraham passed all these tests did offered myself before You.” Then Klal Yisrael will open
the malach tell him, ִּכי ַע ָּת ה ָיַד ְע ִּת י, “Now I know that you their mouths and say, ִּכי ַא ָּת ה ָא ִב ינּו, “For you are our
fear God” (22:12). father” (Yeshayahu 63:16).
So it was with Yaakov. His whole nature recoiled from Perhaps this will be Yitzchak’s great test: the Av whose
falsehood. Forgery and deceit were to him like avodah middah is din will act against his own middah. Of all the
zarah and utterly repugnant. When Hashem wished to Avos, he alone will plead for Klal Yisrael and take all
test how deeply Yaakov clung to Him, there was no their sins upon himself, for that will then be the will of
more fitting place to test him than his middah of emes. Hashem, Who comes to the Avos seeking a defender
Now he was forced to act against the direction of his for His people. And like the other Avos, Yitzchak will
whole life and his uncompromising stand for truth. pass his test and become the protector and savior of
Only if he did so because he had been commanded Klal Yisrael.
would it become clear that everything he did was
Selected excerpts from the forthcoming work, Rav Yaakov on the Parshah. Questions, comments, or to subscribe: RavYaakovOTP@gmail.com
RAV YAAKOV ON THE PARSHAH TOLDOS תשפ״ז
The Name on Yaakov’s Lips
Yitzchak became suspicious when the son before him spoke Hashem’s name. Why
would Esav’s silence have seemed like yiras Shamayim, and who may speak the Name
freely?
ַוֹּיאֶמ ר ִיְצ ָח ק ֶא ל ַיֲעֹקב ְּג ָׁש ה ָּנא ַוֲא ֻמ ְׁש ָך ְּב ִני Even according to the Magen Avraham, the reason
cannot be that one would transgress ֹלא ִת ָּׂש א, for he is
ַה ַא ָּת ה ֶזה ְּב ִני ֵע ָׂש ו ִא ם ֹלא
not saying the Name in vain. He is studying the proper
Yitzchak said to Yaakov, “Come close, please, so I can wording of a berachah, which must include the Name,
feel you, my son. Are you really my son Esav or not?” so his mention of it serves a purpose. It seems, rather,
(Bereishis 27:21) that the Magen Avraham’s concern is one of yirah: that
he transgresses ֶא ת ה׳ ֱא ֹלֶק יָך ִּת יָר א, “You shall fear
R ashi explains that Yitzchak said to himself: it is
not Esav’s way to have the name of Heaven
readily on his lips, and this one said,
Hashem your God” (Devarim 6:13). As the Ramban
explained here, one who fears the Name does not
mention it if he can avoid doing so. Just as a person
ִּכי ִה ְק ָר ה ה׳ ֱא ֹלֶק יָך ְל ָפ ָני, “For Hashem your God arranged does not stand outside next to a wolf, even if he could
it for me” (27:20). The Ramban is surprised at this, for defend himself, for why should he put himself there, so
Esav was not a rasha in his father’s eyes. He suggests one with true yiras Hashem does not bring himself to
that perhaps Yitzchak thought that because Esav was a mention the Name, even when he says it in the course
man of the field whose heart was on the hunt, he of his learning and not in vain. In this respect we are all
refrained from mentioning Hashem’s name out of fear on Esav’s level. We do not have the proper fear and awe
that he would mention it in an unclean place, or without to mention the Name of Heaven as it should be
proper kavanah. In his father’s eyes this was counted as mentioned, and so one who mentions it where there is
yiras Shamayim. no need transgresses ֶא ת ה׳ ֱא ֹלֶק יָך ִּת יָר א. This, it seems,
is the reasoning of the Magen Avraham.
There is a machlokes among the Acharonim whether
one may say Hashem’s name when learning the text of Yaakov Avinu, however, was a yoshev ohalim. He knew
berachos in the Gemara. The Magen Avraham (215:5) that he could mention the Name of Heaven with
rules that when one learns berachos in the Gemara, he complete fear and awe and with full and powerful
should say them without mentioning the Name. The kavanah, and so he would use the Name even when he
Shaarei Teshuvah (215:4) brings from the She’ilas was not saying a berachah or davening. That is why he
Yaavetz (81) that if the Name appears in the middle of said ִּכי ִה ְק ָר ה ה׳ ֱא ֹלֶק יָך. For Yaakov, the Name of Heaven
the text of a berachah written in Shas, one may say it. was readily on his lips even in his ordinary speech with
When one reads Shas or other words of Chazal and people. Esav, a man of the field far from his brother’s
pesukim appear within them, one reads the Names in level, held himself back from mentioning Hashem, and,
the pesukim in the usual way, and so, the Yaavetz as the Ramban says, this was counted for him as yiras
writes, was the practice of his father, the Chacham Tzvi. Shamayim.
We find the same with Shimshon (Shoftim 16:17).
Chazal explain (Sotah 9b) that Delilah knew he had told
her all that was in his heart because she knew that this
Selected excerpts from the forthcoming work, Rav Yaakov on the Parshah. Questions, comments, or to subscribe: RavYaakovOTP@gmail.com
RAV YAAKOV ON THE PARSHAH TOLDOS תשפ״ז
tzaddik would not bring out the Name of Heaven for madreigah and knew that he could mention the Name
nothing. Once he said, ְנִזיר ֱא ֹלִק ים ֲא ִני, “I am a nazir of with complete kavanah, and this was certainly not
God,” she said: now he is surely telling the truth. counted against him as any sin. 1
Shimshon certainly did not say ְנִזיר ֱא ֹלִק יםwithout
actually saying the Name, for then the question would 1. The same must be true of Shaul HaMelech, who said to Shmuel,
return: how did she know he had told her the truth? The ָּב רּוְך ַא ָּת ה ַל ה׳ ֲה ִק יֹמִת י ֶא ת ְּד ַב ר ה׳, “Blessed are you to Hashem; I
Gemara’s explanation would answer nothing. Clearly he have fulfilled the word of Hashem” (Shmuel I 15:13). We see from
would mention the Name of Heaven even when this that Shaul truly and sincerely believed he had fulfilled the
mitzvah to wipe out Amalek, for otherwise he would not have
speaking with people. He too stood on a lofty brought out the Name of Heaven, twice, unless he believed in his
heart that it was so.
For Our Good
Hashem gives a Yid only what is good for him, but He gives a non-Jew whatever he asks.
What does this teach us about how to ask?
ְוִיֶּת ן ְל ָך ָה ֱא ֹלִק ים ִמ ַּט ל ַה ָּׁש ַמ ִים ּוִמ ְׁש ַמ ֵּני ָה ָא ֶר ץ accepts the judgment of Hashem, so he will not
complain against Him. But for a non-Jew who comes to
May God give you of the dew of the heavens and of the
daven in the Beis HaMikdash, Shlomo asked that
fat of the land. (Bereishis 27:28)
Hashem do all that he calls out for (ibid. 8:43). A non-
Jew lacks emunah, so whether he deserves it or not,
R ashi explains that the name ֱא ֹלִק יםrefers to din.
Yitzchak was blessing Yaakov that Hashem
would give to him according to judgment: if he
Hashem should give it to him, so that he will not
complain against Heaven.
deserved it, Hashem would give it to him, and if not, He According to this, we can understand the tefillah of Rav
would not. To Esav, however, Yitzchak said (Berachos 16b), which we recite on Shabbos
( ִמ ְׁש ַמ ֵּני ָה ָא ֶר ץ ִיְה ֶיה מֹוָׁש ֶב ָך27:39), that he would receive Mevorchim: ּוְת ַמ ֵּל א ָל נּו ֶא ת ָּכל ִמ ְׁש ֲא לֹות ִל ֵּב נּו ְל טֹוָב ה, “Fulfill
whether he was righteous or wicked. all the wishes of our hearts for good.” Shlomo asked
that the non-Jew’s tefillah be answered even without
Rashi adds that Shlomo learned from this when he built that condition. We ask Hashem to fulfill our wishes only
the Beis HaMikdash. For a Jew, he asked Hashem, when they are truly for our good.
ְוָנַת ָּת ָל ִא יׁש ְּכָכל ְּד ָר ָכיו, “Give each man according to all his
ways” (Melachim I 8:39). For a Jew is a baal emunah and
Selected excerpts from the forthcoming work, Rav Yaakov on the Parshah. Questions, comments, or to subscribe: RavYaakovOTP@gmail.com
